Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No not understand how our NHS dentist can say our whole family of 5 are now not NHS and must pay private monthly fees to stay

207 replies

P3ff3r · 10/02/2022 21:34

Said monthly plan doesn’t even cost of treatment.

We were NHS, how can we not now be and who can afford private x5 at the drop of a hat like that?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CatJumperTwat · 12/02/2022 16:35

@Namechangehereandnow

From the nhs website:

If after contacting several dental surgeries you still cannot find a dentist accepting NHS patients, call NHS England's Customer Contact Centre on 0300 311 2233.

NHS England commissions dental services in England and is required to meet the needs of their local population for both urgent and routine dental care.

That's what I ended up doing last month. The only place they found was 20 miles away (I'm in London, not some remote village) and couldn't see me for a month, for an emergency appointment. I paid privately and was seen the next day.

The helpline can't force a dentist to create an appointment for an NHS user.

maddening · 12/02/2022 16:13

"- I've managed ONE in the (almost) 2 years and that was when, after they cancelled last June, I rang an hour later to ask if I could have a private appointment and got one two days later."

Yes, they had restrictions on treating NHS imposed by the government, however no such restrictions for private.

maddening · 12/02/2022 16:00

I can understand the "non attenders" beings deregistered- the dentist is paid for dental activity, UDAs, they agree a contract based on the dentist completing a certain number of UDAs a year, I think the book of patients registered is part of this, a check up is UDA, treatments also are worth UDAs, the pay is also capped - so if the patient needs 10 fillings or 1 filling the dentist is paid the same and if the patient needs further treatment within a timeframe then that would be no extra UDAs. If the dentist does not achieve their UDAs they have to pay money back, if they do too many UDAs then they get no extra and therefore that work actually costs the dentist.

so if you don't attend for years until half your teeth are rotten they get paid the same for hours and hours of work than a normal check up/1 or 2 fillings slot etc etc

The NHS dentistry has been killed off, the government made it so they could not see the.same number of patients due to covid restrictions (eg empty room between patients) and has requested the same UDAs.for their contracts, it is untenable and no wonder they.are leaving, this is the government's plan I reckon.

Newgirls · 12/02/2022 15:28

Of course nhs dentistry is a political move. It’s expensive and the Tory gov have not invested and supported it in their 10 years in gov.

The move to private provision has not been hidden. It’s happening in the gp services too with some elements (eg ear wax removal, tests, holiday jabs etc).

Get what you voted for and don’t be surprised.

Jjjaaakkk · 11/02/2022 17:59

MPs need serious lobbying on this despicable issue!
Bashing the dentists won’t change anything. This is a political issue, and the governments know that dentistry isn’t a vote winner. Make dentistry a vote winning issue and things will change

dentistattic · 11/02/2022 17:58

@SweetPetrichor
My 6 monthly checkups are free (as everyone gets free checkups in Scotland) and I pay for any treatment if and when required.

That's slightly unusual. I work in Scotland. NHS checkups are free in Scotland, but you still have to pay for NHS treatment, unless you are entitled to benefits. Private checkups are chargeable, wherever in the country you live.

Are you sure it's not NHS treatment you get?
Either way, I would ask and get it clarified. It's not very cool for a dentist to do your checkups free on the NHS then charge you for treatment on a private basis.
If you get free NHS checkups, you are entitled to the full range of NHS treatments.

feellikeanalien · 11/02/2022 17:51

Let's face it, NHS dentistry for adults is finished. I got thrown off our dentist list but thankfully DD was kept on it. I cannot afford to pay privately. I need a filling replaced and have a crumbling back tooth. I will have to wait until I am in agony and get an emergency appointment (if i am lucky).

SweetPetrichor · 11/02/2022 17:06

I moved from an NHS dentist - who did substandard work - to a private dentist by choice. The price isn’t much different, and I can actually get an appointment quickly at a time that suits me. My 6 monthly checkups are free (as everyone gets free checkups in Scotland) and I pay for any treatment if and when required.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 11/02/2022 16:59

It’s an extremely stressful highly skilled profession which is quite frankly unappreciated. Until it’s seen as import as medicine (which it is) nothing will change. The fact that the nhs offered much for free for many years has completely devalued the importance of health care generally. People just don’t appreciate any thing any more!

Yes I'd agree with this.

VickyEadieofThigh · 11/02/2022 16:55

@Newnormal99

If you don't go you get booted off lists - I did and they told me all other nhs dentists were full and to stay with them I need to pay for a private appointment and if no issues I may get back on their list.

I rang another dentist and signed up with them again under NHS - luckily I did as needed an extraction and rather not pay for that privately!

That's all very well, but since the pandemic started my NHS dentist has consistently cancelled my appointments - I've managed ONE in the (almost) 2 years and that was when, after they cancelled last June, I rang an hour later to ask if I could have a private appointment and got one two days later.

With the same dentist. Presumably, had I not taken this appointment, he'd have been sitting around doing nothing...

BoredZelda · 11/02/2022 16:55

Off topic slightly but I would be surprised if dentists take out teeth of a child to account for wisdom teeth that haven't yet erupted?

Depends on the age of the child. My dentist took 4 teeth out when I was 13 because my wisdom teeth were sitting at right angles to the rest of my teeth. He decided taking the other teeth out now and letting the rest of them move and settle made more sense than having them out later. They took my wisdoms out at 17.

BoredZelda · 11/02/2022 16:52

How is this legal?

How would it be illegal? Dentists can go private if they wish.

endlesssighing · 11/02/2022 16:31

@Jjjaaakkk

It’s an extremely stressful highly skilled profession which is quite frankly unappreciated. Until it’s seen as import as medicine (which it is) nothing will change. The fact that the nhs offered much for free for many years has completely devalued the importance of health care generally. People just don’t appreciate any thing any more!
This in spades.
Jjjaaakkk · 11/02/2022 16:30

It’s an extremely stressful highly skilled profession which is quite frankly unappreciated. Until it’s seen as import as medicine (which it is) nothing will change. The fact that the nhs offered much for free for many years has completely devalued the importance of health care generally. People just don’t appreciate any thing any more!

endlesssighing · 11/02/2022 16:04

@MarineBlue33

I have no idea how dentists' contracts work but I know that they are very well paid. We have a few dentists in my family and I know a friend who is one too. All their children are in private school, holidays to far flung places and flashy cars. There is NOT one that doesn't fall into that category. Honestly when think my local dentist will not do many treatments on the NHS, I am saddened. I can't afford to have a £2k implant. I think dental contract need to be reevaluated.
But that’s the same with any specialist field. Doctors, Dentists, Vets or conversely architects and chartered surveyors.

They study for years at great expense. Their field is incredibly well paid because it’s such an important area. Why does the wealth of a dentist offend any more than a GP or Surgeon?

They’re well paid because it’s a difficult job. NHS don’t want to pay that money. If you want to make dentistry cheaper make the medical field more accessible for the every day student. Until then it becomes a more and more sought after trade.

VikingVolva · 11/02/2022 15:01

@Newgirls

This is Tory gov policy. If you voted for a ToryMP and government this is what you voted for 🤷‍♀️
I'm not so sure - last time dentists contracts were changed was 2006, so under labour. They've been looking at updating, but that got held up cos covid (was due 2021)

And ending contracts with individual dentists is done by the PCT locally, no central input

dentistattic · 11/02/2022 13:28

I think dental contract need to be reevaluated

I think dental professionals need to have their worth evaluated. They are highly skilled professionals that have spent five years at university, and additionally several further years of post grad training just to get a list number. Never mind the extra training and time that it takes to become an implant specialist or an orthodontist.
So what if they are well paid. They've worked hard and deserve it.
Here in Scotland the current NHS fee for an extraction is £9.70, of which the average associate gets 45% of that amount. An extraction takes roughly 30 minutes.
Therefore the dentist receives £8.43 per hour. That's less than the minimum wage.

And out of that £8.43 the dentist needs to pay their indemnity, insurance, and registration fees and HMRC.

That's not valuing our profession. No wonder so many are walking away from the health service!

simonthedog · 11/02/2022 13:26

NHS dentists choose to contract out their services to the NHS. They can also choose not to do this and work privately if they wish.

Newgirls · 11/02/2022 13:18

This is Tory gov policy. If you voted for a ToryMP and government this is what you voted for 🤷‍♀️

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 11/02/2022 12:53

@MarineBlue33

I have no idea how dentists' contracts work but I know that they are very well paid. We have a few dentists in my family and I know a friend who is one too. All their children are in private school, holidays to far flung places and flashy cars. There is NOT one that doesn't fall into that category. Honestly when think my local dentist will not do many treatments on the NHS, I am saddened. I can't afford to have a £2k implant. I think dental contract need to be reevaluated.
I think dental contract need to be reevaluated

Ah yes, making their NHS contract even crapper will definitely help encourage people into the profession Hmm

Monopolyiscrap · 11/02/2022 12:40

My DP has a mouth full of fillings because he had neglectful parents who never took him to the dentist. His first ever dentists visit was at 20 in a lot of pain. He also want made to brush his teeth as a child and only started to do so as a teenager.
Do you really think someone should automatically be condemned because their teeth are in a bad state?

endlesssighing · 11/02/2022 12:38

@canary1

Laiste

I see your mother went private to see the same surgeon she would see under the NHS but sooner. If the NHS wanted to employ more of that surgeons time, or another surgeon in addition, then your mother would have no need to go private. The NHS is not staffed adequately - that is the fundamental problem. Obviously the NHS buys X number of the surgeons time. What he/ she does in their own time is up to them, so many do private work then.

I have a chronic pain related medical condition that has required repeated surgery. I see the same specialist both for appointments and the surgery.

He (to a majority of his patients) will see them on a private referral that is paid for and will then request the surgery as urgent as an NHS referral despite having to perform the surgery at a private facility.

It's a broken system and it usually comes to around £400 for the private appointments plus aftercare. However, I physically could not wait the SIX MONTH waiting list just to get a referral, not surgery referral. It condition impacts my ability to parent, go to work, to actually function. It's an impossible situation.

MaggieMooh · 11/02/2022 12:21

My child is technically entitled to free NHS care but I can’t find a dentist who will take him. His teeth are healthy so we’ve decided to pay for checkups (£30 twice a year) and will look for an NHS dentist only if he needs expensive treatment further down the road. It sucks but we have no choice.

I do worry about poor people who need a lot of treatment though - I know a lady in her 80s who recently had 21 teeth extracted and a set of dentures made. The bill to have that done privately would have been several thousand pounds, I don’t see how a pensioner is supposed to afford that when they’re surviving on a state pension.

Bluebottle11 · 11/02/2022 12:06

MarineBlue33
They are paid accordingly they are medical professionals. My children are in private school and we have holidays every year etc etc but we still work hard for those things so please don’t imply that people who have that kind of lifestyle aren’t somehow entitled to ot

Mollysocks · 11/02/2022 11:56

@Hellosunshiner

Mollysocks "Exactly I looked after mine perfectly. I have a small mouth and my dentist when I was a child didn’t take enough of my teeth out to account for my wisdom teeth. So when they came through they impacted into my sinus cavity, became infected and I couldn’t chew for 2 months. Nothing to do with looking after teeth!"

Off topic slightly but I would be surprised if dentists take out teeth of a child to account for wisdom teeth that haven't yet erupted? That would be far too premature as some wisdom teeth don't ever come through and when they do it's normally the wisdom teeth that are removed, not molars.

I also have a small mouth etc and when my wisdom teeth started erupting (but were impacted due to limited space), the wisdom teeth were all removed under general anaesthetic before they could make a problem.

That’s a good point, not all come through. I had 8 teeth taken out when I was 13? (2 each side up and bottom) and there was no room for any more to come through. There was probably less than a cm between my back molar and my jaw.

I also have a small mouth etc and when my wisdom teeth started erupting (but were impacted due to limited space), the wisdom teeth were all removed under general anaesthetic before they could make a problem.

I think there’s where it went wrong for me, mine weren’t. They were left to come out and then removed (after several weeks of antibiotics) by local anaesthetic.

But either way, just shows that having treatment doesn’t mean we didn’t look after our teeth (as a PP has suggested) it’s just luck (or not) a lot of the time. My brother never looked after his teeth snd has the whitest straightest teeth ever and no issues, then there’s me. It’s a running family joke!