Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move because dh inherited property?

641 replies

bowmejen3 · 11/02/2022 12:46

So I'm born and bred in Hackney. Met my husband here who is originally from south Manchester in one of the largest council estates In Europe apparently.

We've been married 10 years and have two children. (4 and 2 months)

We rent privately and was looking forward to getting on the shared ownership scheme this year! 4 year old settled in nursery waiting for reception etc! However DH has been very stressed and with rising living costs. We have not got much to spare each month after saving for our deposit.

Now here is my aibu.
Dh father recently died and left his house (ex council but bought) to dh. It has no mortgage left.

Dh thinks this is the best thing ever as we could move there (3 bed semi detached, big garden, driveway, extra room for washing etc)
Be mortgage free, near his family and have essentially more disposable income to enjoy life, holidays, other ventures etc.

I know I know it sounds perfect on paper... but I always envisioned raising my children in London but dh claims we are actually being selfish because potentially they will never be able to afford to live near us in the future and we may only ever own 25 percent of a flat!
And the area he is from has not got a great reputation...

I believe he could sell the house for around £240,000 (from Rightmove) and put it down for a deposit on a house in London!

Dh thinks I'm being ridiculous to want to not be mortgage free just for the sake of "London" and being snobby towards his childhood area? (Which I'm not)

Aibu?

OP posts:
RoseMartha · 12/02/2022 15:25

I think a mortgage free home sounds better.

Alternatively sell the house and buy something you both agree on and in an area you agree on which might not be London or Manchester. With a small mortgage.

Would it not be better to live half way between both your families.

whywouldntyou · 12/02/2022 15:15

@ShittyFingers

I’m team DH - but what I’d probably do is sell the house and then move to nice part of Manchester

I wouldn’t live in London if I was paid to though

This. Exactly this. (Southerner here)
Pipsquiggle · 12/02/2022 15:08

Glad you're going to go up and see what it's like over Easter.

I would definitely check out Chorlton and Stockton Heath whilst you're up.

I have just had a quick Rightmove search and the disparity in price is just breathtaking. Even if you sell FIL house and use it as a deposit in London - what you get in Hackney is just tiny.

I love London (& Manchester - lived in both cities), but essentially moved out because we needed more space. Do you ever think you'll need more space? You must really, really love Hackney to sacrifice on space.

My only friends who have stayed in London in zone 1 - 6 (their children are teenagers or late primary school) have been able to afford a house - they earn oodles - bankers / lawyers / architects etc. Literally everyone else has moved out. I am saying this, because your support network now, may well move out

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 15:05

But I do agree about perspective. Which is what I was trying to get across to OP. She's concerned about stabbings in Manchester, when she lives somewhere where stabbings are far from an unusual occurrence.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 15:02

[quote TatianaBis]@Tealightsandd

Who says OP needs to stay in Hackney?

Daily stabbings - well there were 27 teens stabbed to death across the whole of London in the whole of 2021, so let’s keep this in perspective.[/quote]
Lots of non fatal stabbings too.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 15:01

OP doesn't want to get out of Hackney (although her DH does).

TatianaBis · 12/02/2022 14:41

@Tealightsandd

I don't know where Blossom is from but I'm also a born and bred Londoner - with relatives who are from Hackney.
And I have friends who live in Hackney.

Croydon 2021 crime stats are 82/1000 people, which is only 2.3% different from Hackney.

If I wanted to get out of Hackney I wouldn’t go to Croydon.

Blossomtoes · 12/02/2022 14:39

I’m a lifelong born Londoner I don’t need lecturing on crime stats from an out-of-towner.

Other people don’t have your superior knowledge. I was just helping them out. Hackney is one of the five boroughs with the highest crime rates. 🤷‍♀️

TatianaBis · 12/02/2022 14:35

@Tealightsandd

Who says OP needs to stay in Hackney?

Daily stabbings - well there were 27 teens stabbed to death across the whole of London in the whole of 2021, so let’s keep this in perspective.

Crimesean · 12/02/2022 14:31

Have a look at nice places in and around Manchester - Didsbury, Heaton Moor, Heaton Mersey, Charlton, Bramhall. All lovely, family-oriented, leafy suburbs with great schools.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 14:29

I don't know where Blossom is from but I'm also a born and bred Londoner - with relatives who are from Hackney.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 14:28

Seriously though Croydon isn't all so terrible. It's like a lot of places. It has pros and cons, good and bad.

In fact if OP does want to stay in London, there are several new build help to buy type schemes being built in Croydon - and as it's cheaper than Hackney, she might also be able to afford an outright mortgage (rather than shared ownership).

TatianaBis · 12/02/2022 14:24

@Blossomtoes

I’m a lifelong born Londoner I don’t need lecturing on crime stats from an out-of-towner.

As I said London is massive, the boroughs are large and within them there are areas of lower and higher crime.

If you take Hackney crime stats at face value - crime rate for 2021 is 105 per 1000 people, so 90% of people in Hackney didn’t experience crime in 2021. And if you look at the bar chart - many crimes including vehicle theft, violence + sex offences, drugs, criminal damage + arson aren’t much different to the London average.

Excited101 · 12/02/2022 14:12

I’d sell it and use it as a down payment, yes. How much mortgage would you be able to get do you think? What could you afford in London?

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 14:07

Being honest I too would prefer Hackney to Croydon (although Croydon isn't all bad).

But a pp is wrong to say Hackney is all gentrified and lovely. There is gentrification, yes, but there is also huge deprivation.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 14:03

It's not a terrible place to live, Hackney. It can be great, in fact - depending on personal preferences, needs, and budget. Like many places it has pros and cons.

But it is an inner city borough that, whilst has some very expensive housing and chi chi shops, restaurants and bars, also has a huge amount of deprivation and other issues. Like many large cities - including Manchester.

It might be that for OP, somewhere completely different - not Manchester or London - would be best. Perhaps a smaller town or city inbetween the two.

Shutupandcry · 12/02/2022 14:02

And no offence to Croydon- I lived there and liked it although it was a bit rough. No one wanted to visit me though Grin.

Shutupandcry · 12/02/2022 14:02

I do think when considering it you are comparing apples with oranges. An equivalent in Manchester to Hackney is probably somewhere like Heaton Chapel or Withington which wouldn’t have been considered great in the past but are now gentrified and lovely. Wythenshawe is more like maybe Croydon? I’d choose hackney over wythenshawe but East Didsbury over Clapham. We have lives in a nice and rough area in both Manchester and london and while I loved being in my twenties in london as soon as we had kids and finances took a hit we moved. We could never afford our lifestyle in london.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 13:52

Cross-posted with Blossom

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 13:51

@TatianaBis

The thing with London crime stats is that you have to factor in that London is massive with a huge population. Crime is very area dependent. And there are areas of London where the crime is low.
But OP is from Hackney. Which is where OP says she grew up. Even if it was one of the gentrification million plus homes, it would be impossible to ignore or not notice the gang crime, stabbings, and robberies that happen frequently in Hackney.
Blossomtoes · 12/02/2022 13:46

@TatianaBis

The thing with London crime stats is that you have to factor in that London is massive with a huge population. Crime is very area dependent. And there are areas of London where the crime is low.
Unfortunately Hackney isn’t one of them.

crimerate.co.uk/london/hackney

TatianaBis · 12/02/2022 13:29

The thing with London crime stats is that you have to factor in that London is massive with a huge population. Crime is very area dependent. And there are areas of London where the crime is low.

Gingerbreadman1972 · 12/02/2022 13:24

Manchester is great and lots of family friendly areas. But you'd be crazy to live mortgage free in Wythenshawe when you could put down a very decent deposit on a house in a much nicer area. Whether that's London or Manchester depends on how far you're willing to stretch I guess. But when ppl say Manchester is a great place to live, they aren't talking about Wythenshawe, I think you'd be crazy to live there even mortgage free. Most areas of Manchester you can get something decent for 4-500k, so you'd be able to put down a very decent deposit.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 13:24

have spent a lot of time in the area, which isn't too bad but it's what I witness on the community group that scares me. Every night DH is like
"Oh look a old school friends daughter has been attacked on the tram"
"Oh another house robbed "
"Another child stabbed"

Did you grow up in an obscure sleepy village that just so happened to share its name with an inner London borough, OP?

Because otherwise I'm quite bemused. It's impossible to grow up in inner London (or even outer London nowadays) and not be very aware of the daily stabbings and other violent crime.

That includes in and around the social housing estates of Hackney. (And no, I'm not being a snob. I have relatives who grew up in Hackney social housing).

Seriously. If you really are from Hackney, you'll find Manchester no worse - and perhaps better.

I can completely understand not wanting to leave your home city - particularly if you want to stay close to family and support networks. But you don't mention your family (are you close? Do they still live in London?) and seem fixated on a fear that Manchester...because of the crime that so blights London!

If that's the only thing holding you back, you'd be mad not to take the opportunity. A cramped overpriced, likely shoddily constructed, new build in London - that you only part own and still have to pay rent on. Or a spacious, owned outright house with a garden in a different in a different city - where your dc will have family around (you mention your DH's family still being in or near to Manchester).

It's a no brainer. I say that as a born and bred Londoner.

Neveragain85 · 12/02/2022 13:02

I've lived in both cities & sorry I wouldn't want to raise a family in Manchester. I've never felt unsafe in London

Swipe left for the next trending thread