Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No not understand how our NHS dentist can say our whole family of 5 are now not NHS and must pay private monthly fees to stay

207 replies

P3ff3r · 10/02/2022 21:34

Said monthly plan doesn’t even cost of treatment.

We were NHS, how can we not now be and who can afford private x5 at the drop of a hat like that?

OP posts:
dentistattic · 11/02/2022 11:43

I have a small mouth and my dentist when I was a child didn’t take enough of my teeth out to account for my wisdom teeth. So when they came through they impacted into my sinus cavity, became infected and I couldn’t chew for 2 months

I'm a dentist. Wisdom teeth are only present in about 50% of the population. They don't erupt until on average about age 19. Unless you were to take a panoramic radiograph on a child routinely ( unusual) it's unlikely that the presence of future wisdom teeth could be spotted. Even then, they may not be visible on a child's radiograph as teeth haven't developed yet.

MarineBlue33 · 11/02/2022 11:41

I have no idea how dentists' contracts work but I know that they are very well paid. We have a few dentists in my family and I know a friend who is one too. All their children are in private school, holidays to far flung places and flashy cars. There is NOT one that doesn't fall into that category. Honestly when think my local dentist will not do many treatments on the NHS, I am saddened. I can't afford to have a £2k implant.
I think dental contract need to be reevaluated.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 11/02/2022 11:41

Pharmacies, GP surgeries, opticians are all private businesses with NHS contracts. So the majority of primary care. It’s really as simple as if the government would like a service provided they need to pay for it. But they’ve slashed funding so a large amount of pharmacies closed, Dentists can no longer do NHS work, there aren’t enough GPs. Nobody is obliged to do any job and intelligent and well trained employees are in demand either for private work or in alternative careers. Making contracts unviable is a way of privatisation without the big announcement

This. I think it's partly about privatisation, but actually more about cost-saving by stealth. Richer people will pay to go privately, so it's "only" those on lower incomes who will suffer.

Threads like these show how effective the Government's tactics are. 90% of posters blame the dentists, not the Government. Same with GPs - it's our fault they're aren't enough of us, apparently, and we've all been sitting on our arses throughout Covid (even though the Dept of Health figures show our workload has gone up 27% in 2 years).

The public are so easily fooled. And by the time you all wake up, it will be too late. Actually, it's already too late.

Hathertonhariden · 11/02/2022 11:41

@Hellosunshiner

Mollysocks "Exactly I looked after mine perfectly. I have a small mouth and my dentist when I was a child didn’t take enough of my teeth out to account for my wisdom teeth. So when they came through they impacted into my sinus cavity, became infected and I couldn’t chew for 2 months. Nothing to do with looking after teeth!"

Off topic slightly but I would be surprised if dentists take out teeth of a child to account for wisdom teeth that haven't yet erupted? That would be far too premature as some wisdom teeth don't ever come through and when they do it's normally the wisdom teeth that are removed, not molars.

I also have a small mouth etc and when my wisdom teeth started erupting (but were impacted due to limited space), the wisdom teeth were all removed under general anaesthetic before they could make a problem.

This was a 70s thing. I had several healthy teeth removed as a child to make space. Either thinking of the time or a procedure that dentists could get additional payments for.
Pembertonrd · 11/02/2022 11:38

@Orchid876 my dgs dentist refused to allow him NHS treatment and were going to charge adult price for his checkup. I told my ds to query this based on the dentist being fully reimbursed for a dc and magically the price dropped.

Barney60 · 11/02/2022 11:37

This was on the news last week. Most NHS dentists are swopping over to private.
Im private i pay £14 a month i get a check up and clean and polish every 6 months, plus a discount off any other treatments i may need, a friend of mine paid more than i pay in a year for a check up and filling he needed NHS.

dentistattic · 11/02/2022 11:37

@Hankunamatata Denplan Care would work for you then, as all treatment cover with the exception of lab bills and cosmetic treatment such as whitening etc

Orchid876 · 11/02/2022 11:33

And as an aside, we use a private dentist that doesn't take on adult NHS patients, but our kids get free NHS treatment because me and DH are patients. That's at least worth pursuing, even if you can't find an NHS dentist for everyone, you should at least be able to find one that will take the adults on privately, but treat the kids under the NHS.

Orchid876 · 11/02/2022 11:30

There's no way I'd pay a monthly fee to a Dentist just to stay on their patient list. You'd be better off paying monthly for insurance so at least treatment would be covered. If you can't find another NHS dentist then maybe look into that, and choose another dentist regardless. I'm sure you'd be able to find another private dentist that doesn't insist on a monthly fee, I've never heard of such rubbish!

Hellosunshiner · 11/02/2022 11:20

Mollysocks "Exactly I looked after mine perfectly. I have a small mouth and my dentist when I was a child didn’t take enough of my teeth out to account for my wisdom teeth. So when they came through they impacted into my sinus cavity, became infected and I couldn’t chew for 2 months. Nothing to do with looking after teeth!"

Off topic slightly but I would be surprised if dentists take out teeth of a child to account for wisdom teeth that haven't yet erupted? That would be far too premature as some wisdom teeth don't ever come through and when they do it's normally the wisdom teeth that are removed, not molars.

I also have a small mouth etc and when my wisdom teeth started erupting (but were impacted due to limited space), the wisdom teeth were all removed under general anaesthetic before they could make a problem.

IggyAce · 11/02/2022 11:19

A few years ago the dental practice I’d been with since childhood decided it would no longer offer nhs and would become completely private, luckily I found another nhs dentist.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 11/02/2022 11:18

@ENoeuf

^^ that’s really rubbish pinkpussycat ours at least kept us on even though they cancelled twice. Husband just scraped back in.
I decided to phone them as it wasn't actually my fault I haven't been and much to my surprise I'm still registered. I've made an appointment for a check up in June as I recently saw a private dentist.
Monopolyiscrap · 11/02/2022 11:13

Our NHS dentist moved to private only work. None of us now have checkups.

FlibbertyGibbitt · 11/02/2022 11:13

I’ve been at the same practice since I was little (56 now) one of the nhs dentists back in the 80s filled teeth for the sake of it.

My present dentist joined in 1998, went private in the later 2000s. He is fab. However he said to me that nhs dentists are so stressed trying to get patients through the door, it was just awful.

They’ve been through so much through the pandemic but I can see mine. NOW if you want to see a GP at my practice that’s a different story ! My daughter in law is 11 weeks pregnant and cannot see a midwife or GP. The nhs is stuffed.

longwayoff · 11/02/2022 11:12

In 5 years time this conversation will be about GPs. This is just a practice run for ditching all but emergency NHS provision across the board.

Zilla1 · 11/02/2022 11:10

Have a lot of empathy for NHS dentists, during lockdown the commercials were highly adverse. Outside COVID, the funding envelope and contract/model appears highly adverse. Suspect at a political level, NHS dentistry has been a model for the sabotage of GP services - undermining provision, corporatisation and encouraging private insurance for the relatively wealthy and healthy. I think it will take a change in government relatively soon to short-circuit that. If not, dentists, like GPs, will be financially much better off as a result of the changes and less wealthy patients much worse off.

Frenchrugby · 11/02/2022 11:07

And equally hospital doctors are employed - which again is different. My DH loves his work, but there are many times when I look at our insurances needed for self employed sickness and we take the hit on earnings - as all self employed do - when we go on holiday - that I think employment has definite advantages!

I think the BDA latest survey says average dental salaries are £58k. For a stressful and hard to get into profession. We won’t be encouraging our children to go into this field.

Namechangehereandnow · 11/02/2022 11:04

From the nhs website:

If after contacting several dental surgeries you still cannot find a dentist accepting NHS patients, call NHS England's Customer Contact Centre on 0300 311 2233.

NHS England commissions dental services in England and is required to meet the needs of their local population for both urgent and routine dental care.

Frenchrugby · 11/02/2022 11:01

My DH is a dentist - he is fully private.
Two things to note as i understand them - often the cost that patients pay on the nhs is, like prescription charges, not the same as the actual cost a procedure costs to do. Neither is it the amount that the dentist doing the procedure is paid. What patients pay goes to the treasury. The dentist’s nhs contract pays them. So whilst from a patient perspective you look at nhs charges and private charges and compare them, from the dentists perspective it isn’t a case of looking at those two amounts.
Secondly, comparing gps and dentists nhs remuneration can’t be done. Dentists are paid on a patient seen basis - gps are paid differently. I believe gps can also get contributions to premises costs etc - which all make a difference.
Dentists were not well supported during COVID. It’s not going to get better unless it becomes a lot more attractive to do nhs care.

User1isnotavailable · 11/02/2022 10:57

@Namechangehereandnow

Look around for an alternative nhs dental practice … 🤷🏻‍♀️
I just did a search and there are none in a 50 mile radius of my home. Fortunately, I have good teeth and can pay but others do not.
Acqua · 11/02/2022 10:53

Your MP should be aware of the ongoing discussions on contract reform for NHS dentistry and should be representing your community.

Some MPs were debating on this yesterday (Thursday 10th Feb) in Westminster Hall. Sounds promising, but having read the minutes I don't feel hopeful.

Debate Name: Access to NHS Dentistry

Here's a mention of it on the government website if anyone's interested:
committees.parliament.uk/committee/202/backbench-business-committee/news/160843/westminster-hall-to-hold-a-general-debate-on-access-to-nhs-dentistry/

Here's the link to the Hansard minutes of the meeting:
hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2022-02-10/debates/32D38E00-1C1E-4FA3-AEB3-591FF7F5362C/AccessToNHSDentistry

The general gist is that the disasterous contract form 2006 puts disincentives for dentists to remain in the NHS. Reform rhetoric seems to have been ongoing since 2011. It wraps up with saying they should meet again in 6 months time for a progress report.

Also, there was a Commons debate a few days earlier (Debate name: Dentist Industry and NHS Backlogs), Hansard minutes here: hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2022-02-07/debates/1B321002-1A60-45D0-BFEA-F9EF689B8757/DentistIndustryAndNHSBacklogs#780

User1isnotavailable · 11/02/2022 10:53

What's an NHS dentist?

Sausageandeggs · 11/02/2022 10:53

I’m private and my teeth are a mess because of long term medication. About to have some extensive work and it’s costing me around 10k.

I’m not rich, and part of this will be under a medical loan. But it is what it is. Life isn’t fair, and the NHS isn’t an inexhaustible pot of magical money.

fucknuckle · 11/02/2022 10:46

www.nhs.uk/service-search/find-a-dentist

this will show you dentists accepting NHS patients. some say only by referral, so i guess that’s if you have an issue that takes you to Minor Injuries at a hospital. if you can’t find a dentist there’s an NHS Customer Care helpline.

i spoke to a friend yesterday who was facing a £1300 charge for 2 root canals. I searched her area and found her an NHS dentist. they are out there, you just may need to travel a bit further.

i agree that it’s a shambles. kicking NHS patients out is unconscionable. it’s unfair that people have to do so much legwork just to find dental care. i consider myself extremely lucky to be with a practice that has kept me on despite covid and is now back to doing NHS treatment. it’s a fucking disgrace that people can’t easily access dental care.

Namechangehereandnow · 11/02/2022 10:43

Look around for an alternative nhs dental practice … 🤷🏻‍♀️