Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids not meeting expectations

319 replies

followthenoise · 11/02/2022 19:33

Feeling like we may be failing our DC5 and 7 (yr 1 and yr3) Both have received mid year reports indicating they are below expectations. This is despite us doing around 45 mins of homework /reading with them a day. Both are (early) summer born, and both DH and I are in professional roles with masters level qualifications. We try to foster learning in all activities / aim for a growth mindset, but they both appear to be falling behind. I'm not a pushy parent and would be happy with whatever they want to do, but I am at my wits end on how to support them. Eldest DC likely has ADHD and some sensory issues, but we're told this shouldn't impact her academically particularly , youngest seems fine (apart from academics!). School feedback is that need to write more at home, need to improve - but it seems beyond them when I sit down and do it with them!

OP posts:
boredwithfoodprob · 11/02/2022 21:24

My Year 9 (age 13) doesn’t get 45 mins of homework each day! And he’s at an Outstanding secondary school which gets good results. He’s doing well too.
I have 3 children, the eldest (mentioned above) never met expectations until year 6. He is August born, no SEN but wasn’t especially interested in formal learning. All we encouraged him to do was read, most days. As I said above, he’s doing well now. Not SUPER academic but has been predicted good GCSE grades.
My middle child is Year 6 now and severely dyslexic, she’ll never meet expectations but we encourage her in other ways which are just as important.
My youngest is in Year 2 and is bright, academically - he’s met all expectations since starting school. We also only encourage reading and only do the homework if it interests him.
What I’m saying is all children are different and all you can do is nudge them (don’t push) then in the right direction. They will all get there in the end, given the right resources and positivity. Children age 7 and under (possibly older) shouldn’t be doing homework other than reading in my opinion

LunaTheCat · 11/02/2022 21:23

I think your expectations are high .. from my understanding from 5 to 7 learning is play based.
Your children will be aware that they are not meeting these high expectations. Giving them lots love and spending time is more important- I would cut back on the 45 minutes per day.

downbythewoods · 11/02/2022 21:22

Ridiculous feedback from the school and I'd be really angry. It's this sort of stupid labelling that gives kids a complex and they end up pigeon joking themselves. Don't give it a second thought. Everyone is different and they'll get there in their own time.

Gowithme · 11/02/2022 21:22

I think what you're doing is fantastic - if you were sitting them down and forcing them to fill out work books for 45 minutes every day that would be one thing, but a bit of reading, a game, a bit of writing for a purpose all sounds amazing - if only more parents did that! I'd also recommend you read to them every day as well as them reading to you - there are so many amazing kids books. Take them to the library if you don't already. With all the support you've given them with regard to reading and with the possible ADHD in the eldest I'd be wondering about possible dyslexia - ADHD, ASD, dyslexia, dyspraxia etc are all linked. Mine has ASD and dyspraxia.

OfstedOffred · 11/02/2022 21:20

I would focus on the basics & make any work at home games based etc rather than trying to top up school type worksheets etc. Make sure they get plenty of sleep too.

Kids can always improve so dont lose hope. Progress in things like reading and writing aren't linear, you are often waiting for things to "click". Reading often enables writing. Children can't write well until they can read well. At yellow level your youngest probably hasn't "clicked" yet with reading and got a bit more fluency. It's a bit of a self perpetuating cycle where slow reading speed means they cant manage a longer book etc so read fewer words in a sitting than a child on blue or green.

Are their phonics solid? What they will be doing in class will have moved on and this wont help. Go on phonics play website and do loads of the games on phase 3 & 4 sounds to really get them familiar - its worth paying for the subscription to access everything.

Yes yes to playing games!! Also for maths do oral maths blast games - 5 questions, give them a buzzer/doorbell to answer questions and set a timer going and reward them for beating themselves etc.

BitcherOfBlakiven · 11/02/2022 21:20

ADHD absolutely does impact academic ability Hmm Who came out with that crock of shit?!

christinarossetti19 · 11/02/2022 21:19

My children's primary school (state) used to give reports based on 'end of year' or even 'end of key stage' expectations.

It is hardly surprising that they are not meeting expectations if they haven't been taught what they need to to meet them.

What were their end of academic year reports like last year? If okay, then it's so likely that they will be again this year.

Josette77 · 11/02/2022 21:19

I think you need to relax. No homework and ask for more assistance in school if needed.

viques · 11/02/2022 21:18

OP, good learners are people who believe in their own abilities, enjoy having their achievements recognised, are able to recognise and build on prior success, are willing to tackle new learning, are not afraid to fail.

Your children spend 6 hours a day at school reading, writing, thinking, making connections. Then when they come home they have to do 45 minutes of the same. What are the messages that you are giving them?

You didn’t do well enough at school today.
You didn’t learn anything new.
You didn’t remember anything from yesterday.
You failed.
You now need to spend 45 minutes of your home time to make up the deficiency.

How do you expect your children to become confident learners if those are the messages you are giving them?

MumPops34 · 11/02/2022 21:17

This is not an age you need to be worrying about their academic abilities. My son is due to sit his GCSE’s this year, in primary school he was behind in English and he has been predicted a grade A in English language based on his recent mock exams. I think that the home work you are doing is far too much, reading 5 times a week is sufficient at the age.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 11/02/2022 21:15

They will be being assessed in accordance to year end standards. It is only Feb - don't worry. Our school did this in my kids' reports too and I worried until they told me the stupid bollocks system they were using and including in the pointless report.

Sowhatifiam · 11/02/2022 21:12

We all develop at different rates and peak at different times. I had a boyfriend in a bottom set of 8 in high school who had a Phd by the age of 30. My eldest scraped through his GCSEs (one of the few, I expect, who benefitted from teacher grades in 2020) and could never settle in school. He is now thriving academically, doing what he wanted to do in college, all day every day. My ex husband was hard of hearing and very, very dyslexic in the 70s and didn't get any additional support - he acheived his degree by the age of 35. I am someone the system worked for, got all my exams, went to uni and have never earned very much at all as I worked for years in the voluntary sector and have been teaching for about 10 years now.

Try not to worry. Keep supporting your children but don't overload them. They will be fine.

Hepburn76 · 11/02/2022 21:11

I'm a teaching assistant and can tell you that most kids are not where they currently should be because of the impact of the lockdowns. I am in year 6. Our brightest ones who should be exceeding are only just making expected progress.
I also have three children. One of whom was summer born and a bit behind in everything. They are now year 7 and doing well.
My youngest is year 2 and his writing is appalling. His reading however is awesome but I honestly think his writing has been severely impacted by the lockdowns. He lost most of his reception year. I was a very conscientious home learner with them but I couldn't replicate school. Try not to worry - they all flourish at different times. Read with them every day, five minutes of spelling/writing. That's honestly enough. They'll get there. X

Kitkat151 · 11/02/2022 21:05

45 minutes a day? Think that’s a bit much...my DGD is year 1 ....she’s reads her school book for 5 mins 4 times a week ( Monday to Thursday) ....that’s it.....she gets all her spellings right on a Wednesday so she must be doing ok but school don’t do a report until the end of the year.... maybe just chill a bit with the homework....I’m sure they will be fine

Solasum · 11/02/2022 21:04

Keep a family diary. Writing down something from each day, maybe drawing a picture to go with it, or cutting out something etc. Lovely to look back on, and good writing practice .

1AngelicFruitCake · 11/02/2022 21:02

Just to add so I don’t sound like an absolute dragon! My children are encouraged to play with their Barbies, make crafts, make potions (mess), colour in and have fun. It’s about them being the best they can be. Don’t despair though because they can change a lot through primary.

lovelygreenplants · 11/02/2022 21:02

Try not to worry. I am a professional (lawyer) and eldest DC is under achieving at high school, my husband doesn’t think he will get enough GCSEs to make Sixth Form. This makes me feel awful as I was always a hard worker and loved university for the opportunities it gave my and independence. But I am not my son. I give him a happy, safe and cosy house with a loving family, give his encouragement and remind him to do his homework but can’t really do more than that. I have other children and physically can’t sit over him making him do his homework. He is an anxious boy with little confidence which I don’t think helps his focus at school.
I do think that maybe your school is a bit of a hot house and the children that you are comparing your children with may not represent the norm and may be being hot housed. Do your best, that’s all you can do x

lumpofcomfort · 11/02/2022 21:01

Sorry, I missed your update that it is a private school. They will probably have their own standard of "expected" which may differ from the national expectations in a state school. Is it a selective school , or does it become selective further up? I believe some private schools try to "weed out" pupils that they don't feel will meet rigorous standards so have an up-front conversation with their teachers if this could be the case with your particular school.

I agree that 45 minutes homework per night for a Year 1 pupil is far too much.

pennefabredux · 11/02/2022 21:00

OP, please don't worry or overthink this (especially in comparison to your own childhood achievements).

Your DC live in a loving home with parents who are engaged and care. You are what's necessary to them at this point. What you're doing is fantastic.

I cannot read my DC's printing, much less handwriting. DC isn't interested in school or homework. DC has decided low grades are preferable because they don't want to be "corporate" like me and DH. My DC is very capable, just chooses not to demonstrate it in academic settings.

AND my DC was accepted into the uni of choice and a very, very niche programme. DC is going to slay this. Truly phenomenal at their craft. It took me a while to get comfortable with the fact that their learning style and how they measure academic success isn't what mine was. But they are SLAYING their craft.

So, carry on and support and engage with them and LOVE them. Provide opportunities and experiences. Don't get caught up with competitive parenting/education. Showing them your trust in them, your confidence in them and support will be more worthwhile than worrying.

canary1 · 11/02/2022 21:00

It’s all quite ridiculous that the reports are given in accordance with what they should achieve by end of the year. Why on earth are schools required to do this? Where is basic common sense here?
Summer born kids are disadvantaged, and parents made to feel there’s something wrong because their kid just needs to mature/ the school year needs to actually be completed!
Sounds like you are doing a great job, learning but in a fun way!

Goldilocks99 · 11/02/2022 20:59

Oh and if your child finds yellow band boring please feel free to supplement reading with your own books.

Or he might do what I did (stuck on little red hen series and stole chapter books from the school library)

It didn't do me too much harm. Good degree, teaching qualifications. And a good knowledge of stolen children's literature haha.

Theworldisfullofgs · 11/02/2022 20:58

Try not to worry. My August boy was below expectations in ks1, average in ks2 and on track to do v well at gcse.

Covid has made a difference to ks1 children, they will catch up but it will take time. The key now is not to put them off with too much pressure. Reward effort not achievement and try and build learning into every day life as much as possible.

1AngelicFruitCake · 11/02/2022 20:57

Hi OP
I’m a teacher with children the same age. It’s the usual thing of quality over quantity. If I did shopping list, games etc only with my Year 3 child it wouldn’t be enough. I try shorter bursts e.g. 10/15 mins twice in an evening rather than one longer stint, although for my older child I’m trying to get her working and concentrating for longer.

Typical week
Year 1 child
Reading book/reading activity 4/5 times a week
Read a bedtime story every night
Practise number skills 2/3 times a week
Homework once a week
As well as mental maths questions now and again in the car, writing for fun or a purpose e.g. a letter or writing names of toys etc

Year 3 child
Reads to herself every night 20 minutes (only recently started doing this, used to take turns to read to each other)
Times tables few minutes most days
Quick recap of maths/phonics 2/3 times a week
Homework
Writing if I can manage it, some weeks I just don’t want to push it!

This might seem a lot to some, not much to others but both my children were doing fine but not as well as I think they’re capable of. I also ask their teachers what they think I should focus on but I feel I have a fairly good idea.

Finally, if something isn’t working, try something else. My year 1 child doesn’t like writing sums down or answering them on paper so got her doing it on an App.

SallyWD · 11/02/2022 20:55

Both my children are very bright, I can see that, but throughout primary school they've both failed to meet expectations in many subjects. Now they're approaching the end of primary school they're finally meeting expectations. They certainly weren't in years 1 and 3. Honestly relax. I think 45 mins a night is way too much. We do less than that a week. I think many, many bright kids don't meet expectations during those early years and then catch up around years 5 and 6. You're not failing them in any way, just stop stressing. They're still babies.

lumpofcomfort · 11/02/2022 20:55

I teach Year 2. Kids in this age group (Y1-3) have been badly affected by Covid. Speak to the teachers but it could be that they are behind where expected would be for a normal year because of things they have missed rather than that they aren't capable. Did the report say below expected or working towards?

Swipe left for the next trending thread