Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
cuno · 12/02/2022 13:51

I don't see how the line is any thinner than the line between any other behaviour with consent and without consent. You may as well say that freely agreeing to sex makes you more likely to be coerced into sex at a later date.

Sorry no, people having sex is a fact of life. People derive pleasure from it, and it's necessary for reproduction as well. This isn't about consent vs not consent.

Tracking people is unnecessary, all these excuses from people saying they can check when their husband is on his way home so they can get tea ready. Sorry but unfettered access to your location at a press of a button is barmy. There is no need to track someone to check they are on their way home, it's neurotic is what it is. Call or text like a normal person if you want to know where someone is, when they'll be home etc and treat them with respect and trust.

All consensual, yeah? What if the partner turns off their location because they don't like it anymore? This would result in anxiety and assumptions they are up to no good from the other partner. It would create resentment. Once you opt in, there's no opting out lest you want to create an issue.

Entire families tracking each other at all times under the guise of keeping each other safe, getting help when they're lost, and having dinner put on just in time for when you walk through the door, is just not normal. It's a clear lack of boundaries whichever way you paint it. You can use Google maps or if you're too inept to use that, you can send your location/coordinates in that moment to someone for help. You don't need 24/7 tracking in case you get lost on the way to the bathroom. How often are people getting lost to require constant tracking???

Just because technology advances, doesn't mean that it's inevitable and we have to just accept tracking as the new norm and part and parcel of family life. It's insidious.

Momijin · 12/02/2022 13:50

I track one of them at her request so she didn't need to keep updating me. Helps with giving lifts, making sure she's safe and not as a control measure. I only keep an eye on it when it's getting late and she's not home.

As I split parent, it helps her to know whether I'm local or if I'm around to give her a lift when she's at her dad's.

I don't track the others because one is an adult and the others don't go out late.

SparkleTwinkle101 · 12/02/2022 13:46

My mum tracks me still (I'm 25). If I take it off it causes massive arguments but she'll still ring me and say. I see you're out at this time etc. It's annoying.

I do have it in for DH as he does for me which we use for knowing when to put dinner on/when to take the car out to swap them over but we don't look at it otherwise

Echobelly · 12/02/2022 13:45

I don't do it and have found it weird how normal many other parents find it, but then I do also appreciate that now some kids actually prefer their parents to track them on their because it avoid the cringe factor of parents messaging to check where they are/if they're on their way home or, horror actually phoning them when they're with their mates - social death!

Bosephine · 12/02/2022 13:44

@fairylightsandwaxmelts Think we'll just have to agree to disagree.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 12/02/2022 13:43

@planningtomakeaplan That must have been horrific, and I can understand why you'd be so vigilant with your own children.

I worry the tracking tech really would lull me into a false sense of security, and probably my daughters as well. I agree with the posters who suggest that someone snatching a child these days would toss out the phone (or the whole school backpack) first thing. A smart watch would probably be removed and binned pretty quickly too.

These dangers have always been present. I have an elderly relative who climbed into a stranger's car back in the 50s and then realised she was being abducted. Her neighbourhood was so rough back then, a young girl her age was murdered one year and she saw the body while walking home.

All of these possibilities scare me. But I need to balance that against allowing my daughters the chance to develop their confidence and solve problems, just as I was allowed to back in the 90s. Our eldest DD is actually far less confident than the middle one, probably because we were so inclined to hover and intervene with her, rather than give her a little more space to figure things out for herself, even when that made us nervous.

Every family and neighbourhood has different circumstances to work with. I genuinely can't see either of my girls remaining savvy if they think Mom's tracking them anyway. I think they'd relax on that skill maybe a little too much.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 13:40

@Bosephine

They're saying that there's a thin line between tracking for the right reasons and tracking for the wrong ones, and when you normalise tracking someone's every move it's not necessarily easy to know when that line has been crossed.

I don't see how the line is any thinner than the line between any other behaviour with consent and without consent. You may as well say that freely agreeing to sex makes you more likely to be coerced into sex at a later date.

Should add that I'm not arguing for tracking- I don't track my partner and he doesn't track me.

They're not really the same thing though, are they?

You can be tracked without your knowledge and behind your back. It can be used to stop you doing certain things or it can cause you to lie just to avoid an argument.

I know what you're saying when you say that some things are fine consensually and not fine without consent, but I think the line here is really thin and the potential for abuse is huge.

snowstorm2012 · 12/02/2022 13:31

@Fuuuuuckit

Ha, my ds is 18 now, never ever felt the need to track his phone. And with lockdowns taking a big chunk of the last 2 years' freedom, I hardly needed to track him, just bang on the ceiling at mealtimes. I occasionally text 'are you OK?' if he's forgotten to let me know he's arrived somewhere safely (just passed his driving test), the usual response I get is 'no mum, I crashed into a ditch Smile'
This made me laugh, it's exactly the response I get when I ask my son if he got to wherever he was going okay 😂😂
BuddhaForMary · 12/02/2022 13:30

@Bitofachinwag

,None of us see it as an invasion of privacy at all. If I felt "watched" then I'd turn it off

It doesn't matter if you "feel watched". you ARE watched and not just by the people you have given permission to watch you. You are also watched by google or whatever other company you are giving away your information to.

You are slowly being groomed into accepting more and more surveillance ( Alexas, Ring door bells etc) by these large corporations ( and possibly governments) just to " keep you safe".

And no, it doesn't matter if you think that your life isn't "interesting" the potential to control a population that readily accepts this kind of surveillance in exchange for a false sense of "feeling safe" or so that they know when to put their kettle on is huge.

I came here to say something along these lines, but this post sums up how I feel about the rising popularity of constant surveillance.
Photolass · 12/02/2022 13:30

@liveforsummer

Depends on the age of the teen. Dd will be 13 this year and happily shared her location on what's app when she's out with her friends. Was helpful last week when her friend ditched her up town and all the usual bus stops were closed and she had no idea how to then get home.
Why couldn't she just phone you?
Gizacluethen · 12/02/2022 13:25

DH and i both have trackers. DS will have trackers when he's out and about and when he's driving. Part of my job involves accidents and an employee was found by his boss because he was using the companies tracked van when he went off the road into a ditch in the middle of nowhere, you could barely see him from the road. If it hadn't had a tracker they'd have just thought he was skiving and he'd have been lucky to be found by a passing car.

So he'll be tracked, but not secretly and we wouldn't be able to read his messages and stuff. But we'll have a codeword for needing collecting immediately and we can get straight to him wherever he is.

Stillgoings · 12/02/2022 13:20

My dh and I have an app that we put on this summer when I was going to support him on a long distance cycling event. We haven't taken it off because it's really handy, mainly in terms of dinner. I am not against tracking at all.

Bosephine · 12/02/2022 13:18

They're saying that there's a thin line between tracking for the right reasons and tracking for the wrong ones, and when you normalise tracking someone's every move it's not necessarily easy to know when that line has been crossed.

I don't see how the line is any thinner than the line between any other behaviour with consent and without consent. You may as well say that freely agreeing to sex makes you more likely to be coerced into sex at a later date.

Should add that I'm not arguing for tracking- I don't track my partner and he doesn't track me.

Bitofachinwag · 12/02/2022 13:08

,None of us see it as an invasion of privacy at all. If I felt "watched" then I'd turn it off

It doesn't matter if you "feel watched". you ARE watched and not just by the people you have given permission to watch you. You are also watched by google or whatever other company you are giving away your information to.

You are slowly being groomed into accepting more and more surveillance ( Alexas, Ring door bells etc) by these large corporations ( and possibly governments) just to " keep you safe".

And no, it doesn't matter if you think that your life isn't "interesting" the potential to control a population that readily accepts this kind of surveillance in exchange for a false sense of "feeling safe" or so that they know when to put their kettle on is huge.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 12:36

@Bosephine

I don’t find the “it normalises abuse” line persuasive at all.

My husband and I share all our money and regularly take cash from each other’s wallets- totally fine assuming mutual consent. If we did it without consent it would be theft. The idea that you shouldn’t do something with agreement because without agreement it’s abuse is a total non-starter. Look at sex.

Nobody is saying that tracking automatically normalises abuse.

