Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
RagzRebooted · 11/02/2022 23:01

I set up Life360 after DD and her friend (age 11) were very briefly 'missing' (they weren't, they were at friend's house and no one was answering phones, I thought they were in the park) and several people suggested it. We all ditched it after a few weeks. It was annoying with notifications and made you keep location on (obviously) which uses battery. DS1 (15) and DH didn't want it, so only DS2(14) and DD and I got it but it wasn't worth the hassle.

I don't really feel the need to track them day to day, I only got it because so many other parents seem to find it essential. I'm a sucker for a new app/function but tracking is not required for our day to day lives.

DiddyHeck · 11/02/2022 23:00

We occasionally look to see if DH has gone through the nearest town if we want him to pick something up on the way home.

But in order to ask him to do that you'd have to message him anyway wouldn't you? So why bother tracking him?

christmaskittenincoming · 11/02/2022 22:58

Seen a few of these threads and my favourite reason given for stalking significant other is 'I know when to put the dinner on' Hmm

scaredsadandstuck · 11/02/2022 22:57

@Bitofachinwag I never do that. I can't see why I would. Did your parents do that to you growing up?

You literally never ever text your kids to ask them where they are? Never?

I'm old so my parents could not have texted me. However, I was expected to tell them where I was going and when I would be home, and stick to it. That was very common as I recall. If I'd have been found to be lying I would have been in trouble.

I now do have the technology to see where my teen is and/or send them a message, occasionally, to ask where they are. Not obsessively, not every 5 seconds/minutes or even hours. But if I need to know where my 13 year old child is, I will text or check the tracking app. Is that really weird?

Poppinjay · 11/02/2022 22:57

We share locations as a family.

It's on all the time but we rarely use it so I wouldn't say we are tracking each other. Occasionally, if adult DD1 is out on a horse and taking longer than I expected, I'll check on her location to see if she's moving.

We occasionally look to see if DH has gone through the nearest town if we want him to pick something up on the way home. If she's static in a field, at least I know where to find her. This has only happened once but it was helpful.

We occasionally check how close someone in the family is to home when working out when to start cooking dinner.

None of it feels toxic, controlling or like we're being tracked. It just feels like a quick way to find out where someone is if that's helpful. If one of us wanted to go off radar, they could turn off their location sharing and the rest of us would be very unlikely to notice or they would assume no signal.

However, I also understand that normalising this makes it easier for coervice controllers to argue that tracking their victims is reasonable.

Savingpeoplehuntingthings · 11/02/2022 22:56

Ok, what I meant was if he doesn't come home at all! If he has been kidnapped/in an accident/other thing that could happen on the way home. Then you would assume he was still at school and safe. So in that situation tracking would actually make him less safe as you would assume he was safe and not go out looking dor him/phone his friend etc.

No, if he didn't come home I'd be sending him a text or ringing asking where he is. I wouldn't be assuming the tracking app was switched on.
It's a back up, for both me and them. I don't use it to spy on them or to try and catch them out. If I were worried for their safety I wouldn't rely on it and assume they were safe I'd ring them.

Theluggage15 · 11/02/2022 22:56

Weird but then some parents are weird and controlling .

I don’t think people do care about what other people do but that was the whole point of the OP’s question which is why people replied! If people want to be weird with their kids that’s up to them.

honeylulu · 11/02/2022 22:56

I'm pleasantly surprised as I'd thought MN was very pro tracking.

If my teen (nearly 17) is going to be out late he agrees to have his tracking turned on. However I have never checked because he is always back when we have agreed or calls if there is a change of plan. It's more for emergency type situations or if he doesn't turn up I've got an idea where he is or has been. (Only one emergency so far and he called me before I needed to think about looking at the tracker. )

I think teens need privacy and to do a bit of getting up to stuff their parents wouldn't want to know about. I had very strict parents and the only thing that made my teenage years bearable was making respectable sounding excuses to escape and get up to no good!

ClareBlue · 11/02/2022 22:55

@Wherearemymarbles

Wow it seems those anti trackers are far more angry and uptight than those that who couldn't care less about tracking

Ffs each to their own.

To be fair, it's a discussion on how people see this as per the OP. Everyone has their own view but obviously it's down to your own family dynamics. We have a son currently traveling Europe since last November and we never track and never have. WhatsApp every evening and when he is on trains etc but never track. But I found out last week he shares tracking with his sister in Germany and another sister in Ireland, so they obviously don't see it as an issue. Everyone sees this differently
Bitofachinwag · 11/02/2022 22:50

@bebbdebb

I find it odd that some people who don't want to use a tracker care so much that other people do. Horses for courses.
Well, that's what the OP asked about, so I am replying.
DiddyHeck · 11/02/2022 22:48

We've recently been explaining to my 17 year old why it's set up as she feels it's an invasion of her privacy.

And she's absolutely right. She also shouldn't have to turn it off if she doesn't want to be tracked. She just shouldn't have to have it in the first place.

I imagine it won't be long before the Relationships topic is full of OPs either feeling forced to be tracked by their partners, or being forced to justify why they turned it off.

Change123today · 11/02/2022 22:47

I’m not sure I like the word tracking - we all have it on our find the phone thingy. We’ve never used it to track our daughter or call her out on it, she is free to turn it off and on (she may have in the past I wouldn’t know as I don’t check it) - but again we’ve never judged her or questioned her on where she is (we trust her & never given me a reason to not trust her) She has now left home for uni - I thought she may have turned it off - I wouldn’t know as we don’t monitor it!

It’s there but we’ve (thankfully) never used it to check on her or judge her on her choices! She knows that and I asked her why she hasn’t switched it off for us - her answer was we’ve never questioned her on where she is so she knows we don’t misuse it in an untrusting way!

If I felt the need to check & question her why she is where she is - I would probably remove it for as I think it’s controlling and maybe try to improve my relationship with my child as to why they lying etc

When it has been used it’s because she usually lost her earphone things in the house somewhere & she can use either her phone or mine to ping them!!

Bitofachinwag · 11/02/2022 22:47

@Savingpeoplehuntingthings

Bitofachinwag. I literally say in my post that he tells me he doesn't know where his phone is. I didnt say he doesn't tell me. So in your example about your son. He's left his phone at school. Doesn't come home to tell you he's lost his phone, but you look up his location and assume he's safe and .still at school! This has nothing to do with his safety, just an example of how I can easily see where he's left his phone. Daughter often goes out with her friend and goes visiting friends relatives. She's not familiar with the area, no auntie doesn't know exactly where she lives. It makes it easy for me to see where she is.
Ok, what I meant was if he doesn't come home at all! If he has been kidnapped/in an accident/other thing that could happen on the way home. Then you would assume he was still at school and safe. So in that situation tracking would actually make him less safe as you would assume he was safe and not go out looking dor him/phone his friend etc.
Waxonwaxoff0 · 11/02/2022 22:46

@Wherearemymarbles

Wow it seems those anti trackers are far more angry and uptight than those that who couldn't care less about tracking

Ffs each to their own.

Not angry, I just find it weird. But I moved miles away from home when I was 17 and didn't see my parents for months on end so that might be skewing my view.
NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 11/02/2022 22:44

@Wherearemymarbles

Wow it seems those anti trackers are far more angry and uptight than those that who couldn't care less about tracking

Ffs each to their own.

True. It’s weird because my teens prefer for it to be on so they know where their parents areSmile
bebbdebb · 11/02/2022 22:43

I find it odd that some people who don't want to use a tracker care so much that other people do. Horses for courses.

Bitofachinwag · 11/02/2022 22:43

@scaredsadandstuck

And those that don't track, how often do you message or call to check where they are? Do you see that as different?
I never do that. I can't see why I would. Did your parents do that to you growing up?
LynetteScavo · 11/02/2022 22:42

I track DD (she's very happy with this and tracks me too) so I know if she's near the station/still at college/McDonald's. She knows if I'm close to picking her up from where ever she is.

She can turn it off if she wants to.

Wherearemymarbles · 11/02/2022 22:42

Wow it seems those anti trackers are far more angry and uptight than those that who couldn't care less about tracking

Ffs each to their own.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 11/02/2022 22:41

@ClareBlue

Also, can anyone tell me how knowing where your child's phone is means you know they are safe
It really isn’t that useful as a safety measure if your teen is intentionally trying to evade you or be deceptive- as I say they can catch a GPS drift or set the location to somewhere that they (and their phone) aren’t.
Savingpeoplehuntingthings · 11/02/2022 22:40

Bitofachinwag. I literally say in my post that he tells me he doesn't know where his phone is. I didnt say he doesn't tell me. So in your example about your son. He's left his phone at school. Doesn't come home to tell you he's lost his phone, but you look up his location and assume he's safe and .still at school! This has nothing to do with his safety, just an example of how I can easily see where he's left his phone.
Daughter often goes out with her friend and goes visiting friends relatives. She's not familiar with the area, no auntie doesn't know exactly where she lives. It makes it easy for me to see where she is.

scaredsadandstuck · 11/02/2022 22:40

And those that don't track, how often do you message or call to check where they are? Do you see that as different?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 11/02/2022 22:38

@SilkySusan

PS all the people who think that tracking is weird.... you do know that YOU are being tracked every holiday or family outing you go on? If your teen has Snapmaps enabled on Snapchat, their fr can see exactly where you stay and dine! Teenagers have very different concept of privacy!
No one I know has that setting on. I don't want people knowing where I am at all times.
scaredsadandstuck · 11/02/2022 22:38

I thought everyone did have the ability to track their teen! I am surprised by this thread to be honest. I would have thought it would be very frowned upon on MN not to. Life is full of surprises.

Day to day I use it infrequently - if I look at the time and it's later than DS 13 is usually home, then I have a quick look and see where he is.

He's just been on a week long school trip. I liked being able to have the odd look to 'check' on him. I know it's only telling me where his phone is and not him, but I find it reassuring.

What I'm not doing is tracking him obsessively and messaging him to ask where he is/why he's there etc.

I can totally see as he gets older that I would turn it off or only have it on for very specific reasons.

Do those of you saying that it's an invasion of privacy not check your younger teenagers phone occasionally, or have other types of parental controls? If you do, do you see that as different?

megletthesecond · 11/02/2022 22:38

Mine both have family link on their phones.
My 15yo is utterly sensible and never goes rogue. I don't look at his tracker often.
My 13yo on the other hand, loads of problems and a school refuser. I need to know where she is every second of the day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread