Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Splitting with DP - AIBU to think I don't have to pay back his mortgage contributions?

157 replies

StepAwayFromGoogling · 11/02/2022 12:00

Shaking while writing so bear with me. Long back story, but me and 'D'P are splitting up - literally as of about 10 minutes ago. We've had a joint mortgage for 8 years. My parents paid the deposit which is protected. I want to stay here with the DCs and can afford to do so. I was assuming we would transfer the mortage into my name and then would somehow (by remortgaging?) release half the increase in value of the property to him. He thinks I will be forced to pay him half of the mortgage contributions from the last 8 years? So he will essentially have lived here for free that whole time? I just said to him 'I don't think that's how it works' and he lost his temper "THAT MONEY IS MINE, YOU'LL FUCKING PAY ME, YOU'LL FUCKING PAY ME EVERYTHING...". I'm scared and shaky but trying to work out if that's true? Because then I can't afford to keep the house.
YABU - yep, you'll have to pay his mortgage contributions back
YANBU - nope, just the increase in value, divided by two

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 11/02/2022 19:40

Can you hold off the builders?

This is not a good time for you to start fiddling with the value of the property.

mathanxiety · 11/02/2022 18:38

See a solicitor. You will find you are in a better position than he says you are in.

Call the police if he is behaving in a manner that causes you to fear for your safety. This includes punching walls, kicking furniture, threatening you.

CrinklyCraggy · 11/02/2022 17:44

@T00Ts

Slightly concerned that MNHQ refused to delete a thread despite the OP fearing her aggressive soon-to-be-ex husband had found it. But they’ll delete a thread about because some idiotic OP got rinsed and ‘had second thoughts’…
I'm not why sure threads get deleted. Don't assume it's because an OP complained because it went against them. I had a thread where I definitely overshared and was taking a bit of a pasting. It was removed for not being in the spirt or something, but I didn't complain or ask for it to be taken down. I can only assume others reported on my behalf
T00Ts · 11/02/2022 17:40

Slightly concerned that MNHQ refused to delete a thread despite the OP fearing her aggressive soon-to-be-ex husband had found it. But they’ll delete a thread about because some idiotic OP got rinsed and ‘had second thoughts’…

Aprilx · 11/02/2022 16:40

@DumpedByText

Just tell him a solicitor will advise you both on how to proceed and then shut the conversation down. No point in getting into it if he's that aggressive. You know he's wrong but he won't believe you, so leave it to the professionals.
He is wrong, but so is the OP. And the OP is further of the mark than he is. A solicitor will clear up the misunderstandings all round.
DumpedByText · 11/02/2022 16:34

Just tell him a solicitor will advise you both on how to proceed and then shut the conversation down. No point in getting into it if he's that aggressive. You know he's wrong but he won't believe you, so leave it to the professionals.

belle40 · 11/02/2022 16:31

Sorry OP but this is not how it works. I would also seek legal advice but essentially he would get back anything he put in (assuming it was protected) and half the equity. This was the legal position when I split from someone and we owned a house together. Don't let him spook you but do get good legal advice so you can move forward from a secure position of knowledge.

Mayorquimby2 · 11/02/2022 16:15

Wait that's not right either.

Then you get screwed over on the equity as you'll have put in the bulk.

60/40 probably unfair to you too depending on where it is in the life of the mortgage

Your deposit+% increase value of the property out first.

The test 50/50

Mayorquimby2 · 11/02/2022 16:09

"My deposit was 10% of the original price so we split the equity 60/40 in my favour."

Should be 55/45 no?

10% to you
Then 50% each of the remaining 90%

Googlecanthelpme · 11/02/2022 16:02

@Coconuttets

He is clearly entitled to 50% of the current value of the entire property, less perhaps the initial deposit amount. So either you have to buy him out, he buys you out, or you both sell and split the proceeds.
Yes surely this would the case in most scenarios?

I own my property jointly with DP (not married) and I put the deposit in.
If we were to split up then the house would valued minus the mortgage we’d pay off over the years and that would the available equity. My deposit was 10% of the original price so we split the equity 60/40 in my favour.

However if I wanted to stay in the property I’d have to pay him the 40% of the equity. Likewise if I wanted to leave he’d have to pay me 60% of the equity.
Whoever stays in the house would have to remortgage to take out the £ amount to pay off the other and then pay the new mortgage as a single person

lucythejuicy · 11/02/2022 15:57

Although it does seem a little unfair that you keep the deposit the. Get half of what he has paid off if I am honest

lucythejuicy · 11/02/2022 15:57

As others have said he is entitled to half the equity ie what the house is worth minus what is owned minus the deposit then split by half

Cocomarine · 11/02/2022 15:56

@StepAwayFromGoogling

I asked MN to remove this post because I thought he found it. Turns out 'see you're posting on MN again' didn't actually mean that though. But they refused anyway.
That’s bad that they refused. They’ll delete all kinds of non identifiable nonsense because an unreadable OP is unhappy they got their arse handed to them on a plate, yet refused this that could have compromised your safety?!
Viviennemary · 11/02/2022 15:51

He won't get it. But is he annoyed because he alone has paid the mortgage over the last few years? Or have you paid half each.

Coconuttets · 11/02/2022 15:47

He is clearly entitled to 50% of the current value of the entire property, less perhaps the initial deposit amount. So either you have to buy him out, he buys you out, or you both sell and split the proceeds.

Sandinmyknickers · 11/02/2022 15:45

@Lime37

I’d assume it would be 50% of any equity minus the protected deposit and 50% of the increase
This is also how it worked for me and my ex. It is the most reasonable and fair to all parties way Im guessing he is just using he wrong terminology by saying 'mortgage payments' instead of equity during what sounds like a heated and emotional time
Sandinmyknickers · 11/02/2022 15:41

It sounds like he is just using the wrong terms (I.e 'mortgage payments' instead of his share if equity) and rather than seek to understand that, it has resorted to a shouting match. Not excusing his behaviour at all and hope you are safe, but ot sounds like communication is the issue (not surprising considering you are breaking up)
Don't worry about this now. Get yourself somewhere safe where you can sort your head out and process the split in the first instance, and then get advice from a lawyer once calmed down

Mayorquimby2 · 11/02/2022 15:41

@Neverhot

No, it's not true. It's also very likely if you have children together that he will get less than 50% equity.
But if they're not married it's not a division of marital assets in which the needs of the children will be considered etc.

It's the splitting of a joint asset between two parties who have decided to remain seperate legal entities.
If they were renting and unmarried with kids she wouldn't be able to claim a portion of his pension or a BTL he owned.

it will be divided based on what they have put in and how the property of owned.

I would have thought she has no right of claim on any asset of his and he has no right to claim any of hers.

Neverhot · 11/02/2022 15:33

No, it's not true. It's also very likely if you have children together that he will get less than 50% equity.

Mayorquimby2 · 11/02/2022 15:27

"Mayorquimby you're talking through your arse"

In what way?

Zilla1 · 11/02/2022 15:07

One explanation is the obviated rent. Another is what happens when the house loses money (negative equity happens occasionally). Where does the money come from to repay the cumulative mortgage payments if there is no equity gained? Does he get the mortgage payments and their partner lose money?

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 11/02/2022 15:07

As you are not married it very much depends on how the property is owned and how the deposit was protected. I also don't see why your parents deposit money sees no increase in value? Unless it specifically says that it is an interest free loan.

littlewhite · 11/02/2022 15:01

My ex dp tried this. He couldn't get his head around the fact that he had paid in to a mortgage and wouldn't be getting the money back out. Literally took our finance advisor to say to him-'but why should you think you should have been living for free for the last 3 years?' 'What do you think you would have been paying in rent all that time for an equivalent house?' (Answer a lot more than he was paying for half the mortgage)
I paid him back money he had spent on some building works as that seemed fair-he wouldn't be benefitting from them-and I will when the house sells-but I certainly wasn't going to subsidise his life retrospectively for three years!

Dillydollydingdong · 11/02/2022 14:58

Hope you're ok OP. And he's crazy thinking he would be entitled to get his mortgage payments back. Mayorquimby you're talking through your arse. Unless you're a qualified lawyer, pipe down.

MissBridgetJones · 11/02/2022 14:56

@StepAwayFromGoogling

Thanks all, what a mess. We have builders starting on Monday to bloody extend the place too. Funded entirely by me/my parents. But that's a whole other thread.
Take photos of the house before they start. Get an agent (or better still RICS valuer) round to value pre-extension, keep evidence of what you spend on extension.

The line needs to be drawn in the sand before works start.

Good luck

Swipe left for the next trending thread