Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tinder Swindler - victims should accept some accountability

343 replies

sometimespeopletakethepiss · 11/02/2022 21:03

I can completely understand how these ladies could have fell for this guy BUT what I don't understand is the lack of accountability for their poor judgement.

In my life I would never, ever lend money to anyone unless it is money I could afford to lose - and if I did I feel like I'd have to own it as my own poor judgement.

AIBU to think the ladies should repay the money themselves or declare bankruptcy, not setup a 'go fund me' page and take it as a lesson learned?

OP posts:
listsandbudgets · 15/02/2022 09:47

I used to do a public facing job and I once met a man who was trying to get a visa for his girlfriend to come from abroad so they could marry. She'd asked him for passport fees, air fares, money for her sick niece - made excuses about not visiting him because off family emergencies which she needed money for.

He was up to his neck in debt, convinced she would be coming soon and they'd be getting married and wanted to visit her but she kept putting him off because of family problems but couldn't wait to come here to live with him.

It was totally heart breaking. We did eventually manage to get him to understand what was happening but he denied it to himself for months even when his freinds and family were telling him. I remember me and a colleague went to visit him at home and explained very gently what we thought was happening and he literally collapsed on the floor sobbing in front of us. The police and his banks fraud department were astonishingly kind and helpful but it was just horrendous.

He was a victim. He genuinely believed it all and was completely wrapped up in this woman - phone calls, loving messages, long online conversations, even hand written letters sent from her purported home country. I've seen people crumble over many things in the course of my work but this absolute collapse was perhaps the worst. Fifteen years ago now and still sends shivers down my spine Sad

Trippingslippingx1 · 15/02/2022 09:45

Very wealthy people and very cautious about who they get involved with and are usually not keen to marry any random they have just met either.

IcedPurple · 15/02/2022 09:34

Because we keep seeing dramas and heartwarming stories in which this is true? In which addicts have always turned their lives around. In which love does conquer all. In which people come back from CPR with no long-term consequences.

I don't 'keep seeing' these kinds of programmes but in any case, I'd like to think most people are realistic enough to know that "dramas and heartwarming stories" aren't real life.

These women believed this obvious con because they very much wanted to believe it. That's on them, not "dramas and heartwarming stories".

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 15/02/2022 09:31

True, these women were attractive, but still you’d have to ask yourself why a jet-setting billionaire diamond dealer was trawling dating sites and why he was not conducting due diligence on women potentially scamming him . A genuine extremely wealthy man can have their pick of models etc that they meet in real life.

Because we keep seeing dramas and heartwarming stories in which this is true? In which addicts have always turned their lives around. In which love does conquer all. In which people come back from CPR with no long-term consequences.

We valorise people for believing in the power of love and how there's always someone out there for you and it can occur at surprising times. We feed into creating your own reality through your thoughts and the Rules of Attraction.

We never see the denominator or just how rare these outcomes are. We've skewed people's understanding.

Trippingslippingx1 · 15/02/2022 09:27

Friends and I have spoken about this
We can see how he is very persuasive
However if a friend I had known since I was 18 from Uni who I knew their family and friends and had gone through various trials and tribulations with; asked me for a loan of 1k - I would raise an eyebrow.

DottyHarmer · 15/02/2022 09:25

I watched some true crime thing on tv in which a 60-year-old very ordinary woman met a handsome cardiac consultant with a ranch online. Of course it did not end well - fake profile etc. I am in my 50s and not totally gross, but there is no way on earth I would imagine a hot doctor with a ranch would prefer me over any number of options. If we met in real life then maybe I could wow with my fabulous personality Hmm but on paper/virtually it’s unlikely I would attract such a catch.

True, these women were attractive, but still you’d have to ask yourself why a jet-setting billionaire diamond dealer was trawling dating sites and why he was not conducting due diligence on women potentially scamming him . A genuine extremely wealthy man can have their pick of models etc that they meet in real life.

Yeahthat · 14/02/2022 23:38

@lenha

I actually applaud them for coming forward and actually sharing this and doing something to actually warn people. It's something not a lot of people would do because you would get blamed for being so stupid but these women came forward knowing that this would always shadow them. There's nothing wrong with wanting to bag a billionaire or be friends with one as they would have connections if the guy was for real although no way would I ever jump on a plane on a first date or would ignore the red flags and trust so easily. Being scammed is something that would eat you up with embarrassment let alone taking loans out that would kill you financially for the rest of your life and I think they are quite hardcore to come forward with it. I also like how they've formed some sisterhood with the victims and did everything to get his name out.
The "bag a billionaire" thing is exactly why a genuine one would probably not be on Tinder. You'd have to be suspicious of everyone around you - friends, romantic interests etc, and question their motives. Are their emotions genuine, or do they just see what you can potentially offer them and see you as a resource to tap into?

As someone else mentioned, another woman that he attempted to scam has spoken out and described him being on his phone constantly on their first date etc. We saw that the first woman was willing to get on a plane with him regardless - she wasn't interested in him, but what he could offer her.

Turns out that was actually nothing except financial ruin.

Nevertheless, all I can see in this situation is people on all sides who were playing and using each other in some way.

The girls lost.

I imagine the motivation for the documentary was financial, with the segue into GoFundMe possibly planned in advance.

grapewine · 14/02/2022 23:32

50 shades wouldn't have shifted a copy had the male lead not been a billionaire.

Never a truer word spoken. Apparently, it's OK to be a douche if you're rich ...

grapewine · 14/02/2022 23:30

I honestly had empathy for them and felt very sorry for them too. Genuinely. But feeling sorry for someone doesn't mean they shouldn't take accountability.

I couldn't agree more.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 14/02/2022 23:24

I deal with fraud complaints for a bank and romance scams happen much more often than you think. Most victims are too ashamed to tell family or friends but they’ll complain to their bank.

Do they? Are there statistics on this because I'm genuinely interested.

I'm surprised at the number of people I know who have family members who've been scammed who can't be persuaded to tell their banks. They also won't talk about it rationally with their families because the shame and stigma run so deep. Some of these people have gone into substantial cognitive decline or depression associated with the scam.

lenha · 14/02/2022 23:16

I actually applaud them for coming forward and actually sharing this and doing something to actually warn people. It's something not a lot of people would do because you would get blamed for being so stupid but these women came forward knowing that this would always shadow them. There's nothing wrong with wanting to bag a billionaire or be friends with one as they would have connections if the guy was for real although no way would I ever jump on a plane on a first date or would ignore the red flags and trust so easily. Being scammed is something that would eat you up with embarrassment let alone taking loans out that would kill you financially for the rest of your life and I think they are quite hardcore to come forward with it. I also like how they've formed some sisterhood with the victims and did everything to get his name out.

Diqgeneration · 14/02/2022 22:36

Just read that nearly £900 million was lost to dating scams last year! That’s just in the UK. So, it seems worryingly common.

Xenia · 14/02/2022 20:39

They are victims of crime. They might be foolish - they were deliberately picked because of their gullibility but they were stolen from and the man is now out from jail in Israel and living the life of Riley still as he will until imprisoned for more like 20 years and they are left paying debts.

He was in touch with loads of women (one not on the film knew on the first date he was dodgy so obviously she was not the kind he went on after as she was normal, like most of us, realising it was a tall tale). Just because some women are more trusting than others does not mean they deserve what is coming just as if a woman wears a short skirt she is not responsible for being raped etc etc. These women (other than the one with the child) who gave him money did not know about the con and they are victims.

IcedPurple · 14/02/2022 20:31

It is the money. In the case of the first woman, if a skint bloke - or just a plain ordinary man - turned up with a strange woman and their child on the first date - you’d run a mile. The only reason you’d put up with the odd behaviour is because he was minted.

Yes, and how many women would be happy to play 3rd wheel for a male 'friend' and his much younger model girlfriend if it didn't involve extravagant dinners and 5K a night hotels on Mykonos?

Yeahthat · 14/02/2022 18:59

@DottyHarmer

Exactly. I find the helpless victim narrative to be nonsense. I also think that the fact that they seem not to have shared the details of the situation with anyone - friend etc - proves that deep down they knew it was dodgy.

DottyHarmer · 14/02/2022 18:23

It is the money. In the case of the first woman, if a skint bloke - or just a plain ordinary man - turned up with a strange woman and their child on the first date - you’d run a mile. The only reason you’d put up with the odd behaviour is because he was minted.

I had a Google and came up with a woman who went on one date with the TS. She said he was on his phone constantly and wouldn’t engage in any real conversation, just throwing out compliments. Some women didn’t need much grooming, they were jumping on his private jet before you could say American Express.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/02/2022 16:58

Ironically, given these women are being blasted as greedy gold diggers, these scams/manipulations frequently rely on making the mark feel obliged to prove that they're NOT shallow money grabbers, by forking out

This is true, though it still adds up to someone the "marks" hardly know - and in some cases have never even met - asking for money

I agree the psychology's complex, but it's not as if there's any lack of information/warnings out there about this kind of thing, so at some point it has to come down to the mark kidding themselves that "mine is different"
And sorry, but that's a choice

User135644 · 14/02/2022 16:51

There's a reason all those Mills and Boon heroes are rich as Croesus

50 shades wouldn't have shifted a copy had the male lead not been a billionaire.

DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 14:19

[quote Yeahthat]@DrSbaitso

I find it hard to believe, for example, that the first woman had developed genuine feelings and a sense of obligation after one month. The overriding emotion which she described in her account of the initial period after meeting him was awe at the material things he offered her, "The hotel was 5 stars; private jet; I'd never ate this food before." These weren't genuine feelings, they were superficial.

I also thought it was very telling that none of them seemed to have consulted friends or family about the situation to gauge their opinion. The first woman has a sister of approximately her age who's in the police. In my opinion she didn't ask because she "wanted to believe" and probably on some level knew that the bubble would burst if she did.

It's not that I don't have sympathy for victims of scams and I understand that they can involve truly complex psychological manipulation played out sometimes over years. I recently watched Puppet Master on Netflix - which depicts just such a scenario. The romance scams are equally appalling.

A PP has mentioned a case of someone whose parents are attempting to manipulate her with feelings of guilt and obligation into buying them a house. I see that as a case of complex psychological manipulation.

I guess that I just see this particular case as a more simple tale of greed. And in the case of the scammers (because there were at least two others involved, running the scam practically as a business), total amorality. The women had a glimpse of the instagram ideal and didn't want to look under the hood.[/quote]
Perhaps you've never experienced very heady, intense romantic feelings early on. Some people never do. But it's not an uncommon experience. Whirlwind romance and all that.

And as I keep saying (and you claim not to understand), money is dazzling. Coupled with saying and supposedly doing the right things, it's a powerful force. But it's not the only one. It's a very important part of this particular scam but it isn't the only thing. It's dazzling, it's overpowering and when combined with other powers, it can feel very much like love. There's a reason all those Mills and Boon heroes are rich as Croesus. OBVIOUSLY it's still Twoo Wuv between him and the heroine, but all those billions certainly aid the process.

If this isn't something you can relate to personally, I'm sure you can understand it on an intellectual level.

It is NOT simple greed. If it were, it would be a mere investment scam, and given how many people do make wise investments, I'm not convinced there's any automatic moral slam dunk on those victims either.

It's a ROMANCE scam. The clue is in the name. The appearance of wealth is a huge part of it, yes, because it's a dazzling act, but you're oversimplifying it very much to reduce it down to nothing more. As people say, it's not exactly much of a promise of luxury if he can't get the money when he needs it, so they're obviously working on some other thought process than "quids in" by the time they're forking out because he's told them his life is in danger or whatever. If they were utterly tight and self serving, they'd be less likely to be taken in!

People are insisting it's nothing but greed because they're failing to understand how the psychology works, failing to see the context of that psychology and, to a large extent, telling themselves they couldn't ever fall for something like this because they're Not Greedy And Shallow. Despite the fact that people in these scams often feel obliged to fork out precisely to prove they're Not Greedy And Shallow.

It just isn't that simple.

AryaStarkWolf · 14/02/2022 14:08

Ironically, given these women are being blasted as greedy gold diggers, these scams/manipulations frequently rely on making the mark feel obliged to prove that they're NOT shallow money grabbers, by forking out.

Yes that's a very good observation

DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 14:05

And it's foolishness itself just to say "Well, of course I'd never give £700k to someone while I'm renting!"

Of course you wouldn't, if it was just placed flat in front of you with no context. Mix it up with family relationships, a sense of obligation, possibly cultural expectations, a big show of how much they do for you and whatnot....You still might not do it, I'd hope not, but surely one sees that a context and psychological web has been spun around the person, and it's just not quite as straightforward as that.

Ironically, given these women are being blasted as greedy gold diggers, these scams/manipulations frequently rely on making the mark feel obliged to prove that they're NOT shallow money grabbers, by forking out.

Yeahthat · 14/02/2022 14:04

@DrSbaitso

I find it hard to believe, for example, that the first woman had developed genuine feelings and a sense of obligation after one month. The overriding emotion which she described in her account of the initial period after meeting him was awe at the material things he offered her, "The hotel was 5 stars; private jet; I'd never ate this food before." These weren't genuine feelings, they were superficial.

I also thought it was very telling that none of them seemed to have consulted friends or family about the situation to gauge their opinion. The first woman has a sister of approximately her age who's in the police. In my opinion she didn't ask because she "wanted to believe" and probably on some level knew that the bubble would burst if she did.

It's not that I don't have sympathy for victims of scams and I understand that they can involve truly complex psychological manipulation played out sometimes over years. I recently watched Puppet Master on Netflix - which depicts just such a scenario. The romance scams are equally appalling.

A PP has mentioned a case of someone whose parents are attempting to manipulate her with feelings of guilt and obligation into buying them a house. I see that as a case of complex psychological manipulation.

I guess that I just see this particular case as a more simple tale of greed. And in the case of the scammers (because there were at least two others involved, running the scam practically as a business), total amorality. The women had a glimpse of the instagram ideal and didn't want to look under the hood.

HappyDays40 · 14/02/2022 14:01

The only people that parted with the money are the women. I don't think they should be asking other people to pay it backConfused

Diqgeneration · 14/02/2022 13:54

Wants her to buy them a £700k house

Diqgeneration · 14/02/2022 13:53

There’s another whose parents want a £700 k house while she rents and she’s asking if she is unreasonable.