Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
Jeyesfluid · 13/02/2022 13:04

But we live in a society that’s ridiculously over protective of their kids.

If that were true parents would get their kids off social media, especially tik tok.

DeckardK · 13/02/2022 12:38

Good post @RedToothBrush

Reminds me of Jurassic Park...to paraphrase 'just because you could, you're not stopping to think whether you actually should'

catwomando · 13/02/2022 11:47

@PinkSyCo not proud but accept that it happens. When you are a kid with a fledgling sex life, creeping around is part of the process and to be expected that there will be a certain cat and mouse with the adults in your life 🤷‍♀️

To expect teenagers to be celibate (I know some are though) is just not realistic.

Oh, and if you read my post you'd know that she didn't know I was spying on her. I just called her to chat and make sure she was OK. Then I wheedled it out of her.

She's an adult now and a lovely, sensible person with a (different) and very lovely BF. We have a brilliant relationship.

catwomando · 13/02/2022 11:41

@cookiemonster2468 no it's not. She was showing a terrible breaking of trust by lying to me. It's my job as her parent to keep her safe. Staying over at a strangers house without parental knowledge at that age is not OK. It's no different to me ringing the parent of the house she claimed to be staying at to check up - which was what happened when I was a kid.

The only reason I checked was because I suspected she was lying. I was right and would do the same again in a heartbeat if I still had a child that age. Regular 'tracking' of every movement is weird and unnecessary but to check up when parental spidy senses were telling me something was up is totally within bounds.

As an adult I agree that it's an invasion of privacy, but she was a child.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 13/02/2022 11:22

I would love some journalist to properly investigate the whole subject

There are probably plenty of journos who have written about this. I would enjoy reading research from a social anthropologist, social psychologist or child social psychologist (if such a profession exists).

lovelyupnorth · 13/02/2022 11:22

Why would you. Occasionally my dds will share locations as can help with pick up or once when lost I could direct them out more easily. Other than that is their life.

But we live in a society that’s ridiculously over protective of their kids.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 13/02/2022 11:17

[quote Fedupsotired]@NoneOfYour32Potatoes I think it's from all the years we used to write it on their arms when we went to busy places 🤣[/quote]
Ha! I was just thinking the same thing.

I am the one now who has to have a written list of phone numbers with me. And sometimes I just write the feckin numbers on my arm (I do usually wear long sleeves!)

Jeyesfluid · 13/02/2022 11:15

Yeah my kids know my mobile. They have done since they were about 5. Just in case they accidentally got lost somewhere when we were out. Would always recommend teaching kids that at a young age, along with their address.

Fedupsotired · 13/02/2022 11:15

@NoneOfYour32Potatoes I think it's from all the years we used to write it on their arms when we went to busy places 🤣

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 13/02/2022 11:13

Both my children know mine and dh's mobile number, they have done for years.

Same.

Fedupsotired · 13/02/2022 11:06

@RedToothBrush

I'd like people to ponder the following :

You have a 14 year old daughter who you track.
She is mugged and her phone is stolen. Or she otherwise loses her phone.
You are out and about and contactable via your mobile.

Does she know you mobile phone number by heart thus giving her the ability to call you when she needs you in the absence of her phone?

I suspect its actually a surprising number of people who don't know the mobile number of any one but themselves by heart.

Both my children know mine and dh's mobile number, they have done for years.
RedToothBrush · 13/02/2022 11:04

I'd like people to ponder the following :

You have a 14 year old daughter who you track.
She is mugged and her phone is stolen. Or she otherwise loses her phone.
You are out and about and contactable via your mobile.

Does she know you mobile phone number by heart thus giving her the ability to call you when she needs you in the absence of her phone?

I suspect its actually a surprising number of people who don't know the mobile number of any one but themselves by heart.

Tulips21 · 13/02/2022 10:50

@hihellohihello

Erm no I don't. However, if they were going out late it might be an idea to know they were on their way home ok. Would discuss it with them though. Equally I might enable tracking if I were travelling late by myself.
Same. Dc is 18 now and Ive tracked phone, Dc#2 is 14 & I wont likely track either- However, if late out on own ect then I would with their agreement. Dc1 has only really just started going out though and Ive never had the need to track before
U2HasTheEdge · 13/02/2022 10:32

@Angrymum22

I think the pp who claim to be horrified that others use the tracking facilities in their phones need a reality check. If we use a mobile phone we are being tracked by someone or something. My phone know when I am going to work and tells me how long it’s going to take me to get there. It pings this information to me as I leave home or work. I have never set the phone up to do it, it has learned my routine. My phone is a smart phone it is programmed to learn and apply, it’s what we pay for. If you use any of the social media platforms/apps you are being tracked, you may have switched off the sharing of your location but the app will still use it. Many apps just can’t be used without your location. Being able to track your children is hardly intrusive when the world and his wife can see them on Snapchat, or they use any number of apps that require their location.
My settings are quite strict. I have a few apps that use location and it is set to only use my location when I am using the app.

There is a world of difference between an app tracking me and family members.

velvet24 · 13/02/2022 10:15

No i would not do this, its disgusting !

RedToothBrush · 13/02/2022 10:12

@JustLyra

The “keeps them safe” thing is completely wrong and gives a false sense of security.

When my DD has someone track her we all knock and acknowledge that it’s something that helps after something has gone wrong with her narcolepsy.

It absolutely does not keep her safe, it just helps track her down afterward. Those are not the same things and pretending that it keeps someone safe doesn’t do anyone any favours.

This.

If people want to use these things then each to their own. To a point.

However we really should be 'more transparent' and 'honest with each other' about where their use is healthy, what it actually can and cant achieve and where it may leave you vulnerable and open to abuse.

And thst includes conversations about whether your children are genuinely in a situation where they can freely consent or whether due so out of a sense of obligation or misunderstanding about the 'safety' the app can really offer. I wonder if asked by a neutral third party whether you would get such positive responses from children as the parents seem to suggest. (I'd love this to be properly studied)

This is where i have more of an issue. Its the dismissal and hand waving about the legitimacy of the need for this conversation.

It is about the lack of conversation about why normalisation might put you at risk and why you maybe should not be using them in a relationship thats really concerning. The denial about it being used for control is worrying.

If you admit its helping manage anxiety rather than keeping anyone safe, i take slightly less issue with it but still challenge how else you are taking steps to address that other than with a phone. What happens if you lose phone or something strange happens? You need to think that aspect through and im not convinced many are doing that. Its the reliance on the app alone thats troubling.

It certainly isn't about me 'not getting it'. I get it. I get the attraction. I just think the negatives out weigh the benefits and don't think the negatives are properly being considered by huge numbers of people because its easier to ignore this side issues.

Its about statements about 'keeping safe' being trotted out thoughtlessly, time and time again and the lack of consideration about how it might not be all you think it to be and may cause unintended harms.

I am always dubious of the 'but i have nothing to hide' phrase too, because of where that statement has a habit of ending up if things do go bad. You don't have any thing to hide until you need to or until there is an error that you can't them explain. 'The technology doesn't lie' you see, except when theres a banking error for example. Or if you need to do something to protect yourself or others without it being picked up (eg you are in an abusive relationship). Its naively and willingful innocent as a thought process - which if you are saying to children is potentially putting them at risk.

I think there is massive deliberate and willful ignorance going on, which should be highlighted and spoken about a lot more.

I would love some journalist to properly investigate the whole subject tbh.

DeckardK · 13/02/2022 09:56

@solbunny

Not a parent of a child that age yet so can't comment much there, but I do always find it interesting to see such a wide range of opinion on location tracking.

Personally I have my husband, mother, and about five friends on my find my friends. It all started just with a "hey let's add each other on this" with no hidden anxieties or whatever as suggested by other posters. I mainly use it if I've got a busy evening and want tea out on the table and done with asap - DH leaves work at different times each day and I'm buggered if I can keep up with his timetable so I just use it to see when he sets off. I look at my friends' for amusement really. We often ask each other "what were you doing at X?!" which sounds intense I realise but it's only ever asked in a jokey way. Back before COVID lockdowns turned me into a home bird, it was very useful on nights out I have to say. A few of my friends have a tendency to wander off and it's useful to figure out how to get everyone back in one place for our taxi home 🤣

I do totally understand why other people aren't comfortable with it, but it's just never even been a second thought for me and my circle.

Wow. That is so beyond the realms of normality for me, I find it utterly bizarre. I'd be so disturbed to know that a) my friends had tracking for me and b) looked at it to see where I was for 'fun' - it's bad enough the people claiming it's for safety.
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 13/02/2022 09:47

I think you either get it it you don't. If you think it's invasive or untrusting or 'red flag' I would suggest you might have some trust issues.

Not at all, I just don't see the need for my partner (or anyone else) to know where I am 24/7.

I would actually say it shows a huge lack of trust to need to know someone's location 24/7. Why do you need constant transparency? Can someone not want to
go off by themselves for a while without someone else knowing their every move?

JustLyra · 13/02/2022 09:45

The “keeps them safe” thing is completely wrong and gives a false sense of security.

When my DD has someone track her we all knock and acknowledge that it’s something that helps after something has gone wrong with her narcolepsy.

It absolutely does not keep her safe, it just helps track her down afterward. Those are not the same things and pretending that it keeps someone safe doesn’t do anyone any favours.

Angrymum22 · 13/02/2022 09:22

I like the reassurance that if I am taken I’ll while out and about my family will be able to locate me.
Most modern cars now have the facility to alert emergency services if you have an accident. My car has a tracker that is activated when it is moved without the ignition key. It works, it had to be taken by low loader to the garage recently and the tracking company phoned me within minutes.
Tracking does not have to mean 24/7 GCHQ style tracking, for some families it just a way of checking in without the need of a phone call or text.
I remember my grandmother going into full panic mode if my mum didn’t phone her at the usual time for their Sunday evening phone call. This was well before mobile phones. My GM would phone the whole family to alert us and try and create panic, Mobile phones and tracking would have been brilliant for GM along with social media she would have been able to be involved in our lives and less isolated.

twinklystar23 · 13/02/2022 09:21

Reading these, I felt initially that if it's done with openness and transparency and if someone does t want it then that's fine. Though really then concerned that this is normalised, so wide open to abuse. Mine are young adults one just 19 and living in central london. I do just ask for a text/ call to know hes back in London ok, usually met by an eye roll. Reminds me of bad education when the mother had her son chipped Grin

Lightning020 · 13/02/2022 09:21

I would have hated to be tracked when I was a teenager so I am certainly not going to track my 16 year old ds. He always sends me a whatsapp as to expected time of return and has never messed me about.

BuddhaAtSea · 13/02/2022 09:17

I’ve tracked my DD since she started Secondary. And she is tracking me.
It’s not controlling, it’s a mutual agreement. We have a code, if we text each other an X, the other looks up the location and starts moving towards it, and call. If no reply, we call the police.

I was never allowed out as a teenager. I have never ever told my DD you can’t go to the party/camping/shopping in the next town. I let her go to Pride at 13 with a group of friends, I let her go to festivals, to London, it’s really not a problem. I just need the tracker so I know how to find her quick in an emergency.
For my side, I do trail runs, I walk the dog on my own, I go abroad on my own etc. She has my back.

I don’t use it to see where she is on a day to day basis, it’s not that interesting and I can always ask and she’d tell me. But why would I?

SkyDragon · 13/02/2022 09:05

I think you either get it it you don't. If you think it's invasive or untrusting or 'red flag' I would suggest you might have some trust issues.
For us, sharing our locations IS trusting each other, none of us have anything to hide, we don't avidly study each others location, it's just there if we need to find each other.
And the 'safety' thing is that it's an extra tool that might help find someone if anything untoward happens to them.
But like I said, you either get it it you don't.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 13/02/2022 08:53

I think the pp who claim to be horrified that others use the tracking facilities in their phones need a reality check. If we use a mobile phone we are being tracked by someone or something.

Many people turn off their locations and never share where they are via any apps.

There's also a difference between Google/Apple knowing that you go to Tesco every Saturday and having your every move and location tracked by your partner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread