Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Real human behaviour V movie human behaviour.Abusing AIBU because of the voting option.

109 replies

IncompleteSenten · 11/02/2022 06:32

I'm watching geostorm atm.
Inventor of thing gets fired. Thing goes wrong and threatens the earth. Inventor is asked to sort it out and ultimately saves the day.

He was fired by his brother after being treated like shit at a hearing.

If that was me, I would of course ultimately fix the thing because I don't want to die. Obviously. But I wouldn't just say ok and go do it.

I would say my terms are reassemble that hearing and have the man that was so rude to me publicly grovel, say I was right about everything, plead with me to help then he gets fired. THEN I go fix it.

Horror films - go help the person who's been a twat to you and get killed for your trouble. Fuck that.

Have the chance to kill the baddie and ... Don't. Seriously? You get the chance to shoot him between the eyes you take it. You don't hit him with the gun, drop it next to him and turn away. That's stupid.

YANBU. Movies are really unrealistic and people just would not behave like that.

YABU and really, there's something fucking wrong with you. You should probably get help for that.

OP posts:
Laiste · 11/02/2022 15:09

I remember watching transformers not long after we'd been to egypt (years ago) and they were all flinging themselves round the desert in leather trousers ect. and i thought - just no. I nearly fainted from the heat just staggering from the coach to the nearest patch of shade! GrinGrin

Dyrene · 11/02/2022 14:43

@NEUserNamesNotTakenJeez

Yeah, mentioned by a pp, the women waking up in perfect make up and perfect hair grinds my gears. Some heroines like Black Widow, tiny little thing, supposed to be an amazing martial artist... I'm a black belt and know for a fact a grown man twice my weight would floor me by pure physics, not to mention any woman doing high kicks and living in leather pants... Chub rub and thrush galore... I could go on but I can already hear my partner in the back of my mind saying 'it's only a movie, it's not meant to be realistic' 🙄 but look, I can get away with a man flying or zombies or sharks being irrational, just get the other things right 🙄😅
It’s always the footwear and clothing choices that get me. I remember watching buffy and thinking: if you were going out specifically to fight vampires, there’s no bloody way you’d choose heeled shoes.
ifherbumwereabungalow · 11/02/2022 14:41

I think the most unrealistic thing in films and tv is peoples ability to park directly outside where they need to be. I was watching The Responder and a woman managed to park directly outside her daughter's school despite being a bit late on the school run. It completely distracted me!

NEUserNamesNotTakenJeez · 11/02/2022 14:13

Yeah, mentioned by a pp, the women waking up in perfect make up and perfect hair grinds my gears. Some heroines like Black Widow, tiny little thing, supposed to be an amazing martial artist... I'm a black belt and know for a fact a grown man twice my weight would floor me by pure physics, not to mention any woman doing high kicks and living in leather pants... Chub rub and thrush galore...
I could go on but I can already hear my partner in the back of my mind saying 'it's only a movie, it's not meant to be realistic' 🙄 but look, I can get away with a man flying or zombies or sharks being irrational, just get the other things right 🙄😅

Calennig · 11/02/2022 14:00

Not thinking of a specific film to compare this with - just in generaI - i would never in a million years have thought that so many people could be so easily turned into such enthusiastic curtain twitching reporters of their friends and neighbours.

Sadly that didn't surprise me as I was aware of many populations - under hostile governments where people did this - often under guise of greater good.

Laiste · 11/02/2022 13:58

Never fiddling about with the shower gel and, y'know, actually washing Grin

Laiste · 11/02/2022 13:57

Oh yeah - when they show men in the shower it's always with no curtain and they're doing that leaning heavily with both hands on the wall, flexing their biceps and showering the back of the neck thing.

Calennig · 11/02/2022 13:57

They perpetuate disaster myths misconceptions like mass panic,civil disorder and helplessness of survivors are too stunned, passive, and helpless to care for themselves.

There's a fair bit of reasearch that shows in disasters we tend to go to our biological troop roots we work together and look to perceived leaders to be told what to do and do better with more information so we can make more informed decisions.

So all the times in movies they keep things from the public to avoid panic it's probably worse thing to do - while you may get some people being odd but mostly if people are kept informed in impartial factual way most people do better.

Though I do wonder if it's US culture - given how everything is politised and how that's influnced their reponse to covid - how untrusted and pollicat their media and everything else is or whether their culture is like this becuase the media and polticians don't' trust the public,maybe becuase of these myths, and the public reacts to that with distrust back.

It's not that things can't go wrong with crowds it's just sometimes the movie myths lead to actions that cause the problems.

www.bbc.com/future/article/20180312-the-secret-science-that-rules-crowds

hazelnutlatte · 11/02/2022 13:54

Someone collapses to the floor, whispers some last words and dies. Person with them (who is very much not qualified to certify death) will try to feel for a pulse, say 'he's gone' and then everyone will start crying and hugging etc.
In real life - if this happens I would hope there is someone sensible enough to call an ambulance and start CPR!

FastFood · 11/02/2022 13:52

@CounsellorTroi

Standing under the shower with mouth open. Who does that in RL?
who's even remotely sexy under the shower? They always touch their hair and their neck in a very sexy way. And I'm like doing horns or pompoms with shampoo and singing whilst applying soap between my toes in a very inelegant way.
Laiste · 11/02/2022 13:51

The post pandemic thing is interesting.

Not thinking of a specific film to compare this with - just in generaI - i would never in a million years have thought that so many people could be so easily turned into such enthusiastic curtain twitching reporters of their friends and neighbours.

FastFood · 11/02/2022 13:45

When there are two people in a car and the driver never looks at the road, just chats away to the passenger whilst looking at them. Makes me nervous!

Gosh I hate that!

There's also this thing in films / series where they always pop at someone's place unannounced and they get in as soon as the door opens.
No one - NO ONE - does that in real life, thank god.

I also see a lot of women having sex / sleeping with their bra.

Soundwave · 11/02/2022 13:45

@Ponoka7

I've voted YABU because while I'd do what you say this pandemic has shown how stupid people are. I used to get frustrated at horror films etc but have been shown that some people would behave like that. I wouldn't have enjoyed 'Dont look up' pre Covid, but now consider it possible.
Having worked in local government for a long time, I would say the Don't Look Up is very realistic. Even before Covid.

We used to joke about how in films the nuclear launch codes are super secure, need retina scans and finger prints etc . In reality, they are stuck on a post it on a white board in Barabara from accounts office. And the code is 123456789 or password.

hentheeighth · 11/02/2022 13:39

@Pedalpushers Even after the blood-curdling scream from Steve...? Maybe I'm more of a wuss than you! Grin

Laiste · 11/02/2022 13:38

irl no one ever ''splits up''.

irl no one ever stands with their back to an open doorway leading to where the monster/mad man has just been seen.

irl no one would put their child back to bed in the same room night after night where weird shit is going on.

irl no one would stay anywhere at ALL where so much weird shit is going on.

irl no one would get out of the car to 'check' what was scraping a metal object down the roof.

BUT - if you stuck to these rules they'd be hardly any horror films Grin

sashh · 11/02/2022 13:27

Only men van save the day, with very few exceptions.

I recently watched 'United 93', I know we will never know what actually happened but I'm sure the flight attendants didn't just sit there looking pretty.

They have training and will know more about the plane than most passengers.

No one discusses contraception before sex, or very rarely.

No one thinks it odd that 50 year old men have wives who are barely 30.

CounsellorTroi · 11/02/2022 13:26

@DepthOfTheAbyss

Men who keep pursuing a woman who’s told them they’re not interested. They’ll send flowers, turn up at her work and home, get her friends inside. It’s meant to be lovely and romantic. In real life its harassment and he’s a stalker.
Yes, things like flying across the world to return something, or filling the house with flowers are seen as romantic, irl they’d have me backing away sharpish.
PowerhouseOfTheCell · 11/02/2022 13:24

The main white male lead makes everyone split up (Scooby Doo style) and get intel on the ghost/ baddie. NO! Goes as a group there’s strength in numbers you fucking idiot

CounsellorTroi · 11/02/2022 13:20

Standing under the shower with mouth open. Who does that in RL?

TwoMountains · 11/02/2022 13:20

The impatience! One ring of the doorbell or knock on the door is followed 0.00003 seconds later by more ringing and knocking. What if the person is upstairs? Or having a wee?

Sounds like the delivery driver who was banging on my door this morning 🤣🤣

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 11/02/2022 13:17

Yes! The not eating the food they've chosen and paid for.

Can't imagine ever doing that (emergencies like a fire excepted). If I have bought the food I am going to eat the food!

CatJumperTwat · 11/02/2022 13:14

It's very considerate in fight scenes that the baddies patiently wait and attack the hero one by one, not overpowering him/her as a group. Buffy's villains were particularly courteous in that way.

DeeCeeCherry · 11/02/2022 13:12

When people are being chased by evil monster/zombie/whatever and they're running and wisecracking. Instead of saving their breath for running. + you'd be too shit scared to joke, surely. So annoying.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 11/02/2022 12:59

@ChristmasFluff

I once dated the idiot in the horror movie who goes into the evil-feeling cave, even though his dog is snarling and barking and refusing to go in there.
Found out recently I'm married to the idiot who wants to rent a secluded cabin in the woods, miles from anywhere, with only one bath, which is outside on the front porch Shock

I dug my heels in one the grounds that the glowing AirBnb reviews were most likely ALL from serial killers.

2Gen · 11/02/2022 12:52

@WinterCarlisle

The impatience! One ring of the doorbell or knock on the door is followed 0.00003 seconds later by more ringing and knocking. What if the person is upstairs? Or having a wee?

Also people don’t say goodbye on the phone. They just put it down even if it’s not a row. So rude! Grin

The lack of phone etiquette, yes, it really grates on me! In RL, people say "Bye" or "See you later/in a bit" or, if you're like me, it'd be "Bye, bye, bye, bye....!" I've never come across anyone who just cuts you off without saying anything along those lines at all (except scammers when they realise they're not going to be able to con you! ). If I did, I'd think they were ignorant and be annoyed!!!