Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move because dh inherited property?

641 replies

bowmejen3 · 11/02/2022 12:46

So I'm born and bred in Hackney. Met my husband here who is originally from south Manchester in one of the largest council estates In Europe apparently.

We've been married 10 years and have two children. (4 and 2 months)

We rent privately and was looking forward to getting on the shared ownership scheme this year! 4 year old settled in nursery waiting for reception etc! However DH has been very stressed and with rising living costs. We have not got much to spare each month after saving for our deposit.

Now here is my aibu.
Dh father recently died and left his house (ex council but bought) to dh. It has no mortgage left.

Dh thinks this is the best thing ever as we could move there (3 bed semi detached, big garden, driveway, extra room for washing etc)
Be mortgage free, near his family and have essentially more disposable income to enjoy life, holidays, other ventures etc.

I know I know it sounds perfect on paper... but I always envisioned raising my children in London but dh claims we are actually being selfish because potentially they will never be able to afford to live near us in the future and we may only ever own 25 percent of a flat!
And the area he is from has not got a great reputation...

I believe he could sell the house for around £240,000 (from Rightmove) and put it down for a deposit on a house in London!

Dh thinks I'm being ridiculous to want to not be mortgage free just for the sake of "London" and being snobby towards his childhood area? (Which I'm not)

Aibu?

OP posts:
Crayfishforyou · 12/02/2022 12:59

Yanbu.
You live in London, you work in London, you have a life in London. Yes, you could move, but you don’t need a reason to move or stay. If you don’t want to you don’t have to

bowmejen3 · 12/02/2022 12:58

@Blossomtoes

I think we will spend Easter in wythenshawe and let it sink in, he might take his rose tinted glasses off of it being the same when in reality!

Equally, you might find you quite like it. ☺️

I hope I do! It would be great if I was completely onboard and not London tinted.

My in-laws have amazing lives, always on holiday, lovely things etc. nice gardens. Children doing well, go hobbies etc.

It's just my idea of a great successful life differs from them. I don't think living in an apartment is a bad thing where as to most Manchester people it seems it's like equivalent to living in the ghetto and depriving my children of a garden.

I wish I felt as passionate as DH because on paper it does seem like a no brainer
It's just my heart is not in it right now for some reason

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 12/02/2022 12:53

I think we will spend Easter in wythenshawe and let it sink in, he might take his rose tinted glasses off of it being the same when in reality!

Equally, you might find you quite like it. ☺️

bowmejen3 · 12/02/2022 12:50

Oh yes to answer questions!
DH is a area manager for a well known food store.
I am currently not in work but I am a clinical psychologist Smile

OP posts:
bowmejen3 · 12/02/2022 12:45

Haven't ran away! Been reading all the comments etc.
I've been showing dh this thread, I also explained that until FIL passed away, we always had our life set up for London and agreed. We could have bought a house years ago in wythenshawe if that's what he really wanted.

I have spent a lot of time in the area, which isn't too bad but it's what I witness on the community group that scares me. Every night DH is like
"Oh look a old school friends daughter has been attacked on the tram"
"Oh another house robbed "
"Another child stabbed"

And this is nearly every night I've had to listen to these comments. Until recently now he's trying to make out this is far and few between.

My husband is a great man, so is his family and I'm sure thousands of people who live there are great people. But there is a reason he has chose to live in London for the past 18 years! Way before he met me!

I have looked at surrounding areas (Warrington? Stockton heath, Appleton?) and also Chester and The Wirral. Then Crewe, perhaps even the midlands! and suggested selling the house, using it as a big deposit for a house there now he's all of a sudden pro north.
Which he said is not the idea, then we might aswell do that down here!

I think we will spend Easter in wythenshawe and let it sink in, he might take his rose tinted glasses off of it being the same when in reality! Everything would have changed since he lived there as a teenager!

OP posts:
planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 12:39

London ain't the same place it was. I wouldn't bring my kids up there, given a choice.

What do you mean by that exactly?

The place I was brought up which used to be full of gun crime and shit schools, now has some of the best state schools in the country and is spilling over with artisan bakeries, is that what you mean?

I really hope you don't mean it's more racially mixed these days than it was in the mid 20th century, which is often what people really mean when I hear them say that (elderly racists types who moved out of Hackney decades ago. Sadly have met a few of these).

LottyD32 · 12/02/2022 12:05

@bowmejen3

Yes it's in wythenshawe, close to Northenden/Gatley..

The prices there are going up.. so that's an actual excellent suggestions to perhaps live there, sell the property and buy in a different area.

But to those who say they wouldn't raise their children in London, why?

I had a great childhood, went to school on the tube by 13. Went to museums most weekends. As a teenager, I was NEVER BORED. Always something new to explore.
Dh actually said he wish he was brought up here a few years ago as he was really bored in wythenshawe!

London ain't the same place it was. I wouldn't bring my kids up there, given a choice.
cheekyasfish · 12/02/2022 11:39

Why not give it s try? You may be surprised

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 10:39

@Nowayoutonlydown

With all the uncertainty with electric and all other bills rising, I'd snap up the option of being mortgage free and have a lifestyle you will never achieve in London. It doesn't sound like you'd ever achieve that in Hackney, the kids could be closer to other family members and you could potentially use some of the spare money you won't be ploughing into a mortgage to help save for your children's futures- its looking more and more likely that the only way our children's generation will buy is with help from earlier generations.

If the estate is that bad, can't you sell and take on a smaller mortgage for somewhere close to there but not on that particular estate? Cut down on your housing costs massively.

You're not factoring in the higher wages in London or investment of a house rising much faster in London.

I did pretty much exactly what's being proposed - left London and live mortgage free in an ex council house. (Although it's not on a rough estate with a bad rep).

I reckon that decision has cost me in excess of £400k. (Given my current house is worth about £250k, this is a lot!)

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 10:35

*An area, not a level! (Fat fingers!)

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 10:34

@Sceptre86

You are being snobby. I'd take Manchester over London anyway but I'm a mancunian so biased. I'd sell his childhood home and buy in a nicer part of Manchester with good schooling. If you don't overstretch yourselves you could get a smaller mortgage and hopefully overpay and work towards being mortgage free in 10 years or so. You'd then be able to use that money for whatever you wanted.

Manchester isn't the same as London though, it's got a lot if the same or similar attractions and is a lively city but London has its own magic.

Jesus Christ, it's not snobby to not want to move into an area with high crime and not great schools at secondary level. It's just practical.

If you live there, your existing connections and fondness of the place may override that, but if you don't - why would you want to?

And I say that, having grown up in a level with high crime levels that had a bad reputation, and which I was very fond of.

crazyjinglist · 12/02/2022 10:33

Or you might as well stick a pin in a map and move to fuck knows where, just because the houses are cheaper.

^This. And where your dc can breathe cleaner air. Personally I wouldn't have wanted to bring my dc up in London or Manchester, or in the middle of any big city tbh.

Nowayoutonlydown · 12/02/2022 10:18

With all the uncertainty with electric and all other bills rising,
I'd snap up the option of being mortgage free and have a lifestyle you will never achieve in London.
It doesn't sound like you'd ever achieve that in Hackney, the kids could be closer to other family members and you could potentially use some of the spare money you won't be ploughing into a mortgage to help save for your children's futures- its looking more and more likely that the only way our children's generation will buy is with help from earlier generations.

If the estate is that bad, can't you sell and take on a smaller mortgage for somewhere close to there but not on that particular estate? Cut down on your housing costs massively.

Sceptre86 · 12/02/2022 10:03

You are being snobby. I'd take Manchester over London anyway but I'm a mancunian so biased. I'd sell his childhood home and buy in a nicer part of Manchester with good schooling. If you don't overstretch yourselves you could get a smaller mortgage and hopefully overpay and work towards being mortgage free in 10 years or so. You'd then be able to use that money for whatever you wanted.

Manchester isn't the same as London though, it's got a lot if the same or similar attractions and is a lively city but London has its own magic.

Didioverstep · 12/02/2022 09:53

Check the inheritance tax first and any ither fees. Can you cover these? If not. Then I would sell and buy another house in Manchester. I would want to raise my kids in london. But your jobs also play a factor

lottiegarbanzo · 12/02/2022 09:48

On tax, the estate could be liable for inheritance tax if the total estate exceeds the threshold but only on that proportion that exceeds it.

CGT is only on any gain in value of an asset since the date of death.

So if you sell soon, with little increase in value, there's probably no CGT (because everyone gets an annual allowance).

If you hold onto it, let it out and sell up in a few years, then there'd be CGT on any increase in value. (Though there are various reliefs, so you'd need to do the calculation and might not owe a lot).

But if you sell/leave your main residence and move there, there'd be no CGT when you later move on, as you don't pay it on your main home.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 12/02/2022 09:43

The main question here is are your jobs based in London. If so is it something easy to exchange to another city?

Crimesean · 12/02/2022 09:29

I'd be worried about the schools in Wythenshawe if I moved there with DC. Also anti-social behaviour.

Neither of you is being unreasonable, but clearly you need to arrive at a solution that works for all of you as a family.

Daphodils · 12/02/2022 09:13

@Bingbangbongbash

I know both places really well and I would stay in London. £240,000 will buy you about half a house in some Z3 areas and you wouldn’t have to live in Wythenshaw. It’s not like you’re swapping the opportunities and culture of London life for a massive garden and loads of square footage - you’d be moving to a pretty grotty suburb of a not as good city. If you want to give your kids more than London can offer, I’d look further out of either city.
I agree with this.

And @WinnieMac
Or you might as well stick a pin in a map and move to fuck knows where, just because the houses are cheaper.
Exactly, why choose where to live by accident of inheritance? It makes more sense to sell up and use the cash to make an informed choice. And if you're happy where you are then stay there. It seems crazy to uproot everybody just because someone died somewhere else in the country.

(Also London is an amazing place to live Grin)

PurpleCarpets · 12/02/2022 09:02

@ivykaty44

You don’t pay CGT on an inherited property.

Surely you do when you sell it if it’s gone up in value since you became owners and haven’t lived in the property?

Yes, but this isn't a significant part of the plan is it? They will either sell it or live there, not leave it standing empty for years. There might be a small amount to pay at 18% of the gain from the probate valuation as I recall. But probably hundreds, not thousands. And not a significant proportion of a £240k windfall (which in fact will be a bigger windfall by then because there will have been a gain!)
ivykaty44 · 12/02/2022 09:02

have know to move 400 miles away.

It’s 193, don’t exaggerate

To move because dh inherited property?
Stickypace · 12/02/2022 08:59

Manchester isn't 400 miles from London more like 200 miles. I'm not a fan of London so I would side with your DH. Manchester is more appealing to me.

Ponoka7 · 12/02/2022 08:59

I love London for the things to do and transport. I'm from and live in Liverpool. From an outside pov the stabbings seem scary. But residents will know the true picture. I've friends that live in Manchester and go there for concerts/shopping. If I had a choice I'd choose London. It's easy to get around and everything is available. There's work opportunities that don't exist more northern places. We've had an employment boom, but it will drop back down. My children didn't have cousins/family to consider though.

FAQs · 12/02/2022 08:57

@bowmejen3 you’ll regret leaving London !

Kittykatmacbill · 12/02/2022 08:56

I am going to totally break with what everyone else is saying, he is asking you to give up your support network and everything you have know to move 400 miles away. Sell the property and use the money to a deposit some where you want to live.

(Never lived in London before anyone comments!)