Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
feb21 · 13/02/2022 08:49

Nor do I follow them or view their posts on FB, Insta, Snapchat or whatever else they use.

feb21 · 13/02/2022 08:44

I think the point is that tracking doesn't have to be a huge red flag.

My 17 year old went out to a party after school on Friday night. I didn't look at Life360, I didn't track, see or speak to him for 24 hours, I didn't wait up. I trusted him to get himself home. Tracking doesn't have to equal curtailing their freedom or not giving them the space to sort their own arrangements out.

But it's useful on occasions. Some nights he has 45 minutes at home before sports training so it's a quick dinner and back out. I could call him. But he's a fairly new driver and I'd rather he was concentrating on driving than chatting on the phone. I suspect he sees the app as less invasive than me texting or calling him.

If he wanted to turn it off, that would be totally fine with me. Snapchat shows their location to all sorts of random people. A family Life360 used for specific purposes isn't a big deal for us.

Angrymum22 · 13/02/2022 08:24

I think the pp who claim to be horrified that others use the tracking facilities in their phones need a reality check. If we use a mobile phone we are being tracked by someone or something.
My phone know when I am going to work and tells me how long it’s going to take me to get there. It pings this information to me as I leave home or work. I have never set the phone up to do it, it has learned my routine. My phone is a smart phone it is programmed to learn and apply, it’s what we pay for.
If you use any of the social media platforms/apps you are being tracked, you may have switched off the sharing of your location but the app will still use it. Many apps just can’t be used without your location.
Being able to track your children is hardly intrusive when the world and his wife can see them on Snapchat, or they use any number of apps that require their location.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 13/02/2022 07:16

@Blackwidow47

Well I’m 49 and my kids are 32 &30 and we all track each other! One even lives inAmerica. I also track and have shared personal tracking with 5 girlfriends. It’s a safety thing and nothing controlling about it. We love it. I went travelling round Europe for 2 months last year and my friend caught me visiting Mcdonalds 🤣
How is it a safety thing when it doesn't keep you safe?
scooterbear · 13/02/2022 06:45

My dd got spiked and assaulted just before Christmas. We had no idea where she was and the police wouldn't help because she hadn't been missing long enough. I didn't track her but fortunately her sister could see her in snap maps. We found her stumbling down a random street and we were able to get her to a and e. Frankly the worst experience of all our lives. But if we hadn't been able to track her god knows how much worse it would have been.

She is 14. Walked to Asda at 8.30 at night. 5 minute walk. Got chatting to a few boys she knows from school, took a sip of a drink from some older boy that was there with them-and ended up missing for 3 hours and assaulted. We live in a well to do town where this stuff rarely happens. Until it does. So my views on tracking have obviously changed. And so have the DD's, because now they want us to do it to keep them safe.

liveforsummer · 13/02/2022 06:00

That's awful, don't know how you can find that funny. I'll certainly not let my daughter think this is normal or okay. Can't say the same for people who from an early age are used to them and their entire families being tracked though.

But you're daughter will think it's normal because all her friends will have apps that do it. As teens their peers are a huge influence, more so than anyone else and what they see as a stuffy parent lecturing them about not doing things makes little difference. We already know that because teens get up to all sorts with their mates despite being advised or not allowed.

garlictwist · 13/02/2022 05:52

@Bitofachinwag

We all track each other for transparency, it's not about control For transparency? That sounds like you don't trust the people you are tracking.
I completely agree. Tracking people does not tell you they are safe - only where their phone is.

If you really want to know their location for a specific purpose, such as meeting them at the shops - hardly something that occurs multiple times a day - just ask them.

What if they don't have their phone with them? I regularly leave my phone in the car or at home if I'm not going to be out for long.

I hate the thought of being tracked.

solbunny · 13/02/2022 05:39

@cuno because I don't really care! If you do then that's absolutely fine, you can live your life accordingly. My use of technology doesn't affect you so no need to be so short!

cuno · 13/02/2022 05:34

Oh yes a good point about Snapchat - the Snapmap came out when I was at uni and Jesus the amount of people I added in freshers week that proceeded to have my location for years following is ridiculous 🤣 so that probably desensitised me pretty well to tracking.

That's awful, don't know how you can find that funny. I'll certainly not let my daughter think this is normal or okay. Can't say the same for people who from an early age are used to them and their entire families being tracked though. Hmm

solbunny · 13/02/2022 01:52

@Angrymum22

DS17 and friends are so used to being “visible” on Snapchat that being tracked by their parents is a convenience rather than intrusive. DS just tells me to use find my friends when he wants a lift. They are also capable of switching it off if they want. My niece, who are at uni, like to know my DSis is safe since she lives alone and often walks her dog alone. I have a habit of putting my phone onto silent at work. If DH needs to get hold of me he can ring the landline if he knows I am there or at home. We don’t use it to constantly track. Just to locate if we are struggling to get in touch. When I’m driving home through the lanes the signal is very intermittent, if DH can’t reach me tracking lets him know I’m on my way but maybe in a black spot.
Oh yes a good point about Snapchat - the Snapmap came out when I was at uni and Jesus the amount of people I added in freshers week that proceeded to have my location for years following is ridiculous 🤣 so that probably desensitised me pretty well to tracking. I don't use the snapmap (or Snapchat at all tbh) anymore as I don't really want all and sundry knowing my every move, but I'm perfectly happy for friends and family to see.
solbunny · 13/02/2022 01:48

@iCouldSleepForAYear it's just what works for us. Everyone's different. The type of evenings where I'm concerned with getting dinner out as quick as possible are usually the type of evenings where I value speed, and clicking on an app and just seeing his location is a lot quicker than phoning or waiting for a text back!

Also, it's not really an "argument" for tracking, I'm just giving one example of how we use it. I didn't one day say "oh DH, please can I track your location so I can accurately time dinner". We just decided to use the app for no real reason and without much thought, and eventually I found it useful r.e. dinner timings.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 13/02/2022 01:38

I just don't understand the "putting dinner on" argument. I've been late home from work plenty of times. My husband usually calls me if he wants to refine timings for food, and we ... speak.

If I'm really running late, he leaves a plate of food for me to microwave and serves himself and the kids.

Jeyesfluid · 13/02/2022 01:02

Tracking apps don’t preclude trust and openness. One can utilise tech and even tracking tech and maintain an open and trusting relationship with their teens.

Absolutely.

Siameasy · 13/02/2022 01:01

I didn’t know you could do this and I find it disturbing and controlling

Angrymum22 · 13/02/2022 00:59

DS17 and friends are so used to being “visible” on Snapchat that being tracked by their parents is a convenience rather than intrusive. DS just tells me to use find my friends when he wants a lift. They are also capable of switching it off if they want.
My niece, who are at uni, like to know my DSis is safe since she lives alone and often walks her dog alone.
I have a habit of putting my phone onto silent at work. If DH needs to get hold of me he can ring the landline if he knows I am there or at home.
We don’t use it to constantly track. Just to locate if we are struggling to get in touch. When I’m driving home through the lanes the signal is very intermittent, if DH can’t reach me tracking lets him know I’m on my way but maybe in a black spot.

RedToothBrush · 13/02/2022 00:40

I also wonder how many teens freely consent to being tracked, and how many go along with it to keep the peace, or because their parent's anxiety has rubbed off onto them and they now feel unsafe without it.

Whats the MN much used acronym?

FOG.

Fear Obligation and Guilt.

All this business about 'im safer' certainly is pandering to that.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 13/02/2022 00:33

I went travelling round Europe for 2 months last year and my friend caught me visiting Mcdonalds 🤣

It can be fun, can’t it! It’s really nice to read your post.

U2HasTheEdge · 13/02/2022 00:27

I think it is awful. It is scary how normal it has become.

I do worry at times when my older teenage son is out clubbing. There would maybe be some sense of security to be able to track that he is still in the club, or on the way home in a taxi, but I know that this is not fair to him, and safety behaviours like this are rarely good for managing anxiety.

It's all well and good to say your teen can just turn it off, but they are not going to want to alert you to the fact that they don't want to be tracked. That is likely to come with a few questions!

I do not want to teach my children that it is OK to be tracked for their 'safety', or other people's convience. It really isnt OK.

I also wonder how many teens freely consent to being tracked, and how many go along with it to keep the peace, or because their parent's anxiety has rubbed off onto them and they now feel unsafe without it.

If my husband wanted to track me so he knew when to put dinner on, I would wonder what the heck is going on with him. A text message has always sufficed if he really needs to know where I am for some reason.

Doratheexploret · 13/02/2022 00:20

Mt daughter has Life360, she’s 15. I rarely use it unless she’s on her way home in the dark or something and I check to see if she’s close. She has no problem with it. My 14 year old son doesn’t want it so doesn’t have it. I can see where he is on snap chat of I need to. It’s not weird or a red flag.

RedToothBrush · 13/02/2022 00:10

@Blackwidow47

Well I’m 49 and my kids are 32 &30 and we all track each other! One even lives inAmerica. I also track and have shared personal tracking with 5 girlfriends. It’s a safety thing and nothing controlling about it. We love it. I went travelling round Europe for 2 months last year and my friend caught me visiting Mcdonalds 🤣
Again. A tracking app can't keep you safe! Its an anxiety security blanket!

What is it with this myth that a tracking app can somehow mysteriously keep you safe from harm in the real world?

What is it that makes people unable to see this is an app to manage and control your own anxiety?

Its absoluetely fascinating to see person after person trot this out.

HOW does it PHYSICALLY keep you safer than if you didn't have it?
It what way isn't it purely about you make you FEEL less scared of the world around you?

Big big difference.

Its all psychological.

Blackwidow47 · 13/02/2022 00:03

Well I’m 49 and my kids are 32 &30 and we all track each other! One even lives inAmerica. I also track and have shared personal tracking with 5 girlfriends. It’s a safety thing and nothing controlling about it. We love it. I went travelling round Europe for 2 months last year and my friend caught me visiting Mcdonalds 🤣

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 13/02/2022 00:00

I never did it and don't approve. I would rather build trust and openness with teens.

Tracking apps don’t preclude trust and openness. One can utilise tech and even tracking tech and maintain an open and trusting relationship with their teens.

solbunny · 12/02/2022 23:58

Not a parent of a child that age yet so can't comment much there, but I do always find it interesting to see such a wide range of opinion on location tracking.

Personally I have my husband, mother, and about five friends on my find my friends. It all started just with a "hey let's add each other on this" with no hidden anxieties or whatever as suggested by other posters. I mainly use it if I've got a busy evening and want tea out on the table and done with asap - DH leaves work at different times each day and I'm buggered if I can keep up with his timetable so I just use it to see when he sets off. I look at my friends' for amusement really. We often ask each other "what were you doing at X?!" which sounds intense I realise but it's only ever asked in a jokey way. Back before COVID lockdowns turned me into a home bird, it was very useful on nights out I have to say. A few of my friends have a tendency to wander off and it's useful to figure out how to get everyone back in one place for our taxi home 🤣

I do totally understand why other people aren't comfortable with it, but it's just never even been a second thought for me and my circle.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 23:56

@ClareBlue

And a very sinister development. I've just read about women finding apple tracking devices in their cars without their knowledge. Aparantley Apple tell them if it is a device not connected to their phone but partners can easily connect it to their partner's phone and collect data on their phone without the person knowing. This is a new level of concern.
And has nothing to do with the original post.
ClareBlue · 12/02/2022 23:41

And a very sinister development. I've just read about women finding apple tracking devices in their cars without their knowledge. Aparantley Apple tell them if it is a device not connected to their phone but partners can easily connect it to their partner's phone and collect data on their phone without the person knowing. This is a new level of concern.

Swipe left for the next trending thread