Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say post natal depression is limited to women?

314 replies

user7643789 · 11/02/2022 14:47

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-60319568

I do believe men can experience depression at any stage in life but as they cannot give birth they don't experience the hormonal and physical response.

OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 11/02/2022 17:26

@kierenthecommunity

Men are scared of fundamental change in their life, of responsibility, of "growing up". Women are influenced by hormones, maybe traumatic birth plus all the former. Does not feel fair or genuine to mix it all up

I got quite severe depression after adopting. As a mother where there were no hormones involved, was it in fact just fear of growing up and being responsible for me? Would have saved me a course of Sertraline, counselling and time off work if I’d just realised this

Do you feel like it diminishes your suffering if people point out you didn't have PND? I'd be on your side if you said that your experience was deeply painful, very difficult, needed to be taken seriously, and you needed fast and effective treatment for your sake and that of your child. But it wasn't PND. There's no point having a name for a condition if it's not going to have boundaries defining what's within the criteria and what's not, and the boundary that makes practical sense is that it's a diagnosis for people who experience a constellation of mental health symptoms, including low mood, having recently given birth. Even if sometimes those people might be experiencing the same things you did for the same reasons you did, and the actual birthgiving wasn't a major factor, it makes sense for them to be included in that category, and you not, because we don't yet have the ability to definitively tease out the exact reasons for a particular woman's PND but we need to recognise that having recently given birth is a particular state that is commonly associated with certain problems.
Soundwave · 11/02/2022 17:10

I actually think it's pretty ignorant to claim that PND is just down to hormones. As someone who suffered from PND and anxiety, it was not brought on simply by my hormones. It was brought on by a horrendous delivery and emergency csection during which my child almost died. It was brought on by my entire life changing completely overnight with no adequate preparation for it. It was brought on by my child having CMPA and silent reflux and crying for 8 hours a day. Everyday. It was brought on my absolutely no one helping or supporting me whatsoever, other than DH who was also struggling with all of the shit I'd gone through too. And had to go to work.

But yeh, blame the hormones. Hmm

mummykel16 · 11/02/2022 17:09

@kierenthecommunity

Men are scared of fundamental change in their life, of responsibility, of "growing up". Women are influenced by hormones, maybe traumatic birth plus all the former. Does not feel fair or genuine to mix it all up

I got quite severe depression after adopting. As a mother where there were no hormones involved, was it in fact just fear of growing up and being responsible for me? Would have saved me a course of Sertraline, counselling and time off work if I’d just realised this

Yes
kierenthecommunity · 11/02/2022 17:07

Men are scared of fundamental change in their life, of responsibility, of "growing up". Women are influenced by hormones, maybe traumatic birth plus all the former. Does not feel fair or genuine to mix it all up

I got quite severe depression after adopting. As a mother where there were no hormones involved, was it in fact just fear of growing up and being responsible for me? Would have saved me a course of Sertraline, counselling and time off work if I’d just realised this

Elsiebear90 · 11/02/2022 17:06

I can’t believe we’re even discussing this, of course men cannot have post natal depression because they can’t give birth. If they’re depressed because their lifestyle and routine etc has changed due to having a baby that is very different to being depressed because of hormonal changes associated with giving birth.

Canaloha · 11/02/2022 16:58

Who gives a toss what it's called or caused by, depression is depression and should be treated as so

Except it isn't, there are separate considerations for a woman with PND, therefore the 'label' is important.

Canaloha · 11/02/2022 16:57

@bubblesbubbles11

Canaloha so sorry to disappoint.

Last time I looked I was not on commission to provide mumsnet readers with links?
and my post clearly starts "i have not done any searches"....

you are welcome to discount my thoughts as wrong if you want to - that is your choice

Well yes I will because you've assumed there's studies and crafted a post around something that isnt the case, seems odd. And no thank goodness you're not on commission!
HopeYourHighHorseBucks · 11/02/2022 16:57

Are you saying a woman with depression is more important than a man with depression? Who gives a toss what it's called or caused by, depression is depression and should be treated as so

Absolutely yes.

CharacterForming · 11/02/2022 16:55

There's a case for a term of "new parent depression" or "situational PND" which can be suffered by fathers and adoptive mothers, distinct from standard or perhaps "physiological" PND which only birth mothers undergo.

Of course birth mothers may also suffer situational depression.

