Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will you self isolate if covid positive test?

953 replies

Monopolyiscrap · 12/02/2022 00:47

Compulsory self-isolation is ending if you test positive with covid. Instead, people are being advised to choose to self-isolate.
In reality, I think many people will not. I would not get paid if I self-isolate but am well enough to work, so why would I forego a week's wages?

So will you self-isolate if you test positive with covid?

YABU - Yes I will self-isolate
YANBU - No I will not self-isolate

OP posts:
PuzzledObserver · 12/02/2022 07:25

I will, but I’m retired so the disruption is minimal. However, I haven’t been testing routinely (I did for a while), so unless I have symptoms, I wouldn’t know.

Bumpitybumper · 12/02/2022 07:24

@Iggly
The risks of heart disease and long covid are going to exist at the end of March in much the same way as they do now. Scientists are not going to magic a solution to this or any other risks associated with covid in the very near future.

Scientists are also not going to devise a plan for 'living with covid' that is going to satisfy the growing desire and need to live relatively normally for the majority of the population whilst offering those who want the protection of self isolation rules and infinite testing to remain. The two things are incompatible and is increasingly becoming an issue about competing rights. The right of vulnerable and scared to be protected from a virus that we seemingly have very limited control over versus the rights of others to live a life that is unencumbered by a continuous cycle of incredibly disruptive (and expensive testing) and isolating. Neither group is wrong or immoral and waiting until March won't make things materially better or easier.

Shiningpath · 12/02/2022 07:23

This latest announcement has made me feel very ashamed and I think is going to hurt the economy more than we know, especially with summer coming up. As a German or French tourist would you risk coming here where there are no masks, no restrictions and people with Covid freely in circulation, knowing if you catch it you’d have to isolate when you return home, not to mention the long term effects? I wouldn’t.

I’ve never been so embarrassed to be British.

TheOrigRights · 12/02/2022 07:21

[quote OnceuponaRainbow18]@TheOrigRights

So basically you’ll avoid your vulnerable family members but fuck those you don’t know?[/quote]
No, i gave an example of where I wouldn't go to an enclosed space (sport class) which indicates I do care about others. To be more clear I would avoid shops, cinema etc. Do you want me to list all possible places?
But I will still go outside - running or taking my son to his football.

Oblomov22 · 12/02/2022 07:20

I didn't know that they will cost £30 as of March.

Iggly · 12/02/2022 07:16

@ArtemisDarling

I think the scientists have not been heard of because they cannot and will not lie about the 'desirability' of packing in self isolation to save BJ's arse and so he will not let them anywhere near a press conference.
I agree and I think it’s appalling.

They should at the very least let the scientists publish their advice even if they choose to ignore it. We don’t live in fucking North Korea.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 12/02/2022 07:15

@TheOrigRights

So basically you’ll avoid your vulnerable family members but fuck those you don’t know?

WahWahWahs · 12/02/2022 07:14

Yes.

Oblomov22 · 12/02/2022 07:14

Interesting to read all the different views. Trying to get me head around it. I doubt I'll test if i don't have symptoms. But presumably that won't work, if so many people are asymptomatic?

ArtemisDarling · 12/02/2022 07:13

I think the scientists have not been heard of because they cannot and will not lie about the 'desirability' of packing in self isolation to save BJ's arse and so he will not let them anywhere near a press conference.

Overthebow · 12/02/2022 07:12

@Sharrowgirl

LFTs are going to be £30 for a box of 7 from March, so I’ve heard. So I doubt the majority of people will know they have it as they won’t be testing.
That’ll do it then, there’s no way I’m paying £30 for a box.
TheOrigRights · 12/02/2022 07:10

@TicTacHoh

*As a country, we have fantastic scientists and poor politicians. People know this, but follow the politics in this case instead of listening to the science. * The scientists were completely wrong on Omicrom and haven't been heard from since.
Can you expand on how they were wrong?
TheOrigRights · 12/02/2022 07:09

I won't completely SI, but will not visit the my elderly or vulnerable family members or go to my indoor sport classes.
I will test if the care home continues to ask obviously. I am an Essential Care Giver and have been able to continue to visit my FIL when the home has been closed due to an outbreak (thankfully within the staff not the residents recently)

ArtemisDarling · 12/02/2022 07:08

I will continue to test and I will self isolate. I have a disabled son who is immunocompromised. I would not want to risk him or indeed present a risk to anyone like him out in the wider community.

That said, I am self employed and can work from home so it is easy for me to self isolate. I will continue to test my son three times a week like I do currently and I would pay for LFTs if we had to pay for them. However again, it is easy for me to do so because I am not (at the moment anyway) financially stretched.

Iggly · 12/02/2022 07:08

@TicTacHoh

*As a country, we have fantastic scientists and poor politicians. People know this, but follow the politics in this case instead of listening to the science. *The scientists were completely wrong on Omicrom and haven't been heard from since.
? We got lucky with omicron. And Chris Whitty basically told everyone to be careful over Christmas, most people did and lo and behold rates luckily stayed low to give time for people to get boosters.

The bit they got “wrong” was modelling but the key bit is they know that and adjust accordingly.

Do you know how science works? It adapts and updates according to the latest facts.

I’d rather listen to a scientist than our current Prime Minister.

All I’m saying is the government should give more than two weeks to come up with a plan for living with a novel virus!

flowerycurtain · 12/02/2022 07:06

I won't know as I won't be testing. J had covid completely asymptomatical. As did my elderly cancer ridden father in law.

I'll do what I've done with other illnesses. Last week I had a stinker of a cold so took to my bed for two days until symptoms passed. Before Xmas I had a mild cold so cracked on with life but didn't go to visit my granny.

We have staff and I will be thrilled when this comes in. The self isolation rules for people showing no symptoms have been so hard. One or two odd bods have completely taken advantage of the system and kissed off everyone else. They work in big big open spaces by themselves. If they feel fine (obviously if they feel crap that's a different matter) there is no reason why they shouldn't work. They all agree!

megletthesecond · 12/02/2022 07:06

Yes. I can't work from home and I'll go for walks. I wouldn't go to a shop while I was poorly.

gamerchick · 12/02/2022 07:05

If I'm ill I'll stay off work as usual. If I can get on with it then why would I give up the pay? I don't get paid for covid related stuff as it is and am a bit tired of using annual leave for something that has been forced on me.

Sharrowgirl · 12/02/2022 07:05

LFTs are going to be £30 for a box of 7 from March, so I’ve heard. So I doubt the majority of people will know they have it as they won’t be testing.

TicTacHoh · 12/02/2022 07:04

*As a country, we have fantastic scientists and poor politicians. People know this, but follow the politics in this case instead of listening to the science.
*
The scientists were completely wrong on Omicrom and haven't been heard from since.

Iggly · 12/02/2022 07:03

[quote Bumpitybumper]@AFIK
Presumably the majority will therefore be happy for their elderly/vulnerable relatives to be treated by nhs staff with “colds” that haven’t been tested for covid and potentially given a deadly virus
But the elephant in the room is that the virus is being carried and transmitted by a huge amount of completely asymptomatic people and people that haven't yet developed symptoms. Unless the vulnerable are prepared to live in complete isolation then they will encounter the virus at some point, whether it be in the supermarket, at the doctors or through their own family and friends. This is true if we maintain current isolation rules or if we don't, it's just isolation rules might slow down the spread slightly.

Any benefits from the rules need to be balanced against the risks and disadvantages of keeping them in place. For most people (including most vulnerable people), covid is a relatively minor illness and when push comes to shove, we would rather have society where the infrastructure isn't continually hampered by people self isolating, reducing our capacity to function efficiently, effectively and compassionately. I can cite numerous examples in my own life of how people (often vulnerable) have lost so much as a result of the isolation rules. Keeping the self isolation rules has a cost to us all and shouldn't be considered the default or the 'kinder' thing to do.[/quote]
They’ve already reduced the isolation period significantly.

More and more research is coming out about covid showing that even if mild it elevates risk of heart disease for everyone who gets it. Do you may well think you’re fine but later on, you may not be.

What about long covid?

Ending self isolation just means more transmission.

Boris Johnson announced this out of the blue and has no plan at the time of announcement.

He should have left the original date of the end of March to give the experts enough time to recommend a sensible plan for living with covid.

Instead we’ll end up with a jumbled, Prosecco filled rush mess.

All for the sake of his reputation.

Overthebow · 12/02/2022 07:02

When people get chicken pox, D&V, etc are they advised to carry on? Nope. They’re expected to stay away from other people

The big difference though is that it’s pretty obvious when you have d&v or chicken pox. With covid lots have really mild symptoms that are just like a cold, or no symptoms so unless you test you don’t know that you have it. People just won’t be testing anymore for cold symptoms, especially when the tests cost money, as they won’t be free anymore from summer.

SickAndTiredAgain · 12/02/2022 07:01

I easily could, as I wfh 3 days a week anyway and can easily wfh all the time for an isolation period (as I’m doing now with covid).

The issue would be whether I’d be allowed to. Company policy is to be in the office twice a week - if I wasn’t actually unwell I’m not sure extra wfh would be approved. So it wouldn’t necessarily be up to me.

Plus I agree with posters who’ve said that soon we won’t know if it’s covid anyway, unless we’re ill enough to warrant testing. I don’t think free PCRs for anyone with mild symptoms will continue.

FindingMeno · 12/02/2022 07:00

Dunno, ask my boss.

Bumpitybumper · 12/02/2022 06:59

@AFIK
Presumably the majority will therefore be happy for their elderly/vulnerable relatives to be treated by nhs staff with “colds” that haven’t been tested for covid and potentially given a deadly virus
But the elephant in the room is that the virus is being carried and transmitted by a huge amount of completely asymptomatic people and people that haven't yet developed symptoms. Unless the vulnerable are prepared to live in complete isolation then they will encounter the virus at some point, whether it be in the supermarket, at the doctors or through their own family and friends. This is true if we maintain current isolation rules or if we don't, it's just isolation rules might slow down the spread slightly.

Any benefits from the rules need to be balanced against the risks and disadvantages of keeping them in place. For most people (including most vulnerable people), covid is a relatively minor illness and when push comes to shove, we would rather have society where the infrastructure isn't continually hampered by people self isolating, reducing our capacity to function efficiently, effectively and compassionately. I can cite numerous examples in my own life of how people (often vulnerable) have lost so much as a result of the isolation rules. Keeping the self isolation rules has a cost to us all and shouldn't be considered the default or the 'kinder' thing to do.