Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move because dh inherited property?

641 replies

bowmejen3 · 11/02/2022 12:46

So I'm born and bred in Hackney. Met my husband here who is originally from south Manchester in one of the largest council estates In Europe apparently.

We've been married 10 years and have two children. (4 and 2 months)

We rent privately and was looking forward to getting on the shared ownership scheme this year! 4 year old settled in nursery waiting for reception etc! However DH has been very stressed and with rising living costs. We have not got much to spare each month after saving for our deposit.

Now here is my aibu.
Dh father recently died and left his house (ex council but bought) to dh. It has no mortgage left.

Dh thinks this is the best thing ever as we could move there (3 bed semi detached, big garden, driveway, extra room for washing etc)
Be mortgage free, near his family and have essentially more disposable income to enjoy life, holidays, other ventures etc.

I know I know it sounds perfect on paper... but I always envisioned raising my children in London but dh claims we are actually being selfish because potentially they will never be able to afford to live near us in the future and we may only ever own 25 percent of a flat!
And the area he is from has not got a great reputation...

I believe he could sell the house for around £240,000 (from Rightmove) and put it down for a deposit on a house in London!

Dh thinks I'm being ridiculous to want to not be mortgage free just for the sake of "London" and being snobby towards his childhood area? (Which I'm not)

Aibu?

OP posts:
ErinTingey · 13/02/2022 14:18

[quote RussianSpy101]@ErinTingey they should do it for this reason alone![/quote]
That's the biggest reason not to do it!

planningtomakeaplan · 13/02/2022 14:14

@CupOfCake

Pressed post too soon That way, you are gaining two lots of equity, a small income above your costs from the rental and you get to stay in London. It's win, win
I'm not sure that's such a good idea if you factor in capital gains tax?
RussianSpy101 · 13/02/2022 14:14

@HaveringWavering I’m a SAHM so no.
She would be able to afford to rent a full house or at least a flat for what she is paying in a flat share. That’s why it is relevant.

planningtomakeaplan · 13/02/2022 14:12

@mtc2206

I’m with DH. You don’t have to live in that area forever but it would put your whole family in a much better financial situation. Living near family has huge advantages, both for you and your kids if they can be nearer to grandparents and cousins. It’s possible to have a great experience of growing up, regardless of where you live. Good luck but I’d consider it!!
No, it really wouldn't. As I've said upthread, I did exactly what the OP is suggesting, pretty much.

I cashed in a £150k investment (the equity from living in a Hackney flat for a decade) and spent it on an ex-council flat out of London.

And, I've lived mortgage free since.

Has it put my family in a better financial situation?

No. We're in a much worse financial situation. I have never earnt close to the salary I got in London. My peers who stayed there and continued to progress their career in London now earn double or even triple what we do as a family. It's a huge difference.

DP has limited opportunities for jobs in his field compared to London. The value of the flat I sold in London is now £450k more than the house we're in now - and that would all be equity - as London prices always go up more than the rest of the country, and there's been a boom in Hackney this last decade or so.

Not having a mortgage to worry about is good to not be stressed about. I'd be a lot less stressed if I had a load more money in the bank, though!

Money isn't everything and yes, moving out of London and having a nice life in an area you like is worth more to many people than the extra money you can make owning property and working in London.

But it's not that what the OP is proposing - she doesn't even want to live there - and it's not true that it will put them in a better situation financially. If the alternative is putting down a deposit on a property in London, then living in Wythenshaw could make them worse off in comparison.

HaveringWavering · 13/02/2022 14:07

[quote RussianSpy101]@HaveringWavering well I’m married and I assume she isn’t if she’s in a house share. Teachers in my city don’t live in house shares![/quote]
Well exactly. So you have two incomes to fund your lifestyle. Still struggling to understand why you think that comparing yourself to a single thirtysomething is relevant to a thread about London v Manchester?

StargazerAli · 13/02/2022 14:02

This is something only you can decide. Both you and your husband have valid arguments; he understandably sees it as a way out of financial stress and you don't want to leave London, which is your home. Perhaps visit Manchester and find an area that you like and think you may be able to live in. I'm sure your husband would be willing to move a little further away from his family to make you happy.

On the other hand, if you would be leaving your family behind in London and feel that you really would find it a wrench to leave, he will hopefully see it from your side of the argument.

The danger is that if you leave London, you may never be able to afford to go back and it would feel too daunting a prospect to even attempt a few years down the line, once your children are settled etc.
Good luck!

saraclara · 13/02/2022 13:24

@Parkmama

It's also a valid point about when your DC are older, it's unlikely they will be able to afford to live locally to you in London
I grew up in the East Midlands and moved to the South East for my first job. As did my late DH, a Yorkshireman. We always intended to move back up north but never did.

My daughters, having been away for uni, returned here and don't plan to move away, probably partly because of the loss of their dad and us being a small family. We all like being within 40 minutes or so of each other.

Eldest and I were fans of Homes Under the Hammer, which often features the area where I grew up. Eldest has been known to half jokingly say "Why did you have to stay down here, mum?! Look at the houses I could buy up there!"
And she's right. Her tiny tiny terraced cottage cost as much 3/4 bed detached up there.

Parkmama · 13/02/2022 13:15

It's also a valid point about when your DC are older, it's unlikely they will be able to afford to live locally to you in London

RussianSpy101 · 13/02/2022 13:14

@ErinTingey they should do it for this reason alone!

ErinTingey · 13/02/2022 12:47

If you move away, you'll never move back.

CupOfCake · 13/02/2022 12:28

Pressed post too soon
That way, you are gaining two lots of equity, a small income above your costs from the rental and you get to stay in London. It's win, win

CupOfCake · 13/02/2022 12:26

Keep the house, mortgage it, rent it out.
Use the money raised as a deposit for a flat in the area nearest to Hackney that has dropped the most post Covid.

Bridewel1 · 13/02/2022 11:55

Yes I agree with dh. You'd be mortgage free, financially free. And free from the expense of living in London. You'd be mad not agree. Take the house, tart it up if it needed it and sell. Then you can move to another much nicer area of Manchester or Cheshire. Wythenshawe is only a short distance from the exclusive areas of Cheshire known as the golden triangle with the towns Wilmslow, Alderley edge, Prestbury where the wealthy live amongst some footballers and Corrie actors. Although there are some properties affordable within your budget in these areas. So I do your reserch on Manchester and nearby areas and give it some consideration.

samsam123 · 13/02/2022 11:53

your husband is right, you would have a house why even contemplate staying in London

mtc2206 · 13/02/2022 11:50

I’m with DH. You don’t have to live in that area forever but it would put your whole family in a much better financial situation. Living near family has huge advantages, both for you and your kids if they can be nearer to grandparents and cousins. It’s possible to have a great experience of growing up, regardless of where you live. Good luck but I’d consider it!!

LovelyIssues · 13/02/2022 11:05

100% agree with DH. Makes so much more sense

saraclara · 13/02/2022 10:43

What's bizarre about this whole thread, is that people are talking about two huge cities as if they were each a totally homogenous area.

Both London and Manchester have every type of area you can imagine in them. The posh bits, the middle class bits, the cramped bit, the open bits, the dodgy areas, the almost crime free areas.

"I lived in Manchester/London, so I know..." doesn't really make sense. Maybe that poster lived in the 'worst'/'best' area. Maybe they love bustle, maybe they love suburbia. The personal tales are of no use at all. Neither city is entirely one characteristic.

The only thing you can guarantee is that one has the better weather, and in one you're likely to find cheaper housing than in the other. The rest depends entirely on which bit of the city and its surrounds that you live in.

12345FishAlive · 13/02/2022 10:36

I'm not anti London, I've never lived there so I'm not going to bash it.

I know Wythenshawe, I wouldn't raise my kids there. If the house is towards gatley & northenden then it won't be near the tram which I believe is near the civic center so kids wouldn't be able to travel easily other than by bus. If you've pictured your life with London transport links then don't move there!

Areas around Wythenshawe are great for raising families. Heald Green is so close, train station and is a lovely village but too small for me personally. Cheadle is lovely. Altrincham has both the tram and train to Manchester, train to Chester & Stockport. Altrincham (voted Times best place to live in the whole country in 2020) also has some of the best schools in the country and you could get a fully done up 3 bed terrace for about £450000 with a 10 minute walk to the ice rink, cinema, tram/train station & town centre. Sale is really nice, great schools and it is having loads of money invested in it at the moment but not as close to green spaces as Altrincham and similar house prices. Chester is also nice and I would consider moving there for a slightly cheaper house but not as good transport links. You mentioned Crewe, don't move to Crewe, most of it is similar to Wythenshawe.

Spend some time in the various areas while you're staying in Wythenshawe for Easter. But, if you want to live in London and can't see yourself happy outside of London then don't do it!

girlmom21 · 13/02/2022 10:14

@MyAnacondaMight

*It also means they have no rent/mortgage etc and can afford to do nice things with their children they currently can't afford. It'd benefit all of their lives...*

So do that in one of the 300+ other houses in greater Manchester currently available in that price range, if that indeed is a priority for the family. Which it wasn’t until this particular house came up…

She wants her kids to grow up in London... you're arguing against something nobody else is discussing.

Almost everyone has said to sell the house and buy elsewhere...

CarrotVan · 13/02/2022 10:10

£240k would give you a 50-60% deposit on a very nice house with garden in Urmston, Sale, Altrincham, Chorlton, Withington, Didsbury, Heaton Moor, Cheadle, Lymm…all green leafy suburbs with independent high streets and good schools with selective grammars in Trafford.

I personally wouldn’t move to Wythenshawe. It’s got lots of multigenerational families so it could be hard to integrate. I had my eldest at Wythenshawe hospital which is a massive cardiac centre too. If you work in the NHS there’s loads of opportunities - huge teaching hospitals and specialist provision like Christie’s

My family who moved to London and brought up kids there are mostly now moving back north and their kids have moved north to university and settled very happily.

If you don’t like Manchester then Sheffield or Leeds would be good places to consider.

Also with the BBC moving to Manchester there’s loads of displaced London media people in those suburbs I mentioned.

MyAnacondaMight · 13/02/2022 09:49

It also means they have no rent/mortgage etc and can afford to do nice things with their children they currently can't afford. It'd benefit all of their lives...

So do that in one of the 300+ other houses in greater Manchester currently available in that price range, if that indeed is a priority for the family. Which it wasn’t until this particular house came up…

Simonjt · 13/02/2022 09:46

As a fellow Hackney resident I wouldn’t move out of Hackney, I certainly wouldn’t move to Manchester.

inheritancetrack · 13/02/2022 09:27

I'm with DH in this, although I would sell the house and get one in a nicer area nearby, even if it meant a small mortgage. I moved out of London and thank god I did. All my London born family did the same and we live in nice safe areas. I couldn't bear the thought of DS being sucked into knife crime and gangs which would have happened if we had stayed in the area I was born. To live in London and for it to be a success you need to have an awful lot of money.

HaveringWavering · 13/02/2022 09:27

@bowmejen3

Oh yes to answer questions! DH is a area manager for a well known food store. I am currently not in work but I am a clinical psychologist Smile
Yes, but how does that translate to life outside London? Could/would DH move with the same company? Would he lose a London weighting? Are the actually better work prospects in retail management in the North (eg Asda’s HQ is in Leeds I think?).

Are you planning to work privately or within the NHS, or a bit of both? Do you have academic research interests that need a good university nearby? (I have several psychologist friends who have gone down different routes professionally. One moved away from Manchester for academic reasons, another has a great practice working privately with burnt out rich bankers, a third is in the NHS (CAMHS) and teaches in a school on the side, another works in the NHS in a London hospital).

RussianSpy101 · 13/02/2022 09:25

@HaveringWavering But yeah, shared ownership for 25% of a flat or owning a house are not comparable are they for OP.

I don’t see why London is the only place your children can have lots of opportunities? It’s a ridiculous thing to say.