They're saying that there's a thin line between tracking for the right reasons and tracking for the wrong ones, and when you normalise tracking someone's every move it's not necessarily easy to know when that line has been crossed.

Fuuuuuckit · 12/02/2022 12:25

Ha, my ds is 18 now, never ever felt the need to track his phone. And with lockdowns taking a big chunk of the last 2 years' freedom, I hardly needed to track him, just bang on the ceiling at mealtimes. I occasionally text 'are you OK?' if he's forgotten to let me know he's arrived somewhere safely (just passed his driving test), the usual response I get is 'no mum, I crashed into a ditch Smile'

cherryonthecakes · 12/02/2022 12:19

I don't track my kids. They don't want to be tracked and that's fair enough. They are good at texting or calling if they are running late etc Their location is private on SnapChat too.

I think that many time don't realise that location can be faked on tracking apps and they can be inaccurate

There are situations that I would use a tracking app. For example I know people who have them on dogs or elderly parents who are prone to wandering off.

Fuuuuuckit · 12/02/2022 12:17

Jesus, I'm absolutely horrified at the number of people who are OK with tracking!!

I would not be OK with another adult tracking me (I'm open about where I'm going, who I'm with and am completely able to find a way to get in touch with all my nearest and dearest if I'm running late/need a lift/stuck in traffic). Why would my mum or her partner need to know where I am - or me know where they are? It's 30 years since I left home, they can go wherever they want.

As for my kids. I (up until now) thought I was a bit helicopter-y in my parenting. They've had phones since before they started secondary school. But when they were younger, if they were going out it was usually to a friend's house, and I'd have ok'd it with their parent. Now they're older they are again open with me about where they're going, and with who, and when they'll be home. They know my mobile number and have been able to repeat it since maybe 8 years old. They call or message me if their plans change. We live in the suburbs of a city, and I've travelled to 'town' with them so many times I'm not worried about them getting lost, or finding the right bus. Since they were tiny they've been taught to 'find a shop lady' if they got separated from me - I have every confidence they can figure minor problems out by themselves, and delight in telling me how resilient they were afterwards.

Why on earth do folk think its OK to have such access to others' lives as this? And why do they think they need it? The chances of serious incident (I mean things like child abduction, murder on the way home from the pub, rather than tea being delayed by 10 minutes) are so, so minute that this seems completely dis-proportional.

MrPenguinsPoppers · 12/02/2022 12:10

@NoneOfYour32Potatoes I look back at that time with complete sadness. I should have been enjoying shopping trips and meeting friends, instead I spent half my time in total paranoia that one of my parents were about to turn up.

With the benefit of age and lots of talking I did eventually get to understand why it happened. My Mum had lost a child at birth before me, I was an only child. I was very over protected and I do get that now, but none of this was my fault. My parents should have had counselling but at the time it didn't exist. I spent years thinking I must have been such a horrid child to deserve this, but it wasn't my fault.

Obviously my case is extreme, but the whole idea of tracking just does not sit well with me. My DC's had phones. If they needed me they could call me.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 12:03

@MrPenguinsPoppers

I grew up in the days before technological tracking was possible. This did not stop my parents. I'd be out with friends, minding my own business and spot my Fathers car slowly drive past. One night I was meeting a friend and was aware I was being followed. I was quite scared at the time and managed to pop behind a wall out of sight. Imagine my surprise when my Dad turned the corner.

That was two incidents I recall but there were many, all at the behest of my Mum who desperately needed to know where I was, what I was doing and who I was with. This started at around 14 and continued to 17, at which point I walked out and didn't return for two years. I was effectively stalked by my own parents.

It took years to repair the relationship, and it's exactly why I never tracked my own teens past the point of 'where you off to?'.

Yes, exactly- people who are going to stalk someone else are going to find a way, tech or no tech. It really denotes a problem in the relationship rather than a tech problem.

I had a very close friend in my teens whose parents were similar to yours (also in the days before tech tracking) and we would sometimes see her mom when we were out. My friend also had to be at home studying when her parents weren’t there and her parents would phone the landline to make sure she was studying- we used to forward the phone calls to my landline so she could hang out at my house and we would all be quiet when the phone would ring in case it was her parents. Her overbearing parents just drove her to subvert their controlling attempts.

Stalkers gonna stalk, even some parents.

That article just says “we don’t know how tracking kids will affect them but really trust and open communication should be paramount” well, no shit. As for letting them get lost and finding their way, even with Google maps, they can still do that. I certainly can.

Bosephine · 12/02/2022 12:02

I don’t find the “it normalises abuse” line persuasive at all.

My husband and I share all our money and regularly take cash from each other’s wallets- totally fine assuming mutual consent. If we did it without consent it would be theft. The idea that you shouldn’t do something with agreement because without agreement it’s abuse is a total non-starter. Look at sex.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 11:54

I don’t understand the hysteria about it being an invasion of privacy. If you feel that your partner is controlling because they want to track you then the tracking is not your problem, the relationship is doomed.The partner still be controlling or obsessive without the tracking.

Nobody is saying otherwise.

But the more these things are normalised, the more they can be used against people when they object.

Someone could argue "there's no reason for you not to be tracked - my parents tracked each other and they were happy" etc.

The more people track each other (and their kids) the more it's seen as "normal" and so it becomes harder to object to.

The tracking just adds an extra layer of coercion to relationships and could stop people going and seeing friends/family or accessing help if they know their partner can track their every move and cause a fight (or worse) because of it.

MrPenguinsPoppers · 12/02/2022 11:50

I grew up in the days before technological tracking was possible. This did not stop my parents.
I'd be out with friends, minding my own business and spot my Fathers car slowly drive past. One night I was meeting a friend and was aware I was being followed. I was quite scared at the time and managed to pop behind a wall out of sight. Imagine my surprise when my Dad turned the corner.

That was two incidents I recall but there were many, all at the behest of my Mum who desperately needed to know where I was, what I was doing and who I was with. This started at around 14 and continued to 17, at which point I walked out and didn't return for two years. I was effectively stalked by my own parents.

It took years to repair the relationship, and it's exactly why I never tracked my own teens past the point of 'where you off to?'.

Tohaveandtohold · 12/02/2022 11:50

I don’t understand the hysteria about it being an invasion of privacy. If you feel that your partner is controlling because they want to track you then the tracking is not your problem, the relationship is doomed.The partner still be controlling or obsessive without the tracking.

In a place where all the people involved consent to being tracked then I don’t see what the issue is.
My children are young so I’ve not had to deal with that but we started using the tracking app when MIL asked us to use it to check on her. She is a community nurse and lives abroad, in a country where the gun laws are relaxed, etc, she goes to lots of people’s homes and sometimes to places she’s never been to, she felt ‘safe’ because we agreed to keep the app to check her if we’ve not heard from her. Since then, myself and dh have added ourselves to. Since wfh, I’ve not had any need to check him on it but if he starts travelling again for work, I’ll check if he’s not yet home and I just want to see if he’s driving. He picks up for one of our kids after her activity on his way from work and he used to tell me to check 30 mins to pick up time so I’ll know if he’ll be there in time or I pick up myself because then, I’ll have to postpone bedtime for the younger child, etc. I’m definitely not interested in where he has been.
If my child is older, I’ll ask her and hopefully she’ll be happy to have the app too. As a teenager, I never had to sneak out with friends, etc I told my parents or siblings where I was going after school. I hope my child will be that way and they’ll know that the tracker is not to limit them but to hopefully allow them the freedom they need sensibly

bebbdebb · 12/02/2022 11:33

@Madcats

I suppose it depends on your family circumstances. All the family have it on their phones, but only look at it once in a blue moon.

We first used it for when DD was transported to fixtures and competitions by her school and club. It saved a lot of hanging about on parents' part.

If DH is away and had a long journey home it was useful to see whether it is worth waiting to eat as a family or leave him to fend for himself.

Yes, my teens travel across London to various fixtures, sometimes with several changes of train/busbon the way, so it's useful to see where they are on their journey and that they've arrived safely. I don't need to remind them to tell me they've got there safely (which they would find very annoying). Also, they have left phones on buses in the past - you can see where they are and meet the bus on its return journey to pick it up.