SemperIdem · 11/02/2022 16:49

Yanbu -

Men cannot have PND. Cannot believe we’re having to discuss it. Is there nothing women are allowed to not include men in?

mummykel16 · 11/02/2022 16:44

@sparepantsandtoothbrush

Yes because women deserve ZERO acknowledgement of the hormone changes and physical effects of giving birth. We’re never allowed anything away from men

Are you saying a woman with depression is more important than a man with depression? Who gives a toss what it's called or caused by, depression is depression and should be treated as so

At that time, yes
FloBot7 · 11/02/2022 16:44

@Hoardasurass

Having had both PND and situational depression I can assure you that they are completely different. What men are suffering from is situational depression if they want to call it something different to help raise awareness of mens vulnerability to it after becoming a dad fine but not PND as that just confuses the matter and causes these sorts of arguments and noone is helped but plenty of people will be harmed(mostly women) by conflating them and minimizing actual PND. This will also prevent men from paying attention to it especially since many people will just assume that this is more woke bs like pregnant "men"
You've put it better than I could. I don't deny that men can get depressed by the situation but it's very different to the hormonal and physical changes that can lead to PND. It shouldn't be classed as the same illness.
cherrysthename · 11/02/2022 16:44

YANBU.

AssignedNorthern · 11/02/2022 16:44

@peachgreen

I think unless you've experienced the intensity of PND it's hard to understand why this situation is so emotive for women. IMO, both men and women can experience reactive depression after the birth of a baby, and it can be incredibly hard - but only the person who has given birth can experience the kind of depression that can be triggered by the physical and hormonal changes you get after you have a baby. It feels completely different to reactive depression (I've had both), and the treatment is, by necessity, different, and as such it needs a different term.
Exactly this
Lockedoorsopen · 11/02/2022 16:41

@NightmareSlashDelightful

Another possibly salient point -- the article headline may say 'postnatal depression in men' but that might just be clumsy phrasing, or needing to keep wordcount down.

Nowhere in the article does anyone apply the term 'postnatal depression' directly to men. The wording is things like mental health, feelings of depression, depression after the birth of a child, depression in the postnatal period.

So just because the BBC News calls it PND once doesn't mean that any eventual screening programme for mental health in new fathers will be called PND.

So this may actually be a storm in a teacup.

I was on a group last night that had scores of women stating their husbands had PND and been officially diagnosed.

There are also many pages on twitter devoted to PND in men.

There is also an interesting article on Channel 5 twitter account where a dad is talking about his PND. Apparently after a while he started to get jealous and resent full of his new baby. PND robbed him of that special time with her...

This is really coming people. And I can see many many women being left to carry the burden of a new baby because the men have developed PND.

Thewindwhispers · 11/02/2022 16:40

Yanbu. Women obviously go through massive post-childbirth physical changes, which can affect the brain in different ways, including post-natal psychosis, post-natal anxiety, and post-natal depression. These are very serious conditions with physical causes. Men do not give birth and if they get clinically depressed after becoming a father that is a completed different (and far less serious, frankly) condition.

Insisting that both men and women get PND is just more erasure of women, and of women’s issues, and minimises the very serious physical trauma that happens to a woman during childbirth.

As my friend’s husband said an hour after she’d given birth: “You’re not the only one who’s tired, I am too.” 😐 🙄🤨🤬

mummykel16 · 11/02/2022 16:40

@user7643789

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-60319568

I do believe men can experience depression at any stage in life but as they cannot give birth they don't experience the hormonal and physical response.

True
bubblesbubbles11 · 11/02/2022 16:32

Oh, and i agree that only women can get postnatal depression.

Lockedoorsopen · 11/02/2022 16:30

I seen a page on facebook explode last night because of this topic.

MIND (UK leading charity in mental health) states

Doctors can only formally diagnose you with a perinatal mental health problem if you are pregnant or have given birth to a child in the past year

But if your partner is pregnant or recently gave birth, you may also experience mental health problems during this time. For example, some studies show that partners can experience depression or anxiety around the time of their child's birth

Now I know males mental health is real - especially after the birth of a child but it should be conflated just because it happens around the birth of a baby.

Women already struggle to admit and talk about PND. Its hounded women since time began. Women were routinely put in asylums, locked away, called looney, hysterical, mental, unloving, unnatural because they were suffering PND. Its very fucking hard to tell some one you don't love your brand new, pink and gorgeous smelling baby because you are unwell. The stigma for women around PND is still very real.

The services women have set up for this is dreadful. Once you get to the end of a very long waiting list, you might get offered a text counselling session with a councillor on line.

Which is fucking incredible actually because these women are seriously unwell and it can have life long effects for the new babys development.

Yet now men have PND too - well this new. Are we now going to have to share these already shite services with men too - how far down the list will that take women?

