Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Splitting with DP - AIBU to think I don't have to pay back his mortgage contributions?

157 replies

StepAwayFromGoogling · 11/02/2022 12:00

Shaking while writing so bear with me. Long back story, but me and 'D'P are splitting up - literally as of about 10 minutes ago. We've had a joint mortgage for 8 years. My parents paid the deposit which is protected. I want to stay here with the DCs and can afford to do so. I was assuming we would transfer the mortage into my name and then would somehow (by remortgaging?) release half the increase in value of the property to him. He thinks I will be forced to pay him half of the mortgage contributions from the last 8 years? So he will essentially have lived here for free that whole time? I just said to him 'I don't think that's how it works' and he lost his temper "THAT MONEY IS MINE, YOU'LL FUCKING PAY ME, YOU'LL FUCKING PAY ME EVERYTHING...". I'm scared and shaky but trying to work out if that's true? Because then I can't afford to keep the house.
YABU - yep, you'll have to pay his mortgage contributions back
YANBU - nope, just the increase in value, divided by two

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FantasticFebruary · 13/02/2022 07:40

Make sure the values know why you're getting the valuations done. Otherwise they'll value it higher to make you feel good. The mortgage company's valuation will be on your last mortgage statement & will be lower. That will impact how much you can remortgage for.

You'll be the one responsible for the kids, so you NEED to get as much stability as you can & this will be a hugely important part in that.

Take care

You definitely still need a good solicitor, although you're not married they might be able to get you to keep more of the equity in the house as you'll have his kids to house, unless you're going to do 50:50 with the kids?!

Apply for

HelterSkelter224 · 12/02/2022 20:52

He doesn't get 8 years free accommodation. If you were to charge him the rental value as a landlord that would be much higher so would he agree to getting his mortgage payments back but then paying you rent? Doubt it.

I imagine tensions are high right now given you've just split up (I'm so sorry OP) so hopefully he'll simmer down but agree with others, please call the police or at least someone you trust if he is making you feel afraid.

Good luck xx

Keepitonthedownlow · 12/02/2022 20:43

Good luck Flowers

Capri3 · 12/02/2022 19:55

@StepAwayFromGoogling

I wish people would have read my OP properly. All I said was "I don't think it works like that" before I got a load of swearing and abuse. Even if I had set out how I thought it works, I still didn't deserve swearing and abuse. Nobody does.
Ignore the swearing and abuse, 95% of the votes agree with you. Your DP getting both his contributions and the increase in equity makes no sense.

Good luck! 😊

StepAwayFromGoogling · 12/02/2022 19:46

Thank you to everyone who has given really helpful advice. I do appreciate it and it has helped me to panic less and focus on the practicalities of what I need to do now.

OP posts:
StepAwayFromGoogling · 12/02/2022 19:42

As it stands, I've arranged three valuations next week. We are due to remortgage by the end of March and he seems happy for me to buy him out. We'll base that on the valuations, and then the extension is neither here nor there.

OP posts:
StepAwayFromGoogling · 12/02/2022 19:37

I wish people would have read my OP properly. All I said was "I don't think it works like that" before I got a load of swearing and abuse. Even if I had set out how I thought it works, I still didn't deserve swearing and abuse. Nobody does.

OP posts:
Keepitonthedownlow · 12/02/2022 18:42

If you buy a house and sell it you get your money back. You pay interest however you also get increases in value. Of the ex gets his contributions back then he will not have paid 'interest' on the borrowing, however if he forgos any of the capital appreciation that seems fair.

LittleMissTake · 12/02/2022 16:42

You’re getting some good and poor advice on here OP.

Please see a solicitor.

To calculate your DP’s share of the equity you need to ascertain how the house is owned legally and how your deposit is protected.

Good luck OP.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 12/02/2022 15:49

AFAIK having children is not relevant because they are not married.

In a divorce a joint asset can be split to take account of the need to house children but this is not a divorce. The house is owned as stated in the Deec when they bought, and will be divided accordingly.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 12/02/2022 15:45

The Equity is made up of any capital paid off as part of the mortgage repayments plus any increase in value.

His share therefore is
The market value of the house, minus the outstanding mortgage, minus the OP’s deposit, divided by two.

If he thinks this is unfair, he needs to STFU. The OP’s savings created the deposit that enabled them to buy and him to have a house to live in and any equity at all, and if it is simply the cash value of the deposit that was ringfenced then in the sun above he is actually walking away with half the increase in value of the OP’s deposit.

OP, hopefully your deposit is clearly named in the Deed in which you bought as Tenants In Common? In which case the solicitor that handles the sale of his share to you can distribute the monies as per the Deed.

I very much hope that the money for the extension has been similarly protected.

sueelleker · 12/02/2022 10:10

And if you'd been renting, would he want his rent payments back? YANBU

THisbackwithavengeance · 12/02/2022 09:26

@Dreamstate

What yabu!!!! If this was other way round everyone would be saying it.

He is right to a certain degree. At the time of splitting the value of the house minus protected deposit is split. E.g. deposit 25k House value is 200k, leaving 175k to split

The bit that he might not be right on is whether its a 50:50 split of that 175k
Mostly becuase yo have children that tends to change it.

But you are wrong to say its a split of the increase only. Otherwise you are keeping his mortgage payments he paid and getting free money.

That is why u need legal advice as does he.

But if my partner turned round and said what u said I'd be absolutely 💯 be fuming and angry too.

Indeed.

Op is proposing ripping the man off big time and he has rightly got angry and shouted. And then everyone says call the police. Hmm

OP: just buy the man out. You can get a lawyer and get 60% rather than 40% I suppose but whether that extra 10% is worth your lawyer's costs, only you can judge. I'd try and keep it amicable personally.

AgathaMystery · 12/02/2022 09:25

@Furbulousnous

And cancel that building work! You’ll be adding value to the property that you will then have to give to him. Press pause on that for now. It can take a LONG time to come to an agreement on financials and separation esp. if he refuses to leave the hse.
I agree.

You do not have to have it done. Certainly not this week. I would seriously cancel the builders.

Dreamstate · 12/02/2022 09:21

What yabu!!!! If this was other way round everyone would be saying it.

He is right to a certain degree. At the time of splitting the value of the house minus protected deposit is split. E.g. deposit 25k House value is 200k, leaving 175k to split

The bit that he might not be right on is whether its a 50:50 split of that 175k
Mostly becuase yo have children that tends to change it.

But you are wrong to say its a split of the increase only. Otherwise you are keeping his mortgage payments he paid and getting free money.

That is why u need legal advice as does he.

But if my partner turned round and said what u said I'd be absolutely 💯 be fuming and angry too.

Bunnycat101 · 12/02/2022 09:18

I think the fairest way would be to determine what percentage of the purchase price your deposit represented and then split the rest equally

Eg deposit = 125k on a 500k property = 25%
Property now worth £700k so you’d get £140k back and then split the remaining equity according to the percentage of payments paid.

But it really depends on the way you brought the property given you’re not married.

Furbulousnous · 12/02/2022 09:14

h, you’re not married.
So it is just the hse that needs spitting. You can do that quite quickly and also quickly get a financial
Separation order too.

Furbulousnous · 12/02/2022 09:10

And cancel that building work! You’ll be adding value to the property that you will then have to give to him. Press pause on that for now.
It can take a LONG time to come to an agreement on financials and separation esp. if he refuses to leave the hse.

NewtoHolland · 12/02/2022 09:09

I'm really shocked that MN wouldn't remove a post where there is a clear risk of domestic abuse towards the poster!!
I would be asking the moderator to put you in touch with their manager as that's a clear reason why a post should be removed.

Furbulousnous · 12/02/2022 09:08

He’s entitled to 50/50 of joint assets usually. But if you’re staying with kids and paid the deposit then you may get more of house. You may not be able to stay though and big him out so be prepared for that news. Does he want his kids 50:50? If so he’ll need to have enough to buy ahis own place to house them.
Get some legal advice. Then get a mediator.
Hopefully it will all calm down for you.
And no, you don’t have to give him back his bloody mortgage payments. What a dickhead.

monkeysox · 12/02/2022 09:03

Teentitan explains it well

monkeysox · 12/02/2022 09:02

She will get a higher % of equity as deposit was hers

Capri3 · 12/02/2022 08:56

@belle40

Sorry OP but this is not how it works. I would also seek legal advice but essentially he would get back anything he put in (assuming it was protected) and half the equity. This was the legal position when I split from someone and we owned a house together. Don't let him spook you but do get good legal advice so you can move forward from a secure position of knowledge.
That makes no sense. If OP pays him back what he paid in, why would he also be entitled to half of the equity? He wouldn’t have paid anything at all towards the mortgage, and therefore wouldn’t be entitled to any increase in equity.

As PP have said, if they had had a mortgage for 30 years, there’s no way OP would have to pay back 30 years of mortgage contributions, plus the increase in value.

If you were going to work it out that way, then both OP and her OH get back all of their contributions, OP also gets her deposit back, then you split any remaining increase in equity. Depending on the area they live in that may not be a very large amount of money.

TeenTitan007 · 11/02/2022 20:53

@chesirecat99 explanation makes most sense. It's not a straightforward A-B = C/2 calculation.

OP will get a ratio of the increase proportional to her deposit followed by a % of the remaining. Her DP's contributions will sit in his % of the equity. The interest he has paid will square off with the rent we would've otherwise paid. So he won't be losing the money he paid into the house - he will get that back and some more when OP buys him out by remortgaging.

mjf981 · 11/02/2022 19:52

Check if half the increase in value of the house plus half the reduction in the mortgage (since he started paying) is worth more than his total contribution. If so, you could be quids by just paying him back his contributions!