Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say post natal depression is limited to women?

314 replies

user7643789 · 11/02/2022 14:47

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-60319568

I do believe men can experience depression at any stage in life but as they cannot give birth they don't experience the hormonal and physical response.

OP posts:
bubblesbubbles11 · 11/02/2022 16:00

i have not done any searches but i would be surprised if there are not academic studies out there which show that men go through hormonal changes whilst their wife is pregnant, when she gives birth and after the baby is born.
Not all men will do I guess because some men are particularly detached from some or all of the process but those who are not will have their own hormones affected in some way I am guessing, whether that is through anxiety as a result of the pregnancy or imminent new life, changes in their sex life due the pregnancy and birth etc .
Of course the hormone changes will be very different compared with those in a woman's body when she is growing a new person, but nonetheless, any man who is in some way engaged in the process after conception will have hormonal changes.

I say this as a woman and a mother myself.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 11/02/2022 15:49

Another possibly salient point -- the article headline may say 'postnatal depression in men' but that might just be clumsy phrasing, or needing to keep wordcount down.

Nowhere in the article does anyone apply the term 'postnatal depression' directly to men. The wording is things like mental health, feelings of depression, depression after the birth of a child, depression in the postnatal period.

So just because the BBC News calls it PND once doesn't mean that any eventual screening programme for mental health in new fathers will be called PND.

So this may actually be a storm in a teacup.

ErrolTheDragon · 11/02/2022 15:44

Well, what else do you call it when a man comes down with depression due to the birth or stillbirth of his child?

New/early parental depression for birth. Applicable to any parent for depression not related to having actually given birth. Stillbirth might be something like infant bereavement depression. More accurate and specific.

Canaloha · 11/02/2022 15:43

@EmpressCixi

Well, what else do you call it when a man comes down with depression due to the birth or stillbirth of his child? Just plain old depression? If so, then why isn’t it also plain old depression when a woman comes down with depression due to the birth or stillbirth of her child?

It seems to me that if we have a special name for depression caused by the birth or stillbirth of a parent’s child, we should use it equally for mothers and fathers. Or we just drop the “post natal” and it’s all plain old depression which can be caused by suicide, death, job loss, relationship breakup, financial issues, nothing, terminal illness, life changing injury, head injury, etc etc etc.

Postnatal depression isn't just a new mum with depression though, extremely ignorant. Of course men can struggle after the birth of a child, but I agree it isn't PND and don't see the value in labelling it as such. Surely the support that is beneficial to a man differs to that which is beneficial to a new mother.
Hoardasurass · 11/02/2022 15:39

Having had both PND and situational depression I can assure you that they are completely different. What men are suffering from is situational depression if they want to call it something different to help raise awareness of mens vulnerability to it after becoming a dad fine but not PND as that just confuses the matter and causes these sorts of arguments and noone is helped but plenty of people will be harmed(mostly women) by conflating them and minimizing actual PND. This will also prevent men from paying attention to it especially since many people will just assume that this is more woke bs like pregnant "men"

user7643789 · 11/02/2022 15:37

If men can experience PND why are we limiting it to just them? Can grandmas experience it? Friends of a child whose just been born? Women take on the weight of childcare.

What about when the father isn't involved?

OP posts:
user1478172746 · 11/02/2022 15:32

Men are scared of fundamental change in their life, of responsibility, of "growing up". Women are influenced by hormones, maybe traumatic birth plus all the former. Does not feel fair or genuine to mix it all up.

Ylfa · 11/02/2022 15:32

www.reddit.com/r/AskPsychiatry/

peachgreen · 11/02/2022 15:32

@sparepantsandtoothbrush I don't mind if the term is changed, and we call the reactive depression experienced by parents in the wake of having a child "post natal depression" and come up with something new for the one experienced by the birthing mother, but I still think they need to have separate terms as they're not the same thing and require different treatment.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 11/02/2022 15:31

Men don't get postnatal depression. This is a ridiculous conversation.

Ylfa · 11/02/2022 15:30

Why do you think it’s a myth? Ask any psychiatrist.

Midlifemusings · 11/02/2022 15:30

@Ohsugarhoneyicetea

Of course men cannot experience post natal depression. It is specifically related to the changes (hormone, thyroid and immune system fluctuations and dysregulation) your body undergo through gestation, birth and lactation. All things men cannot do. New parent depression, for sure, both and men and women experience that.
Where are you taking this definition of PND from - that all PND is specifically related to hormonal and physical effects of pregnancy, birth and lactation?

That isn't the definition used by the medical community who is assessing, diagnosing, and treating it.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 11/02/2022 15:29

Baby loss, miscarriage, stillbirth grief again both men and women experience that. But for the female the PND can be layered on top of the other grief, depression, adjustment crisis.

EmpressCixi · 11/02/2022 15:28

men don’t currently get pregnant or give birth or become as seriously unwell as new mothers.

Men don’t currently get pregnant or give birth, but they do in fact become as seriously unwell as new mothers. And I’d argue potential in greater numbers, have you even seen the statistics on suicide and family homicides? Majority men and majority fathers.

The myth that it’s only mothers that get psychologically unwell is why more new fathers and more child victims of them continue to die.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 11/02/2022 15:26

Of course men cannot experience post natal depression. It is specifically related to the changes (hormone, thyroid and immune system fluctuations and dysregulation) your body undergo through gestation, birth and lactation. All things men cannot do. New parent depression, for sure, both and men and women experience that.

Hapoydayz · 11/02/2022 15:25

Men can have depression after becoming a father but no they can't have PND they have had no hormone or bodily change and haven't given birth.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 11/02/2022 15:25

@peachgreen

I think unless you've experienced the intensity of PND it's hard to understand why this situation is so emotive for women. IMO, both men and women can experience reactive depression after the birth of a baby, and it can be incredibly hard - but only the person who has given birth can experience the kind of depression that can be triggered by the physical and hormonal changes you get after you have a baby. It feels completely different to reactive depression (I've had both), and the treatment is, by necessity, different, and as such it needs a different term.
I've had PND twice. Once after the birth of my DD and once after a still birth. Yes it's emotive and probably the two worst times of my life, but the fact still stands than post natal means "after birth" and can affect men too
Ylfa · 11/02/2022 15:23

After a woman has given birth she is vulnerable to more severe mental illnesses than other adults in the general population. Not just postnatal depression or psychosis, but a whole range of psychiatric conditions. These are associated with pregnancy and birth, men don’t currently get pregnant or give birth or become as seriously unwell as new mothers.

peachgreen · 11/02/2022 15:22

I think unless you've experienced the intensity of PND it's hard to understand why this situation is so emotive for women. IMO, both men and women can experience reactive depression after the birth of a baby, and it can be incredibly hard - but only the person who has given birth can experience the kind of depression that can be triggered by the physical and hormonal changes you get after you have a baby. It feels completely different to reactive depression (I've had both), and the treatment is, by necessity, different, and as such it needs a different term.

EmpressCixi · 11/02/2022 15:20

@Naunet
Yes because women deserve ZERO acknowledgement of the hormone changes and physical effects of giving birth. We’re never allowed anything away from men 🙄

So, excluding fathers is how we acknowledge the hormones and physical changes to mothers? I do not understand this mentality.

To my mind actually, the existence of post natal depression as a “special” depression is a direct result of the early days of psychiatry when all psychiatric illness in women was linked back to their uterus, and thus women were also considered the weaker sex mentally than men because men do not have a irksome uterus to drive them mad.

That’s the history behind why we even have PND called PND instead of just falling under “depression” umbrella which affects men and women both for a long list of causes and reasons.

Clinging on to it, is clinging on to the exclusivity of PND for women is clinging to a misogynistic label and thinking that it means something good. It doesn’t. We know men can get post birth/still birth depression (literally post natal depression). So why pretend we are still the weaker sex and only we can get this illness? Unless you believe the misogyny that invented it as a woman only affliction in the first place, it makes no sense at all.

Midlifemusings · 11/02/2022 15:20

What do you call it for a woman who adopts a new born. They are a mother but haven't gone through the hormonal or physical experience either.

The experience of having a new born, sleep deprivation, stress of the responsibility of being a new parent, life changes etc can lead to depression at higher rates than at other times for any parent - that is post natal depression.

For how long after birth would a mother's depression still be considered to be hormonally driven by the birth? When does it also change to 'reactive'?

I believe the research shows that there is a subtype of post partum depression that is hormone sensitive and therefore only experienced by birth mothers but that there are many other subtypes of PPD that mothers and fathers experience that do not have the hormonal factors.

Theunamedcat · 11/02/2022 15:17

Fucks sakes face facts a LOT of the care and responsibilities of raising a child in the early days is on the woman they literally grow a whole human being ideally breastfeeding said human being waking up in the night to feed and change the human being and are basically ontap food and care providers yes men can get depressed but let's not pretend that the vast majority are caring 24/7 for a baby and the physical effects of that are going to exacerbate any hormonal changes which can lead to depression

NightmareSlashDelightful · 11/02/2022 15:16

Yes because women deserve ZERO acknowledgement of the hormone changes and physical effects of giving birth. We’re never allowed anything away from men

If a woman experiences PND symptoms and goes to a doctor after giving birth, the fact that they have physically recently given birth will be taken into account and factored into diagnosis and treatment. That's the acknowledgement.

Readytogogogo · 11/02/2022 15:12

Post natal depression is specific to the mother who gives birth. If the father develops depression subsequently, surely that is a reactive depression. Not the same thing at all.

1940s · 11/02/2022 15:12

@Theunamedcat

Post natal depression is different though I've been depressed on and off throughout my entire life post natal depression was way WAY different for me and yes men can get depressed because they have had a baby but why not call it by a different name? Why shove the two together? It's like calling it genital cancer when men and women have different genitals
Why would you suggest for a name?
Swipe left for the next trending thread