Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids not meeting expectations

319 replies

followthenoise · 11/02/2022 19:33

Feeling like we may be failing our DC5 and 7 (yr 1 and yr3) Both have received mid year reports indicating they are below expectations. This is despite us doing around 45 mins of homework /reading with them a day. Both are (early) summer born, and both DH and I are in professional roles with masters level qualifications. We try to foster learning in all activities / aim for a growth mindset, but they both appear to be falling behind. I'm not a pushy parent and would be happy with whatever they want to do, but I am at my wits end on how to support them. Eldest DC likely has ADHD and some sensory issues, but we're told this shouldn't impact her academically particularly , youngest seems fine (apart from academics!). School feedback is that need to write more at home, need to improve - but it seems beyond them when I sit down and do it with them!

OP posts:
Feeascotime · 12/02/2022 18:00

My youngest leaving for uni in September.
In retrospect don't worry about teacher expectations too much. Dont start taking on the schools responsibility. Ensure they do their homework and leave it at that. All children level off and can eventually read and write equally well. They have done school hours and relaxing and family time to distress is more important. You can be as "sneaky" as you like, they' will be on to you.
Throughout my children's schooling, teacher predictions proved flakey. They have to put something in that report!
More important is confidence and resilience - not grades. Find fun physical activities that foster that. At mid high school they will have to choose what grades they want. It is not up to parents to set expectations. If they learn to take ownership you will be set for uni.
I wish I could confront junior school teachers on their "predictions and concerns" with actual outcomes 🤣
Do not let your young children go into high school set up with anxiety issues.
BTW, I disagree that Adhd does not influence school work. A different approach is needed at school and these children suffer holding it together at school. Both academically and socially. The last thing they need is extra pressure on top of homework. Tgey usually let it all out at home. Let them figure it all out - being on time, organisational skills, dealing with frustrations, working out how they learn best and social skills so they set up by the time they enter year 9.
Its a process, and your children are very very young. As a mum I just supported and loved and encouraged AND kept teachers and school expectations under control.
Don't get sucked in. My 3 all did well.
Your children will be fine. X

Macanncheese · 12/02/2022 17:35

@Goawayangryman

ADHD not impacting academically?! Who the heckers told you that?? It also often coexists with other learning difficulties such as dyslexia.

Primaries can be really shit at screening for these sorts of things. My DD slipped through right till year 6 being told she needed to do more at home Hmm. Nope.

Exactly this!
gettingshorter · 12/02/2022 17:35

Personally think just too young to judge. My DS summer baby was in special needs group for reading and writing in year 3. Made me worry and panic that would always be behind but gradually improved and now predicted A* in English A level.

90sCliche · 12/02/2022 17:15

I sometimes think this is the school playing the system. They send home the mid-year report saying 'working below expectation' and then - surprise, surprise, - the end of year report says 'working at expectation.' That way the school are able to say that a child has made progress. Same way the ones 'working at' are then 'working at greater depth'. It's a data game. And ignore class WhatsApp!

inheritancetrack · 12/02/2022 16:44

Private schools hothouse children from very early on. They have to, to keep the grades high. Not good for a child with ADHD. DS had this and he was a nightmare in a large class, so you had the right idea, but it backfires when the children feel under so much pressure. DS(8) knows when we are playing and it involves school work, and is highly resistant.

Maybe a private tutor is the way to keep up with a high achieving class, but more expense and more pressure on the child. Bit of a no win situation at the moment.

Kennykenkencat · 12/02/2022 15:01

@followthenoise

Thanks it's definitely not always 45 minutes of sit down with a book every day, may be 20 mins with school work, then 15 mins game then 10 minutes reading.

Yes @inheritancetrack they schools are private. We didn't think DC1 would thrive in a large class and then it's hard not to give all your kids the same opportunity...

A private school I know near went from ages 4 to 18. It is considered to be an outstanding school with very very good gcse and A level results. I think it is often in the top 10 results in the country list.

However in the primary school section up to I think year 6 there is no homework.
As one teacher said to me when I visited with Dd it was along the lines of . We are here to teach your children. We have them for 6 hours per day and that is enough for them. If we can’t teach them what they need to know in those 6 hours then we aren’t doing our job.

cherryonthecakes · 12/02/2022 12:35

It's a private school. That changes things if it's the type that's about having kids pass their exams to prestigious schools. They want their kids ahead of expectations (especially if those expectations are National Curriculum ones) because there is pressure from parents to make sure their kids are ahead of state school peers.

I would be considering an assessment at a more gently paced school. They might do better long term and enjoy learning more if their confidence is built.

My kids are state educated and while my son was below expectations, I found it far too vague for my liking. Was he below now but likely to reach expectations by the end of the year ? Is he so far below now he won't even reach current school year's expectations even in a year's time ? I think you should find out what the expectations are. If it's trajectory for passing the exam to an elite school like St Paul's Girls then you just need a school that matches realistic expectations for your children

christinarossetti19 · 12/02/2022 09:57

I think some posters are being a bit hard on the OP tbh.

She isn't hot-housing her children or wanting them to be 'top' of the class or miss out on their childhood - she's worried because their school reports suggest that they are falling behind.

It honestly sound like the problem is the reports. If they are assessing children against end of year 'expectations' then of course most children won't be meeting them. It's also in the schools interest in terms of 'showing progress' that children aren't assessed as meeting end of year targets at this point of the academic year.

Additionally, it's quite handy for schools to panic parents a bit so that they enlist tutors, do more academics at home etc (not that OP has given any sort of indication that she's going to do this) which reflects well on the school in terms of pupil outcomes.

ChocolateMassacre · 12/02/2022 09:22

The problem is the school.

You're paying £££ for an educational approach which is too rigid and pressured and doesn't meet your children's needs.

Move them to a different school. Your children only get one childhood - don't let the school ruin it for them.

Trinity69 · 12/02/2022 09:13

@Goawayangryman

ADHD not impacting academically?! Who the heckers told you that?? It also often coexists with other learning difficulties such as dyslexia.

Primaries can be really shit at screening for these sorts of things. My DD slipped through right till year 6 being told she needed to do more at home Hmm. Nope.

This. 100% this. ADHD can have a huge impact on learning and co-morbid conditions that run alongside it may also be having an impact. I'd recommend contacting your GP and getting on the pathway for an ADHD assessment (or go private if money allows, NHS waiting lists are huge at the moment) and go from there. My son also slipped through the net at school (but not with me, I always knew but school wouldn't back me up or help at all). He now has a list of diagnoses as long as your arm, still struggles massively and is still behind, but now is in a setting that supports him 100%.
Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 12/02/2022 08:58

To be honest this is how it got phrased often at my son's primary school,- not meeting expectations. End of year report comes along and Ta Da! expectations have been met! It is so that the teachers can say - yes we are doing the job and we have improved this batch of kids.

Mischance · 12/02/2022 07:36

@ConfusedParticle

for fucks sake theyre human beings not machines. let them grow imagination, play, creativity.

glad im not your kids.

Quite.

When did all this start to happen? - force-feeding children and taking away their childhoods.

CarbonelCat · 12/02/2022 07:27

This is clearly child dependent. As I say, my year 1 is red book band band and this causes him not one iota of concern!

School have been v reassuring. He is part of a year group of children who have had no uninterrupted teaching ever.

Why would you want your child to measure their worth by book band at 6?!

iRun2eatCake · 12/02/2022 07:04

[quote followthenoise]@Bathsheba1878 that's lovely to hear. I don't even have ambitions for them - I just want them to be happy - and frankly have a job that they enjoy rather than my corporate rat race ! It's just so hard not to feel like you're not supporting them when others seem to breeze through ![/quote]
But you do have ambitions for them which is why you're pushing them to do more at home.

However what you're doing does sound enjoyable.... but are they really enjoying it?

Maybe you need to focus on one thing. So DS is sad about his reading level. Concentrate on that as that is affecting his esteem.

What does he struggle with in regards the reading? Does the text "move" about?

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 12/02/2022 03:55

My little girl was like this in year 1. She is flourishing now in year 6 and is working at greater depth. What turned it round? Harry potter. She just loved it and found a love of reading. This means she reads widely. She has a twin sister and was a summer baby also which were factors in her being behind.

MrsGatsby99 · 12/02/2022 03:34

I haven’t RTFT but sounds like you are doing (almost) everything you can. I would cut down to 15 mins max per day of ‘formal’ learning as little and often is much better imo. You said you were playing games though in the 45 mins which is great. Like PP have said, I think you need more specific detail on areas for development. Let them strengthen their hands and bodies as this really helps writing. Talk about stories and books. Play word games in the car etc… get them to write for a real purpose. But also try to give them space and time just to be.

mathanxiety · 12/02/2022 02:51

Get your children assessed for ADHD/ ADD. Whoever told you it wouldn't affect academic performance knows nothing about factors influencing how children learn.

Also, turn off the class WhatsApp.

DreamTheMoors · 12/02/2022 02:50

STUDY STUDY STUDY !!!!!
GET GOOD GRADES !!!!!
DO BETTER !!!!!*

That’s what I heard my entire life. It made me physically ill. All I concentrated on was grades. I’d lie awake all night at age 11, 12, 13, just worrying about how I was doing in school and what marks I was going to take home.
As a result, I got excellent marks and hated every minute of school and university the rest of my school days.
@followthenoise don’t be like my mum.

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/02/2022 02:30

Whoever told you ADHD doesn't affect them academically is an idiot.

It doesn't affect intelligence but it hugely affects ability to learn.

DC has ADHD and has just got an EHCP which is no mean feat.....demonstrating how much it does affect learning.

Spencer95 · 12/02/2022 02:10

Why do I feel like the worst mother when my now 4 year old is still not using the toilet, I've tried everything from charts, rewards, encouragement, praise but nothing seems to be working, can anyone please help me or give me any tips or ideas that worked for them.

SpidersAreShitheads · 12/02/2022 01:56

Just going to reiterate this point here - if your DC does have ADHD it will absolutely affect their learning. I've never heard a more ridiculous comment (not having a dig at you OP, but the expert who told you this).

By definition ADHD affects executive function including working memory, concentration, focus, attention, motivation and the ability to organise thoughts. So yes, ADHD will absolutely have an impact.

For disclosure, I have ADHD and it's a bloody uphill battle.

And that's without your DC being summer babies etc which has a MASSIVE impact at their very young age. There was a good article I read somewhere about summer babies struggling in primary and being quite a steep curve for them.

Also, in some European countries, formal learning doesn't even start until age 7. I was a school governor and I firmly believe that we've gone way way too far down the rabbit hole. The pressure on our little children and the teachers to get results isn't helpful to anyone.

Rummikub · 12/02/2022 01:34

My dd1 in year 1 couldn’t read or write her name.
She wouldn’t do her homework / read the school books and I never pushed it. We did read other books though and I encouraged her to be curious. We had lots of discussions and look at that etc. I didn’t like the ‘she’s behind’ at such an early age. I wanted her to enjoy reading and learning instead.
She’s now at a top ranked uni and doing well.

It sounds like you’re doing similar and being creative. The school sounds pressured and unhelpful. Take the pressure off your children and yourself.

tcjotm · 12/02/2022 01:34

@Xx1d1xX

I think supporting your kids at home should be focused on learning through play mostly. Particularly at the ages of them just now. I agree with previous posts about 10 mins max on "proper homework" and the other ways you are doing seem fine as well. I would stop myself from worrying about this too much as this will impact on the kids without you realising and could make them worry themselves.

At that age I used to get involved more often in imaginative play like:

Homemade shops where we pulled lots of groceries out the kitchen and labelled them with prices / numbers before buying them from each other. Much more fun than plastic goods. Maybe setting up a picnic area in the room with blankets for after the shop play to eat our "shopping". Lots of fun but also learning without them realising. How much is such and such etc..... For your older one bringing out change money and playing with the money in the context of the "shop".

Post Offices - (this was one of my childhood favourites I then played with my child) Selection of pens, stampers, ink pad, writing paper and stamps if you can. Someone being in charge of the post office counting the pretend letters, stamps etc while the other must write / design their letter and "attend" the play post office to have it stamped and sent away. Even attach real stamps and have a walk to post a letter to you or back to themselves. Again lots of fun and learning at the same time. Especially when the letter falls back through the door from the postman.

Cafes - have all the teddies sat at little pretend tables and work on serving, again with pen and paper. Work together to write down the order for the "Dog, cat etc. If someone wants a milkshake write a M for milkshake or make up menus where they have to tick on the sheet the order you say out loud. Reading without realising.

Play these games at a very basic level of understanding to begin with and build up complexity based on what you think is mostly fun but a little educational. My daughter thrived with this sort of thing but didn't like the sit down homework for too long.

You also can't underestimate the worth of messy play at this age either. Painting letters on large sheets of paper, making banners, names made from clay then baking it.

Find books that interest them along side the school books and read the same ones regularly to them. They will build up knowledge and words from listening to the books regularly without realising. I could literally read the books with my eyes shut from the amount of times we read them but it's now paid off because she now loves to read and is really competent even though for years she would only listen to the stories.

This is only some things that worked for us as a family and you just need to take ideas that suit you as a family and find your own balance but please try not to worry (which is also easier said than done)

Good luck.

I didn’t read this post before mine but yes to all of it.

Kids love real life type games. The world is full of fascinating things grownups do.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/02/2022 01:31

If they’re doing 45 minutes of homework every day, and it’s still not enough. then I’d think it’s the school that’s failing to meet expectations.

tcjotm · 12/02/2022 01:31

Would they be interested in an ongoing project like writing postcards to a pet? Something simple that gets them practising each day but is fun to do and doesn’t feel like school? For example, could make postcards (just cut up paper in a postcard shape) so they could do a picture on one side and then write their letter on the other. Simple, but good practice.

They could also write letters to be actually posted, if someone would write them simple ones back that would be lovely. I wouldn’t suggest that for every day though as you’ll go broke with postage. Pet postcards could be ‘posted’ into a box or stuck up near the dog’s bed or whatever.