Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 15:17

Perfectly said @RedToothBrush.

It just gives people a false sense of security and an easy way out.

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2022 15:14

Obviously carrying a tracker doesn't keep you safe. What it does mean is that if someone is in danger eg if they are supposed to be walking to school and are suddenly travelling at speed (ie in a car) in a different direction, then loved ones can be aware that something is wrong, and make attempts to contact the person or intervene to prevent something worse happening, rather than not knowing there is a potential problem until after your child has been raped/murdered/assaulted.

You are at work. You are not constantly looking at your child's tracker to make sure something funny isn't happening (or at least I hope you aren't and actually do some work). You happen to look at your phone when you get a moment about 9.45am. You think 'huh' whats going on. You then do what exactly? Ring the police and say 'my child's phone track is in the wrong place'? Talk to your boss and decide to nip out of work to check the location of your child's phone? If you do go and check up on your child, what exactly are you going to be able to do if, in the unlikely event, they have been kidnapped? How do you tell the difference between bunking off school and being kidnapped? If your child is bunking off school and get caught in this way, do you think they will be dumb enough to do this again? Or do you think they will disable the tracker / leave it somewhere else? If they are bunking off, you've already failed on the parenting and are now going to have to do some actual parenting which you should have done before installing said tracker.

Honestly, I don't get the insane logic of any of this. Its a parental anxiety manager thats all. And in a couple of years your darling is still going to be leaving home and having a life (hopefully without still being tracked). How are you going to cope with that then?

We have a mass culture at the moment which seems intent on profitting off anxieties which would be better managed in different ways. Worse still they offer false senses of security, whereby little darlings are more likely to do things that cover their tracks if they are up to no good, rather than communicating with parents or leaving a trail which, if god forbid something did actually happen, could potentially waste more time than it saved (lets all go on a wild goose chase for a device rather than a child).

You should be building up and fostering trust and a proper relationship, and not relying on devices as your primary way to ensure you know what your kids are up to and who with.

The logic and thought processes going on here are completely back to front.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 15:11

@Jeyesfluid

I track my kids. They agree and consent to it. It's helpful particularly as they have a long journey to school, that I can see they've got the bus and got into school ok. Each to their own though.
Why can't they just...text you if there's a problem? And surely school will ring if they don't turn up? What does the tracking achieve?
MisAnn · 12/02/2022 15:11

We have life 360. No big deal. Got it originally in case of lost phone and was useful when ds was out and about when he was a pre teen to see when he was on his way home for dinner etc.
Now I insist he has it on when I go out as I like to go hillwalking alone and would like to be found should I have an accident. So basically my teen tracks me now I'm a middle aged liability Grin.

Jeyesfluid · 12/02/2022 15:04

I track my kids. They agree and consent to it. It's helpful particularly as they have a long journey to school, that I can see they've got the bus and got into school ok.

Each to their own though.

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2022 14:59

@Photolass

It pings to tell me they have arrived at school. Since parents are legally responsible for their children's school attendance I think that knowing they are at school when they should be is indeed called good parenting, and just assuming they are there when actually you have no idea where they are would be called 'piss poor parenting. You appear to have very little trust in your children's ability to find and turn up at their school.
I'd go further than that and say outright that if you have to use a tracker to ensure your kids have gone to school as they are supposed to, I would say you have well and truly already failed at parenting!
Photolass · 12/02/2022 14:52

It pings to tell me they have arrived at school. Since parents are legally responsible for their children's school attendance I think that knowing they are at school when they should be is indeed called good parenting, and just assuming they are there when actually you have no idea where they are would be called 'piss poor parenting.
You appear to have very little trust in your children's ability to find and turn up at their school.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 14:50

Obviously carrying a tracker doesn't keep you safe. What it does mean is that if someone is in danger eg if they are supposed to be walking to school and are suddenly travelling at speed (ie in a car) in a different direction, then loved ones can be aware that something is wrong, and make attempts to contact the person or intervene to prevent something worse happening, rather than not knowing there is a potential problem until after your child has been raped/murdered/assaulted.

