Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
Jeyesfluid · 12/02/2022 17:59

No my children don't have either of those things. Although potentially useful for those groups of children too.

But other people don't really need to understand it really. It's a choice individual families make for themselves, just like anything else.

Cameleongirl · 12/02/2022 17:57

I can completely understand tracking if your child has a physical or mental health condition that makes them especially vulnerable.

Jeyesfluid · 12/02/2022 17:43

Why can't they just...text you if there's a problem? And surely school will ring if they don't turn up? What does the tracking achieve?

Well they could do that, but I'm happy with the tracker. Then they don't need to bother to remember. Also the school don't ring when they don't turn up. They sent a message through their app. Which often doesn't arrive until the afternoon. So it works for me to know they've got in safely without a gap of some hours before I know if there's a potential problem. But obviously if other people don't feel comfortable using trackers then it's up to them. Each to their own.

JustLyra · 12/02/2022 17:42

The only one of our children that was tracked was our DD with narcolepsy as a way to give her more freedom safely. It was her suggestion.

However, she turns it on and off whenever she likes and it’s only ever actually been used once when she was an agreed/set amount of time late home. Tracking her generally isn’t on.

My biggest concern with this tracking stuff is two fold. Firstly the number of people who use it to see when someone will be home for dinner plans - it takes minute to text or call when on the way home. Using technology to allow people to get lazy and/or rude isn’t a good thing.
Secondly it’s an abusers paradise. I’ve made it absolutely clear to mine that a partner insisting on tracking you is not normal. I’m very thankfully that DD instantly dumped a boyfriend who kicked off that her tracking app wasn’t on when she was out with friends - she was with friends so it wasn’t needed.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 17:41

@megletthesecond

bit I won't know for 20 mins or so if I wait for the school. If I can see her phone is at school at 8:20 I know I don't have to panic. I don't want her "missing" for 20 mins if she hasn't arrived. We're in CAMHS and self harm hell at the moment.
I have to ask, though, what's to stop her giving her phone to a friend to take to school for her, or simply turning it off? How would you know where she was then?
megletthesecond · 12/02/2022 17:39

bit I won't know for 20 mins or so if I wait for the school. If I can see her phone is at school at 8:20 I know I don't have to panic. I don't want her "missing" for 20 mins if she hasn't arrived. We're in CAMHS and self harm hell at the moment.

justanothermanicmonday21 · 12/02/2022 17:36

I track my 12 year old son, he's diabetic and we have both agreed to this incase anything was ever to happen to him I would know where he is but tbh I hardly ever use it as he's really good at telling me where he is and keeping in contact. As he gets older we will probably change it as I doubt I'll be tracking him at 16!!

BuddhaForMary · 12/02/2022 17:30

I think there is a deeper issue here - we think it's totally innoccuous to track people we love because we just want to know they are safe. But when did we begin to feel anxious/ unsafe if we didn't constantly know where people were - ie. to the exact pinpoint on a map?

The more we rely on this stuff the less secure any of us will feel.

We are teaching teenagers that they are 'unsafe' all the time. It's interesting that someone mentions their daughter wanting to be tracked .
This links in to children not playing so freely and with autonomy as in previous generations - we are beginning to develop fearful minds and a belief that unless we are 'seen' and 'known ' every minute we are at risk

Think of the joy of being a growing teen - I remember it! - knowing that you are 'off grid' 'really hanging out with your mates in a new bubble your mum doesn't know exactly where you are and what you are doing - that is part of developing the independence that makes you a resilient and confident adult

When we say to teens - you are only safe if i know exactly where you are at all times (and I do wonder what 'safe' means here? kidnapping?! getting lost? ) - what are they internalising about their own capabilities to manage risk in the world.

I love every word of this post @Wondergirl100

We're walking into a world of normalising day to day surveillance. Making teens feel they're only safe if someone is watching their every move. Not sure I like where that's heading.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 17:28

@megletthesecond

I have to check my DD has arrived at school. Parents who don't have a school refuser should count themselves lucky.
Why do you need to check? Surely the school ring you if she doesn't arrive?
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 17:27

@LuckyAmy1986

I track DH. With his permission…. It was very handy the other day when he lost his phone and we were able to track It at the shop we had been in 20 minutes earlier. Very handy
But surely he remembers where he'd been and would just retrace his steps, or call the phone itself?
Cameleongirl · 12/02/2022 17:25

I will say that the parents I’m friends with who track their older teens are more anxious types who worry a lot about their children, even though they appear to be well-functioning, attend school regularly, etc. One of DD’s friends is turning 18 later this year and I wonder whether she’ll refuse to be tracked once she’s an adult-and how her Dad will react. He’s the anxious parent, her Mum finds his attitude annoying! He’s a lovely person, but very protective.

nanbread · 12/02/2022 17:17

@Wondergirl100

I think there is a deeper issue here - we think it's totally innoccuous to track people we love because we just want to know they are safe. But when did we begin to feel anxious/ unsafe if we didn't constantly know where people were - ie. to the exact pinpoint on a map?

The more we rely on this stuff the less secure any of us will feel.

We are teaching teenagers that they are 'unsafe' all the time. It's interesting that someone mentions their daughter wanting to be tracked .
This links in to children not playing so freely and with autonomy as in previous generations - we are beginning to develop fearful minds and a belief that unless we are 'seen' and 'known ' every minute we are at risk

Think of the joy of being a growing teen - I remember it! - knowing that you are 'off grid' 'really hanging out with your mates in a new bubble your mum doesn't know exactly where you are and what you are doing - that is part of developing the independence that makes you a resilient and confident adult

When we say to teens - you are only safe if i know exactly where you are at all times (and I do wonder what 'safe' means here? kidnapping?! getting lost? ) - what are they internalising about their own capabilities to manage risk in the world.

100% agree
Bitofachinwag · 12/02/2022 17:08

@LuckyAmy1986

I track DH. With his permission…. It was very handy the other day when he lost his phone and we were able to track It at the shop we had been in 20 minutes earlier. Very handy
Yes I see your point, but surely he knew he'd been in that particular shop 20 minutes earlier and that his phone might be there?
StScholastica · 12/02/2022 17:07

I think its very Intrusive and I'm glad it wasn't a thing when my DC were young teenagers. They need to find their own way in the world and learn personal safety.
I think its also likely to increase parent anxiety rather than reducing it. Better to recognise that we live in a relatively safe country and learn to relax rather than drive yourself mad with helicoptering.

Hamjamwich · 12/02/2022 17:06

Using Life 360 has helped my son on two occasions. I'm glad we have it

BuddhaForMary · 12/02/2022 17:05

@RedToothBrush I agree with absolutely everything you've written.

Bitofachinwag · 12/02/2022 17:05

@megletthesecond

I have to check my DD has arrived at school. Parents who don't have a school refuser should count themselves lucky.
Won't the school tell you if she hasn't arrived?
Bitofachinwag · 12/02/2022 17:03

It does mean is that if someone is in danger eg if t (ie in a car) in a different direction, then loved ones can be aware that something is wrong, and make attempts to contact the person or intervene to prevent something worse happening, rather than not knowing there is a potential problem until after your child has been raped/murdered/assaulted

It's not like I sit there staring it whenever my children are out of my sight. But in the event of them not being where they are expected to be at a particular time then I will have a look to see where they are

But unless you are "sitting there staring at it" when "they are supposed to be walking to school" you won't know if they "are suddenly travelling at speed in a car".

LuckyAmy1986 · 12/02/2022 17:02

I track DH. With his permission….
It was very handy the other day when he lost his phone and we were able to track
It at the shop we had been in 20 minutes earlier. Very handy

Bitofachinwag · 12/02/2022 16:57

@RedToothBrush

Carrying a tracker doesn't keep them safe!

If someone wanted to kidnap, rape, mug, assault, murder or otherwise harm you, you will not have a magic force field around you that stops it happening!!

I completely agree.
Landlubber2019 · 12/02/2022 16:43

@Bakewelltart987
With consent my mum and i track each other, whilst it doesn't keep her safe it can provide reassurance to me that she hasn't fallen or is unwell and needing assistance, which she hasn't been able to alert us to. The tracker simply telling me she hasn't left the home in 24 hours would be huge flag for me especially if she hasn't answered the phone or texts. I don't care where she goes and I don't care to spy on her either....

onedayoranother · 12/02/2022 16:34

We had mutual tracking when they first got their phones but my son took the app off and that was that. My daughter never had enough memory to have it work, but she has no objection to it. It can be useful in that 'I expected them home hours ago' situation, but I do think it's an invasion of privacy too.

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2022 15:47

The family I know who all track each other have two kids who are the most well behaved kids going.

The Dad is over authoritarian and gets pissy if his wife does something like go to the pub without him knowing in advance. He's generally a bloody nice guy, but he has moments where he acts like he owns the family and they must obey him. To an unhealthy degree. (Yes we have challenged over it in the past and are making some progress).

Its far from being about making sure the kids are ok. Its asserting control over family members.

In this sense, I think the ability for it to be misused, far outweighs any (non-existent) benefits it might have.

cuno · 12/02/2022 15:29

@RedToothBrush

Thank you so much for putting it so eloquently. In the children's homes I've worked at it would be unethical, lazy and entirely inappropriate to track them by their mobile phones constantly. And these children are far more vulnerable than the average Mumsnetter's darlings, and honestly not nearly impossible they might be kidnapped or some such. Yeah I don't think anyone on here is tracking their 16 year old with the genuine fear they might be kidnapped and tracking will save the day... and surely you'd have to be watching it like a hawk to notice something was wrong, if you're checking it when you would usually do a call or text what difference does it make. In fact their phone could be thrown away somewhere innocuous that you wouldn't think twice about while they're halfway across the country. Ludicrous. And to think people are subjecting their partners to this, christ alive.

megletthesecond · 12/02/2022 15:18

I have to check my DD has arrived at school. Parents who don't have a school refuser should count themselves lucky.

Swipe left for the next trending thread