The NHS website doesnt even suggest childbirth is a trigger for PND. Not sure which melon thought they would forget to add that trigger. You know as PND comes after having a baby

The strain the female body goes under in labour is traumatic to the body and also the mental health of the mother. A massive drop in two vital hormones which can take SIX months to get back to normal levels. 1in 4 women develop anaemia through rapid blood loss in birth. Add in birth trauma or the mum being treated like shite by the midwives and doctors.

The body and the mind is exhausted physically and mentally because of pregnancy and child birth. This is PND

Men do not suffer PND, they suffer adjustment disorder, depression, anxiety, PTSD. it just so it happens at the same time a new baby has come along - but that doesnt mean its PND

We need to be really really careful about making PND inclusive of men because it waters down the shit services women already receive. It diminishes the traumatic event that some women labours are - events that women still get told to stop shouting' or "just get on with it", still laughed at ( The new TV program 'This is gonna hurt')

So no, im not going to sit up and take notice because all these men are now suddenly appearing with PND, I mean when was the last time women were talked about on the News about PND?

This thread highlights the internalised misogyny that so many women have towards themselves.

Yes we can claim PND as women only and triggered by giving birth and we should be demanding better services to help women with PND.

Yet we can also agree that men and partners can suffer depression around the time of the birth.

We are not in the same boat and it needs addressing separately.

Ylfa · 11/02/2022 16:28

www.rcpsych.ac.uk/mental-health/treatments-and-wellbeing/what-are-perinatal-mental-health-services some info about maternal mental health

HopeYourHighHorseBucks · 11/02/2022 16:22

Yes I know postpartum psychosis and PND are not the same but the Hormonal changes through pregnancy can lead to both and it is really not the same and shouldn't be viewed as the same as what fathers can potentially go through.

HopeYourHighHorseBucks · 11/02/2022 16:19

Men can get depression of course, after their wife/GF give birth, they can get it after losing their jobs, health declines, number of reasons.

Women however can only get postnatal depression. Nothing to do with women being the weaker sex but there is absolutely no need to lump men in with it, they might go through some Hormonal when parenting but are we really going to pretend it's the same? Ffs. A relative of mine suffered terrible postpartum psychosis, thought creatures were trying to steal her baby and her family were in on it.

They can create their own if their like but it's hard enough to get support as a struggling new mum with PND let alone if men jumped on it. Mind you, with the way society works it might get taken a bit more seriously if men complained about it too. Sad really.

bubblesbubbles11 · 11/02/2022 16:19

Canaloha
so sorry to disappoint.

Last time I looked I was not on commission to provide mumsnet readers with links?
and my post clearly starts "i have not done any searches"....

you are welcome to discount my thoughts as wrong if you want to - that is your choice

Theunamedcat · 11/02/2022 16:10

[quote EmpressCixi]@Naunet
Yes because women deserve ZERO acknowledgement of the hormone changes and physical effects of giving birth. We’re never allowed anything away from men 🙄

So, excluding fathers is how we acknowledge the hormones and physical changes to mothers? I do not understand this mentality.

To my mind actually, the existence of post natal depression as a “special” depression is a direct result of the early days of psychiatry when all psychiatric illness in women was linked back to their uterus, and thus women were also considered the weaker sex mentally than men because men do not have a irksome uterus to drive them mad.

That’s the history behind why we even have PND called PND instead of just falling under “depression” umbrella which affects men and women both for a long list of causes and reasons.

Clinging on to it, is clinging on to the exclusivity of PND for women is clinging to a misogynistic label and thinking that it means something good. It doesn’t. We know men can get post birth/still birth depression (literally post natal depression). So why pretend we are still the weaker sex and only we can get this illness? Unless you believe the misogyny that invented it as a woman only affliction in the first place, it makes no sense at all.[/quote]
Really? Excluding father's? You think women are misogynistic for "gatekeeping" PND? so next will be cervical cancer effects men just as much as women as does ovarian cancer a hysterectomy will effect men more than women because why? He happens to be around? He might be forced to help a bit?

Excuse me while I hold the door to all these people erasing women

Canaloha · 11/02/2022 16:07

@bubblesbubbles11

i have not done any searches but i would be surprised if there are not academic studies out there which show that men go through hormonal changes whilst their wife is pregnant, when she gives birth and after the baby is born. Not all men will do I guess because some men are particularly detached from some or all of the process but those who are not will have their own hormones affected in some way I am guessing, whether that is through anxiety as a result of the pregnancy or imminent new life, changes in their sex life due the pregnancy and birth etc . Of course the hormone changes will be very different compared with those in a woman's body when she is growing a new person, but nonetheless, any man who is in some way engaged in the process after conception will have hormonal changes.

I say this as a woman and a mother myself.

So you'd be surprised it there weren't any, but haven't linked any- useful input!