Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 11/02/2022 22:38

But what's the point of tracking if you're not worried if it's turned off?

We do it for communication, not really for safety or transparency. I trust my teens. I don’t need a GPS. But it is easier to just look up where someone is to know if they are available for a call for example or out of the house (when I am too lazy to get up and look who is home) and they know where their parents are if they need a lift or want to phone, ask to grab something for them, find out when we will arrive or even if we drift apart when on days out together- we just look at the GPS to find one another, we don’t have to make arrangements to meet up at a particular location.

Bitofachinwag · 11/02/2022 22:36

@ClareBlue

Also, can anyone tell me how knowing where your child's phone is means you know they are safe
Exactly. It doesn't.
ClareBlue · 11/02/2022 22:36

@NoneOfYour32Potatoes

*Those saying they can turn it off at anytime. What would you think if your child suddenly switched it off. Oh that's fine, just wants some privacy. I very much doubt that will be your reaction.*

I wouldn’t think much if they turned it off. It would just mean they didn’t want it on anymore. No more than that.

They sometimes set the GPS at a funny location as a joke.

Which sort of defeats doing it
SpikeySmooth · 11/02/2022 22:36

Never used tracking apps, ever. It's controlling. If I want to know where anyone is, I text them to ask.

ClareBlue · 11/02/2022 22:34

Also, can anyone tell me how knowing where your child's phone is means you know they are safe

Bitofachinwag · 11/02/2022 22:33

@NoneOfYour32Potatoes

*Those saying they can turn it off at anytime. What would you think if your child suddenly switched it off. Oh that's fine, just wants some privacy. I very much doubt that will be your reaction.*

I wouldn’t think much if they turned it off. It would just mean they didn’t want it on anymore. No more than that.

They sometimes set the GPS at a funny location as a joke.

But what's the point of tracking if you're not worried if it's turned off?
NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 11/02/2022 22:31

Those saying they can turn it off at anytime.
What would you think if your child suddenly switched it off. Oh that's fine, just wants some privacy. I very much doubt that will be your reaction.

I wouldn’t think much if they turned it off. It would just mean they didn’t want it on anymore. No more than that.

They sometimes set the GPS at a funny location as a joke.

sashagabadon · 11/02/2022 22:29

I didn’t even know this was a thing! I would never do it to my children or my husband and would absolutely hate anyone tracking me.

MakkaPakkas · 11/02/2022 22:27

I don't have a problem with others doing this but I do find it a bit weird. There's a sort of big brother vibe to it I don't like and I think it would add to my anxiety rather than reduce it as I'd be checking them all the time. As it is neither one has a smart phone yet so it's not an option.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 11/02/2022 22:26

I mostly use mine for lazy reasons, like waking up on a Saturday morning and wondering who is at home and who has gone for a run.

Who knows what “the norm” is these days? My DS turned it on himself on mine and his Dad’s phones then it just became the norm.

Mojoj · 11/02/2022 22:26

Tracking people is seriously weird. No. Just no. I have teenagers and I am treating them as my parents treated me, i e. tell me approximately when you will be in/phone/txt me if you're going to be later or are staying with girlfriend/pal. Stalking your kids/partner is wrong.

ClareBlue · 11/02/2022 22:26

Those saying they can turn it off at anytime.
What would you think if your child suddenly switched it off.
Oh that's fine, just wants some privacy. I very much doubt that will be your reaction.
How many make it implied condition of being able to go out for your children.
I agree that it installs anxiety. To me, it is incomprehensible how we have normalised survalience to this extent and rationalise it but that's just me.

GrandTheftWalrus · 11/02/2022 22:25

When my dds are old enough for a phone I won't track them. My tracking of dh consists of a text saying "how far away are you?" So I know if he'll make it home in the morning after a nightshift to take dd to school.

A580Hojas · 11/02/2022 22:25

@Hungry625f

Wow. Tracking partners and parents?? Its not about knowing they are safe, it's a completely inappropriate way to manage your own anxieties. And also controlling. And weird. And a massive red flag.
My thoughts exactly. It makes me shudder to think people somehow think of it as benign and normal.
iridescentpaint · 11/02/2022 22:23

@sadpapercourtesan completely agree. I felt uneasy reading @beautifullymad 's post.

SilkySusan · 11/02/2022 22:21

PS all the people who think that tracking is weird.... you do know that YOU are being tracked every holiday or family outing you go on? If your teen has Snapmaps enabled on Snapchat, their fr can see exactly where you stay and dine! Teenagers have very different concept of privacy!

iridescentpaint · 11/02/2022 22:20

No. Because I believe in showing my kids that I trust them. They know I am only at the end of the phone if they need me.

A580Hojas · 11/02/2022 22:20

My children are 20 and 18 and between them they only know one friend who has been subjected to this by their parent. It is not the norm at all.

strawberrrycheeesecake · 11/02/2022 22:18

I would track my kids with their permission for safety reasons but not behind their backs.

ThackeryBinks · 11/02/2022 22:17

I track mine. My eldest and I used to argue about it. However after she nearly died because her drink was spiked and I could get to her really quickly she hasn't murmured. My DD's can see my location as well.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 11/02/2022 22:17

@beautifullymad

We have location on in this family. Everyone has the app, everyone can see everyone else's whereabouts in the family unit.

We've recently been explaining to my 17 year old why it's set up as she feels it's an invasion of her privacy.

It's her choice to have the app on or off. But if I'm worrying about her and she's late home then I can see where she is. If she gets into difficulties my phone will track her phone to within a meter. I can get her without her having to call me, she just needs to send me a specific emoji.

I've assured her that I won't be tracking routinely and not her unless I have good cause to worry (her missing a bus or last train).

She understands now I've explained. She's still free to turn off the app.

I feel more secure knowing where they all are. I also feel secure knowing my husband knows where I am. I don't think there is anything wrong with this as long as it's consensual.

Sounds like you've coerced her to be honest.
Bitofachinwag · 11/02/2022 22:16

@Savingpeoplehuntingthings

I think that some of you are misunderstanding what people who use tracking app use them for. Dd is out god knows where with her friend, I'm not going to track her whereabouts. She says she might be late home as she's gone to friends aunties and doesn't know exactly where she is. I can either look it up and say oh you're here get XXX bus or say do you want a lift home, I can be there in 30 mins Or Ds comes home saying I've lost my phone, I remember having it at lunch... I can see it's in school and tell him to ask in the office tomorrow. Dh works away, says he'll text when he arrives safely, forgets as usual. I can look up his location and know he's safe. I finish work at 4pm but unexpectedly need to stay till 5pm. I don't have access to my phone, dc are expecting me home an hour ago and are worried, they can see I'm still at work.
Surely the auntie know where she lives? If your daughter is at someone else's house she can just ask them for their adress.

So in your example about your son. He's left his phone at school. Doesn't come home to tell you he's lost his phone, but you look up his location and assume he's safe and .still at school!

beautifullymad · 11/02/2022 22:16

@sadpapercourtesan she knows she can turn it off. She was discussing it as we always discuss everything.

She asked how I'd feel if she turned it off and I said she was completely free to do so. She is. She's almost an adult and I want her to have that choice.

But she also understands why I worry about her. There have been times in the past I've needed to get her when she hadn't been able to call. So it's not an unfounded concern.

For our family it's not about control, it's a means of communication and safety.

SilkySusan · 11/02/2022 22:15

I can track DD16. She can also see where I am. She doesn't give a shit that I can see where she is and I completely trust her to make good judgements about where she goes. I'm not a strict mum but a caring one.

The truth is I only do look at the app when I'm planning on giving her a lift from somewhere (eg. I time my departure from work in order to meet her from the station on my way past and save her a 15 minute walk in the cold).

I definitely don't spend every evening obsessively looking where she is because the truth is, it isn't that interesting. In fact I probably give her MORE freedom and leeway because I know I can find out where she is if I were worried.

Her older sister is at Uni in a different city and has turned her tracking off - fair enough. Although she can probably see where I am; I have nothing to hide!

Savingpeoplehuntingthings · 11/02/2022 22:10

I think that some of you are misunderstanding what people who use tracking app use them for.
Dd is out god knows where with her friend, I'm not going to track her whereabouts. She says she might be late home as she's gone to friends aunties and doesn't know exactly where she is. I can either look it up and say oh you're here get XXX bus or say do you want a lift home, I can be there in 30 mins
Or Ds comes home saying I've lost my phone, I remember having it at lunch... I can see it's in school and tell him to ask in the office tomorrow.
Dh works away, says he'll text when he arrives safely, forgets as usual. I can look up his location and know he's safe.
I finish work at 4pm but unexpectedly need to stay till 5pm. I don't have access to my phone, dc are expecting me home an hour ago and are worried, they can see I'm still at work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread