Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off we won’t get the £150 rebate

286 replies

Usererror1999 · 10/02/2022 22:06

I feel like the rebate is giving with one hand and taking with the other. But now I also realise that as we are in band E: we aren’t getting the rebate at all! So it’s just “take” from us. We already pay a higher amount of council tax and we aren’t high users of council services

We aren’t rich: but we do have a fairly decent house that we make other sacrifices to afford. We work hard and pay into a pension and pay off our mortgage in the hope that we’re fairly self sufficient in old age. This just feels like a bit of a slap in the face.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 11/02/2022 19:17

@rattlehum

"Isn’t that because Westminster is almost exclusively commercial properties and there’s very little demand for services?"

No, it's because tories have cut council funding disproportionately across the U.K., meaning lots of councils - particularly those with high social care bills - have had to tax their citizens more and more. Obviously somewhere like Westminster is a bit at the extreme end because there are fewer residential houses, much higher than average wealth in those houses, and much lower than average social care costs across the borough, but the point still stands that the way people pay council tax in this country is grossly unfair.

Isn’t that what I said? 🤔
Crimesean · 11/02/2022 19:15

Look, someone has to pay - and it makes sense for those with the most assets to bear a greater burden. Whining about poverty when you're sitting on £750k plus is unbearable privilege.

The asset-rich elderly are already getting the best deal of anyone in society with years of above-inflation pension rises, universal winter fuel allowance/travel passes.

I'd like to see some cash redirected to the poorest 20% of society, especially children growing up in poverty.

KeepYaHeadUp · 11/02/2022 19:10

@BurntO

55k is well off to me… and me and my partner both work full time. The rebate is a drop in the ocean, can’t see why people are getting their knickers in a twist over it.
I think it's the implication that people living in band E properties aren't included in the "struggling" band. In my town in the south east band E properties are only slightly above an average house price. We're very much in the middle
KeepYaHeadUp · 11/02/2022 19:08

@tootyfruitypickle

I think the point is there is no perfect way and this way covers most of the low and middle earners in a simple way to administer
Is it earnings or is it amount of borrowing?
KeepYaHeadUp · 11/02/2022 19:07

We're in a band E. we're in our 30s. 2 young kids. Pushed our borrowing limit to the max with future proofing in mind. We're already at the limit and have cut spending down as much as poss. We could really do with the £150 more than we could have in our old band C property earning the same amount. Only thing that council tax bands represent for most people is amount of borrowing through a mortgage.

rattlehum · 11/02/2022 19:00

"Isn’t that because Westminster is almost exclusively commercial properties and there’s very little demand for services?"

No, it's because tories have cut council funding disproportionately across the U.K., meaning lots of councils - particularly those with high social care bills - have had to tax their citizens more and more. Obviously somewhere like Westminster is a bit at the extreme end because there are fewer residential houses, much higher than average wealth in those houses, and much lower than average social care costs across the borough, but the point still stands that the way people pay council tax in this country is grossly unfair.

Waddlegoose · 11/02/2022 18:52

Yep we are the same, council tax E yet both parents are living in bigger houses (different area of the country) and they are banded D

llansannan21 · 11/02/2022 18:47

It's not that only some people will get it, it's that there is no windfall tax on those companies who are benefiting from high energy prices or exorbitant charges during the pandemic, that I object to.

Blossomtoes · 11/02/2022 18:41

@rattlehum

Did you know that the council tax on a band D house in Westminster is about £800pa but a Band D in eg. Liverpool is over £2000pa? Doesn't help you OP but just wanted to point out how unfair council tax is in general
Isn’t that because Westminster is almost exclusively commercial properties and there’s very little demand for services?
bluemumsbluedog · 11/02/2022 18:35

@TheMoth

Nothing said in Wales about a rebate. But our ct is going up 4%.

We moved into a bigger house, because our childcare bills have finally gone down. But we're going to be worse off than before, due to everything else. And no pay increase this year at all.

Do people in England pay extra for garden waste?

We have to pay for garden waste here in Powys mid wales
ivykaty44 · 11/02/2022 18:34

We won’t get it either as we’re an E. It’s really unfair and I don’t think it’s right that those in higher bands have to sub others.

No different from other tax, the more you buy the more you pay.

If you have more medical treatment on NHS should I complain it’s unfair as I’ve had to sub you?

PickledOnionSandwich · 11/02/2022 18:32

We won’t get it either as we’re an E. It’s really unfair and I don’t think it’s right that those in higher bands have to sub others.

Feelingoktoday · 11/02/2022 18:27

Each local authority is also getting a discretionary pot of money to hand out to those not in band A-D but meet other criteria ie tax credits etc but they are still deciding how to pay this.

At the moment it is a big logistic nightmare. 40% of our council tax payers are not on DD so we will have to get their bank details as at the moment although the Govt calls it a council tax discount/rebate legally it isn’t and so it cannot be offset against your council tax bill. As usual this govt is shit and never thought about the mechanics.

Nospringchix · 11/02/2022 16:54

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Get a bloody parent of a big family in charge of this country, it'll be ship shape and running like clockwork in no time.

Boris is the parent of a big family - thy just don't all live in the same household....

Unfortunately not all of the desperately poor will get it. Those on basic UC of 70 something a week don't always pay as much as 150 a year council tax, so will have less than 150 extra to help.towards energy bills. Some possibly pay no council tax so will not have any extra at all.

No, there are always some who will slip through and be completely forgotten/ignored. However, if it's a rebate, shouldn't that go against ALL qualifying households' accounts? Thus if I owed the council, say, £160 for a month and got a £150 rebate, I would owe them £10; if somebody on UC owed them £10 a month and got the £150 rebate, the council would then owe them (and pay them) £140 - or at the very least, keep it on their account so that they would eventually get 15 months of free CT? I realise I'm probably dreaming in even asking this....

I hope that is the case. It would make it much more fair, but yes we are probably dreaming...
NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/02/2022 16:45

@Cockle1234

Yes because the property value is higher. But that's exactly why the disabled band reduction scheme exists, which quite rightly accounts for that scenario
It doesn't. I appealed against the banding and it was refused because it wasn't an older property that had been converted, it was purpose built nearly twenty years earlier.

Basically, 4 bed Victorian valued at say £48,000 in the early 1990s pays band C and happens to be worth around £786,000 now.

2 bed flatpack built in 2010 theoretically worth around £186,000 pays Band G. Because it didn't exist in 1992. The house opposite in band C would have been around £385,000 on the same day.

It's always been a lower value in comparison. But purely because it didn't exist decades previously, it's 'worth more'? And because I couldn't get an accessible property that had stood in the area for twenty years, I should pay more just for being disabled?

That's the point. It's not worth more than the expensive and valuable properties opposite. Never has been, never will be. But it costs me more and I won't be eligible for any help because I am disabled and needed that rental property.

AmbushedByCake1 · 11/02/2022 16:44

Council tax isn't fair in the first place. I have a 2 bed house, band d, and I pay one of the most expensive council tax rates in the country; £2300 a year.

ditalini · 11/02/2022 16:36

@SpaceDetective

I'm curious about what parts of the country have 200k Band E houses.
I live in a Band E 3 bed flat. It's worth about £170k.

In this area there's about a 1 band anomaly between property built before 1991 and property build around 10 years later and newer. As there are a lot of very expensive period properties in the area it means that a house or flat worth 2 or 3 times more than mine and with rooms twice the size, within a mile, will often be Band D.

You'd hear the screams a thousand miles away if there was a rebanding though so noone will ever touch it.

I'm not fussed about the £150.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/02/2022 16:22

Get a bloody parent of a big family in charge of this country, it'll be ship shape and running like clockwork in no time.

Boris is the parent of a big family - thy just don't all live in the same household....

Unfortunately not all of the desperately poor will get it. Those on basic UC of 70 something a week don't always pay as much as 150 a year council tax, so will have less than 150 extra to help.towards energy bills. Some possibly pay no council tax so will not have any extra at all.

No, there are always some who will slip through and be completely forgotten/ignored. However, if it's a rebate, shouldn't that go against ALL qualifying households' accounts? Thus if I owed the council, say, £160 for a month and got a £150 rebate, I would owe them £10; if somebody on UC owed them £10 a month and got the £150 rebate, the council would then owe them (and pay them) £140 - or at the very least, keep it on their account so that they would eventually get 15 months of free CT? I realise I'm probably dreaming in even asking this....

Whitefire · 11/02/2022 15:32

OP I understand your pov a bit more as you have expanded.

The calls to downsize / cheaper property are strange. As I said previously I upsized both property and area wise and my CT went down a band. The difference being my new house is a 1960's build, the former was built in 2000.

rattlehum · 11/02/2022 15:23

Did you know that the council tax on a band D house in Westminster is about £800pa but a Band D in eg. Liverpool is over £2000pa?
Doesn't help you OP but just wanted to point out how unfair council tax is in general

CornishGem1975 · 11/02/2022 15:10

@Monopolyiscrap

If you can afford a band E property you are well off. If you have an expensive house you can't afford to upkeep, then downsize.
That's a crock of shit.
Cockle1234 · 11/02/2022 15:08

Yes because the property value is higher. But that's exactly why the disabled band reduction scheme exists, which quite rightly accounts for that scenario

girlmom21 · 11/02/2022 15:05

If your house is worth £200k and you're paying £1000 a month on your mortgage is your mortgage over a short term? That's a lot.

Although I agree with the others you're just complaining to be contrary - you don't need the money.

Those who are getting the reduction are having to pay it back anyway. It's an involuntary 'loan'

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/02/2022 15:00

[quote ChoiceMummy]@HadaVerde
I'm yet to find many people living in social housing that is a 1 room studio flat, unless they're choosing to live in an expensive metropolitan area.

So more rooms, garden etc should quite rightly mean higher banding.[/quote]
So needing level access from the street, wetroom and wiring/preconstructed framing in place in case a wheelchair lift is necessary, plus enough turning space/open plan downstairs to get into the wetroom should quite rightly mean higher banding than huge houses with massive gardens opposite that just happened to be built before an arbitrary date?

HadaVerde · 11/02/2022 14:56

[quote ChoiceMummy]@HadaVerde
I'm yet to find many people living in social housing that is a 1 room studio flat, unless they're choosing to live in an expensive metropolitan area.

So more rooms, garden etc should quite rightly mean higher banding.[/quote]
My home is identical to my neighbours and their homes are band D. It is a normal size family home.

There is very often no sense to CT bandings and they don’t necessarily indicate current value…or occupants wealth.