Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women taking the fall for men

84 replies

UnbelievableAlien · 10/02/2022 19:36

I think women are often set up to take the fall for men.

Whether is Allegra Stratton having to lose her job for a couple of comments about parties while her boss Johnson keeps his after actually attending the parties.

Or, more seriously, Ghislaine Maxwell being the only person who is alive facing justice (rightly) for her role in trafficking while not a single man who actually commuted the abuse is.

Possibly Cressida Dick taking the fall for her disgusting sexist, homophobic, racist male colleagues, but the buck does stop with her, so probably not such a concrete example.

Of course these women are responsible for their own actions, but it is weird that what the men do is often worse but the woman are the ones who take the blame! AIBU?

OP posts:
Thewindwhispers · 11/02/2022 00:26

Plus she resigned waaaaay too quickly, someone had obviously told her to.

Thewindwhispers · 11/02/2022 00:25

Yanbu. The Allegra one really bugs me. Her career is ruined for laughing about something that her BOSS did. Boss is fine. Not ok.

TomPinch · 11/02/2022 00:21

@CruCru

I agree. I’d actually include Theresa May as well.
Theresa 'hostile environment' May? I think there are some short memories here.
TomPinch · 11/02/2022 00:18

@BlueBellsArePretty

It was very annoying that Nicola Sturgeon's trial for breaking the ministerial code of which she was cleared was viewed by her detractors as Alex Salmond's retrial. Effectively a woman, being held accountable for the behaviour of a man.
Under Sturgeon's watch-
  1. The Scottish Gvt investigated Salmond, and was found by a court to have been biased against him.
  2. They then passed a file to the police who charged him. He was acquitted.
  3. Sturgeon was found to have misled the Scottish Parliament regarding her dealings with Salmond. She was lucky that the committee made no finding as to whether she intentionally misled the parliament.

I've no liking for Salmond, but this was an attempted beat-up of a political opponent and Sturgeon was not held responsible for her behaviour in any meaningful way.

BlueBellsArePretty · 10/02/2022 23:48

It was very annoying that Nicola Sturgeon's trial for breaking the ministerial code of which she was cleared was viewed by her detractors as Alex Salmond's retrial. Effectively a woman, being held accountable for the behaviour of a man.

wightwine · 10/02/2022 23:04

I don't know about women who are not in the public eye, but the women named here are all 'well educated' middle class women who, despite knowing better, chose to join misogynistic/racist/homophobic organisations with very particular, negative cultures. Everyone in London knew what Boris Johnson is, professionally and personally. Why should anyone have sympathy for Allegra Stratton and Carrie Johnson. They both made 'clear eyed' decisions to join him in his endeavours. Ghislaine Maxwell deserves anything she gets. She procured vulnerable, poor girls to be consumed by men in exchange for a 'nice' lifestyle and money for herself. Cressida Dick spent her whole life in the current police culture. I am sick of hearing her say she is sorry for the latest shitstorm to come out about the police. You lie down with dogs, you get up with fleas.

x2boys · 10/02/2022 22:57

[quote cocktailclub]@x2boys
But when will the real issue of male behaviour be addressed? She was head of the met but she didn't cause their behaviour.
Anyone who thinks one person can undo years of mysogynistic sexist behaviour is dilusional[/quote]
But it was literally her job to do that
Any head of a service who has failed so miserably take the rap for it ,it's part of having such a prestigious job

Blinky21 · 10/02/2022 22:55

It's right that all of these women were held accountable for their behaviour none of them are victims, but yes the men should be accountable too

Blossomtoes · 10/02/2022 22:54

Anyone who thinks one person can undo years of mysogynistic sexist behaviour is dilusional

This is controversial but I don’t think any woman could do it. What the Met needs now is a really tough male commissioner from another force who will be prepared enforce decent standards and knock some heads together.

UnbelievableAlien · 10/02/2022 22:48

I am far from being a supporter of any of these women! Maxwell is hellish and she really sickens me, Dick is incompetent and Stratton is about as far from my politics as is possible to be!
Nor did I suggest they should not be held accountable for their various evil crimes/ wrongdoing/ incompetences.
However why are non of the myriad of clearly guilty men being held accountable for THEIR crimes and wrongdoings in these cases?!

OP posts:
cocktailclub · 10/02/2022 22:44

@x2boys
But when will the real issue of male behaviour be addressed? She was head of the met but she didn't cause their behaviour.
Anyone who thinks one person can undo years of mysogynistic sexist behaviour is dilusional

Abhannmor · 10/02/2022 22:41

Dick has gone because of sexism in the Met though, not because of the murder of an innocent man. Or the lies and slander which followed it. I have some sympathy for Stratton however. But her resignation will turn out to have been a good career move imo.

Bosephine · 10/02/2022 22:40

A fair point in relation to Allegra Stratton but not the others.

GM was convicted for the crimes she herself committed. Dick presided over a catalogue of policing disasters. It does women no favours to suggest these women are just carrying the can for others because of their sex- they were hugely powerful women who should be held to account.

Nietzschethehiker · 10/02/2022 22:35

Actually poor wording in my first post apologies. We are not asking that men are held accountable we are damn well demanding.

Nietzschethehiker · 10/02/2022 22:34

Also , this winging that women only ever behave negatively because of men as an automatic is beyond detrimental to actual feminism. If we argue that we are equal we argue that we are also capable of taking consequences. This isn't about excusing dick or maxwell behaviour by painting them as incompetent patsies. Neither of them were.

Cressida dick was not weak and incompetent and simpering over men. She was ambitious, selfish and a misogynist for personal gain at the expense of other women. Maxwell was not the innocent dupe she had money and power. Trauma is not an excuse for her behaviour. Many women experience trauma and manipulation and don't drag other women down as well.

We don't get to claim strength if we hide behind weakness and don't expect our own sex to be able to withstand reasonable scrutiny without trying to undermine their freely made decisions. When ours behave like that, they face consequences.

Back to the point this isn't about them. Its about the question of pushing for the convictions of the men as well.

We are not so weak we can't handle our own consequences.

Nietzschethehiker · 10/02/2022 22:28

I don't disagree with the theory at all. However this rhetoric isn't doing us any favours.

By framing it that the women were treated unfairly (which maxwell and dick were not) we simply need to ask that the men are held accountable for their actions
The wording here is important because it's distracting the point and sounds as if we want them not to be held accountable.

It translates as the women shouldn't be held accountable if the men aren't but mostly the fair argument is simply why are the men not facing accountability. Don't hand the misogynists an easy rebuttal to keep us arguing while they carry on. We are smarter than that.

This argument deflects for them without them even having to try.

x2boys · 10/02/2022 22:17

Cross post!

x2boys · 10/02/2022 22:17

@cocktailclub

Cressida Dick has resigned because she has not been able to address the poor behaviour of MALE police officers. Of course they can't control their own behaviour. Their senior male officers can't control them or perhaps don't see anything wrong with it. Naturally the woman should go because the men can't behave.
Well she's the head of the metropolitan if she can't control what's going then she's in incompetent at her job that's why she has to go the buck stops with her.
Blossomtoes · 10/02/2022 22:16

@cocktailclub

Cressida Dick has resigned because she has not been able to address the poor behaviour of MALE police officers. Of course they can't control their own behaviour. Their senior male officers can't control them or perhaps don't see anything wrong with it. Naturally the woman should go because the men can't behave.
She was the head of the organisation, ffs. The buck stopped with her.
Blossomtoes · 10/02/2022 22:15

@MarchCrocus

There's a point in there about awful men being more likely to get away with being awful for longer than awful women do. I'm just not sure Cressida Dick is the example you want.

She was like fucking Teflon. To the extent that I always assumed she'd only been able to hang on that long because she had some serious dirt on someone, even bearing in mind her significant class privilege. She hasn't taken the fall for anyone: she hasn't even taken anything like enough fall for her own misdeeds.

This in spades. She hung onto the job long after she should have been fired.
cocktailclub · 10/02/2022 22:11

Cressida Dick has resigned because she has not been able to address the poor behaviour of MALE police officers. Of course they can't control their own behaviour. Their senior male officers can't control them or perhaps don't see anything wrong with it. Naturally the woman should go because the men can't behave.

x2boys · 10/02/2022 22:06

Let's not minimize Maxwell,s involvement,she procured young ,women to be essentially sex slaves ,it's not like she accidentally got involved, and she allegedly sexually assaulted some women herself ,I hope more men do stand trial for this I suspect some are extremely high profile,but that shouldn't minimize Maxwell,s crimes

AuntyJanet · 10/02/2022 22:05

I agree that women often cop the flak for men. However, the examples you’ve given are dreadful.

Grilledaubergines · 10/02/2022 22:02

Yabu. These women are responsible for their own monumental fuck ups.

PearPickingPorky · 10/02/2022 22:02

[quote Porcupineintherough]@PearPickingPorky well yeah, he died. I wouldnt exactly say he got off easy, though it would be nice to have seen him on trial naming names.[/quote]
I am aware. My point was, he was never jailed. He was never convicted and he escaped his due punishment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread