Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say post natal depression is limited to women?

314 replies

user7643789 · 11/02/2022 14:47

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-60319568

I do believe men can experience depression at any stage in life but as they cannot give birth they don't experience the hormonal and physical response.

OP posts:
EmpressCixi · 16/02/2022 15:58

@Jedsnewstar

Men really have to take everything from women don’t they. They can have depression after the birth of their child. PND is a specific to women who have given birth!!!!!! How many women is this going to stop getting help. This is dangerous.
Don’t be ridiculous. Increasing awareness means more help, not less.
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 16/02/2022 15:57

Whatever. You're the one who thinks men can get PND, so… 🤣

EmpressCixi · 16/02/2022 15:57

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

You're the one who threw the straw man into the ring by going on about women whose babies have died, Cixi. You spent a great deal of time talking about this group of people whose experiences are irrelevant to the question of whether people, especially male people, who haven't given birth can have PND. If my conjecture as to why you chose to spend so much time talking about women whose babies have died is wrong, then feel free to tell us the real reason you brought them up. Either you're too stupid to understand that women whose babies died are still postpartum, or you had some other motive.
No I did not. I only did 1 post in response to a poster who stated OND had nothing to do with stillbirth, which I corrected by stating the facts, that experiencing stillbirth increases risk of PND 7 fold.
EmpressCixi · 16/02/2022 15:55

@Ereshkigalangcleg

No it isn't because it's a category error. The drive for this is coming from the decentring of female experiences across the board. This is a women's health issue.

Men can't give birth. Men may have depression after their partner has given birth. It is good that studies are looking at that. But they are not postnatal, because they haven't actually given birth, and there needs to be a term for the kind of depression that occurs after a woman has given birth.

“Post natal” literally means “post birth”(of a baby). Just like “post traumatic” means “post trauma”

You are getting confused about language. There is nothing in Post Natal Depression as a diagnosed condition that requires the sufferer to have actually given birth at the birth event in question.

From NHS
www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/post-natal-depression/overview/
“Postnatal depression is a type of depression that many parents experience after having a baby. It's a common problem, affecting more than 1 in every 10 women within a year of giving birth. It can also affect fathers and partners.”

And here we have from the same NHS page a list of the MYTHS which persist on this thread:

“Postnatal depression is often misunderstood and there are many myths surrounding it.

These include:

-postnatal depression is less severe than other types of depression – in fact, it's as serious as other types of depression

-postnatal depression is entirely caused by hormonal changes – it's actually caused by many different factors

-postnatal depression will soon pass – unlike the "baby blues", postnatal depression can persist for months if left untreated and in a minority of cases it can become a long-term problem.

-postnatal depression only affects women – research has actually found that up to 1 in 10 new fathers become depressed after having a baby

-These factors are equally true of antenatal depression.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 16/02/2022 15:54

You're the one who threw the straw man into the ring by going on about women whose babies have died, Cixi. You spent a great deal of time talking about this group of people whose experiences are irrelevant to the question of whether people, especially male people, who haven't given birth can have PND. If my conjecture as to why you chose to spend so much time talking about women whose babies have died is wrong, then feel free to tell us the real reason you brought them up. Either you're too stupid to understand that women whose babies died are still postpartum, or you had some other motive.

Jedsnewstar · 16/02/2022 15:51

Men really have to take everything from women don’t they. They can have depression after the birth of their child. PND is a specific to women who have given birth!!!!!! How many women is this going to stop getting help. This is dangerous.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/02/2022 15:48

I think some posters on here are missing the point completely. I'm not engaging with anyone who doesn't grasp how important it is for this specific health condition in WOMEN ONLY to have a name and be differentiated from other situational depression that men, adoptive parents, family members might have.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/02/2022 15:45

Because it's a term women need. Men, and everyone else, get depression for reasons. Look at that, by all means. It's very important that there is a term for what is an exclusively women's health issue.

EmpressCixi · 16/02/2022 15:44

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

This is the same offensive lineshifting crap we see with other categories, isn't it? "If you say men can't get PND cause they haven't had a baby, you're saying women whose babies died can't have PND, because neither of them have a baby!!!!"

No, women suffering the grief of a stillbirth on top of PND are not any kind of evidence that men can get PND. True, both are depressed, and neither of them currently have a baby they birthed themselves. But they're completely unrelated otherwise.

You’re mis-characterising the discussion completely and building a strawman. The fact you can develop PND following a stillbirth was never presented by me as “evidence” that men can get PND too. I merely stated from the start birth/stillbirth when posting about PND because these are the primary trigger events for PND.

The evidence as to why men can suffer from and can be diagnosed with PND is detailed in the scientific study I posted which also has in its reference list a few dozen additional scientific studies focussed on PND in men. If you took the time to read any of these studies, you wouldn’t be making up such a silly argument. PND in men isn’t theoretical, it’s fact.

MorningStarling · 16/02/2022 15:44

Nobody has the right to define how someone else sees their suffering. You might not think a man can suffer from something, but for the man who believes he is suffering from it, putting a name on it might help him come to terms with it, understand it and get help for it.

I find the idea that some women are possessive over who gets post natal depression bizarre, it's not something that anyone actually wants to have, surely?

Compare it to the scenario of a woman who tells you she's just been raped. Would you tell her that the person who did it is innocent until proven guilty, therefore he's currently innocent because he hasn't been charged yet. If he's innocent, she cannot have been raped by him (in practical terms, if he is innocent of raping her then she hasn't been raped by him).

Of course you wouldn't, you'd offer her support and get her help. Denying her claim is true would mean calling her a liar. She believes she has been raped, and the support she gets will be based on that assumption.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/02/2022 15:43

No it isn't because it's a category error. The drive for this is coming from the decentring of female experiences across the board. This is a women's health issue.

Men can't give birth. Men may have depression after their partner has given birth. It is good that studies are looking at that. But they are not postnatal, because they haven't actually given birth, and there needs to be a term for the kind of depression that occurs after a woman has given birth.

EmpressCixi · 16/02/2022 15:35

@Ereshkigalangcleg

And "numerous professionals in the field" write all sorts of reality denying nonsense which decentres female bodies and experiences.
No one is saying anything that “decentres female bodies and experiences” as we all agree that PND affects women. The issue is the obstinate denial of men’s bodies and experiences by women claiming that men cannot also experience PND when the scientific evidence is blatantly there that they can and do also experience PND.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/02/2022 00:20

This is the same offensive lineshifting crap we see with other categories, isn't it? "If you say men can't get PND cause they haven't had a baby, you're saying women whose babies died can't have PND, because neither of them have a baby!!!!"

Yes, it is the same logic.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 16/02/2022 00:12

This is the same offensive lineshifting crap we see with other categories, isn't it? "If you say men can't get PND cause they haven't had a baby, you're saying women whose babies died can't have PND, because neither of them have a baby!!!!"

No, women suffering the grief of a stillbirth on top of PND are not any kind of evidence that men can get PND. True, both are depressed, and neither of them currently have a baby they birthed themselves. But they're completely unrelated otherwise.

RobertaFirmino · 15/02/2022 21:30

Isn't most depression associated with hormonal changes?

No. Depression can also be:
Genetic/hereditary
Reactive/situational
Biochemical (serotonin, dopamine and norepinephrine are not hormones, they are neurotransmitters)
Seasonal

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 15/02/2022 21:24

I don't think anyone has suggested that a woman whose baby has died is ineligible for a PND diagnosis Hmm It's possible that diagnosis could be complicated, because there's grief in the equation, but the conversation isn't going to be a matter of "no baby, no PND" is it??

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 21:00

And "numerous professionals in the field" write all sorts of reality denying nonsense which decentres female bodies and experiences.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 20:59

Men haven't given birth, whatever hormones are driving their depression. Isn't most depression associated with hormonal changes? This is specifically a form of depression many new mothers have of which a large component is associated with hormonal changes around pregnancy and birth.

Sprucewillis · 15/02/2022 20:36

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Sprucewillis · 15/02/2022 20:36

Paternal depression would be a more accurate term for it.

EmpressCixi · 15/02/2022 20:24

We will just have to agree to disagree. The fact that numerous professionals in the field are writing dozens of research papers on PND in men, tells me MN has quite a talent for denial by claiming men can’t get PND. PND in men is a documented and recognised medical condition.

You can be the proverbial ostrich, or actually read the research. PND in men isn’t caused by serotonin levels or other claptrap. It can also be triggered by hormones such as estrogen, testosterone, oxytocin, progesterone- all the same hormones triggering some cases of PND in women.

And yes, you can get PND following a still birth as well as a live birth or even an adopted birth. You don’t have to have given birth to a live baby to get PND. In fact, a woman who has a still birth is 7x more likely to develop PND than a woman who has a live birth.

There is so much out-dated information on this thread, I encourage you all to read the more recent literature out there.

Sprucewillis · 15/02/2022 19:44

EmpressCixi
Well, what else do you call it when a man comes down with depression due to the birth or stillbirth of his child? Just plain old depression?

No this is grief and depression.

If so, then why isn’t it also plain old depression when a woman comes down with depression due to the birth or stillbirth of her child?
*
This is grief and depression, also sometimes postnatal depression. A condition that follows giving birth (postnatal). 1 in 10 women suffer from this condition in the year following birth. This statistic is higher in bereaved mothers.*

It seems to me that if we have a special name for depression caused by the birth or stillbirth of a parent’s child, we should use it equally for mothers and fathers.

Postnatal does not refer to the death of a child. It is a condition suffered by some women following the birth of their baby. It can contribute to PND in a woman. Men by their physicality can not be in a post natal state of being. They have not gestated, given birth too or breastfed a baby.

Or we just drop the “post natal” and it’s all plain old depression which can be caused by suicide, death, job loss, relationship breakup, financial issues, nothing, terminal illness, life changing injury, head injury, etc etc etc.

Again this is depression - circumstantial or situational. There is no need to drop post natal from the experience suffered by some women. That would be cancellation of a well documented and recognised medical condition.

Meatshake · 15/02/2022 11:53

I agree the language isnt right, calling male depression after the birth of a baby "post-natal depression" ignores the "birth injury" aspect of PND.

I agree that there is a type of depression in males triggered by birth, it's just not post natal depression. The PND I experienced was so much worse than my garden variety depression, I can't even begin to describe it. The hormones made it so all consuming, three years on and I'm only just really getting to a place where I'm fully recovered.

MayMorris · 15/02/2022 09:59

[quote EmpressCixi]Men also suffer post natal depression triggered by hormonal fluctuations. I’m not denying that hormones aren’t one of several causes for PND, but to say this doesn’t happen in men is outdated thinking. Yes the hormone levels are different, but hormone fluctuations caused by pregnancy and fatherhood are ALSO a cause of PND in men:

Postpartum Depression in Men
Jonathan R. Scarff, MD
Innov Clin Neurosci. 2019 May 1; 16(5-6): 11–14.
Published online May-Jun 2019.
PMCID: PMC6659987

“According to a review article by Kim and Swain,11 a father can experience hormonal changes during pregnancy and for several months following the birth of the child. Many of these hormonal changes are thought to assist in the formation of a strong father-child relationship. For example, Kim and Swain described studies linking decreased testosterone levels in new fathers to lower levels of aggression and increased sympathetic responses to a crying baby—effects that, in turn, are thought to strengthen the father’s attachment to the child.
Kim and Swain also described studies linking increased estrogen levels in new fathers to more engaged paternal parenting behaviors.

Additionally, increases in other hormones, such as cortisol, vasopressin, and prolactin, might be associated with more engaged paternal parenting and stronger parent-infant attachment.11

These hormonal changes, however, might predispose the father to experience PPD or exacerbate existing symptoms associated with PPD. For example, low testosterone has been directly linked to symptoms of depression in men,12 whereas low levels of estrogen, prolactin, vasopressin, and/or cortisol in new fathers might cause difficulties in father-infant bonding/attachment, which in turn can contribute to depressed mood in the father.11 Table 2 compares hormonal changes between men and women during prepartum and postpartum periods.11–13”

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6659987/#!po=23.3333[/quote]
This is fine and good to see research.
BUT
they are still not post natul or post partum….they are not pregnant and it is not progesterone r eastrogen that is causing this

This condition in men needs a clearly identifying different name - without that it will be impossible to highlight it, understand is prevalence and understand how to treat.

That is why PND was used to describe this type of depression in women- to allow us to name it, track it, treat it for the specific cause it has
It is not PND

MayMorris · 15/02/2022 09:53

@EmpressCixi

Well, what else do you call it when a man comes down with depression due to the birth or stillbirth of his child? Just plain old depression? If so, then why isn’t it also plain old depression when a woman comes down with depression due to the birth or stillbirth of her child?

It seems to me that if we have a special name for depression caused by the birth or stillbirth of a parent’s child, we should use it equally for mothers and fathers. Or we just drop the “post natal” and it’s all plain old depression which can be caused by suicide, death, job loss, relationship breakup, financial issues, nothing, terminal illness, life changing injury, head injury, etc etc etc.

🤦‍♀️Becuase PND is relate to hormone changes immediately after birth and the impact on the brain due to that impacting serotonin Other depression is caused by changes to the serotonin levels in the brain caused by other things such as stress, lack of sleep, sleep apnea, , shock, poor self esteeem, grief etc etc - any number of things Anyone can get depression at any time- including unsurprising new fathers. But the sort of depression caused by progesterone and estrogen changes are restricted to women: PND, pre menstruaters tension and peri menopausal anxiety and depression, I had both PND and other bouts of depression unconnected to anything hormonally. The sysmtoms don’t change necessarily- the term PND allows us to serrated out a class of people who have depression for a very specific reason, and identify a class of people who are at a higher risk of development of depression . This allows health visitors and doctors to monitor transient “ baby blues” and intervene early if it evolves into PND, or god forbid post partum psychosis Men cannot get PND in terms of how that word was originally intended . It’s another example of those that are in control of the language control the power.
Swipe left for the next trending thread