Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if schools are just a bit crap at the moment (not teacher bashing)

144 replies

Terribleenergy · 11/02/2022 13:34

Added that caveat as am definitely not being deliberately provocative - it’s more to do with funding and class sizes being too big, and just too much crap than individual teachers. I’m a teacher myself and I don’t know that I’m offering the best ‘diet’ for my students - I do my best but I’m limited I suppose.

It’s similar with the NHS and dentists and so on: just seems services aren’t running brilliantly.

So we’ve bitten the bullet and paid for private healthcare and I’m just wondering if I should do the same for private education when the time comes (dc still little) or if people think there will be an improvement in years to come? I can’t see it myself but interested in thoughts and predictions.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CheesecakeAddict · 17/02/2022 19:29

@OnceuponaRainbow18 tbf we had a neighbour's 12ft trampoline blow over the wall and into the playground, almost taking out a group of year 8s today. We also have the issue of buses and trains not running so some staff can't get into work. They won't have made the decision lightly

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 17/02/2022 15:39

My kids is closing tomo cause the predicted wind!

LollyLol · 17/02/2022 15:35

@AllisoninWunderland yes, I think I'm lucky and the schools in my area are all fairly great. However we are a really poorly funded school, and HT decided to invest in "staff not stuff", so compared to other schools it looks a bit down-at-heel. Not perfect- oh my life, it was a shambles in the first lockdown! But then it was a transformation and the teaching team pulled together and suddenly it was fantastic.

There is a healthy supply of cover so the teachers get a day out of the classroom each week to do all the Ofsted admin and other crap. I think that makes their lives bearable, but I'm speculating.

I feel so sad when I hear people say the curriculum is a strait-jacket. My dd has covered so much in her time at primary school and yes, that is the word for it - delivered creatively so the kids really engage ... If the purpose is to create a lifetime love of learning, then mission accomplished.

I guess I'm going to have to write a really nice Thank You to the HT at the end of Y6.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/02/2022 10:22

Dishwashersaurous,

I’m not sure that’s true. I taught in a school similar to the one you describe. It was full of self entitled disruptive arrogant students.

As it was OFsted outstanding, there was horrific pressure on the staff all the time.

It was very high achieving. The majority of A level students went to red bricks or Oxbridge. But still disruptive.

Dishwashersaurous · 17/02/2022 09:32

It's all about the school. Local secondary school has loads of children coming out with racks of 9/8 and going off to top universities.

Everyone locally seems really happy with it and the kids do loads of extra curriculum stuff as well.

This clearly isn't universal nationally.

Best thing is to move close to a good secondary school

AllisoninWunderland · 17/02/2022 08:57

@LollyLol
I think you’ve got a point - your child obviously goes to a good school. You’ve lucked out there. It’s nice to hear that some schools are doing some creative things.

AllisoninWunderland · 17/02/2022 08:53

@RoastedTurnip it’s so sad isn’t it. I started teaching in 2002 and we were encouraged them to produce ‘creative curriculum’. Yes we had to teach maths and English but there was so much scope to inspire and create. You could (in primary anyway) follow the children’s interests to an extent. You could add your own twist. Now it’s just about delivering a set out out-dated objectives to pass tests and tick boxes.

Since they changed the national curriculum in 2014 the government have tried to send us right back to the Victorian era.

Teachers are burnt out and pupils are uninspired and under so much pressure to perform.

Terribleenergy · 17/02/2022 07:12

I know, @LollyLol. I’m not convinced it’s necessarily better or worse now - admittedly, I did start teaching (back in 2003) in a really rough school - it was on a very shabby, rundown council estate which depressed me just to drive through, so god knows what it did to the kids! But we had so many fights, lots of teenage pregnancies, big families - it wasn’t unusual for mum and eldest daughter to be having a baby at the same time and we often had aunts in the same class as nephew / niece. There were some lovely kids but there were some very troubled ones as well.

A lot of schools now seem to have swung to the Michaela outlook which I also dislike.

So it’s hard to say how much of it is pandemic related and how much is just an impossible situation. As I say, my main ‘worry’ is that my children wouldn’t be pushed to achieve what they would actually be capable of in smaller classes and with more intense support.

OP posts:
LollyLol · 17/02/2022 06:31

If you compare state and private education, then private education is always going to look better - if it didn't, no one would pay for it and it would cease to exist. Market forces.

If I compare the state schools now with what I experience 20/30 years ago there is no comparison; facilities and curriculum and teaching and school dinners are so much better now. There is far better provision for and understanding of SEN and ND kids than when I was at school. Far better pastoral care - mental health wasn't even considered during my education.

My DD goes to an average primary and I have my complaints but overall I think it is brilliant, aside from a lack of cheap peripatetic music lessosns or any real drama lessons (that is the only thing that seems to have got dramatically worse in the past few decades). New initiatives like forest schools are a brilliant thing for our kids, and complement the curriculum so well. I look at the quality of work the kids produce and in English in particular, it is stellar compared to what we did at school. Plus they cover such a big curriculum, everything from French to electronics.

I can see all the downsides people are listing but sometimes you've just got to stand back and say, overall, is this state education good value for money? And I say yes it is.

RoastedTurnip · 17/02/2022 06:19

@Allisoninwunderland

I was thinking about this on valentine's Day. When I started teaching (MFL) I'd quite often do something fun & valentine's related (writing poems but working on dictionary skills) but there isn't even breathing space for that with y7 now!

AllisoninWunderland · 17/02/2022 00:23

Teacher here too and I agree with lots said on here. I took myself and my DC out of the system to home educate/unschool as I was so bitterly disillusioned.

In my view, one of the main problems (other than chronic underfunding) is ofsted and the sheer prescriptiveness of the national curriculum. It’s so exam focused now that teachers are in the main only expected to ‘teach to the test’ type teach. There is no longer the scope to be creative and inspiring. The very things I went into teaching for no longer exist really. Children are just numbers on a graph, they’re expected to be mini robots following a set of age related expectations and it just serves to stress the teachers and most of the children. Your job ends up being trying to fit square pegs into round holes.

The system that was set up during the industrial revolution is just unfit for purpose in today’s society.

Heshcher · 16/02/2022 17:43

I have a masters in maths and I’m embarrassed to tell my old friends from university about my work day. I went into teaching through Teach First, and was (bizarrely) put in a primary school as a maths specialist rather than secondary maths. I stayed in teaching because I moved abroad and could easily find work speaking English. I’ve been teaching 9 years and I’m rather good at it, but I work longer hours for less money than my course mates did in their first years of their careers even after 9 years. It’s not like there is a lovely environment in schools or the hope of phenomenal career progression to make it worth it, so I constantly feel like I have to explain my irrational career choice. It’s no wonder there is a shortage of teachers.

Terribleenergy · 16/02/2022 17:27

I don’t know if it’s political so much as just teaching not being a very appealing option. If I had a good maths degree, I wouldn’t go into teaching!

OP posts:
Calennig · 16/02/2022 17:18

*It's an absolute shit show, lets be frank. Tories have utterly destroyed it.

Welsh Labour have control of education in Wales and have for 20 + years - and it's not great.

I'm not saying the Tories are great but I do wonder if it's a wider issue - maybe it's value attached to schooling and money that comes with that - maybe it's parenting or wider educational changes, loss of esteem for teachers or way too much focus on paper work or maybe ageing population takes political focus off child age group- I don't know maybe it's none of that and something else entirely - but it's not just the Tories and I'm not seeing solutions from other parties.

HoldenCaulfieldismyhomeboy · 16/02/2022 17:06

It's even worse if your child has sen in a mainstream school.

Sqeeeel · 16/02/2022 16:47

*It's an absolute shit show, lets be frank. Tories have utterly destroyed it.

I'm a third year mature student on an Education course and the number of people who still want to teach after is tiny. The reality is that there are bright, able, potentially brilliant teachers who aren't even training because they can't even begin to bring themselves to be in that environment.

Inclusion has failed, 'closing the gap' has failed, COVID has compounded all the previous issues and made them worse. There is no funding. And some of the teachers remaining, hanging on, have become so bitter and twisted that children genuinely suffer from them in ways that would never have been tolerated a few years ago.

These children need nurture, love, kindness and guidance. They need to be helped to heal from the trauma of the pandemic. Instead they are being destroyed by this desperate need to 'catch up.' Catch up to what, exactly?*

Incredibly sad. Very glad I took my children out of the system completely years ago as it seems to be becoming more toxic by the year.

Unbelievable when the system is completely at breaking point that Local Authorities are making it their life goal to push thriving, happy home educated children back into schools.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/02/2022 16:58

I taught in an outstanding comp. Lots of the students were disruptive.

One of the reasons is class size. You can get on top of 20 or so students. 35 is a different matter. Class sizes have gone up under this lovely government.

Mummadeze · 13/02/2022 15:57

My DD is at an outstanding secondary comp. She is not v happy and I am unsure what to do as thought it was the best option in the area since we can’t afford private. The school are helpful around her SEN but the classes are very disruptive and stressful for her. She just wants to work quietly and it sounds like the children in many of the classes are out of control. She has probably an upsetting situation to deal with a few times a week. There also seems to be endless new teachers, which is also stressful for her. But the thought of changing her now also feels like something she might not cope with. My main worry is, how do I know if it is her or the school that is the problem. Not that it would be her fault but I don’t know if she would be so stressed in any secondary school or if it is not such a good school as I thought.

Fairislefandango · 13/02/2022 15:48

I've taught in state schools and private schools. Yes, there are some really good state schools and some shitty private schools, but an average private school has a lot of advantages over an average state school.

I'm kind of anti private schools in theory - it would be better if they didn't exist. But they do, and if I could afford it I'd put my dc in one like a shot (while feeling a bit of moral guilt).

The private school I worked in for 10 years had literally none of the many problems I've seen in all of the state schools I've worked in (which seem to get worse and worse with every passing year.

It was an absolute delight to teach there, and the kids (all girls) almost all loved school, got on brilliantly with almost all the teachers, achieved stellar results and had huge amounts of extracurricular opportunities. Totally different world tbh.

HelpMeHiveMind · 13/02/2022 15:35

Our DCs go to supposedly one of the best states in the area and I've been so disappointed with it. Huge churn of teachers, constant supply teachers, awful communications, just not pushing the more able students - happy to let them coast along, very poor (and bizarre!) Selection of gcse subjects on offer, lack of career guidance and extra curricular etc. At parents eves the teachers hardly seem to know who the pupils are. Of course I know covid has taken its toll....but if this is one of the best, I hate to think what others are like!

TempsPerdu · 13/02/2022 15:31

I hate to say it but secondary teachers, watch out for the current primary cohort coming up in the next few years. I teach in an infant school and the junior teachers next door are in for a shock. Speech and language issues have exploded. Many children with social and behavioural difficulties. Much higher incidence of SEN but no hope of getting an EHCP. We are offering parental classes as so many children have no structure or boundaries at home. 4 year olds on YouTube all night watching inappropriate content and playing 18 rated games on consoles. Stressed out parents struggling to make ends meet who are emotionally unavailable in some circumstances due to domestic violence, poverty, addiction. Far more children arriving in year R in nappies unable to communicate effectively and far more mental health issues

Hearing this more and more from the many teachers I know irl. Every single school we viewed for DD mentioned the impact of the pandemic on their Reception/KS1 cohort, especially an uptick in speech and language issues. I’m actually considering retraining in SALT myself as it’s clearly going to be a huge area of need in the future (albeit probably without the necessary government funding to accompany it).

I’m slightly dreading DD starting Reception in September tbh. Due to our highly fortunate position (comfortable home life, two highly educated parents, masses of attention from an ex primary teacher mother with a Master’s in child development/psychology and who is currently a SAHM, two days a week at a very good nursery), she is extremely school ready. She is naturally inquisitive, loves learning, received a good grounding in basic phonics and number work from me while we were bored over lockdown, has a decent level of independence etc. We have bypassed the local community school and gone for a slightly more middle class church school precisely because I saw these problems coming down the line and wanted her to be in a setting whose intake was that bit better resourced and more shielded from the pandemic fallout. But we live in a mixed area and I’m under no illusions about the fact that her teachers will be faced with many of the issues mentioned upthread. I just hope her start to school isn’t too disrupted, and that she doesn’t lose her early enthusiasm for learning.

A few years ago I would have been implacably opposed to the idea of private education for DD, and we can’t comfortably afford the fees anyway - but with the state system as it currently is I’m starting to have a nagging sense that this is where we might end up.

Calennig · 13/02/2022 14:01

What does concern me from a selfish stance is that I just don’t see children encouraged to meet their potential. They come out of school having done reasonably well but not brilliantly.

I feel this happened to DD1 - though her college thankfully is better and I fear it's even worse for DS Y10 - having a sucession of supply teachers often not qualified in that subject - its particulary bad with English and Welsh.

There does come across as a total lack of ambition for the kids - with few a departments and teachers fighting the good fight but increasingly just leaving.

We do what we can at home but we can afford the guides and are well educated enough to help - but it often feels like we have to fight the lack of ambition as the school instills as well.

I thought it was just becase this school does seem to be in decline - but DN has similar in her English State secondary and that's considered a good secondary - though she is in lower sets.

I have no idea what the answers are - but I agree there do seem to be huge problems.

CheesecakeAddict · 13/02/2022 12:39

@Whatwouldscullydo honestly? I think there are too many strands to unpick:
Social services need more funding - they are massively understaffed (our local council only has 2 safeguarding SS employed permanently and they've been advertising the jobs for about 5 years, no one wants to do the job because the pay is peanuts and there's very little value added). Because SS are so stretched, schools (and the police tbf) are having to pick up the pieces for free. More time spent dealing with stuff we are ultimately not qualified to do means less time to do the stuff we should be actually doing e.g. in my RQT year I was sent to do a home visit on a neglected child because SS couldn't get there for a while as everyone was working on a full caseload. My classes for that afternoon had to have a non-specialist babysit them whilst they did cover work.

Outside agencies e.g. CAMHS need more funding and we need to be in a position where we can give students outside support. The number of kids with SEN is going up and up but funding is going down, so they are not getting what will help them thrive. Again, this is coming down to the classroom teacher who then has, as you say, many conflicting needs in one classroom (I regularly teach classes with student with ADHD whose parents claim I need to stimulate their child more to "control" them, alongside a student on the autism spectrum, for whom too much stimulation makes them have a meltdown.) The level of differentiation I have to do to help my students achieve, which I want them to do, is like a full-time job now on its own.

For the reasons above, and as per PP, we need to be paying TAs more to make them even apply for the job in the first place, before we even think of retention, because again, you can't give a student 1-on-1 support that their plan asks for, if no one is applying for the job.

Get rid of the uniforms and have a blanket dress code like most 6th forms and European schools do e.g. no crop tops, no logos, no references to guns etc. It does not avoid bullying because they still know who the poor kids are and find something to bully them about e.g. shoes, bag, the faded school jumper because it's 2nd hand, and I've dealt with several cases of bullying because they have a stitched on logo on their blazer rather than the usual school one. This will help parents make school clothes more affordable which means they will have more money to put into affording living cost price hikes, school equipment and revision materials.

Sort out the way staff are performance managed and what kids are being examined on, so that teachers don't carry the whole blame for students failing. If a student with poor attendance, lots of SEMH issues etc. is failing, it's probably not for lack of the teacher trying. If teachers know their ability to pay the mortgage next year is based on needing 80% of their GCSE class to get their predicted grade, based on exams they took under very different circumstances when they were 10 years old, then the only thing that will matter will be dragging that grade out of that kid, which is when you get parents complaining about lack of focus on mental well-being. You also have the dreaded parent saying "I'm making my child concentrate on the subjects they need to get onto their course at college" - which is reasonable, except that will impact whether I get a pay rise next year and whether I can afford to eat 3 meals a day. Equally, the exams are very skewed to certain demographics. One paper talked about a winter sports holiday, in the school I was in at the time, the kids' version of a holiday was if they got to go to a caravan over the bank holiday weekend, they couldn't ask questions to the ski instructor because they had no idea what that would look like. So they weren't being examined on the subject being taught, they had the added disadvantage of being too poor to understand the context to draw experience.

And this is just the tip of the ice-berg. We haven't even got to schools funding meaning staff are being let go, classes made bigger and timetables stretched with more cover. The amount of admin needed to "prove" what we are doing just in case Ofsted come, which has no benefit to the students. And I'm sure there are also many other layers that I can't think of just yet.

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 13/02/2022 12:19

@noblegiraffe yes I agree the system is truly broken! But in countries where there is no welfare system education is valued as a way out of poverty.
We have a welfare system that is abused in many cases.
Can we blame every badly behaved dragged up kid on ADHD when in actual fact its just bad behaviour?
Its a disservice to kids who actually have ADHD and need support.
Should we give even more money to families who dont value education so they can never work, but its ok for us to?
I see it every day and its very sad and hard to see what is coming.
Maybe more funding given to low income families who really support their kids at school as bonuses.
While those that abuse it get penalties.
More funding for poorer families to get kids in univesities.
School is not just lessons, kids learn how to be healthy, sex ed and life skills. We cant blame everything on covid or special needs.

Terribleenergy · 13/02/2022 12:10

No, indeed, although I do think there were different types of problems in the 2000s, certainly.

What does concern me from a selfish stance is that I just don’t see children encouraged to meet their potential. They come out of school having done reasonably well but not brilliantly.

OP posts: