Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No not understand how our NHS dentist can say our whole family of 5 are now not NHS and must pay private monthly fees to stay

207 replies

P3ff3r · 10/02/2022 21:34

Said monthly plan doesn’t even cost of treatment.

We were NHS, how can we not now be and who can afford private x5 at the drop of a hat like that?

OP posts:
Mollysocks · 11/02/2022 09:04

So its right that a huge amount of people only go to the dentist when they are in pain.

Yes because shocker not everyone can afford a dental plan. You’re talking from a very privileged viewpoint if you can’t understand this and think it’s because they don’t want to. No one wants bad teeth ffs.

We dont want to spend ANY money on them, we want the NHS to fund it

See above. Also, that is what the NHS is for. (At least that’s why Aneurin Bevan set it up) To provide healthcare for all, those who can’t afford it. Have you had any NHS treatment at all? A GP appointment perhaps? Why do you expect the NHS to pay for that and not dentistry? I’m assuming all your healthcare is private or you’re a hypocrite.

Angrymum22 · 11/02/2022 09:03

It’s probably to do with the NHS funding, when the patient fee goes up in April their UDA rate may be less than the fees they collect and will be paying the government back the excess. So if you pay £25 for a check up the dentist gets £24 pounds and has to pay £1 back to the government. If they go private and charge you £25 they get to keep the whole £25.
UDA rates differ from dentist to dentist. The contract I work under will be going private in the next couple of years. We will probably lose 70-80% of our patients but since we have very few exempt patients we will retain enough private patients to still earn the same amount of money. I am looking forward to it. I can use quality materials and spend the time actually needed for good preventative dentistry.
The UDA debacle was the idea of the labour government back in the early 2000s. A truly socialist idea where everyone pays the same fee but some get more for their money than others and thereby are subsidised by other patients payments.
The UDA value was calculated by some weird formula based on activity in 2004 ( I was on maternity leave and in true NHS form they didn’t factor in what to do if dentists were pregnant so had no plan or fair way of calculating my UDA rate, there were not enough of us to bother with. Since we are self employed ant discrimination claim was brushed under the carpet and to be honest who is going to sympathise with a dentist) I could go into great detail how it is patients who have been discriminated against by the system but that’s a whole different thread.

dentistattic · 11/02/2022 09:01

In Scotland we do have continuous registration. We also have a few per item
System of remuneration. It's different contracts for various parts of UK.
One thing we all have in common is that we are self employed.

However if I have a choice of doing "nice" dentistry, in a relaxed environment, using good materials, and get well paid for it, without time pressures, or doing a rushed job with substandard materials in a surgery that's not well maintained, with additional bureaucracy, not to mention being poorly paid, I know which one I'd rather do

NOTANUM · 11/02/2022 09:00

I should clarify- London is so populated that 5 miles is like 20 miles outside. No dentist or doctor would consider you as a patient at that distance.

NommyChompers · 11/02/2022 09:00

The public need to wake up and realise that last week it was pharmacist, this week it is dentists, next week it is GPs and then it’s the rest of the NHS.

The Tories are privatising by stealth

NommyChompers · 11/02/2022 08:59

@Mollysocks if my patients would rather assume the worst of me as a person rather than blame those responsible for the mess (government) then that I wouldn’t lose any sleep going private. I only stay flogging myself in the nhs because I care about my patients. If they don’t feel the same I’d leave tomorrow.

You can’t force people to stay in their jobs

NOTANUM · 11/02/2022 08:58

I live in London and there isn’t an NHS dentist within 5 miles. There have been very few for a long time.
I sat on a table of dentists recently at a wedding and they were extraordinarily wealthy: weekend houses, exotic holidays, kids at top private schools.
Perhaps medicine is the same but those I know doing private work are also senior NHS consultants whereas dentists have gone exclusively private.
It is incredible how fast the NHS is moving to a US model.

SusannaQueen · 11/02/2022 08:56

I also wonder how many people now have private medical insurance.

We've always had some form of medical insurance, but it just gets prohibitively more expensive as you age, and harder to change when you are more likely to have acquired an ailment or two along the way.

Mollysocks · 11/02/2022 08:55

[quote BungleandGeorge]@SilverontheTree it’s not true that if you go to the dentist regularly and look after your teeth you’ll never need any complex treatment is it? And the cut off for free dentistry is about 15k annual salary.

OP what I would say is that £10 per month for an under 16 is very expensive for even private dentistry and I would shop around. For some reason all the dentists I’ve looked at do charge full price for 16-18 which makes no sense[/quote]
Exactly I looked after mine perfectly. I have a small mouth and my dentist when I was a child didn’t take enough of my teeth out to account for my wisdom teeth. So when they came through they impacted into my sinus cavity, became infected and I couldn’t chew for 2 months. Nothing to do with looking after teeth!

SusannaQueen · 11/02/2022 08:52

DD hasn't had NHS dental care since she was 10. I also haven't had NHS for a long, long time. I'm sick of private care, I've had so much work that I'm suspicious that I didn't need, they do x rays at the drop of a hat. They wanted to do major work on DDs teeth with a brace, then it turned out they couldn't as she has no wisdom teeth, yet 6yrs later her teeth are fineHmm.
We struggle to afford it, although we do have insurance.

Franklin12 · 11/02/2022 08:52

So its right that a huge amount of people only go to the dentist when they are in pain. Its also correct that we have a reputation for bad teeth. We dont want to spend ANY money on them, we want the NHS to fund it and even then we often cannot be bothered to use the service.

I have a couple of dentists in the family (retired). They did ooh service and found people messed them around so much I think they were massively relieved when they hung up their toothbrushes.

As I have said on previous threads. We need to review the NHS as a whole. It needs a massive shake up which will sensibly be required to pay something towards for their treatment.

But I dont think that is going to happen anytime soon. I also wonder how many people now have private medical insurance. I used to have it with my old company left it for a few years and am now funding it again.

NommyChompers · 11/02/2022 08:51

@longwayoff hate to break it to you but According to the contract there is no such thing as being registered unless you are in the middle of a course of treatment.

The registration thing is more of a tradition to reward loyal patients. Maybe reconsider how you talk to the staff at the dental practice or you may find them reminding you that They are really only seeing you as a courtesy.

BungleandGeorge · 11/02/2022 08:51

@SilverontheTree it’s not true that if you go to the dentist regularly and look after your teeth you’ll never need any complex treatment is it? And the cut off for free dentistry is about 15k annual salary.

OP what I would say is that £10 per month for an under 16 is very expensive for even private dentistry and I would shop around. For some reason all the dentists I’ve looked at do charge full price for 16-18 which makes no sense

Mollysocks · 11/02/2022 08:50

@NommyChompers

Im one of those NHS dentists who was working full time for frankly no where near enough money to justify the stress (I’m a soft touch!) and honestly these threads make me want to change career. Clearly all my patients think I’m swindling them.

We aren’t running a con - there’s just not enough money to make it viable to stay open on the NHS and if a dentist leaves a practice and they can’t recruit then they will obviously have to cut patients. The contract and this government failing to fix it or train enough of us (and losing lots of dentists to Brexit) are to blame but really dentistry has been declining for a long time.

If the country wants more NHS dentists they need to make the job more attractive!

We aren’t running a con - there’s just not enough money to make it viable to stay open on the NHS …

Can you see why people think this though? Dentists just bumping people off the books for no reason (most had ongoing treatment and/or were attending regular check ups) forcing people to go private. Imagine if GPs did that, why is it different for dentists?

endlesssighing · 11/02/2022 08:48

Bloody hell.

Ours has been private for years but no monthly fees!

£25 for a child's check up.

£60 for an adult's.

Work on top.

DD will need braces god bless her but I'm hoping the orthodontist will be NHS if not subsidised.

DirtyDancing · 11/02/2022 08:47

I am private but my two kids are NHS & free at my dentist. I don't pay anything for them and just sign a NHS form each time they are seen.

NommyChompers · 11/02/2022 08:45

@BungleandGeorge said it better ^

longwayoff · 11/02/2022 08:45

I'm interested that no appointment for 2 years is being given as a reason to ditch patients. I managed to prise my way into my dentist's in December and the schoolboy - maybe not but he looked about 12 - new dentist said I hadn't attended in the last 2 years. Not so, I've never missed a dental check up in the last 10 years, ditto hygienist. Any cancellations were by them and due to covid. We had a firm exchange of views with me insisting he check the records right now in my presence. I wonder if they would have ditched me quietly if I hadn't chipped a tooth and insisted I needed an appointment which, coincidentally, fell within the 2 years since last appointment. I'm considering insurance now.

NommyChompers · 11/02/2022 08:44

Im one of those NHS dentists who was working full time for frankly no where near enough money to justify the stress (I’m a soft touch!) and honestly these threads make me want to change career. Clearly all my patients think I’m swindling them.

We aren’t running a con - there’s just not enough money to make it viable to stay open on the NHS and if a dentist leaves a practice and they can’t recruit then they will obviously have to cut patients. The contract and this government failing to fix it or train enough of us (and losing lots of dentists to Brexit) are to blame but really dentistry has been declining for a long time.

If the country wants more NHS dentists they need to make the job more attractive!

BungleandGeorge · 11/02/2022 08:42

@Laiste

So - pp said all dentists are self employed and none have to do NHS work.

Now - genuine question - what other health profession is like this? Are ALL surgeons, for example, also self employed?

(When my mother went private for a knee op a few years ago she saw the same surgeon she would have seen if she'd sat on the NHS waiting list. Going private is just paying to jump the queue to see the same person)

I mean if all the health professions who are all self employed (as a pp said dentists are) eventually refused to care for NHS patients what would happen?! And if there's something stopping this happening then why doesn't it currently apply to dentists?

Pharmacies, GP surgeries, opticians are all private businesses with NHS contracts. So the majority of primary care. It’s really as simple as if the government would like a service provided they need to pay for it. But they’ve slashed funding so a large amount of pharmacies closed, Dentists can no longer do NHS work, there aren’t enough GPs. Nobody is obliged to do any job and intelligent and well trained employees are in demand either for private work or in alternative careers. Making contracts unviable is a way of privatisation without the big announcement
SilverontheTree · 11/02/2022 08:41

Hospital doctors are employed. Obviously if they choose not to work in an NHS hospital they can work privately on a self employed basis. Most don’t.

Jjjaaakkk · 11/02/2022 08:40

The system is crumbling because it’s run by bureaucrats who simply don’t understand dentistry. And the government don’t care. Lobby your MPs for change or nothing will

dentistattic · 11/02/2022 08:39

My dentist must have had a good regular income from denplan during the covid months. I paid for a service I could not access.

To be fair, Denplan was amazing! Denplan fees during lockdown allowed me to pay my overheads fir a few months, such as GDC registration, indemnity, insurance, practice heating/IT bills, HR and accountancy support in a crisis time. Denplan fees helped to pay my nurses what I could.

It was a time that was "unprecedented" as has been quoted many times. I wouldn't call it a regular income so much as a way of avoiding total bankruptcy.

We we were allowed to open up again in July, we made sure our Denplan patients were prioritised. Denplan themselves have us an allocation of PPE to help make this happen. So whilst there was a delay in checkups, in the same way that lockdown caused a delay in MOTs, haircuts and driving tests, we still did manage to make sure that all Denplan patients got their two yearly checkups in 2020. The occasional one that slipped through the net either got their payments frozen for several months, or money back. I didn't lose a single patient.

What do I think will happen with NHS dentistry? I think it will go the same way as a lot of other countries such as Ireland, USA and Australia. There will be a core basic service provided by the government to cover emergencies and toothaches. Everything else will need to be private. The only way I see that NOT happening, is if the government invest significantly in the service

SilverontheTree · 11/02/2022 08:37

I think if left to this government (or in fact labour who brought in the massive con that was the 2006 contract!) then the dental health of the nation will be a mess. But it already is! Lots of people smoke, eat loads of sugar, not cleaning properly and only turn up in pain. When they only turn up in pain they then end up with an extraction or expensive complex treatment. If they came regularly they would be able to have a small filling.
Personally I think we need a core system whereby only children and exempt adults get NHS which entities you to exam, scale, fillings, extractions, root fillings and crowns for front teeth and premolars but not molars. Plastic dentures to replace front teeth.
This should be claimed for from the nhs on a fee per item system but free to the patient. Adults who aren’t exempt and therefore earn enough to pay, pay privately.

RosesAndHellebores · 11/02/2022 08:36

DS had slightly gappy teeth. He did not meet the bar for NHS orthodontics as work was cosmetic only. It cost just under £3k. He pays to have his teeth whitened; they were naturally not gleaming white.