Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move because dh inherited property?

641 replies

bowmejen3 · 11/02/2022 12:46

So I'm born and bred in Hackney. Met my husband here who is originally from south Manchester in one of the largest council estates In Europe apparently.

We've been married 10 years and have two children. (4 and 2 months)

We rent privately and was looking forward to getting on the shared ownership scheme this year! 4 year old settled in nursery waiting for reception etc! However DH has been very stressed and with rising living costs. We have not got much to spare each month after saving for our deposit.

Now here is my aibu.
Dh father recently died and left his house (ex council but bought) to dh. It has no mortgage left.

Dh thinks this is the best thing ever as we could move there (3 bed semi detached, big garden, driveway, extra room for washing etc)
Be mortgage free, near his family and have essentially more disposable income to enjoy life, holidays, other ventures etc.

I know I know it sounds perfect on paper... but I always envisioned raising my children in London but dh claims we are actually being selfish because potentially they will never be able to afford to live near us in the future and we may only ever own 25 percent of a flat!
And the area he is from has not got a great reputation...

I believe he could sell the house for around £240,000 (from Rightmove) and put it down for a deposit on a house in London!

Dh thinks I'm being ridiculous to want to not be mortgage free just for the sake of "London" and being snobby towards his childhood area? (Which I'm not)

Aibu?

OP posts:
Bridewel1 · 12/02/2022 22:44

I'd say just a little unreasonable. Dh has a valid point but ho wouldn't want to be mortgage free and London I'd just so expensive. So I get your point and your used to London and your daughters getting settled it doesn't seem nice uprooting to a council estate. But I'd at at least think about it. You could always give it ago and tart the house up then sell and move to a nicer area in Manchester or just outside Manchester. If it's in the area I'm thinking of which is called Wythenshawe then it's quite near to Cheshire. If you've heard of the exclusive area in Cheshire known as the golden triangle where a lot of wealthy people live including some footballers and coronation st cast known as the Cheshire set then this is within 20 minutes drive from Wythenshawe. The golden triangle consists of the towns Wilmslow, Alderley edge, Prestbury and Altringham. So you have options. Being mortgage free and as I said sell the house and move to a nicer area nearby. London is just to expensive in my opinion. And do your reserch find out about the area, and surrounding areas. You could join a local Manchester fb group and ask members about the area. I'd certainly give it some consideration.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 22:43

It's perfectly safe for many families and individuals. But it is absolutely not 'all gentrified and chi chi'. It is very mixed.

www.hackneygazette.co.uk/news/crime/report-on-knife-crime-in-hackney-8438082

Hackney had worst knife crime rate in London, report finds

Hackney youth worker James Cook MBE said: “The figures don’t surprise me. Some people think that Hackney is a new trendy area, but there’s no point in gentrifying it when there’s so much poverty and drug issues around.”

James, who runs youth boxing centre The Pedro Club, has lived in Hackney for 42 years. He said gang violence has increased since he moved to the area.

“Years ago, this was happening every month or every few weeks," James said. "Now it’s every day. It feels like America, not London."

Ownedbyafrenchie · 12/02/2022 22:40

@ShittyFingers

I’m team DH - but what I’d probably do is sell the house and then move to nice part of Manchester

I wouldn’t live in London if I was paid to though

This!
TheJade · 12/02/2022 22:36

For me living in London is the last thing I’d want to do.

If you’re not bothered about work/friends/family down there then I would certainly move up north! You can’t beat Manchester 😉 even if you sell the council house and move to a ‘nice’ bit of the northwest you’ll have a better quality of life and more spare cash than if you stay in London

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 22:22

Although I understand it has been gentrified, it's still Hackney and still London.

This. It is very mixed. Gentrified parts, yes, but also a lot of deprivation.

That's not to say it's a terrible place. It's got positives and negatives. Whether to live there or not, like most places, is a matter of personal preference really. We all have different tastes, priorities, needs, and budgets.

Personally I would prefer a mortgage free house over a mortgaged flat, but what's right for me isn't best for somebody else.

OP doesn't mention her own family. If she's close to them and they're still in Hackney, she might want to stay nearby.

Mortgage free is indeed priceless, but then sometimes so too is being near family. It's a hard choice for OP if her family are in London but her DH's are in Manchester - with both of them craving their home city.

Tealightsandd · 12/02/2022 22:12

Sorry, but I don't think you really understand London.

I'm a born and bred Londoner. With family from Hackney (social housing estates) and friends who currently live in the borough. I have friends and family living all over London. So actually I do understand London.

But I don't think you seem to understand my posts. We seem to be saying the same thing - that the borough of Hackney is indeed very mixed.

I never suggested the social housing in Hackney was the same as in Manchester, but that isn't relevant to my point. OP was concerned about crime in Manchester but lives in a part of London with a high crime rate.

Clearly some of Manchester's social housing is mixed. OP's DH inherited home is a right to buy. I assume his parents weren't the only ones on the estate to do that. Whether as mixed as London, well that's another matter. But then OP's concerns were about crime rates, not social housing.

TheHumanExperience · 12/02/2022 22:11

I think that maybe you haven't sat down and written a list of pros and cons of each option.

Having lived in London all mu life I'd never want to bring up children there, especially near Hackney, sorry. Although I understand it has been gentrified, it's still Hackney and still London.

We moved out of London to have children and it was the best decision we ever made. Quality of life is so much better in every way. When we want to go into London we do, but are glad to leave a d go home. Our house feels safe, even when I forget to lock the door, I walk the dogs at 10pm not looking over my shoulder, my children are relaxed at school with no stress. I was running the gauntlet at school, in breaks and on transport on the way home every day. So much so I walked when I could. Not an experience I would wish my children to have if it could be avoided.

No mortgage in these times is priceless. It fees you both up from stress and the uncertainty of covering these massive bills, if the unexpected happens.

Sit down and write a pro/con list for both options. Take your time. Ask your partner to do the same and then meet together and respectfully swap lists and then discuss. Go away for a while before re-discussing it further.

You may find your thoughts may change.

I'd never move back to London, for any reason.

Rewis · 12/02/2022 22:03

I don't think either of you are unreasonable. I'm one of these people who is very affected by location (and there are several factors that go into it). So something that is good on paper does not mean I'd be happy. I know there are people who can just move and it's not big deal and say something about "as long as you kids a either you you'd be happy wherever". It's just not something that works for me.

Daphodils · 12/02/2022 21:53

[quote Pipsquiggle]@Daphodils

"St Albans and Harpenden named expensive property hotspots | Herts Advertiser" www.hertsad.co.uk/lifestyle/property/st-albans-and-harpenden-make-most-expensive-list-8021102[/quote]
Thanks @Pipsquiggle, I hadn't seen that.

Pipsquiggle · 12/02/2022 21:45

@Daphodils

"St Albans and Harpenden named expensive property hotspots | Herts Advertiser" www.hertsad.co.uk/lifestyle/property/st-albans-and-harpenden-make-most-expensive-list-8021102

SnozPoz · 12/02/2022 21:44

Some very bigoted anti London sentiment here! Anyone would think Manchester was crime free! An anti knife crime campaign was launched in Manchester just yesterday! Ffs!
They are both great cities and kids can have a fantastic childhood in both places.
I think you have to ask DH why he moved to London and was happy to settle there? I don't think it's fair to say it's selfish to stay in London because he was happy to live there before his inheritance. You don't mention the job situation which clearly has to be a factor, but I can see the draw of living mortgage free tbh. The suggestion of selling the property and finding an affordable alternative somewhere you'd both be happy seems to be the compromise.. but some soul searching and calm conversation needs to be had between you both. Did he know you've always wanted to bring the kids up in London? Did he always want to go back to Manchester deep down? What's the deal breaker for you both? Good luck

Imouttahere · 12/02/2022 21:38

Haven't had time to RTFT so sorry if this has already been suggested. Would you consider renting the house out for some time? Then perhaps look for your own house just outside of London, a short commute back into London for any activities at the weekend with the kids. I'm from Camden but moved out of London a few years ago. It's great to go back for the day but I wouldn't buy there. Not when you can get so much more for your money just outside of London

Daphodils · 12/02/2022 21:25

@Pipsquiggle
*@Londoncallingme move to St Albans for cheaper housing ha ha ha - are you having a laugh?

St Albans is much cheaper.

DilyteGelyte · 12/02/2022 21:23

No, YANBU. If everyone thought like your DH, everyone would live up North. Location matters. London is where you live, met him and lived married life with him for 10 years. After all that it's not fair for him to think you'll drop everything and go live in, where was it? Manchester?
You were going to buy a property anyway, sell his house and put it towards the deposit. Or rent it out and that will be extra income to help with mortgage payments. And why does he think that your kids won't be able to afford to live near you, talking of having no faith in him raising successful human beings, pff. Seems like 10 years of marriage were wasted on you guys if he knows you so little.

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 21:10

I'm from Hackney, born and bred, and there's a HUGE difference to the Hackney I grew up in, even when the gang culture was rife, and a sprawling estate in south Manchester.

And, anyway, those days are gone. These days, it's full of rich people, it's been gentrified to fuck!

It's a world away from south Manchester. Seriously.

Pipsquiggle · 12/02/2022 21:10

@Londoncallingme move to St Albans for cheaper housing ha ha ha - are you having a laugh?

St Albans is one of the most expensive areas in the country to buy and Thameslink (or whatever it's called nowadays) is ropey. I used to live there, could only afford a tiny terraced house when we wanted a 4 bed detached so moved away. A lot of my friends have stayed and they go on about it in much the same way as OP talks about Hackney. They think it is an amazing place in their smallish houses, nice but not the be all and end all

planningtomakeaplan · 12/02/2022 21:07

@Tealightsandd

have spent a lot of time in the area, which isn't too bad but it's what I witness on the community group that scares me. Every night DH is like "Oh look a old school friends daughter has been attacked on the tram" "Oh another house robbed " "Another child stabbed"

Did you grow up in an obscure sleepy village that just so happened to share its name with an inner London borough, OP?

Because otherwise I'm quite bemused. It's impossible to grow up in inner London (or even outer London nowadays) and not be very aware of the daily stabbings and other violent crime.

That includes in and around the social housing estates of Hackney. (And no, I'm not being a snob. I have relatives who grew up in Hackney social housing).

Seriously. If you really are from Hackney, you'll find Manchester no worse - and perhaps better.

I can completely understand not wanting to leave your home city - particularly if you want to stay close to family and support networks. But you don't mention your family (are you close? Do they still live in London?) and seem fixated on a fear that Manchester...because of the crime that so blights London!

If that's the only thing holding you back, you'd be mad not to take the opportunity. A cramped overpriced, likely shoddily constructed, new build in London - that you only part own and still have to pay rent on. Or a spacious, owned outright house with a garden in a different in a different city - where your dc will have family around (you mention your DH's family still being in or near to Manchester).

It's a no brainer. I say that as a born and bred Londoner.

Sorry, but I don't think you really understand London.

That includes in and around the social housing estates of Hackney.

Yes, there are estates in Hackney. But it's nothing like Manchester, and particularly nothing like the area the OP is considering moving to.

in Hackney, as much of London (with the exception of the bit of Clapton near the river) there aren't large areas of social housing.

Instead, there are pockets of social housing and well-to-do housing cheek and jowl next to each other. And there were, going back a few years, loads of council house properties Victorian houses of flat conversions, in hackney and in Islington too. (I suspect most of these have been sold off now).

It's really, really mixed. Clapton, E5, is home to Pembury and Nightingale Estates which had a reputation back in the day, for example but also a plethora of artisan bakeries, craft beer distilleries, trendy wanker media types. (No offence to trendy wanker media types honest Grin.

The front line (e.g. where crack was sold) was in places like Cricketfield Road and - going back further - Sandringham Road - roads of Victorian houses, not dark seedy estates, where many people could quite happily live in ignorance for a while at least, not realising the extent of what was going on right under their noses.

AuntyBumBum · 12/02/2022 21:07

@Sceptre86
You are being snobby.
A very unappealing trait.

I'd take Manchester over London anyway but I'm a mancunian so biased. I'd sell his childhood home and buy in a nicer part of Manchester with good schooling.
You are being snobby.

PrincessSpanky · 12/02/2022 21:05

Oops sorry didn't mean to post Grin

PrincessSpanky · 12/02/2022 21:05

U

AuntyBumBum · 12/02/2022 21:01

@Blondeshavemorefun

Surely you can see a house with garden you own mortgage free if far better then a flat you rent /part own/share
You cunningly omitted to mention Manchester Grin
mazmum21987 · 12/02/2022 20:57

To give a slightly different take on it. I live in a borough just outside of London, one that on paper it’s very attractive, and one of the wealthiest in the country but the reality is different. I also live in a shared ownership property. We had every intention of only being here a few years and then moving on, however with shared ownership there are ever increasing costs- the rent goes up every year without fail - as does the service charges- it’s well known you pay a premium on rent and service for shared ownership. I only share this as it’s something to consider that if you don’t have much spare money now, you’ll need to ensure your income increases yearly to cover this.

We’ve now been here 8 years and no signs of getting out soon. Yes we’ve made money on our share, but everything else around us has gone up too, and we tied here due to work.

Life these days is so busy and too short, often throughout the time of striving to afford to buy a home and all the things we want for our ‘future’ we forget to actually live in the present , and before we know it 5-10 years have passed. In all honestly I love my home I really do, but if I was asked to do shared ownership again, i would have some reservations but hindsight is a wonderful thing. I’m not trying to burst your bubble, but if you can be mortgage free with a young family and enjoy life to the fullest then grab it with both hands. Nothing is forever and you can always sell and move when your financially more comfortable.

AuntyBumBum · 12/02/2022 20:55

@Bogasphodel

It won’t be 240k if he sells as he may have to pay Capital Gains Tax……
He won't have to pay. The £240k is free from CGT. It doesn't apply to inheritances.
handsanitiser · 12/02/2022 20:27

Prices in Hackney are likely to rise faster - plus there are some brilliant schools in the borough, and it’s a really vibrant area. I’m with you, OP

RussianSpy101 · 12/02/2022 20:26

@Londoncallingme but there are lots of opportunity and high expectations elsewhere too.
Why do you assume everyone who doesn’t want to live in London is jealous of those who do?

I have a much, much better lifestyle than the few schoolmates of mine who have ended up in London and as an extension of that, our children have much better opportunities because we can afford them. There’s another thread running at the moment of a woman mid 30s still in a house share in london. At mid 30s!! That is absolutely mental to me. We’ve got 2 DC in private school at a similar age to her and our 3rd child starts next year and we own a 5 bed detached house with a really small mortgage. DD has sport lessons at an amazing facility that GB athletes train at. I really don’t see how our life would be in anyway enriched by living in London. We certainly wouldn’t have 4/5 holidays abroad a year like we do now.