Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off we won’t get the £150 rebate

286 replies

Usererror1999 · 10/02/2022 22:06

I feel like the rebate is giving with one hand and taking with the other. But now I also realise that as we are in band E: we aren’t getting the rebate at all! So it’s just “take” from us. We already pay a higher amount of council tax and we aren’t high users of council services

We aren’t rich: but we do have a fairly decent house that we make other sacrifices to afford. We work hard and pay into a pension and pay off our mortgage in the hope that we’re fairly self sufficient in old age. This just feels like a bit of a slap in the face.

OP posts:
Nospringchix · 11/02/2022 10:22

YANBU in my opinion. This should have been based on income rather than how much your house is worth. It is, after people's income from either wages and or benefits or pensions that is used to pay energy bills. ( unless of course you sell your house and live off the equity which means the hassle of moving etc)

Then there are those who do not pay £150 council tax a year because their income is extremely low eg universal credit, ESA JSA and therefore miss out on any extra help apart from the £200 that has to be paid back in the future. Some of these people will be disabled, on sick leave, and those caring for poorly relatives. They will need to find the extra money for energy bills from their benefit, which can be as low as 70 odd quid a week.

Phrowzunn · 11/02/2022 10:20

@Gowithme thank you so much, that’s exactly how I feel, like you are specifically penalised for having a SAHP
@cuno I honestly do understand how privileged I am and wouldn’t and don’t for a second begrudge taxes paying for people who need it but it’s just a bit of a hard pill to swallow to know that we are having to make sacrifices whilst paying out money to give it to people who have more than we do..? That honestly wouldn’t annoy you?

Hshuznw · 11/02/2022 10:19

I agree it’s nonsense. DH and I both earn 6 figure salaries and because we live in a D, we will get it.

My aunt rents a G, is on a very low income but needs the space, and she won’t get it.

I genuinely think it’s unfair.

Gowithme · 11/02/2022 10:10

Oh yeah and Westminster has the lowest council tax in the country I seem to recall - crazy.

@cuno - don't you think though that one parent being able to stay at home and raise their kids shouldn't be a huge privilege? It should be perfectly normal and possible if that is what they want? That the government shouldn't make everything feel designed to push women into work rather than be at home with their kids. Also the idea that people can just tell their boss that their wife has a job now so they're going to cut their hours is ludicrous.

randomsabreuse · 11/02/2022 10:05

I'm currently living in a Band E 3 bed new build semi. Previous house 4 bed 30s semi with big extensions was bumped up to a C when we bought it - it's twice the size of our current house. Main thing is that newer houses are generally higher bands than older houses which will hit younger people harder - because help to buy pushed them into having new builds as the only choice in budget

HadaVerde · 11/02/2022 10:01

If you are in a Band E house you have a house that is worth a lot. I really don't feel any sympathy that you won't get a rebate

My home is band E.

I pay £2k+ per year. I’m on a low income.

I don’t own my home. Many people don’t own a property.

Confused as to why this conversation seems centred around property ownership.

Everyone pays council tax not just homeowners.

Gowithme · 11/02/2022 09:58

OP that does sound really unfair, I imagined your house must be worth 5 or 600,000 to be in band E and thought you were being a bit grabby. We're band C and ours was valued at £325,000 a couple of years ago so it's crazy that you are band E and yours is £200,000 and you'll miss out.

There are lots of poorly thought through schemes, we don't get child benefit because OH earns too much but I earn very little, if we both earned just less than OH but had a much higher combined total we'd still get it. Doesn't make sense at all.

cuno · 11/02/2022 09:50

@Phrowzunn

I get you OP, we are a single-income household and have saved really hard to get our new house which the council decided (after we bought it!) to re-band at E so we will not get the rebate even though it would make a big difference to us. We also don’t get child benefit because of my DH’s wage. Now all of that is fine EXCEPT people I know who have two separate incomes that add up to more than our household income do still get child benefit, plus both tax free personal allowances, plus no higher rate income tax, plus the rebate because of the specific house they live in and it just feels really unfair. It should be based on joint household income in my opinion. My DH pays a ridiculous amount of tax but we get absolutely nothing back at all, nothing, because we chose to have one parent stay at home. Lots of people are much better off than us but get all this extra help that DH’s tax is paying for! It really doesn’t seem fair, but you can’t talk to anyone about it because they just tell you that if you’re not struggling to afford food every week you have no right to feel slightly peeved at the system.
You said it right in your post, all this because you chose to have a parent stay at home. You do realise right this is a massive privilege and you have to make financial sacrifices for it? Why don't you go back to work if relying on a single income is too much? Your husband could cut his hours to share childcare as well and then you'd likely be able to have all these wonderful things you speak of like child benefit, two tax free personal allowances, and no higher rate income tax while on two incomes. What's stopping you?
LemonSwan · 11/02/2022 09:50

Lol you really pushed it with those rates - thats hilarious.

2.8% with a 20% deposit and a 15 year mortgage.

Unheard of lol! Mortgage rates are nearer 1% for a 5 yr fix atm.

And if you choose to pay off a whole mortgage in less than 15 yrs then thats up to you but you cant then complain about £150 being make or break in your life.

I would go as far as to say you should spend an additional £150 on getting a financial advisor. Your paying way over odds unnecessarily.

Iggly · 11/02/2022 09:43

[quote Usererror1999]@Pinkyantelope it’s the fact that lots of people who
Have more money than I do are still getting the rebate.[/quote]
It has been known since the days of Jesus that council tax is not a fair tax.

And anyway, I wouldn’t use logical fallacy such as “but I’m not a heavy user of council tax services”. It doesn’t work that way.

Council tax only funds a portion of local authorities expenditure. Central government also provide monies direct to LAs. And you never know, you may need adult social care when you’re older.

It would be better for local authorities to be funded out of general taxation then people can get away from the nonsensical notion that “their” council tax funds everything that a LA does.

Instead of grumbling that your neighbours are getting a better deal, maybe ask yourself why 99% of us are getting a shit deal and the 1% are rolling in it.

We are suffering from the consequences of decisions made over the last few decades. Short term decisions made with no real sensible evidence under pinning them. (Privatisation. There is no evidence that the private sector is better at running services for the greater public good).

ChoiceMummy · 11/02/2022 09:41

[quote Usererror1999]@Pinkyantelope it’s the fact that lots of people who
Have more money than I do are still getting the rebate.[/quote]
It must be hard for you being capital rich!

Pinkyantelope · 11/02/2022 09:40

[quote Usererror1999]@Pinkyantelope it’s the fact that lots of people who
Have more money than I do are still getting the rebate.[/quote]
But people who've got more money than me could have a cheaper house and pay less council taxes than I do. Pensioners who are billionaires can get fuel rebates. It's impossible to make it completely fair, and would cost too much to administer.

My point is, why are you not more concerned about the people whose bills are going to be unaffordable for them even with the rebate?

There's always someone moaning about taxes but very rarely thinking about the services their taxes pay for. It's not why shouldn't I get a rebate but why should I?

Phrowzunn · 11/02/2022 09:39

I get you OP, we are a single-income household and have saved really hard to get our new house which the council decided (after we bought it!) to re-band at E so we will not get the rebate even though it would make a big difference to us. We also don’t get child benefit because of my DH’s wage. Now all of that is fine EXCEPT people I know who have two separate incomes that add up to more than our household income do still get child benefit, plus both tax free personal allowances, plus no higher rate income tax, plus the rebate because of the specific house they live in and it just feels really unfair. It should be based on joint household income in my opinion. My DH pays a ridiculous amount of tax but we get absolutely nothing back at all, nothing, because we chose to have one parent stay at home. Lots of people are much better off than us but get all this extra help that DH’s tax is paying for! It really doesn’t seem fair, but you can’t talk to anyone about it because they just tell you that if you’re not struggling to afford food every week you have no right to feel slightly peeved at the system.

BaconMassive · 11/02/2022 09:37

If you start a crowd funder for your missing £150, I'll chip in a few quid.

ChoiceMummy · 11/02/2022 09:35

@Bellringer

Poorer on benefit, low wage & housing benefit won't get it. Mad, stupid and criminal
But in that case, surely the recipient is already receiving a significant discount in their council tax?
cuno · 11/02/2022 09:19

[quote Usererror1999]@Cuno. You replied at 3am!!! I have no problem if it was means tested and only went to those who actually needed it (possibly about 25% of the country). But it’s based on council tax banding which is very random (based on house value 30 years ago, hence why our £200k house is in band E. other friends are in modest houses that are in band E. whereas there will be loads of people with more money than us getting the rebate. That’s why I’m pissed off[/quote]
No, you're pissed off because YOU are not getting the £150. The title of your thread says it all! You would not be here complaining about the morality of it if your band was included, you'd be happy in fact. Yet here you are whining about it meanwhile people have to choose between heating and eating.

ivegotthisyeah · 11/02/2022 09:17

Band E here too, single mum who just scraped through to cling onto my children house in a Recent divorce. My income is very very low but because we bought the house at the right time the mortgage is less than rent would be for a smaller house.
So no it's not fair which brainless idiots come up with these ideas is beyond me

SpaceDetective · 11/02/2022 09:16

As a blunt instrument (as means testing costs money) it doesn't strike me as ridiculously unfair. Im sure there are always some anomalies but in the county I live in 90% of houses are band A-D

Usererror1999 · 11/02/2022 09:09

@Pinkyantelope it’s the fact that lots of people who
Have more money than I do are still getting the rebate.

OP posts:
Pinkyantelope · 11/02/2022 09:00

[quote Usererror1999]@cuno I wish we were in an £1m house![/quote]
Yes but £1 million house where I live would probably be the same house as yours. A bog standard three bedroom costs between £600,000 and £1.1 million and that's just in the London suburbs, not central London.

Plus you have to remember everything else is more expensive too, like drinking in the pub, meals out, babysitting costs, nursery etc. So someone living in London on £50k is going to have a lot lower standard of living than elsewhere in the country.

I can't imagine thinking I should get a rebate in your situation. £50k salary in a £200k house is only 4x your income. To get a two bedroom flat where I live you'd have to earn £100k.

hopeishere · 11/02/2022 09:00

@Inspectorslack

Join the club.

No one in Northern Ireland is getting it.

I'm not sure what the rebate is but we did get £100 to "shop local".
Usererror1999 · 11/02/2022 08:57

@Cuno. You replied at 3am!!! I have no problem if it was means tested and only went to those who actually needed it (possibly about 25% of the country). But it’s based on council tax banding which is very random (based on house value 30 years ago, hence why our £200k house is in band E. other friends are in modest houses that are in band E. whereas there will be loads of people with more money than us getting the rebate. That’s why I’m pissed off

OP posts:
Wincher · 11/02/2022 08:55

I’m inclined to agree, OP - it is a blunt instrument. Our house is band D despite being worth prob £650k, and we are high earners. We will be donating the rebate either to our local food bank or to a charity which helps people with fuel costs. But to be fair a more equitable system would be costly to administer. Taxes for higher earners should really go up but that isn’t going to happen under a Tory government!

Usererror1999 · 11/02/2022 08:53

@ChoiceMummy we are not significantly above average income. Average salary these days is £30k. I’m on that and DH is on £25k

OP posts:
Usererror1999 · 11/02/2022 08:50

@BobbleAlong average salary in the uk is around £30k now. We don’t have a joint salary of £100k, we have a joint salary of £55k

OP posts: