Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids not meeting expectations

319 replies

followthenoise · 11/02/2022 19:33

Feeling like we may be failing our DC5 and 7 (yr 1 and yr3) Both have received mid year reports indicating they are below expectations. This is despite us doing around 45 mins of homework /reading with them a day. Both are (early) summer born, and both DH and I are in professional roles with masters level qualifications. We try to foster learning in all activities / aim for a growth mindset, but they both appear to be falling behind. I'm not a pushy parent and would be happy with whatever they want to do, but I am at my wits end on how to support them. Eldest DC likely has ADHD and some sensory issues, but we're told this shouldn't impact her academically particularly , youngest seems fine (apart from academics!). School feedback is that need to write more at home, need to improve - but it seems beyond them when I sit down and do it with them!

OP posts:
Lalliella · 11/02/2022 23:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Furbulousnous · 11/02/2022 23:29

‘DC2 is very sad he is the only one in his class still on yellow book band.’

He shouldn’t even be aware that he is. Has an adult said something? A teacher? You? Or is he in the kind of hothouse atmosphere yhatbitbhas become a thing that he is.
Book bands should be for teachers and parents as a rough guide that’s it.

Furbulousnous · 11/02/2022 23:26

Chill. Out. They should not even have ‘homework’ at their age, let alone 45 mins. In many countries they wouldn’t even be in formal schooling yet - but you probably already know that.
Presuming they are in private school,
who set homework at this age because of parental expectation not because one single
Teacher thinks they need homework.
It DOES matter that they are summer born. I would hope at least that your teachers are taking that into account, but possibly not - again the private school expectation.
Read to your children. Read to them and play games. If they do music or an instrument get them to practice 10 mins a day. Other than that there’s nothing else you should be doing.

CookieMunch · 11/02/2022 23:23

We had a similar situation with DC2 in year 3 although state school and no SEN as far as we’re aware. I found it really stressful trying to do lots of work to support (lockdowns didn’t help that) and it didn’t seem to help anyway so I got him a tutor (1 hour per week 121). He’d caught up within 4 months. Turns out he doesn’t learn well the way they teach at school. I just do a bit of reading with him and let the tutor (the expert!) handle it now and it’s a lot less stressful. Not a cheap option for sure but maybe worth considering if you can afford it

DixonD · 11/02/2022 23:22

@followthenoise

Thanks it's definitely not always 45 minutes of sit down with a book every day, may be 20 mins with school work, then 15 mins game then 10 minutes reading.

Yes @inheritancetrack they schools are private. We didn't think DC1 would thrive in a large class and then it's hard not to give all your kids the same opportunity...

My child is in a state school in a class of 12.

That’s half the size of the class in the private school we looked at sending her to.

Mine is in year 1 and summer born. She’s good at reading, and things like spelling come after mastering reading. We read together for 5 minutes a day. I think you’re doing too much.

me4real · 11/02/2022 23:20

DC2 is very sad he is the only one in his class still on yellow book band.

@followthenoise I would focus on trying to make him feel ok about himself. A 5 year old should not have noticed things like this at all. They are picking up on the way you and your husband feel about it IMHO. He will get unhappy if he carries on thinking that way.

Bellex · 11/02/2022 23:19

When I was in primary school I was completely written off my the teachers. Also under achieving. When it came to yr5/6 and SATS my mum sent me to Kip McGrath (tutoring franchise) initially for English and then we added Maths. Once a week then twice a week towards the exam part. I also revised a lot from what I got at school. Predicted low 3s, came out with all 5s and the highest in the school.

I did a lot of dancing at the time, did the required homework but nothing additional really. I think if my mum had started me earlier I’d have burnt out. I also achieve all A*’s at GSCE, A-level and a first at Uni

Chichimcgee · 11/02/2022 23:16

Also kids aren’t daft, they’ll know the ‘games’ are educational. Just let them be kids

BitcherOfBlakiven · 11/02/2022 23:13

You have to make sure that learning is FUN for children and not a slog or a chore - there’s plenty of time for that in Y10/11/12/13!

happyfroday · 11/02/2022 23:12
  • food diary
Benjispruce5 · 11/02/2022 23:11

It is sad @Livpool and it’s not school’s fault. We hate it too!

BitcherOfBlakiven · 11/02/2022 23:11

@Benjispruce5

Lots of children with ASDs don’t use phonics, they memorise. Unfortunately, Ofsted is really pushing phonics at the moment. Hmm
Yep, our primary has just announced a new phonics scheme and DD (Y1), already struggling with phonics, likely to have ADHD/ASD like me and her sister - yay.
happyfroday · 11/02/2022 23:11

I would say from my DS going to a private school nursery and the friends who's kids have stayed on they seem to work the kids at a year ahead of what my DC are doing in their council owned school.

Do you also know when the others in class are born ? All the DC in my friends small private school class of 8 are September/ October.

I have a year one, we do reading (one book) and spellings issued by the school. Occasionally like you a birthday card, or a postcard. We did a good diary for a week and it was hard work. I also let Dc sound out the words and write them rather than spelling them out. At home you can make mistakes and I feel being corrected too much can seem to critical .I'm very slack on maths. I should try to do something, counting in 2/5/10'a out loud or written, but times just flies by and they are tired. It maybe in class your DC is already beyond this.

Livpool · 11/02/2022 23:10

Sorry but your poor kids! Just let them be children and play.

My DS is year one and we get weekly homework plus we read - a LOT. The children are so young and it sounds like they are already a disappointment because they aren't meeting arbitrary levels of marking them. This makes me quite said ri read to be honest

Benjispruce5 · 11/02/2022 23:09

Lots of children with ASDs don’t use phonics, they memorise. Unfortunately, Ofsted is really pushing phonics at the moment. Hmm

StoppinBy · 11/02/2022 23:08

Who said ADHD wouldn't affect a child academically? Of course it does.

The best thing we ever did for our child was try medication for her ADHD. Prior to this she was struggling to take in information and to get it back out on paper when needed.

Also, all that homework is crazy, it may also be pointless if your child isn't actually taking it in. Get a referral for your kids to see a peadiatrician if you haven't already and get them a proper review.

DePfeffoff · 11/02/2022 23:08

What does "aiming for a growth mindset" mean?

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 11/02/2022 23:07

This is what I was talking about..

Kids not meeting expectations
Livandme · 11/02/2022 23:06

I haven't rtwt but your dc are v young.
Do they meet your expectations? Are they kind? Good friends to others? Caring? Do they share?
School expectations are not important. Honestly.
Being a good kind person is much more important.
My son used to get "marked down" at primary school but as a teenager now he has other skills that are much more useful in life.

CarbonelCat · 11/02/2022 23:04

Your DC will have absolutely no recollection of life before covid. They've not had a full academic year in school!

This all, quite frankly, sounds a bit mad. The school sound unhelpful, unrealistic, unimaginative, unsupportive and unkind.

Doing more formal learning at home is rarely going to be the answer. Share more stories, do more talking, read to them, point out numbers, times, prices etc but don't make them 'do homework'.

My year 1 6 year old is 'way behind'. He is barely coping with red band books and is reluctant to write his name, let alone anything else. School are being really reassuring and supportive and have rightly pointed out that he is socially capable, interesting and interested, articulate and imaginative - the rest will come.

If you think your dd has a specific developmental or learning issue then of course get all the assessment and help that you can for her, but in general I would take all this pressure off.

Lindsaycreate · 11/02/2022 22:57

This may or may not help. My son was in P2 at the time of the first lockdown. To me he was clearly very bright but his teachers (it was a job share) had basically written him off. He was stuck at a table that the Classroom Assistant worked with and they clearly had no interaction with him. He would say to me (at 5) that he was ‘not smart’. I hate that he was made to feel like that. To cut a long story short I had him reading fluently within two weeks of lockdown by not using phonics - he has a mind that is better at remembering than sounding (especially when the sounds sometimes don’t fit logically). He’s now in P4 and in the top group in the class. They are tested relentlessly and he regularly gets 100% in literacy and numeracy (and he loves reading). Another child I know was in p5 and could hardly read before lockdown - she was clearly intelligent and had been tested for dyslexia etc (no issues). Her dad got an allotment during lockdown and the lady on the one next to it was a retired schoolteacher who had her reading in a few weeks. Sometimes the teaching methods in schools aren’t right for all children. You sound like you do lots of work with them. They will be fine.

Lindtnotlint · 11/02/2022 22:54

I sympathise. I was an early achiever at school and my kids have been anything but - it can be a bit of a jarring adjustment. Genuinely though, the best advice is to relax. There is almost nothing you can actually do to change things - more practice, less practice, more tree climbing etc will basically make very little difference either way. It comes when it comes. You really do have to think about some of the academic stuff at this age as being more like teeth coming through - it’s not something you can rush and everyone gets it at the right time for them.

I know that’s a hard thing to truly believe - but honestly speaking from experience it really is true.....

Confrontayshunme · 11/02/2022 22:53

Year 1 TA here. Many kids struggle with the fine motor control aspect of writing. Sitting and writing won't fix this, but scissor skills, play doh, colouring and tweezer activities will.
Reading bleeds into everything so read a short book they are able to (not above their current band) every day. Keep rereading so they gain fluency and learn common words and sentence structure. Also, read TO them so they learn story structure and common plots of stories. I know less about maths, but continue to count everything- steps, how long they brush their teeth or wash hands, how many pieces of pasta they have. Take some away or add them and see if they can do lots of concrete and practical maths with objects like lego rather than written sums.

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 11/02/2022 22:45

Remember that in many countries dc don’t even start school until age 7, and everything up until then is play based with no formal academics. Just like when they are babies and anywhere between 9-17ish months is normal for walking, so anywhere between 3-4&8+ is normal for reading and writing.. The arbitrary standards of English primary schools do not actually match the pedagogy! Have a look at the pictures of children's hand bones at various ages, and you can see they are barely physically able to hold a pen properly at that age. I would honestly encourage you to push back against the school, homework at that age has no actual value (studies have shown that it doesn’t improve outcomes) and push for the proper ADHD diagnosis for your eldest.

PoshPyjamas · 11/02/2022 22:43

You say you used to be an overachiever at school, and your OP reads as though you are doing your best to be an overachiever at parenting too - but there's no awards in parenting.

Of course you could always go on a parenting forum and say things like We try to foster learning in all activities / aim for a growth mindset So that everybody will tell you you're doing too much, so that you feel like an overachiever again...

Are you sure your children aren't picking up the vibe that you think they are substandard? That's the impression I get - you of course are doing everything you can. If it weren't for the shoddy raw materials you have to work with, you'd be bloody brilliant at... erm... fostering a growth mindset...

Swipe left for the next trending thread