Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why Camilla will become Queen....

90 replies

Camillaxoxo · 11/02/2022 09:10

After all, Prince Phillip never became King, did he?

OP posts:
Maireas · 11/02/2022 17:03

@KittenKong

It then there’d be two queens?
Yes. When the QM was alive there were two Queens. Both Elizabeth! As someone has said upthread, old Queen Mary was still alive in 1952, so there were three Queens!
KittenKong · 11/02/2022 17:00

How mad is this - we haven’t had a chance of regent in lifetimes!

KittenKong · 11/02/2022 16:59

It then there’d be two queens?

Maireas · 11/02/2022 16:58

@KittenKong

Should Charles die and William takes over - she won’t be the Queen mother will she? Queen step mother?
No. If she'd already become Queen, she'd just be known as Queen Camilla. If Charles predeceases his mother, I suppose she'd carry on with the Duchess of Cornwall title
riotlady · 11/02/2022 16:57

@EdithWeston

Prince Philip was a prince in his own right, as part of the Greek royal family, not through being married to the Queen

He renounced his foreign princedom in order to marry Princess Elizabeth. He was recreated as. British Prince in letters patent issued in 1957. In the early years of their marriage he was simply HRH the Duke of Edinburgh

You are right, I stand corrected!
KittenKong · 11/02/2022 16:56

Should Charles die and William takes over - she won’t be the Queen mother will she? Queen step mother?

RustyBear · 11/02/2022 16:55

Actually it's not true to say a man married to the Queen could not have the title of King. He wouldn't be The King, but if Parliament wanted to give him the title of King in the same way as a Queen Consort, there's no constitutional reason why not. Phillip of Spain (who was a king in his own right) had the title when he married Mary I. It was not held to be a great success, and Queen Anne's husband was just known as Prince George (of Denmark).
Before Anne, there were King William III and Queen Mary II, who were joint monarchs, although Mary was the actual heir of her father James II, who was deemed to have abdicated when he fled the country after William III invaded. William was reputed to have refused to be his wife's 'gentleman usher' and as Mary supported him and Parliament was grateful to him for having saved them from the Catholic James, he was made joint monarch - and actually ruled alone for several years after Mary's death.
Victoria was very keen to have Albert given the title of King Consort, but was advised that Parliament wouldn't grant it; there was a fair amount of prejudice against the foreign Albert.

CheeseMuffin · 11/02/2022 16:54

Yes, and when warned by someone to not hire too many homosexuals she apparently said "without them we'd have to go self-service"!!

mixum · 11/02/2022 16:53

Queens, queens....

The late QM is reputed to have said of her "camp" male butlers/servants. -

"I don't know what those queens are doing in the kitchen, but THIS Queen wants a G+T now so tell them to hurry up!"

RoseAndRose · 11/02/2022 16:52

Thanks!!

Maybe I got misled by the name of the horse race.

CheeseMuffin · 11/02/2022 16:49

@RoseAndRose No, HM The Queen is also the title given to the spouse of the King. It isn't reserved for queens regnant, as per the list of titles the QM and Alexandra of Denmark held.

AIBU to ask why Camilla will become Queen....
AIBU to ask why Camilla will become Queen....
Itsalmostanaccessory · 11/02/2022 16:46

@riotlady
No, he wasnt. He had to give up his titles before he could marry Elizabeth. He was not a prince. He was titled Duke of Edinburgh by King George.
First the first several years of ther married he wasnt a Prince. He was just a Duke. Elizabeth then made him a Prince of the United Kingdom.

EdithWeston · 11/02/2022 16:44

Prince Philip was a prince in his own right, as part of the Greek royal family, not through being married to the Queen

He renounced his foreign princedom in order to marry Princess Elizabeth. He was recreated as. British Prince in letters patent issued in 1957. In the early years of their marriage he was simply HRH the Duke of Edinburgh

RoseAndRose · 11/02/2022 16:42

When Charles inherits then Camilla will become HM The Queen. If she outlives him then she'll become HM Queen Camilla and Kate will assume the title of HM The Queen. She won't officially be titled Queen Catherine unless she outlives William

The won't be The Queen because she isn't regnant.

Just like it was King George VI and Queen Elizabeth before his death, it will be King William V and Queen Catherine

riotlady · 11/02/2022 16:37

Prince Philip was a prince in his own right, as part of the Greek royal family, not through being married to the Queen. He could have also been Prince Consort (as married to the Queen) but declined the role and was styled Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh. There’s no option to be a King Consort because of historical sexism, King is higher than a Queen etc (hence why Elizabeth I never married and Prince Albert was Prince Consort)

The Queen is Queen Regnant (a ruler). Camilla will be Queen Consort, which is just bog standard woman married to a King and very common throughout history.

Basically the monarchy is set up for men to rule and although we’ve had female rulers throughout history, they’re uncommon enough that the rules haven’t really properly adapted to be equal.

Pedalpushers · 11/02/2022 16:33

@sabrinatheteenagemortal was about to say the same thing...Great word, queen, but suddenly lost all meaning...

CheeseMuffin · 11/02/2022 16:16

When George VI died there were 3 queens living: his mother HM Queen Mary, his widow HM Queen Elizabeth who chose to be officially styled as HM the QM and his daughter HM The Queen.

When Charles inherits then Camilla will become HM The Queen. If she outlives him then she'll become HM Queen Camilla and Kate will assume the title of HM The Queen. She won't officially be titled Queen Catherine unless she outlives William.

TheSpottedZebra · 11/02/2022 16:03

@sabrinatheteenagemortal

Is anyone else looking at the word queen and thinking it looks wrong as they have read it so much in one thread? Just me... ok.
It looks so wrong now. It looks spelt wrong, and also rude.

Queen. Queef. Queen.

Thewindwhispers · 11/02/2022 15:40

Yabu when this has been asked soooo many times and a quick google would tell you the answer

SickAndTiredAgain · 11/02/2022 15:34

Sorry, I meant use of the term , as we didn't with the Queen Mum, though I think we did with Queen Mary?

Oh I see, I think there is an element of choice in how they want to be styled. Queen Mary could have used “the queen mother” (until her son died) but didn’t. Queen Elizabeth chose to be known as The Queen Mother - possibly because there was already a dowager queen, and because she had the same name as her daughter. But she could have also been known as the dowager queen, and Camilla could as well. Camilla would presumably just be queen camilla if she was widowed, there’s more of a need for additional titles when you’ve got three queens, two of whom have the same name.

Nanny0gg · 11/02/2022 15:29

@SickAndTiredAgain

Whatever happened to the 'Dowager Queen'?

All queen mothers are dowager queens. Dowager queens are widows who were queens through their husband. Queen mothers are widows who were queens through their husband, and who are the mother of the current monarch.
“Queen mother” doesn’t mean mother of the queen, it means mother who is a (dowager) queen.

Sorry, I meant use of the term , as we didn't with the Queen Mum, though I think we did with Queen Mary?
Cofifeefee · 11/02/2022 15:28

Is anyone else looking at the word queen and thinking it looks wrong as they have read it so much in one thread? Just me... ok.

Not just you, it's a funny word when you see it over and over again!

I think it's great news for Camilla and all the frothing over whether she deserves it or not is nonsense. Firstly, none of them deserve it. Secondly why should she be punished for having an affair when Charles did the same and he gets to become King.

SickAndTiredAgain · 11/02/2022 15:20

@sabrinatheteenagemortal

Is anyone else looking at the word queen and thinking it looks wrong as they have read it so much in one thread? Just me... ok.
No, I was thinking that as I typed my last post!
sabrinatheteenagemortal · 11/02/2022 15:17

Is anyone else looking at the word queen and thinking it looks wrong as they have read it so much in one thread? Just me... ok.

SickAndTiredAgain · 11/02/2022 15:16

Whatever happened to the 'Dowager Queen'?

All queen mothers are dowager queens. Dowager queens are widows who were queens through their husband. Queen mothers are widows who were queens through their husband, and who are the mother of the current monarch.
“Queen mother” doesn’t mean mother of the queen, it means mother who is a (dowager) queen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread