Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 09:02

@iCouldSleepForAYear

It didn't occur to me to track our just-turned-16 year old. I have her phone linked to mine to enforce downtime and share any subscriptions. But just checked our settings now because of this thread: her location sharing is off. No idea if she and her pals are using SnapMaps... hoping they can't be bothered.

I can definitely see the temptation to geo track. My 8 year old has just started walking to and from school with friends and is asking for more permission to roam the neighbourhood with them. And I don't want to give her a phone yet, because if I give her a smart phone, it really will be the only thing she'll pay attention to. She's too young and immature to have one yet. But then, that means letting her go straight to the library after school on her own feels like too high a risk: too many gaps in the day and journey to fill, should something go wrong. A tracking watch sounds like a great solution at first... unless she's not wearing it, and there's every chance she'd take it off and forget to put it back on.

I think I would rather teach both girls to communicate with me. Text me when you've arrived. Text me when you're on the bus. Call me if you're running late; do not make us worry. Charge your phone. Take a power pack with you if your battery might run low. Call me and have a long chat if you're walking around somewhere and feeling nervous. Tell me about the landmarks around you if you're lost; read the street signs, read the bus stop sign. Come home and ask me first if it's ok to go to the park with your pals. Learn to wear a normal watch and pay attention to the time. Be home when we've asked you to. Be savvy about your surroundings and the people you interact with.

Yes, that's all great and teaching your girls to be aware is great.

But you're making it sound as if an 8 year old can be expected protect themselves from predators if they have a sensible head. And this isn't true. They're only children. Yes, we can teach them not to go off with strangers willingly. But that doesn't stop them literally being snatched (as someone tried with me when I was 13). Or from being groomed by people they trust.

My DD is the same age and wanting more independence. I'm not at the point where I'll let her be out of the house on her own. But when I am, she'll have location on, on her phone. It's not foolproof, of course. But it's one thing that could be very helpful to help us find our children in an emergency.

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 09:02

I think wholesome for-the-whole-family tracking normalises something quite sinister.

Fair dues, it doesn’t necessarily need saying but it’s a valid opinion. I disagree. But I am reading the posts against geo-tracking with an open mind. There will be varying opinions on this just as other aspects of parenting.

As for the social psychology of tracking within the context of a family unit and the long term imprint that will leave, I guess time will tell.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 12/02/2022 08:55

It didn't occur to me to track our just-turned-16 year old. I have her phone linked to mine to enforce downtime and share any subscriptions. But just checked our settings now because of this thread: her location sharing is off. No idea if she and her pals are using SnapMaps... hoping they can't be bothered.

I can definitely see the temptation to geo track. My 8 year old has just started walking to and from school with friends and is asking for more permission to roam the neighbourhood with them. And I don't want to give her a phone yet, because if I give her a smart phone, it really will be the only thing she'll pay attention to. She's too young and immature to have one yet. But then, that means letting her go straight to the library after school on her own feels like too high a risk: too many gaps in the day and journey to fill, should something go wrong. A tracking watch sounds like a great solution at first... unless she's not wearing it, and there's every chance she'd take it off and forget to put it back on.

I think I would rather teach both girls to communicate with me. Text me when you've arrived. Text me when you're on the bus. Call me if you're running late; do not make us worry. Charge your phone. Take a power pack with you if your battery might run low. Call me and have a long chat if you're walking around somewhere and feeling nervous. Tell me about the landmarks around you if you're lost; read the street signs, read the bus stop sign. Come home and ask me first if it's ok to go to the park with your pals. Learn to wear a normal watch and pay attention to the time. Be home when we've asked you to. Be savvy about your surroundings and the people you interact with.

cuno · 12/02/2022 08:54

@NoneOfYour32Potatoes

Just because you use it for nice, wholesome reasons doesn't mean everyone does so it shouldn't be something we teach our children is normal.

Christ almighty, using tech in one context does not mean that the same tech will be normalised for all other contexts. Do you really think that young people are that lacking in good judgement skills?

We use it primarily functionally- to make our lives easier. Thankfully my DSs know the difference between functionality and coercion - they aren’t so asinine as to think that the use of geo-tracking to simplify family life would always be the same as in other contexts. They know that it can be used for nefarious reasons.

Some kids have grown up with tech all their lives, they know how to avoid being located when they don’t want to be and how to discern appropriate use of tech given the context of varied types of relationships.

But the tracking and having your location always on and available is the starting point, the baseline. It will escalate from there. I think it is better to instead show that it is not normal or healthy to know where your loved ones are at the push of a button, that no matter how much you love someone you are allowed boundaries and privacy. I think wholesome for-the-whole-family tracking normalises something quite sinister.
NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 08:53

Well from reading many posts here, young people are infantilised and mollycoddled to such a degree that I suspect their ability to appraise a situation and judge it correctly is quite impaired. Have a look at the relationship board and see how many women cannot tell how shitty and abusive their relationships are

Yes, I don’t disagree with the sentiment of what you say, although I don’t think the MN relationship board is a good snapshot of the social writ at large.

However, many people who respond on the relationship board often demonstrate good judgement skills and adult (not infantilised) perspectives. But to argue that the thin edge of the wedge is tech doesn’t make sense. Tech is a tool and discernment, judgement, relationship skills, and maturity are developed or not developed regardless of tech.

LynetteScavo · 12/02/2022 08:52

And what if your child decides to change loops or stop for a coffee and isn't home when they say, and their partner assumes they're lying or cheating and starts an argument or worse?

That's not about technology, that's about healthy relationships.

This tech is here to stay, so kids need to know how to use it healthily, just like the internet and cars.Modern fangled things while bringing great convenience can also cause a risk, which is why we teach children to cross roads and not talk to strangers online and incorporate tracking devices into their lives in healthy ways. Teaching about healthy relationships has been part of parenting since the beginning of the human race.

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 08:52

I wonder how many people here are being tracked by their phone and don't realise it?

Go to www.google.com/maps/timeline and see if there's data there on where you've been? (Or, where your phone has been).

This isn't the same as sharing a live location with someone else. But the data is collected there if you have location switched on, and can be seen on any device where you're logged into a google account (e.g. if it's logged into your google).

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 08:46

I used to feel strongly about not tracking. But now we've got the technology on our phones I'm used to it.

DP shared his location with me when he was on a long journey home, and has left it on. I don't use it to spy on him! But very occasionally it's useful to see how far he is from home.

Similarly, I've shared my google location with him now.

Sadly our lives are so predictable these days, we're never anywhere interesting so there's no surprises! But it is useful on occasion.

I have asked 13 year old DS to put the tracking on, on his phone, so if I ever needed to find him I could. It would be great in an emergency and I'd regret not asking him to do it, if there was such an emergency.

The tracker tracks the phone not the child! If he wanted to trick me he could just turn the location function off or leave it with a friend and I'm sure DC do this all the time.

Trackers could certainly be used in very controlling and oppressive ways. It depends on who's using them and how, I now realise. Having it on for emergencies is a good idea in my opinion.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 08:46

Those saying their kids just tell them when they go somewhere else/change plans - what do you do if they don't? How long do you leave after you expected them to be home before you ask where they are? Or do you still not ask/ check?

I was expected to be home at a certain time. I never pushed and stayed out later as I know the response from my parents would be to ground me and not let me out and I didn't want to to get into trouble.

But I have to ask - what do you think tracking achieves here? Your kids could turn off tracking or switch off their phones and you'd be none the wiser. They could check in elsewhere to fool you, leave their phone at a friend and do all manner of things to stop being tracked.

And then what would you do? Rely on the tracking which could be wrong and giving you a false sense of security because their phone says they're at Joe's house?

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 08:39

Christ almighty, using tech in one context does not mean that the same tech will be normalised for all other contexts. Do you really think that young people are that lacking in good judgement skills?

That's not what I said at all.

But abusive relationships rarely start with you being punched in the face - or nobody would stay in them. They start slowly.

So if you've been raised with tracking as the norm and your partner suggests it when you go on your long runs, you may not see it as weird as it's what your parents did.

But then it grows. They track your runs. Ask where you've been if you're longer than necessary. Wonder why you needed to stop in x park for coffee when you could come home and have it there etc. wonder why you went on a different route than planned and don't believe it's because it was too muddy or whatever.

Most abusive relationships start normal and become abusive over time so you don't realise it's happening until you're in too deep. I just don't think it's a good idea to normalise things like tracking peoples movements when it's not necessary in everyday life and something that's so, so open to abuse.

It's also something that feeds into peoples anxieties and doesn't actually help them feel better as as soon as that technology fails or the other person changes their mind, the anxieties will be back and worse than ever.

sammylady37 · 12/02/2022 08:38

Do you really think that young people are that lacking in good judgement skills?

Well from reading many posts here, young people are infantilised and mollycoddled to such a degree that I suspect their ability to appraise a situation and judge it correctly is quite impaired. Have a look at the relationship board and see how many women cannot tell how shitty and abusive their relationships are, and trot out the ‘great Dad’ line time and time again as if it justifies everything else.

sirfredfredgeorge · 12/02/2022 08:37

A lot of the justifications here for universal tracking is that it's convenient in a few situations, and almost always situations where other solutions are even better. The horse/cycle riding off in to the wilds - not actually ideal as knowing where they are is only any use once you're concerned they're missing, by which time they've probably bled to death, a sport specific tracking enabled only for the activity would now also have included shock alerts, so when the horse threw the rider or the bike crashed an alert would've gone including the location so you knew there was an accident.

That's actual safety, the simplistic tracking does little, even if you're staring at the dot on the map, it doesn't tell you if it's stopped because there's a nice view to sit and watch and contemplate the world.

The "I'm home" etc. alerts, universal tracking for convenience, again the big problem is you need to stare at the map to see where they are, much better solution is some sort of geofence app which triggers actions when they arrive at a place - better functionality without the risk of spying.

If you're really doing it for these purposes and not because you like to monitor your family, please use better methods, the horse/bike is not safer.

scaredsadandstuck · 12/02/2022 08:35

I find it a bit surprising that people think it's an invasion of privacy for 13/14 year olds. They are children. I don't think it an invasion of privacy to know where your child is at that age. Of course at 16/17 it is much more so, but at 13 they are children, not grown ups.

However I hadn't thought about the unhealthy lesson we could be teaching them that tracking is a way you show love. That's definitely food for thought and I agree I wouldn't want my kids to think that it was a good thing in an adult relationship. My husband and I do not track each other.

However I know my older teen niece and her friends all have snapmaps on. They seem to think it's normal.

Those saying their kids just tell them when they go somewhere else/change plans - what do you do if they don't? How long do you leave after you expected them to be home before you ask where they are? Or do you still not ask/ check?

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 12/02/2022 08:28

Just because you use it for nice, wholesome reasons doesn't mean everyone does so it shouldn't be something we teach our children is normal.

Christ almighty, using tech in one context does not mean that the same tech will be normalised for all other contexts. Do you really think that young people are that lacking in good judgement skills?

We use it primarily functionally- to make our lives easier. Thankfully my DSs know the difference between functionality and coercion - they aren’t so asinine as to think that the use of geo-tracking to simplify family life would always be the same as in other contexts. They know that it can be used for nefarious reasons.

Some kids have grown up with tech all their lives, they know how to avoid being located when they don’t want to be and how to discern appropriate use of tech given the context of varied types of relationships.

Juanbablo · 12/02/2022 08:11

We all have Find My Friends enabled on our iPhones, me, dh, ds1 and dd. I don't track the dcs as such but might check if they have got to town or see where dh is on his journey home so I know what time to make dinner without phoning him.

Bosephine · 12/02/2022 08:09

Some people seem to think technology is all or nothing. Just because trackers can be used to monitor someone's every movement doesn't mean they have to be. Just because we all used to live without this technology at all doesn't mean we have to now. There is a sensible middle ground.

I think this is a very good point. I also think you make a good point about having the ability to track but not doing so- my husband could track me in the same way that he could read my diary. I trust him not to do either.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 08:08

My husband could sit and monitor my run 🤣 but he's not a dick so he doesn't.

But this is such an important point that many people are missing.

Your husband might be a good person but what if you've taught your kids that it's okay to be tracked and their partner is a dick who tracks their every move?

And what if your child decides to change loops or stop for a coffee and isn't home when they say, and their partner assumes they're lying or cheating and starts an argument or worse?

Just because you use it for nice, wholesome reasons doesn't mean everyone does so it shouldn't be something we teach our children is normal.

bhooks · 12/02/2022 08:05

We have a family link. That means I can check where my children's phones are. I don't track them, as such. But if one of them didn't come home when expected (both the type to let me know) or one of them loses their phone (one is very scatty, like me), then I could use the 'tracker' to find the phone. I've had to help my eldest with finding a mislaid/lost phone more than once.

I also use 'live track' on my running app when I go for a run. I used to only turn it on if it was dark but that got annoying to remember. So now it's on every time. My husband could sit and monitor my run 🤣 but he's not a dick so he doesn't. But if I said I was going for a 45 minute run and was gone much longer without a word, it might be useful.

Some people seem to think technology is all or nothing. Just because trackers can be used to monitor someone's every movement doesn't mean they have to be. Just because we all used to live without this technology at all doesn't mean we have to now. There is a sensible middle ground.

Bosephine · 12/02/2022 07:50

When my kids were smaller they had location turned on- very useful for finding lost phones. We all knew it was on. I suppose I could have used it to track them but it didn't cross my mind to do so and in any event what would it have said? They're at school! They're at home! They're at football practice which I knew as I just took them there!

DH has never had his turned on, whereas mine is always on and shared with everyone so that the kids can find me when I'm picking them up after matches etc.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/02/2022 07:50

I think it's really disturbing that people track
their partners, fronds and children, tbh.

I also agree with a PP who said that by teaching them it's normal, all you're doing is setting them up for huge issues in the future.

If you're raised to think having your every move and location tracked is normal and healthy, what happens when you get into a relationship with a man who says he must know where you are 24/7? And who will confront you and cause an argument (or worse) if you end up going somewhere else?

It also gives a false sense of security as all tracking someone does is show you where their phone is. It doesn't tell you they're alive, safe or in that location themselves.

And if you're used to knowing exactly where someone is all day, everyday and they suddenly turn their location off, are you really going to sit there and go "oh, it's fine" or are you going to get hugely paranoid and anxious and start thinking the worst?

AnnaSW1 · 12/02/2022 07:44

It's not an appalling thing to do when they know about it . It's good sense.

mugoftea456 · 12/02/2022 07:31

It's awful. I would have hated this as a teenager.

If I'm on a night out and will be getting a cab home I usually send DP my live location on WhatsApp. Or going for a run on my own etc.

Never would I think of tracking Any of them day to day

SartresSoul · 12/02/2022 07:29

I have the find my iPhone app. My DC aren’t quite teens yet but when they are I’ll still be using it. I don’t watch them like hawks on their way home from school because that would be weird and I have better things to do. It’s just for my peace of mind if they’re ever later than usual. When they’re teens and they’re out alone more I’ll definitely want to know they aren’t in trouble if they’re late back.

110APiccadilly · 12/02/2022 07:26

Is it instead of not letting them go out, or instead of letting them go out untracked? Because if it's being used to give them more freedom by letting them go further/ stay out later, etc then I think that's different to just automatically tracking them all the time.

Full disclosure, I plan to get DD one of those smart watches for kids you can track when she's a pre-teen, so that she can go out and about locally (we live rurally so basically running wild in the woods!) a bit younger than I'd otherwise be happy with. But I wouldn't be tracking her as, say, a 14 year old, unless maybe she wanted to go a really long way or camp out or something.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 12/02/2022 07:17

Not an issue yet but I think I probably will have find my phone or something when ds is a teenager. Tbh it's a fair time away, we will probably all have body computers by that point anyway haha

Swipe left for the next trending thread