Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tracking teenagers

410 replies

glittergrrl · 11/02/2022 21:27

Am I the only person not doing this or to find this really odd ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Norgie · 19/07/2022 10:32

How on earth did we manage without all this spying and paranoia.
It's not something I would want on my phone.
Its a controlling abusers wet dream.
And as far as dinner is concerned, it's ready when it's ready.

Bouledeneige · 19/07/2022 09:35

I never tracked my teens and thought it was an awful thing to do. They need to be allowed their independence. Mine thought it was awful when their friends' parents do it.

My DD suggested we do find my phone with each other when she was 20 and a student so we do that - I live alone and often go off and do things like walking in the country without telling anyone.

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 17/07/2022 17:07

No, it's never made sense to me why people do this. They need to grow up and I need to let them go.

springisaroundthecorner · 17/07/2022 17:00

ButchWaghorn · 16/07/2022 19:47

Is there a tracking app that tells your teenager when their location has been accessed? My 14 yo son is resistant to sharing his location with us and I can see why. I want to be able to access his last location if there is genuine reason to believe he needs help or to be able to find his phone when he loses it.
Letting him know when his location has been accessed would help with his concerns about lack of freedom and reduce the likelihood that is start using it as an anxiety prop!

I use MSPY. It's easy to set up

ButchWaghorn · 16/07/2022 19:47

Is there a tracking app that tells your teenager when their location has been accessed? My 14 yo son is resistant to sharing his location with us and I can see why. I want to be able to access his last location if there is genuine reason to believe he needs help or to be able to find his phone when he loses it.
Letting him know when his location has been accessed would help with his concerns about lack of freedom and reduce the likelihood that is start using it as an anxiety prop!

floweringpoppies · 11/07/2022 16:20

When my teen got taken to a netball match at a different location find my iPhone meant it was easy to collect her!

Hankunamatata · 11/07/2022 14:51

Really depends on your teen and their age. 13 is a whole different ballgame to 16. My 13 year old has apple watch as he always forgets his phone (yep a weird species who isnt attached to his phone). He knows I can do find my iphone. I dont as i just ring and ask him if i need to..

springisaroundthecorner · 11/07/2022 14:41

My 16 year old with ADHD was very late last night. Found him 3 miles away with no transport at 10p.m. if I didn't track, I would have had to ring the police.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 11/07/2022 13:59

We have Google family.
I've not really used the tracking bit yet.
Probably will when they're out and about.
Although neither of them will be hanging around parks or wandering around cities or towns without a purpose.
ATM just use it to regulate their time on social media.

Maybebabyno2 · 11/07/2022 13:55

unanswered

Maybebabyno2 · 11/07/2022 13:48

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 09:02

@iCouldSleepForAYear

It didn't occur to me to track our just-turned-16 year old. I have her phone linked to mine to enforce downtime and share any subscriptions. But just checked our settings now because of this thread: her location sharing is off. No idea if she and her pals are using SnapMaps... hoping they can't be bothered.

I can definitely see the temptation to geo track. My 8 year old has just started walking to and from school with friends and is asking for more permission to roam the neighbourhood with them. And I don't want to give her a phone yet, because if I give her a smart phone, it really will be the only thing she'll pay attention to. She's too young and immature to have one yet. But then, that means letting her go straight to the library after school on her own feels like too high a risk: too many gaps in the day and journey to fill, should something go wrong. A tracking watch sounds like a great solution at first... unless she's not wearing it, and there's every chance she'd take it off and forget to put it back on.

I think I would rather teach both girls to communicate with me. Text me when you've arrived. Text me when you're on the bus. Call me if you're running late; do not make us worry. Charge your phone. Take a power pack with you if your battery might run low. Call me and have a long chat if you're walking around somewhere and feeling nervous. Tell me about the landmarks around you if you're lost; read the street signs, read the bus stop sign. Come home and ask me first if it's ok to go to the park with your pals. Learn to wear a normal watch and pay attention to the time. Be home when we've asked you to. Be savvy about your surroundings and the people you interact with.

Yes, that's all great and teaching your girls to be aware is great.

But you're making it sound as if an 8 year old can be expected protect themselves from predators if they have a sensible head. And this isn't true. They're only children. Yes, we can teach them not to go off with strangers willingly. But that doesn't stop them literally being snatched (as someone tried with me when I was 13). Or from being groomed by people they trust.

My DD is the same age and wanting more independence. I'm not at the point where I'll let her be out of the house on her own. But when I am, she'll have location on, on her phone. It's not foolproof, of course. But it's one thing that could be very helpful to help us find our children in an emergency.

Honestly, if they were snatched, the phone would be the first thing out the window. Better to stich air tags into their shoes if kidnap is the reason you are using it.

I get it, I too was nearly taken with a friend when we were around 12. A tracked phone would not have helped one bit, infact, I think it would have prevented people from worrying about us as the phones would likely have been dropped at the location we would have been taken (if we hadnt have run away) so people would assume we were safe.

An answered phone call / text? That would have had people start to worry.

OopsAnotherOne · 11/07/2022 11:22

I'm 23 and still live with my parents. They have life 360 and track each other, just to see when they're on their way home from work to start dinner, or seeing whether they've made it somewhere safely. I was never made to join the app in any way but they asked me if I'd like to and I did. It gives me a bit of security knowing that if anything happened to me, they could track my phone. I know that they don't "check up" on me, but even if they did, I couldn't care less. I'm 23. It's up to me where I go and they know/appreciate that.

It's also been useful on several occasions where I've lost my phone.

My 20 year old brother is at university and he doesn't want the app as he finds it invasive, so he doesn't have it. I also know that there would be no issue or backlash if I decided to remove it from my phone. I know that it certainly isn't everyone's cups of tea but I have a fantastic relationship with my parents so there's no downside of them being able to see where I am, but quite a few convenient upsides.

PADPlaces · 11/07/2022 11:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

PADPlaces · 11/07/2022 10:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JeyesFluid · 15/02/2022 09:45

Good post NoneOfYour32Potatoes

NoneOfYour32Potatoes · 15/02/2022 09:39

Authoritarian tools are good for authoritarians. They are not good for freedom.

You mean tools for propaganda? Such as radio, the media, and television? They are the most widely used tech for authoritarian regimes and/ or controlling influence.

China bans software such as Facebook due to the possibility of subversive ideologies, (and for other reasons) you’d think they’d allow it and use the data mining as a way to control / influence their population but that type of influence is probably far too subtle. I wouldn’t know for sure, just a guess.

And Facebook / YouTube / Podcasts have probably been far more pervasive in terms of disseminating authoritarian ideology than geo-tracking. As well as useful for anti-authoritarian ideologies to have access to social platforms.

I think the UK is the most viewed (CCTV) country in the world (could be wrong) - this is surveillance, and could be used to argue that it is authoritarian. However the CCTV is primarily used for our safety. Such Surveillance in the wrong hands is a tool for oppression. It depends on who is using the tech, not the tech itself.

For our young people, it is probably most helpful that they have good critical thinking skills to assess tech tools and how they are being used, to understand how they influence us, not just outright dismiss a tech tool as a tool of authoritarian repression because they can’t think beyond the simple concepts of of bad vs good.

Understanding authoritarianism, freedom, propaganda, the influence of media, the spoon feeding mechanisms of algorithms on SM platforms, and being able to think critically about these tools in light of that understanding is vital for young people.

Understanding how tech can be used to influence our behaviour isn’t too difficult if a young person can think for themselves. It’s the thinking part that is difficult, what’s that saying, “some people would rather die than think, many do”. Developing meta-cognitive skills for young people to self-assess: “is this tech influencing or informing the way that I think? And does that influence align with who I am or who I want to be?” These meta-cognitive skills aren’t beyond the ability of young adults. Indeed, some young adults have led social and political rebellions with precisely that thinking.

Anyway, the argument is essentially that the personal is political, that allowing geo-tracking teaches submissive behaviour which could be exploited. I would think that submissive behaviour is far more insidiously learned in our society. They way to fight the ideologies of authoritarianism are through teaching the freedoms of thinking for oneself and understanding and thinking about the insidious nature of the pervasive negative influences that can inform our thinking.

RedToothBrush · 15/02/2022 07:54

People who are vulnerable to manipulation by dickheads are going to be exploited whether or not a tracking app is involved. It's the dickhead that's the problem, not the app.

First of all ANYONE is potentially vulnerable to manipulation. You can become worn down by years of someone trying to control you. A tracking app makes it easier for someone doing this, and harder for someone to escape it. It alters power dynamics in a relationship and makes uneven ones even more unequal in a faster and perhaps more all incompassing way.

Authoritarian tools are good for authoritarians. They are not good for freedom.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 15/02/2022 07:37

They're not going to let themselves be tracked by someone they barely know. As soon as a dickhead shows their true colours, with or without an app, they'll be off.

How do you know that, though? Abuse doesn't just start one day - it creeps up on you and by the time you realise the extent of it, you're in too deep. If it was that easy to leave an abusive relationship, they'd not exist.

People who are vulnerable to manipulation by dickheads are going to be exploited whether or not a tracking app is involved. It's the dickhead that's the problem, not the app.

Of course - but things like tracking apps just enable poor behaviour and if someone thinks being tracked is normal (because their parents have always done it) they may not realise how dangerous it can be until it's too late.

BuddhaForMary · 15/02/2022 07:31

They're not going to let themselves be tracked by someone they barely know. As soon as a dickhead shows their true colours, with or without an app, they'll be off.

I think you missed the point.

bebbdebb · 14/02/2022 22:04

@BuddhaForMary

The point is *@bebbdebb* they wouldn't KNOW this partner was a dickhead straight away. It doesn't work like that, otherwise there wouldn't be countless women on here saying their once lovely partner turned out to be controlling/abusive/etc. If they'd started out like that they wouldn't have lasted 2 minutes.
They're not going to let themselves be tracked by someone they barely know. As soon as a dickhead shows their true colours, with or without an app, they'll be off.

People who are vulnerable to manipulation by dickheads are going to be exploited whether or not a tracking app is involved. It's the dickhead that's the problem, not the app.

BuddhaForMary · 14/02/2022 21:40

The point is @bebbdebb they wouldn't KNOW this partner was a dickhead straight away. It doesn't work like that, otherwise there wouldn't be countless women on here saying their once lovely partner turned out to be controlling/abusive/etc. If they'd started out like that they wouldn't have lasted 2 minutes.

bebbdebb · 14/02/2022 21:33

Your husband might be a good person but what if you've taught your kids that it's okay to be tracked and their partner is a dick who tracks their every move?

That's boloney. They're happy to be tracked by people they trust, not by dickheads. They know how to turn it off in a heartbeat.

I don't let any apps know my location, apart from the tracker app we use as a family. We trust each other to use it sensibly and reasonably and it has been very useful in many different scenarios.

bhooks · 14/02/2022 20:13

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

My husband could sit and monitor my run 🤣 but he's not a dick so he doesn't.

But this is such an important point that many people are missing.

Your husband might be a good person but what if you've taught your kids that it's okay to be tracked and their partner is a dick who tracks their every move?

And what if your child decides to change loops or stop for a coffee and isn't home when they say, and their partner assumes they're lying or cheating and starts an argument or worse?

Just because you use it for nice, wholesome reasons doesn't mean everyone does so it shouldn't be something we teach our children is normal.

But the technology is there. It's not going anywhere. Acting like the technology doesn't exist change the fact it does! just ensure children don't grow up knowing what healthy boundaries are for using the technology.

Kids need to learn how to use all kids of technology in a healthy, boundaries way. One of the best ways children learn is from behaviour modelled around them/at home. I don't see why find/track phone technology is any different.

I don't see it as any different from whether we show our kids how to use a phone without harassing someone with hundreds of messages. Or maybe we shouldn't use mobile phone technology because some people use it as a tool of abuse? Abusers and controllers will always find ways to abuse and control - it's the person who is the problem, not the technology. And that is a really, really vital for children to fully understand.

Fedupsotired · 14/02/2022 14:20

@NeverDropYourMooncup wow that doesn't happen with ours, one time it was in the next door shop, if we loose it in the house we know it's here but not exactly where. Maybe we've dodgy signal 🤷🏼‍♀️

26dX · 14/02/2022 10:43

Tbh I'm 26 and my mum, dad and sister (30) all share our location on find my iPhone 😂😂😂

Me and my partner also as I worry because he travels everyday on the motorway for work.

No big deal we don't really care tbh I like to know everyone is ok and I'm nosey sometimes 🤷🏽‍♀️😂 ..

Swipe left for the next trending thread