But if someone is going to attack/rape/murder your child, they're going to switch the phone off and dump it at the first opportunity - so why would a tracker help?

It's not like I sit there staring it whenever my children are out of my sight. But in the event of them not being where they are expected to be at a particular time then I will have a look to see where they are. This can provide reassurance eg they are still walking from the station to school or raise a question - they are heading towards the park instead - which would lead me to check up on them that they are okay.

And what if they'd decided to switch their phone off or disable tracking?

It pings to tell me they have arrived at school. Since parents are legally responsible for their children's school attendance I think that knowing they are at school when they should be is indeed called good parenting, and just assuming they are there when actually you have no idea where they are would be called 'piss poor parenting.'

And again, what if they turn it off? Or turn up at school and then walk out again later with their phones off/tracking disabled?

Tracking only tracks the device, not the person. So if you rely on tracking to know where your child is, what are you going to do when it fails or they turn it off?

You could check and see your child is at Joe's house, and think they are, but in reality they could have gone out and purposefully left their phone behind, putting them in even more danger as they're now out with no way of contacting you for help.

feb21 · 12/02/2022 14:44

Wow. Some strong reactions. We have Life360. I don't religiously monitor my teenagers. I look at it sometimes if I'm trying to work out when they'll need picking up from the station or timing tea if we have a quick turnaround.

I really don't see it as that big a deal, nor do my kids. They've chosen to have my credit card on their Samsung pay accounts so frankly I have more visibility of their locations from that, as it pings me when there's a payment.

Do it, don't do it. But I don't see it as a massive red flag. My kids have plenty of freedom, I don't use the app to track them around their nights out. It's just useful on some occasions and saves me calling them to ask what time they'll be home if it's tight time wise.

savehannah · 12/02/2022 14:42

@RedToothBrush

Carrying a tracker doesn't keep them safe!

If someone wanted to kidnap, rape, mug, assault, murder or otherwise harm you, you will not have a magic force field around you that stops it happening!!

Obviously carrying a tracker doesn't keep you safe. What it does mean is that if someone is in danger eg if they are supposed to be walking to school and are suddenly travelling at speed (ie in a car) in a different direction, then loved ones can be aware that something is wrong, and make attempts to contact the person or intervene to prevent something worse happening, rather than not knowing there is a potential problem until after your child has been raped/murdered/assaulted.

It's not like I sit there staring it whenever my children are out of my sight. But in the event of them not being where they are expected to be at a particular time then I will have a look to see where they are. This can provide reassurance eg they are still walking from the station to school or raise a question - they are heading towards the park instead - which would lead me to check up on them that they are okay.

It pings to tell me they have arrived at school. Since parents are legally responsible for their children's school attendance I think that knowing they are at school when they should be is indeed called good parenting, and just assuming they are there when actually you have no idea where they are would be called 'piss poor parenting.'

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 14:32

@cuno

I find people who state their opinions as absolutes to be weird and unhealthy because they are.

If you and your adult family members are all tracking each other you have more to worry about than my opinion. No-one I know thinks this is remotely normal. Only on Mumsnet, good grief.

I’m stating my opinion about your opinion. It’s okay, I am not worried about your opinion.
collieresponder88 · 12/02/2022 14:31

One of my daughters friends used to leave her phone at our house when she went out with my daughter on a night out because her mum was tracking her. Much more risky for her in my opinion to be without her phone her mum would have been better off just keeping contact with texts rather than tracking which Is what I do with My teens

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 14:30

@savehannah

There's nothing sinister about it, it's called parenting. Just because it didn't exist in previous generations doesn't mean parents didn't worry. My mum sent my dad out in his dressing gown in the car once to look for me aged 18 when I had missed the night bus and was two hours later coming home than I had planned.
I would actually say it's pretty piss-poor parenting.

Parenting is teaching your kids about independence and freedom - it's not tracking them on their phones the second they're allowed out of your sight.

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2022 14:25

Carrying a tracker doesn't keep them safe!

If someone wanted to kidnap, rape, mug, assault, murder or otherwise harm you, you will not have a magic force field around you that stops it happening!!

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2022 14:23

@savehannah

There's nothing sinister about it, it's called parenting. Just because it didn't exist in previous generations doesn't mean parents didn't worry. My mum sent my dad out in his dressing gown in the car once to look for me aged 18 when I had missed the night bus and was two hours later coming home than I had planned.
Er how is this parenting?!

Your children will not suffer in anyway if you don't have it!

The fact that its seen as almost essential and as a comforter to anxiety is quite worrying.

Its just a way of not letting go and allowing full independence - and not necessarily the independence of the child at that!

Some of the reasons for using it on here are troubling tbh.

I think the only one i can get on board with, is avoiding teenage social death tbh (and frankly its good for kids to have that to a degree still).

cuno · 12/02/2022 14:22

I find people who state their opinions as absolutes to be weird and unhealthy because they are.

If you and your adult family members are all tracking each other you have more to worry about than my opinion. No-one I know thinks this is remotely normal. Only on Mumsnet, good grief.

Bakewelltart987 · 12/02/2022 14:16

@Landlubber2019

I track my kids, they track me. I also track my husband and my mom. It's about knowing they are safe.
That's ridiculous kids I get but mom and husband how is tracking them keeping them safe? More like spying on them.
savehannah · 12/02/2022 14:12

There's nothing sinister about it, it's called parenting. Just because it didn't exist in previous generations doesn't mean parents didn't worry. My mum sent my dad out in his dressing gown in the car once to look for me aged 18 when I had missed the night bus and was two hours later coming home than I had planned.

savehannah · 12/02/2022 14:10

@Echobelly

I don't do it and have found it weird how normal many other parents find it, but then I do also appreciate that now some kids actually prefer their parents to track them on their because it avoid the cringe factor of parents messaging to check where they are/if they're on their way home or, horror actually phoning them when they're with their mates - social death!
Quite true. If I had no idea where my kids were, especially late, I would be much more likely to ring them to check they are okay, than if I can see at a glance they are still at their friend's house.
savehannah · 12/02/2022 14:07

It's a useful tool for families to know each others' whereabouts. It's not about control. It's reassurance. It also tells you when someone's battery is nearly dead which is helpful as you won't be panicking that they haven't rung you etc. My kids can see me and my husband in it too so it's not just about tracking kids.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 14:02

Yes of course people can carry on tracking each other if they so wish, and me and others are entitled to find it weird and unhealthy because it is.

I find people who state their opinions as absolutes to be weird and unhealthy because they are.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 14:00

Sorry but unfettered access to your location at a press of a button is barmy. There is no need to track someone to check they are on their way home, it's neurotic is what it is.

Not a very nuanced opinion, is it? Neurotic and barmy.

Perhaps others choose to live a different life from the one that you lead and have differing opinions about how to interact socially with other people using technology. Maybe, even though I interact differently within my family than you, I am not barmy nor neurotic. It is a possibility.

cuno · 12/02/2022 13:59

@Bosephine
Yes of course people can carry on tracking each other if they so wish, and me and others are entitled to find it weird and unhealthy because it is.

Bosephine · 12/02/2022 13:57

@cuno It's (in part) about consent where people are suggesting sharing your location is a gateway to abuse.

I'm not arguing in favour of tracking generally- there are lots of good reasons not to do it. But telling people they shouldn't share their location with their husband because otherwise their children are less likely to recognise an abusive relationship (as PP have done up the thread) is not right.

cuno · 12/02/2022 13:53

@SparkleTwinkle101

My mum tracks me still (I'm 25). If I take it off it causes massive arguments but she'll still ring me and say. I see you're out at this time etc. It's annoying.

I do have it in for DH as he does for me which we use for knowing when to put dinner on/when to take the car out to swap them over but we don't look at it otherwise

And this EXACTLY proves my point. "But we're all consenting adults". And then look at the aggro it causes the moment you turn it off. Jesus.
Swipe left for the next trending thread