Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say post natal depression is limited to women?

314 replies

user7643789 · 11/02/2022 14:47

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-60319568

I do believe men can experience depression at any stage in life but as they cannot give birth they don't experience the hormonal and physical response.

OP posts:
Somethingsnappy · 11/02/2022 18:59

[quote Mamette]@bubblesbubbles11 I wasn’t laughing at your theory just your unique method of backing it up 😂[/quote]
She was very up-front about the fact she wasn't backing it up. She was offering an opinion. No need for the hysterics emoji...

Somethingsnappy · 11/02/2022 18:55

@Mamette

Just the bare-faced cheek of it *@Somethingsnappy*
Why cheeky? There is some evidence to suggest men do go through some hormonal changes during partner's pregnancy and birth. Although I agree this is on a different league to women's, it isn't so extreme as to be laughable.
Mamette · 11/02/2022 18:55

@bubblesbubbles11 I wasn’t laughing at your theory just your unique method of backing it up 😂

bubblesbubbles11 · 11/02/2022 18:42

Goooglebox and others who think my thoughts / theory are "hilarious"

How about this:
ec.europa.eu/research-and-innovation/en/horizon-magazine/new-fathers-may-undergo-hormonal-neural-and-behavioural-changes

And by pasting that I am NOT saying that any hormone related depression in men is the same as PND. Of course it isn't. But I believe it is true that men's hormones are affected and change as part of the process of having a baby (and the extent to which they do depends on how involved or otherwise they are in that process after the obvious at the point of conception).

By saying that I am NOT somehow validating men's depression in this way or devaluing a woman's experience of PND (I had PND myself at least once if not twice but it was never formally recognised, but looking back I am sure that was what it was).

WonderfulYou · 11/02/2022 18:41

Both me and my husband suffered postnatal depression after our longed for daughter was stillborn.

I would actually be very angry if I lost a baby and I was told I’m sad simply because of PND, something that is caused by the massive hormonal changes and affects many women who haven’t lost their baby.

greyinganddecaying · 11/02/2022 18:41

Men can experience MH issues after their partner has a baby. These are most likely to be adjustment disorder, depression, PTSD. They should be taken seriously.

However, men do not experience PND.

cuno · 11/02/2022 18:39

Also the number of threads I've seen where a woman has just given birth and is getting little support from her partner who is acting like a dickhead, and people pipe up with "could he have post natal depression?" Gives me the rage.

cuno · 11/02/2022 18:38

I agree OP. And I feel like the PND that women experience, and the depression that a new father experiences, present very very differently.

Mamette · 11/02/2022 18:36

Just the bare-faced cheek of it @Somethingsnappy

Goooglebox · 11/02/2022 18:35

have not done any searches but i would be surprised if there are not academic studies out there which show that men go through hormonal changes whilst their wife is pregnant, when she gives birth and after the baby is born.

Well, yes. But they're not hormones specific to the experience of having a baby, just common or garden depression related imbalances.

Goooglebox · 11/02/2022 18:33

I think the term should be protected for women. Women are at risk of psychosis following delivery because of what is happening in their body. It is an experience unique to the female body. Suggesting men are in the same boat risks passing over that reality, risking women's lives and leaving science behind. Men are not at this risk because they're not postnatal anymore than they were antenatal.

However it's not a competition and I'm very willing to acknowledge that men can be vulnerable to situational depression at this time - maybe they can create their own word.

Antsgomarching · 11/02/2022 18:31

I think my PND was about how my life changed, i still have it 2years later. I think perhaps we need 2 different description of depression after a baby is born. For me i don’t think it was hormonal necessarily, I just adjusted badly.

As PP perhaps saying reactive depression can occur for men and women and only post natal for women.

Somethingsnappy · 11/02/2022 18:30

@Mamette

I got absolutely battered on a thread about 3 or 4 years ago on this topic.

have not done any searches but i would be surprised if there are not academic studies out there which show that men go through hormonal changes whilst their wife is pregnant, when she gives birth and after the baby is born.

Sorry but this is just hilarious 😂

Not me who posted that, but why hilarious?
FloBot7 · 11/02/2022 18:30

Sadly, in my very short lived career in clinical negligence I dealt with two cases of women who died from PND. They were both healthy women in their 30s with no history of mental illness prior to birth. One jumped from a multi story car park, the other jumped in front of a train. It's a very serious illness that requires it's own research and it's own clinical guidelines. Lumping it in with men will dilute that research to the detriment of women.

littlejalapeno · 11/02/2022 18:29

Yanbu. This has given me the rage.

Somethingsnappy · 11/02/2022 18:28

@user1471517095

Both me and my husband suffered postnatal depression after our longed for daughter was stillborn. I should have told him to snap out of it then? He didn't give birth, he was just moping about lifestyle changes...
Grief after the death of a baby or child is in another league to PND, so different perhaps to this debate.

I'm so so sorry for your loss.

FloBot7 · 11/02/2022 18:26

@WonderfulYou

I am very for support for men who have depression. Huge numbers of men suffer with MH issues and they have a much higher suicide/self harm rate which needs to be changed.

However I think PND should be for those who have given birth.
Dads, adoptive parents etc should just have the term depression.

Adoptive parents do use the term PAD or post adoption depression.
strawberrrycheeesecake · 11/02/2022 18:24

PND refers to the period after a woman gives birth - postnatal. So no a man can't suffer from that.

A man can of course suffer depression as a result of life style changes, but not specifically post natal.

Mamette · 11/02/2022 18:22

I should clarify that no, I do not believe that men can experience PND and I never will believe it, regardless of “studies”, imaginary or otherwise.

AutomaticMoon · 11/02/2022 18:20

@Lockedoorsopen The quote is from here, btw.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6659987/

Mamette · 11/02/2022 18:19

I got absolutely battered on a thread about 3 or 4 years ago on this topic.

have not done any searches but i would be surprised if there are not academic studies out there which show that men go through hormonal changes whilst their wife is pregnant, when she gives birth and after the baby is born.

Sorry but this is just hilarious 😂

AutomaticMoon · 11/02/2022 18:17

@Lockedoorsopen Read the above, it’s from a medical journal. Academia is also trying to normalise and destigmatise pedophilia so don’t know why I’m surprised by this.

WonderfulYou · 11/02/2022 18:17

I am very for support for men who have depression.
Huge numbers of men suffer with MH issues and they have a much higher suicide/self harm rate which needs to be changed.

However I think PND should be for those who have given birth.
Dads, adoptive parents etc should just have the term depression.

AutomaticMoon · 11/02/2022 18:15

F me!

“ The Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) assesses postnatal depression and anxiety in men and women. Because men might be less expressive about their feelings and thus underreport symptoms, the scale uses a lower cutoff score for men.23”

So they have a higher threshold for diagnosis of PPD in women than men?! And men can have post partum even though they weren’t the ones with the gestation in the first place???

Wow.

I’ve seen plenty of questionable science but this takes the biscuit. There’s not accepted definition of PPD in the DSM? Not surprised as the DSM is a farce anyhow. How about ‘after their body parts with the baby’s body’?!?! It seems extremely self explanatory.

WonderfulYou · 11/02/2022 18:14

I think unless you've experienced the intensity of PND it's hard to understand why this situation is so emotive for women. IMO, both men and women can experience reactive depression after the birth of a baby, and it can be incredibly hard - but only the person who has given birth can experience the kind of depression that can be triggered by the physical and hormonal changes you get after you have a baby. It feels completely different to reactive depression (I've had both), and the treatment is, by necessity, different, and as such it needs a different term.

Absolutely this!!

Men can of course get depression after birth but it’s not the same as PND it would be the same if you used a surrogate or adopted a baby - you can get depression from the impact of having a new child but it’s not due to the massive hormonal changes that occur during pregnancy, birth and BF.

PND is such a taboo subject as it is and comparing it to regular depression that anyone can get at any time is going to make new mums feel even more shit as it’s meant to be the happiest time of their lives etc and it takes away the massive impact that having a baby has mentally and physically.