Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let my 8 year old have a snack supply in her room?

185 replies

jilllanguage · 11/02/2022 20:06

My DD is 8 and a couple weeks ago she asked if she could have a snack supply in her bedroom. I said yes but she still needed to ask if she was going to have any out of it. It's unhealthy snacks, mainly chocolate I admit.

She's had it a few weeks and most of it is still there. The bits she's had she has asked me and I've said it's fine. She likes to set it up all nice and just know it's there more than anything I think.

When she told her dad though he phoned me saying there is no need for it and it's encouraging bad eating habits. He thinks she's too obsessional with food as it is at my house. I suppose he does have a point. She is always thinking about what she'll eat next.

However, she's not overweight at all, she's very active, she eats her vegetables (fruit not as keen on), she will leave breakfast/lunch/dinner/dessert/yogurt etc on her plate so she knows when she is full, in fact she never finishes a full meal to be honest.

I don't see a problem with the snack box, if she was eating it without permission etc then I'd take it away but she's not.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Darkstar4855 · 12/02/2022 11:28

She doesn’t eat full meals but you let her keep a stash of chocolate in her bedroom at age 8? Yes YABU.

TheKeatingFive · 12/02/2022 11:15

Claudia kept her junk food stash hidden in her room too!

Ah, loved those books. And they all thought Stacy and Dawn were weirdos for not eating endless crap 😂

BuddhaForMary · 12/02/2022 11:15

Such dramatics on this thread. No surprise though, this is MN after all Grin

blackdumpling · 12/02/2022 11:12

Keeping food in your room isn't a habit would encourage
For me old fashioned but think food goes in the kitchen
That's what the kitchen was designed for
It's an odd request to make
If you met a bloke who kept food in his room, you wouldn't date him
Would offer her to have a special snack shelf in the kitchen instead
I'd talk to her about vermin & mice, so she understood why it's a no
It sounds like she has been reading old Babysitter Club Books
Claudia kept her junk food stash hidden in her room too!

LadyEloise1 · 12/02/2022 11:07

Snacks in her bedroom Shock
Food upstairs Shock
Absolutely not !
Mice !!!!!

Unless you live in a bungalow Smile

Better in the kitchen.
You can keep an eye on what she's eating.

Phormiumjester · 12/02/2022 11:05

There's some real dramatics out today...

Rats, mice, awful smells, choking, nobody ever eats alone... crikey!

I can't see the point in doing it, OP. Nor can I see how it leads to anything good but all this FUSS?!? How do some posters deal with life with this level of outrage and fear?

TeloMere · 12/02/2022 10:59

However, she's not overweight at all, she's very active, she eats her vegetables (fruit not as keen on), she will leave breakfast/lunch/dinner/dessert/yogurt etc on her plate so she knows when she is full, in fact she never finishes a full meal to be honest.

Maybe she doesn't finish a full meal because she's been snacking. Even small amounts of chocolate can take the edge off appetite for a meal.

My SIL is healthy and slim and carefully controls her calorie intake, she cuts out meals and eats 1600 cals a day, mostly consisting of chocolates and crisps .

BuddhaForMary · 12/02/2022 10:34

@RedToothBrush

An 8 year old? In her bedroom?

Good god no.

This has to be a wind up.

Why? If you've rtft you'll see some of us have done this with our kids and everyone survived the experience without piling on weight, getting cavities or choking.
Berengaria1 · 12/02/2022 10:34

Ginghamstarfish I agree, but I'm in my 50s so older than most on here. I didn't snack as a child and neither did my friends (although we were given food if we were hungry) and I don't snack now. I'm amazed when I go to the cinema and people have trays of food and buckets of popcorn and coke to watch a one and a half hour film!

I accept mine is probably a minority view though.

If a child has free access to snacks I can't see much difference between them being downstairs and in the bedroom as long as the parent knows what's being eaten.

TheKeatingFive · 12/02/2022 10:22

Yeah, I wouldn't do this. I don't think it could achieve anything positive in terms of her relationship with food.

We also have a no food upstairs rule, but that's more to do with paranoia about rodents.

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2022 10:13

@ginghamstarfish

I may be missing the point, but if a child eats healthy meals why do they need snacks? We grew up fine without them (yes I'm old). We wouldn't have dared go in the kitchen and help ourselves to a biscuit or anything for that matter, we ate what mum we were given or went without. Same at, friends' houses too. Strangely there didn't seem to be many fussy eaters in those days. Amazing how things have changed.
You are not missing the point.

You are identifying the problem.

Noisyneighneigh · 12/02/2022 10:12

@ginghamstarfish

I may be missing the point, but if a child eats healthy meals why do they need snacks? We grew up fine without them (yes I'm old). We wouldn't have dared go in the kitchen and help ourselves to a biscuit or anything for that matter, we ate what mum we were given or went without. Same at, friends' houses too. Strangely there didn't seem to be many fussy eaters in those days. Amazing how things have changed.
I agree. I think it's healthier not to snack unless the kid has to wait a really long time for a meal. My kids do have puddings and cakes sometimes but they don't regularly snack in between meals as they wouldn't bloody eat their meal. However I don't think kids were less fussy back then, my granny who's nearly 80 remembers being fussy and just having to go hungry. The same for me. I had a few genuine dislikes and I had to go hungry.
Noisyneighneigh · 12/02/2022 10:05

8 is really little. Plenty of time for that when she is a teen. Seems unwholesome for a small child to sit in her room eating unhealthy snacks. It might encourage unhealthy associations.

I am prepared for all the HmmConfused emojis.

ginghamstarfish · 12/02/2022 10:04

I may be missing the point, but if a child eats healthy meals why do they need snacks? We grew up fine without them (yes I'm old). We wouldn't have dared go in the kitchen and help ourselves to a biscuit or anything for that matter, we ate what mum we were given or went without. Same at, friends' houses too. Strangely there didn't seem to be many fussy eaters in those days. Amazing how things have changed.

LuckyAmy1986 · 12/02/2022 09:58

I think that's part of the reason she wants a treat box, she thinks it adds to her room as she has it sitting out for anyone to see when they walk into her room like a little set up you'd get in a hotel room

That’s so cute! I think I’d let her have it up there but she has to ask before having something and has to eat it downstaursv

liveforsummer · 12/02/2022 09:58

@AbsentmindedWoman

Why on earth would anyone need snacks in their room?

I keep juice boxes beside my bed because of type 1 diabetes.

There are other medical conditions where food is a tool in managing the illness.

I don't think OP's dd has any of them though. I'm sure she'd have mentioned that.
Soontobe60 · 12/02/2022 09:57

Snacks in the bedroom for an 8 year old is a rubbish idea.
Those who say it’s good because it’s giving her an element of choice - she can choose from healthy foods that are in the kitchen can’t she?

Soontobe60 · 12/02/2022 09:54

@Thewindwhispers

Yanbu. She’s enjoying feeling grown up. Grown uos fhave a food cupboard: she wants her own food cupboard. Allowing her to have her own choices about what and when to eat is oart of building a healthy attitude to eating.

So keep an eye on how much junk is in it though. Maybe replace the chocolates with popcorn / choc flavour cereal bars etc

I’m a grown up. My food cupboards are all in the kitchen and there isn’t a box of confectionary snacks there.
Barrawarra · 12/02/2022 09:54

My DD, 6, had a ‘secret stash’ of some Xmas sweets in her room over the holidays which we let her crack on with. It wasn’t secret, we knew where it was and she would tell us if she wanted it. She is also slim and athletic. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with giving kids some control and responsibility, if they’ve shown you they can manage it. When they show they can’t, then they need our help.

Soontobe60 · 12/02/2022 09:53

@AbsentmindedWoman

Why on earth would anyone need snacks in their room?

I keep juice boxes beside my bed because of type 1 diabetes.

There are other medical conditions where food is a tool in managing the illness.

So they’re not ‘snacks’ as such.
peboh · 12/02/2022 09:50

I'm not sure why she needs snacks in her bedroom? Surely she can access your kitchen to grab a snack should she want one?
We try to keep food outside of our bedrooms, I especially don't like the idea of a child dropping something under their bed, or behind a desk or something, forgetting it's there and then it growing mouldy! It's just not necessary.

liveforsummer · 12/02/2022 09:47

@cheekychaplin

Why would vermin appear? We don't have vermin in the kitchen so why would we get them in the bedroom by having a few snacks in a drawer?
Kitchens tend to have hard floors and are swept daily or as necessary, in a bedroom with carpet and soft furnishings crumbs nestle and go unnoticed. Doesn't take much to attract a hungry mouse (or worse) family
Thewindwhispers · 12/02/2022 09:43

Yanbu. She’s enjoying feeling grown up. Grown uos fhave a food cupboard: she wants her own food cupboard. Allowing her to have her own choices about what and when to eat is oart of building a healthy attitude to eating.

So keep an eye on how much junk is in it though. Maybe replace the chocolates with popcorn / choc flavour cereal bars etc

Thirkettle · 12/02/2022 09:40

No, that's a bunch of fillings waiting to happen. She clearly developing unhealthy habits, and it's your job to dissuade them, not encourage hoarding and mindless snacking.

She will not enjoy fillings and root canals.

cheekychaplin · 12/02/2022 09:18

@LouLou198

Choking hazard was the first thing I thought of too. Nobody eats alone in our house for this reason.

Nobody? What do you do if you are hungry and there isn't another adult around?

Swipe left for the next trending thread