Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off we won’t get the £150 rebate

286 replies

Usererror1999 · 10/02/2022 22:06

I feel like the rebate is giving with one hand and taking with the other. But now I also realise that as we are in band E: we aren’t getting the rebate at all! So it’s just “take” from us. We already pay a higher amount of council tax and we aren’t high users of council services

We aren’t rich: but we do have a fairly decent house that we make other sacrifices to afford. We work hard and pay into a pension and pay off our mortgage in the hope that we’re fairly self sufficient in old age. This just feels like a bit of a slap in the face.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 10/02/2022 23:05

@Crinkle77

We’re using less - no kids, no need for social services. All we use is refuse collection and roads. BUT we live in a house worth £600k and have above average incomes so it’s only fair that we don’t get a subsidy we don’t need.

Council tax pays for a lot more than roads, refuse and social services. It also pays for police, fire, parks & recreation, environmental health, trading standards, registry offices and local elections.

The point I was making is that we as a household use very few of the services on offer. We don’t need a subsidy of £15 a month.
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/02/2022 23:02

One common marker of household poverty is families with a lot of children - and the likelihood is that many of them will of necessity have to live in a bigger house, which is more likely to be in band E or above.

They will miss out, whereas a theoretical very wealthy childfree couple who spend so much of their time abroad on holiday/business and on world cruises that it's not worth their while maintaining anything more than a small, cheap flat in the UK for the few weeks a year when they're at home would get the full rebate.

nettie434 · 10/02/2022 23:02

@ENoeuf

Council tax banding needs to be revisited every five years or something. We are band E and the band D houses next door are bigger and better thanks to extensions and improvements.
That is the real problem. No government has dared to reform council tax in England. The Welsh government is due to have a consultation on reform later this year and I think there were some minor reforms in Scotland. The system is different in Ireland where they kept the rates.

Given the rise in property prices since 1991, it is ridiculous that council tax bandings are based on property prices in 1991. That is why the refund is unfair. It should have been linked to income.

stickysellotape · 10/02/2022 23:02

We’re band E in a tiny terraced house because properties have all been rebanded here Hmm

Crinkle77 · 10/02/2022 23:01

We’re using less - no kids, no need for social services. All we use is refuse collection and roads. BUT we live in a house worth £600k and have above average incomes so it’s only fair that we don’t get a subsidy we don’t need.

Council tax pays for a lot more than roads, refuse and social services. It also pays for police, fire, parks & recreation, environmental health, trading standards, registry offices and local elections.

MRS54321 · 10/02/2022 23:01

Ach doesn’t it al need paid back in dribs n drabs anyways? The fuel one?

Fuck it OP I qualify, I’d rather not bother tbh .. seems pointless as I don’t see Life getting any cheaper to the point where I’ll be buzzing to pay back £200

VictoriaBlossom · 10/02/2022 22:58

Feel your pain. I tried to get my band looked at as I literally scrape in the E band. Single garage and 1 parking space but because the square footage of the house is 5% more than the band D 40yds away they’re saying they won’t budge.
I don’t really see how £150 will help people who are making the choice between heating and eating. Maybe sort out the big fuel companies making so much money so they’re incentivised to keep pricing reasonable!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/02/2022 22:57

The idea is that everybody who is of average means (in a Band D house) or below will get it, and those better off than that won't need it as much.

We all know that it's a very crude way of blanket-assessing it, and can be extremely unfair - like with so many government schemes - but that's the way they've chosen.

If they had total confidence that your CT band was directly linked with how well-off you are, they could/would have given a sliding scale of rebate e.g. £120 for band D, £140 for band C, £160 for band B and £180 for band A; but this would just shine even more of a light on how unfair it is to many people. basing it on such an arbitrary system, with a huge amount of variables.

It will probably mean that most of the most desperately poor WILL get it, as not many of them will live in band E and above homes, but you're right that it is a massively flawed broad-brush approach, which will exclude a lot of people who will also be really struggling financially.

Itscoldouthere · 10/02/2022 22:56

@NeesAndToes but I thought this rebate was to ‘help’ people to pay towards rising fuel bills, not rising council tax.
The council tax system is just being used as a way of delivering the ‘help’ so it still means students are missing out.

Monopolyiscrap · 10/02/2022 22:54

@Usererror1999

DH and I work full time too... but £55k actually works out at £27.5 k each which is below Average salary
It is higher than the average household income.
caranations · 10/02/2022 22:54

@Usererror1999

I don’t think the “less council tax” would make up for the costs of moving.

I don’t actually agree with council tax bandings: I think a tax on income or by household or overall wealth would be fairer. Because my house was worth x in 1991 seems a bit random to determine I pay more in council tax

Hahahahaha.

Margaret Thatcher tried that. It was called the Poll Tax. You might like to look it up and see what happened.

houselikeashed · 10/02/2022 22:53

A bit along the same lines as only certain self employed people got any covid financial help. meh.

labyrinthlaziness · 10/02/2022 22:53

I don't think this scheme is good but if you are a Tory voter, it is tough shit - the Tories are unfair bastards, this time you are on the wrong end of it.

The other scheme is shite too, borrow now and pay it back later. Thanks so much Rishi.

Monopolyiscrap · 10/02/2022 22:52

@lightsoutminty

Sooooo.. what happens when all of the band Es decide to downsize? It's a ridiculous system that squeezes the middle and people will vote with their options. Before anyone has a go at me for being a mad Tory or totally bougie - I'm neither. But I do have the option to leave the country, even as an extreme option, which by the way no longer feels extreme as an immigrant. And then we have brain drain. Good luck sustaining an economy.
Don't be ridiculous. No one is going to move from a house at these prices because you aren't getting a one-off £150 rebate.
cuno · 10/02/2022 22:49

[quote Usererror1999]@cuno yeah, but I still wish I lived in one[/quote]
If that's your main takeaway from what I wrote, then you've clearly missed my point.

Feelingoktoday · 10/02/2022 22:47

Collecting garden waste is not a statutory service so therefore councils can choose to charge. My council charges. This income goes into the general pot to be spent funding homelessness, street cleansing etc.

Usererror1999 · 10/02/2022 22:47

@cuno yeah, but I still wish I lived in one

OP posts:
tootyfruitypickle · 10/02/2022 22:46

I do think that the money should have gone to lower earners . I earn what you do and am a lone parent. I certainly struggle every month to balance the budget, but I also work with clients who are on the breadline and desperate - this govt just has no idea as shown by giving middle earners a rebate .

ENoeuf · 10/02/2022 22:45

Council tax banding needs to be revisited every five years or something. We are band E and the band D houses next door are bigger and better thanks to extensions and improvements.

cuno · 10/02/2022 22:45

[quote Usererror1999]@cuno I wish we were in an £1m house![/quote]
I didn't say that you live in a million pound house!

Usererror1999 · 10/02/2022 22:42

@cuno I wish we were in an £1m house!

OP posts:
cuno · 10/02/2022 22:41

@TheMoth

Nothing said in Wales about a rebate. But our ct is going up 4%.

We moved into a bigger house, because our childcare bills have finally gone down. But we're going to be worse off than before, due to everything else. And no pay increase this year at all.

Do people in England pay extra for garden waste?

I'm in England and I think it varies by council, but in my council we have to pay for garden waste.
TheMoth · 10/02/2022 22:39

Nothing said in Wales about a rebate. But our ct is going up 4%.

We moved into a bigger house, because our childcare bills have finally gone down. But we're going to be worse off than before, due to everything else. And no pay increase this year at all.

Do people in England pay extra for garden waste?

TheHateIsNotGood · 10/02/2022 22:38

I have heard lots of Tories are complaining that this policy is a bit too 'socialist' for their liking. You can't win for losing.

With every 'redistribution' policy there are winners and losers, this time you're a loser OP and I'd just take it on the chin and count your blessings (agnostically) and put things into perspective.

£150 off an annual Council Tax Bill does make a positive difference to me, it's one of the largest monthly bills I have (Band B).

cuno · 10/02/2022 22:38

I don't think people sitting in million pound houses should be getting £150 rebate for their energy bills, so a line has to be drawn somewhere and unfortunately for you Band E is where the line is drawn. However, council bands can be nonsensical as they are based on 1991 valuations which do not reflect the current value and the massive skyrocketing house prices in some areas. And new builds can be in super high bands but no better or bigger than older houses in much lower bands. I think the system used for calculating council tax needs a massive upheaval really.

Swipe left for the next trending thread