Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say post natal depression is limited to women?

314 replies

user7643789 · 11/02/2022 14:47

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-60319568

I do believe men can experience depression at any stage in life but as they cannot give birth they don't experience the hormonal and physical response.

OP posts:
Ylfa · 15/02/2022 09:43

It is incel type logic 😂

borntobequiet · 15/02/2022 09:15

@C8H10N4O2

But fathers aren't postnatal 🤦🏽‍♀️ they are just depressed

Yes exactly. PND is the specific condition caused by the biological experience of pregnancy and birth and the specific hormonal behaviours in a woman's body. It can develop into pyschosis.

Anything else is not postnatal, its depression associated with a major life event.

Agree with this and the many similar observations. Postnatal depression in women who have recently given birth and situational depression as suffered by people around them who have not gone through the immense hormonal upheaval of pregnancy, birth and its aftermath are categorically different things. I’m astounded that anyone with any knowledge of reproductive biology can argue differently. It seems perverse.
C8H10N4O2 · 15/02/2022 08:11

But fathers aren't postnatal 🤦🏽‍♀️ they are just depressed

Yes exactly. PND is the specific condition caused by the biological experience of pregnancy and birth and the specific hormonal behaviours in a woman's body. It can develop into pyschosis.

Anything else is not postnatal, its depression associated with a major life event.

Sprucewillis · 15/02/2022 01:38

@EmpressCixi

One suggestion is to distinguish the two by calling PND for mothers, maternal postnatal depression (MPD) and for fathers, paternal postnatal depression (PPD).
But fathers aren't postnatal 🤦🏽‍♀️ they are just depressed.
grey12 · 14/02/2022 17:59

Maybe they should call it PBD post baby depression for men Wink it definitely can be a trying time, but they didn't birth anyone 🤷🏻‍♀️

CharacterForming · 14/02/2022 17:52

Not all mothers give birth though. Adoptive mothers and lesbian non-biological mothers may also suffer "new parent depression" but won't present the same very specific medical considerations as a woman who's just given birth.

EmpressCixi · 14/02/2022 17:43

One suggestion is to distinguish the two by calling PND for mothers, maternal postnatal depression (MPD) and for fathers, paternal postnatal depression (PPD).

EmpressCixi · 14/02/2022 17:39

Note PND is called PPD in the United States, but is same thing.

EmpressCixi · 14/02/2022 17:38

Men also suffer post natal depression triggered by hormonal fluctuations. I’m not denying that hormones aren’t one of several causes for PND, but to say this doesn’t happen in men is outdated thinking. Yes the hormone levels are different, but hormone fluctuations caused by pregnancy and fatherhood are ALSO a cause of PND in men:

Postpartum Depression in Men
Jonathan R. Scarff, MD
Innov Clin Neurosci. 2019 May 1; 16(5-6): 11–14.
Published online May-Jun 2019.
PMCID: PMC6659987

“According to a review article by Kim and Swain,11 a father can experience hormonal changes during pregnancy and for several months following the birth of the child. Many of these hormonal changes are thought to assist in the formation of a strong father-child relationship. For example, Kim and Swain described studies linking decreased testosterone levels in new fathers to lower levels of aggression and increased sympathetic responses to a crying baby—effects that, in turn, are thought to strengthen the father’s attachment to the child.
Kim and Swain also described studies linking increased estrogen levels in new fathers to more engaged paternal parenting behaviors.

Additionally, increases in other hormones, such as cortisol, vasopressin, and prolactin, might be associated with more engaged paternal parenting and stronger parent-infant attachment.11

These hormonal changes, however, might predispose the father to experience PPD or exacerbate existing symptoms associated with PPD. For example, low testosterone has been directly linked to symptoms of depression in men,12 whereas low levels of estrogen, prolactin, vasopressin, and/or cortisol in new fathers might cause difficulties in father-infant bonding/attachment, which in turn can contribute to depressed mood in the father.11 Table 2 compares hormonal changes between men and women during prepartum and postpartum periods.11–13”

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6659987/#!po=23.3333

peaceanddove · 13/02/2022 19:46

peachgreen my consultant gynaecologist told me the same thing. Classic PND is triggered by the huge hormonal fluctuations after giving birth. And this PND is often highly resistant to standard anti depressants because of the hormonal element. Ideally, PND should be treated with high dose estrogen but that's still considered contraversial.in the NHS.

But, it's for this reason that NICE guidelines now state that women suffering with peri menopausal depression shouldn't be offered anti depressants as first line treatment - and that HRT should be the first option.

peachgreen · 13/02/2022 17:20

When I had PND I was seen by the leading perinatal mental health team in my country and this is how they explained it: men and women can get situational depression following the birth of a baby - and this can vary in severity, including the very severe - but only the person who gave birth can experience the depression that is triggered by hormonal and physical changes. They have different causes, are assessed differently and, in many cases, require different treatments.

The latter is what I believe should be called PND - but if we extend PND to include men, the latter kind of depression needs a separate term because it is a different thing. Not necessarily better or worse, but different.

EmpressCixi · 13/02/2022 16:42

@peachgreen

They’re both reactive depression. After all PND “triggered by the physical and hormonal changes you get after you have a baby” is still depression in reaction to physical and hormonal changes. Just because it’s not exactly the same, doesn’t mean it shouldn’t have the same diagnosis.

It’s that way with all types of depression....it’s not exactly the same in a man vs a woman or even triggered by/reacting to the same things, but the symptoms are alike enough to be called by same diagnosis. After all a diagnosis of depression is assessed not by looking at the cause/trigger that sets off the depression, but by the cluster of reactive symptoms and their severity.

coconuthead · 13/02/2022 11:28

@peachgreen

I think unless you've experienced the intensity of PND it's hard to understand why this situation is so emotive for women. IMO, both men and women can experience reactive depression after the birth of a baby, and it can be incredibly hard - but only the person who has given birth can experience the kind of depression that can be triggered by the physical and hormonal changes you get after you have a baby. It feels completely different to reactive depression (I've had both), and the treatment is, by necessity, different, and as such it needs a different term.
This ^
SleepingStandingUp · 12/02/2022 20:49

@yellowtwo

Your comments are interesting Sleeping, "His partner moans" "He isn't allowed out", you place blame on the Mother.
I'm not blaming his mother or his partner, I'm merely positing different reasons he might not be going out And there def men who would absolutely be out the house like a shot if his partner said yes dear go and didn't moan at him going out again. Some of those will be justified moans and some won't. Just like some of the "pathetic sad men who don't want to grow up" will be men with genuine mental health concerns who have become isolated, underwent their own trauma at their child's birth, feel overwhelmed and sleepdeprived with the pressure of not letting the helpless baby die etc.
AutomaticMoon · 12/02/2022 19:39

@Dutch1e Tell me about it, it’s too much, garbage masquerading as science is distorting society even further.

Flowersandhearts · 12/02/2022 18:33

I think new Dads can experience an Adjustment Disorder but would be worried that suggesting men can experience PND actually takes away from a condition, which is for the most part is caused by physical factors relating to giving birth (i.e. the hormonal and physical impact of pregnancy and birth) and which often has different features to clinical Depression.

KittenKong · 12/02/2022 18:24

Not PND but something else. Like kids get after all the excitement of Christmas or their birthday.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 12/02/2022 18:16

research has actually found that up to 1 in 10 new fathers become depressed after having a baby

So, when your life suddenly and dramatically changes and you have a whole new raft of responsibilities and difficulties you didn't have before and your most important relationships are irrevocably changed and your identity has undergone a massive adjustment and you're probably short on money and low on sleep and your partner hasn't got a lot of time for you and needs physical and emotional help and you're culturally required to pretend everything is fine, 10% of people get an adjustment disorder? Who would've thought.

Still not PND.

OnlyAFleshWound · 12/02/2022 17:45

A lot of men really can't stand the thought that something, somewhere, might not include them.

Dutch1e · 12/02/2022 17:45

@AutomaticMoon no, I'm sorry I missed the bit about a lower threshold for diagnosis! Ffs, how very #bekind of us all. Most days I could scream, not about just this one thing but the seemingly endless occurrences of misogyny repackaged as open-mindedness.

AutomaticMoon · 12/02/2022 17:39

@Dutch1e I don’t know if you saw where I posted that the threshold for PND in men is lower than in women, it’s actually easier to get diagnosed as a man with it.

AutomaticMoon · 12/02/2022 17:36

@Dutch1e The nhs claims this affects males too 🙄

“Overview - Postnatal depression

Postnatal depression is a type of depression that many parents experience after having a baby.

It's a common problem, affecting more than 1 in every 10 women within a year of giving birth. It can also affect fathers and partners.

It's important to seek help as soon as possible if you think you might be depressed, as your symptoms could last months or get worse and have a significant impact on you, your baby and your family.”

“Myths about postnatal depression

Postnatal depression is often misunderstood and there are many myths surrounding it.

These include:

postnatal depression is less severe than other types of depression – in fact, it's as serious as other types of depression
postnatal depression is entirely caused by hormonal changes – it's actually caused by many different factors
postnatal depression will soon pass – unlike the "baby blues", postnatal depression can persist for months if left untreated and in a minority of cases it can become a long-term problem.
postnatal depression only affects women – research has actually found that up to 1 in 10 new fathers become depressed after having a baby
These factors are equally true of antenatal depression.“

AutomaticMoon · 12/02/2022 17:30

[quote Dutch1e]For anyone falling into the trap of thinking that every conversation about women's health/rights/existence also needs a nod to men, remember this opinion by the woman who has founded charitable foundations for both men's mental health and women's mental health. The different public responses are unsurprising
victimfocusblog.com/2018/01/03/stop-asking-me-what-about-men/[/quote]
Thank you, excellent and sad article on that blog.

Goooglebox · 12/02/2022 17:01

No, I think post natal should be reserved for women because they can actually give birth and have some serious risks as a result.

bluechinavase · 12/02/2022 16:56

I think a new term should be coined - post natal realisation. The realisation that your life is now changed forever and it’s going to be shit for quite a bit of the time. And I think both women and men can suffer that for the same reasons. And yes you could get depressed about it. But PND as we know it could only relate to the woman as she’s gone through the vast hormonal changes and given birth. Wonder what the stats are for women/men who have adopted or become mothers/fathers in a same sex relationship

Swipe left for the next trending thread