Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 12/02/2022 07:13

Depends on the age of the teen. Dd will be 13 this year and happily shared her location on what's app when she's out with her friends. Was helpful last week when her friend ditched her up town and all the usual bus stops were closed and she had no idea how to then get home.

cuno · 12/02/2022 07:07

At the children's homes I worked at it would have been outrageous if we did that with the teens there, to be honest. Seeing a location on a map tells you nothing about your teens' safety. Firstly it's the location of their phone not a microchip in their arm, secondly they could very well be dead or have their safety compromised in any number of ways. It's just to spy on where they are, plain and simple, not for safety reasons, no matter how well intentioned it is. It's especially crappy to do it covertly. And I think these people who claim their entire families rely on it (partners, adult children, parents, extended family), I actually think it shows lack of boundaries and normalises controlling behaviour, and it doesn't really teach our daughters that it's not healthy for them to be in relationships with men who track their every movement, after all their mum and dad did the same and it was all happy families!

I am of the opinion that people need to have honest conversations with their teens and always leave the door open, but you need to let them have the freedom and opportunity to risk assess by themselves, and to make mistakes and learn from them. As a teen, to always know that their parents can check where they are at any given time, as often as the parents deem fit without the teen's knowledge or consent each time, must feel like they are being micromanaged to be honest. I would have hated this and it would have caused me a lot of anxiety, even though on the whole I was a good teen who kept out of trouble.

sammylady37 · 12/02/2022 06:42

I find this so intrusive and invasive. I would never agree to it and if any man suggested it he would be swiftly dispatched from my life.

It’s all about pandering to the other person’s anxieties and controlling tendencies.
Tracking doesn’t keep someone safe, nor does it actually tell you they’re safe, it tells you where their phone is.
If you see my phone is in a park and has been for an hour, you don’t know if that’s because I’m sitting under a tree reading (which may be my routine on summer Saturdays) sitting on a bench slumped over having had a heart attack or lying in the bushes having been strangled. Or maybe my handbag was stolen and thief made off with my bulging wallet and threw the bag with phone inside into a rubbish bin.

And the ‘so I know when to put the dinner on’ justification makes me laugh and feel sad in equal measure. Who are these hoards of DHs and DCs who will expire from exhaustion if they’re not fed within a minute of walking in the door? And who are these 1950s wives/mothers who think it’s their duty to feed their husbands/children the minute they arrive? Do they have a pipe and slippers waiting too? I don’t know anyone IRL who actually wants to eat immediately when they arrive home, people I know want to relax for a bit, chat to whoever is at home etc.

CheesePlantMurderer · 12/02/2022 05:55

Me and my 2 teens have Life360. We don't all live together since I separated from my exH and it's been really useful for us all. Nothing sinister or weird, just handy to quickly check where someone is when needed.

Oblomov22 · 12/02/2022 05:31

Nope. Never have, never will. I don't like it, it sits uncomfortably with me. Maybe it's because my teen boys are relatively mature and I trust them and thus I've never felt the need to?

PinkSyCo · 12/02/2022 05:23

I used it when mine were younger but didn't tell them. Caught DD (then 14) staying over at her boyfriends house (she'd lied about a girls sleepover). She never did work out quite how I knew. Scared the shit out of her when I rang her at 11 at night saying "where are you really? "Gave her a hard stare (mums can do that over the phone too) , and she cried and fessed up. I insisted calmly that she carry on staying there and to come home in the morning when we'd talk it over. She spent the night bricking it. She never did that again without permission (which wasn't for another couple of years for boyfriend sleepovers) grin

I’m surprised that you’re laughing about your 14 year old DD sleeping with her boyfriend at his house, and that you seen proud that you put a stop to it only by letting her know you were spying on her to be honest. Confused

cookiemonster2468 · 12/02/2022 05:10

@catwomando

I used it when mine were younger but didn't tell them. Caught DD (then 14) staying over at her boyfriends house (she'd lied about a girls sleepover). She never did work out quite how I knew. Scared the shit out of her when I rang her at 11 at night saying "where are you really? "Gave her a hard stare (mums can do that over the phone too) , and she cried and fessed up. I insisted calmly that she carry on staying there and to come home in the morning when we'd talk it over. She spent the night bricking it. She never did that again without permission (which wasn't for another couple of years for boyfriend sleepovers) Grin

I think it can be a sensible precaution but used lightly and only with agreement once they are past, say, 16 years old and not really a child anymore.

once she hit adulthood and the hard partying I kind of didn't want to know when she was! None of my business. And now she's older and tells me some of the stories I'm glad I didn't know as I never would have slept!

What a horrendous invasion of privacy.
JangolinaPitt · 12/02/2022 05:07

@Hungry625f

Wow. Tracking partners and parents?? Its not about knowing they are safe, it's a completely inappropriate way to manage your own anxieties. And also controlling. And weird. And a massive red flag.
This. I found it astounding that people do this!!!!
cookiemonster2468 · 12/02/2022 05:05

When we say to teens - you are only safe if i know exactly where you are at all times (and I do wonder what 'safe' means here? kidnapping?! getting lost? ) - what are they internalising about their own capabilities to manage risk in the world

@Wondergirl100 I couldn't agree more.

As hard as it is, we have to let some element of risk into our lives (and our children's) in order to encourage independence.

Too many young people now are suffering with serious anxiety and fear (I say this as someone who works with young people and I have seen a stark increase over the last 5 years).

Parents tracking them will only make this worse as they just don't develop the resilience to cope with being alone.

You have to let your kids live and take risks sometimes or they will always feel dependent.

catwomando · 12/02/2022 05:03

I used it when mine were younger but didn't tell them. Caught DD (then 14) staying over at her boyfriends house (she'd lied about a girls sleepover). She never did work out quite how I knew. Scared the shit out of her when I rang her at 11 at night saying "where are you really? "Gave her a hard stare (mums can do that over the phone too) , and she cried and fessed up. I insisted calmly that she carry on staying there and to come home in the morning when we'd talk it over. She spent the night bricking it. She never did that again without permission (which wasn't for another couple of years for boyfriend sleepovers) Grin

I think it can be a sensible precaution but used lightly and only with agreement once they are past, say, 16 years old and not really a child anymore.

once she hit adulthood and the hard partying I kind of didn't want to know when she was! None of my business. And now she's older and tells me some of the stories I'm glad I didn't know as I never would have slept!

PinkSyCo · 12/02/2022 04:34

I’m not their friend, I'm their parent.

Unless friends are tracking each other now that doesn’t even make sense.
No I would never track my kids. The way I see it you either trust them to go out without you or you don’t. I would have HATED to have been watched constantly as a teen, so why would I inflict that on my kids?

Cameleongirl · 12/02/2022 01:48

@mallees. If the parent is paying for the phone contract, though, they can put pressure on the teen to use the app. I’m not saying it’s wrong to track your children, it’s just not something I’m personally comfortable doing.

mallees · 12/02/2022 01:02

If they don't collaborate you can't track them. They have to buy-in and have the app.

Cameleongirl · 12/02/2022 00:45

I’ve discussed tracking with my DD (16, nearly 17) and we’ve agreed that we won’t do it, unless she’s going on a long journey, for example, and she agrees to it. Some of her friends are constantly tracked and she finds it disturbing, as do they. It’s very Big Brother, tbh. These teenagers are responsible, as is DD, and they don’t need to be tracked.

I had autonomy back in the 1990’s and I want DD to have the same. I respect her and trust her to make good decisions.

GrandTheftWalrus · 12/02/2022 00:40

@DiddyHeck he didn't seem to believe me about a lot of things. I went away to work at NYE and told him that our transport home wasn't available and we had to make our own way from a ferry, he turned up at the ferry port.

DiddyHeck · 12/02/2022 00:31

@GrandTheftWalrus

He had came to the pick up point for the coach with me. Saw me meet workmates etc yet when I was halfway there he told me to put on location as he didn't believe where I was going. I didn't put it on and told him to fuck off.

Other people won't be able to do that.

Other people won't be able to do that.

Nope, especially if they've been raised to believe it's a 'normal' sign of love.

DiddyHeck · 12/02/2022 00:28

We live in different times and if we can use technology to feel and be safe, then why on earth not use it?

Because it's nearly always about the adults personal anxiety issues and that's not a fair thing to put upon your child. Kids shouldn't be raised to think that someone else tracking their movements is in any way normal because it isn't.

Worried about your kid? Send them a text or a quick phone call but don't raise them ( especially girls ) to believe tracking is a 'sign of love or concern'.

Raise them instead to expect others to manage their own anxiety.

partytime50 · 12/02/2022 00:25

@Wondergirl100

I think there is a deeper issue here - we think it's totally innoccuous to track people we love because we just want to know they are safe. But when did we begin to feel anxious/ unsafe if we didn't constantly know where people were - ie. to the exact pinpoint on a map?

The more we rely on this stuff the less secure any of us will feel.

We are teaching teenagers that they are 'unsafe' all the time. It's interesting that someone mentions their daughter wanting to be tracked .
This links in to children not playing so freely and with autonomy as in previous generations - we are beginning to develop fearful minds and a belief that unless we are 'seen' and 'known ' every minute we are at risk

Think of the joy of being a growing teen - I remember it! - knowing that you are 'off grid' 'really hanging out with your mates in a new bubble your mum doesn't know exactly where you are and what you are doing - that is part of developing the independence that makes you a resilient and confident adult

When we say to teens - you are only safe if i know exactly where you are at all times (and I do wonder what 'safe' means here? kidnapping?! getting lost? ) - what are they internalising about their own capabilities to manage risk in the world.

I absolutely agree.

GrandTheftWalrus · 12/02/2022 00:24

He had came to the pick up point for the coach with me. Saw me meet workmates etc yet when I was halfway there he told me to put on location as he didn't believe where I was going. I didn't put it on and told him to fuck off.

Other people won't be able to do that.

partytime50 · 12/02/2022 00:23

@Bitofachinwag

Still seems weird to me, how on earth did people manage before tracking was a thing? They learnt to look after themselves and take responsibility.

You mean us. Well assuming you're my age anyway. Remember those days when mobile phones didn't exist!! I survived. As did most of us. My parents didn't track me.

It's nothing to do with keeping the child safe and everything to do with an individual's neurosis.

ANameChangeAgain · 12/02/2022 00:20

Some of the responses to these location apps are bonkers! We used life 360 in our home so we all know where each other is. Probably a little different to some because we have a rural lifestyle? The kids can and do switch and them on and off at will but very occasionally I will have a message from my dd, if she feels a bit unsure, to let me know she has switched hers on again as she wants me to know where she is. We live in different times and if we can use technology to feel and be safe, then why on earth not use it?

DiddyHeck · 12/02/2022 00:15

@GrandTheftWalrus

My exdh wanted me turn on my location as he didn't believe where I was going with work. I was away 10 days. By the end of the 10 days he was my exdh.
And this is what I mean by future Relationships threads. They're likely to be full of women either complaining their DPs insist on tracking them, or suspicious that their DPs have turned off tracking for a night etc.

A whole new level of red flags and anxiety for some, no matter how you look at it.

GrandTheftWalrus · 12/02/2022 00:07

My exdh wanted me turn on my location as he didn't believe where I was going with work. I was away 10 days. By the end of the 10 days he was my exdh.

DiddyHeck · 12/02/2022 00:06

@BitcherOfBlakiven

My DD is 13, we have the tracking on our iPhones. I didn’t know it existed until she told me, it seems she likes to watch me on my way home and try and guess how long I’ll be Grin I’ve not used it to track her, though. And wouldn’t unless she was late home, not answering her phone and I was worried.

With all the violence against women, it’s really on sensible to have the Find My Friend option ON.

With all the violence against women, it’s really on sensible to have the Find My Friend option ON.

Is it though? What happens when violent, controlling men find out their partner wasn't in the place they said they would be for whatever reason?

Raising girls to think being tracked is a sign of someone loving/caring for them, rather than controlling and spying on them is likely storing up lots of problems for the future.

NewYearNewMinty · 12/02/2022 00:05

On the whole I agree with PP, but a couple of months ago DD17 went to London for the first time with a couple of friends (about 90 minutes train journey each way, although we've been together several times and she's great at getting round onto the Tube).

I suggested she enabled her Snapmaps just for the day but she downloaded Life360 instead and it's brilliant.

She had it on for a couple of weeks before switching it off and it's so handy I asked her to put it back on Blush.

I've absolutely no interest in tracking her from a mistrust pov and she knows that but she is so busy these days with college, work, driving lessons, gym and social life that I can't keep track of her schedule.

I probably look at it a couple of times a week..to check she's on her way back from somewhere so I know when to put the dinner on, or check where she is if I've forgotten she's going to gym or popping into her dad's after college.

I went on a date the other week and realised she'd been using the app to keep tabs on me Grin.

If she wants to switch it off in general that's fine, but it's handy to have at a time when she's doing a lot of things independently for the first time...it gives me reassurance without having to disturb or embarrass her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread