Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women taking the fall for men

84 replies

UnbelievableAlien · 10/02/2022 19:36

I think women are often set up to take the fall for men.

Whether is Allegra Stratton having to lose her job for a couple of comments about parties while her boss Johnson keeps his after actually attending the parties.

Or, more seriously, Ghislaine Maxwell being the only person who is alive facing justice (rightly) for her role in trafficking while not a single man who actually commuted the abuse is.

Possibly Cressida Dick taking the fall for her disgusting sexist, homophobic, racist male colleagues, but the buck does stop with her, so probably not such a concrete example.

Of course these women are responsible for their own actions, but it is weird that what the men do is often worse but the woman are the ones who take the blame! AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Diqgeneration · 11/02/2022 08:56

I see woman taking the fall for men all the time. Mainly protecting them despite domestic violence. On a smaller level sacrificing their jobs/free time/money to pay/look after kids when the man won’t.

dottydodah · 11/02/2022 08:51

Or the American girl who returned from her night shift to realise her little boy was unresponsive .Her BF who had been looking after him overnight had disappeared and was found to have taken his own life. SHE is facing life in prison although entirely innocent! (Rebecca Hogue BBC news) Laws there include "failure to protect child" WTF! she was on a night shift! So she is responsible for him killing her child when she wasnt even there FFS

NightmareSlashDelightful · 11/02/2022 08:22

I think there’s a legitimate conversation to be had about women being scapegoated for things but I think the more interesting and pertinent examples are more day to day, and to do with relationship dynamics. Dr Jessica Taylor’s book Why Women Are Blamed For Everything is really good on this.

But I don’t think holding up Ghislaine Maxwell, Cressida Dick or (to a lesser extent) Allegra Stratton is the right exemplification really. Sometimes women do make mistakes, bad choices, are cruel, or do hurtful, criminal, violent or upsetting things in pursuit of power, advantage, revenge or advancement.

When holding power, women are equally capable of fucking things up as men are.

Mediocrates · 11/02/2022 08:10

"The problem is not these women being held to account, the problem is the paucity of men being held to account with them."

Exactly this

FrancescaContini · 11/02/2022 08:05

@VladmirsPoutine

I'm with you. These women were the very definition of girlboss feminists. Yass Queen! What we need is more female serial killers!
GM???? She was predatory, abusive, manipulative. A thoroughly nasty piece of work. Not a “girlboss feminist”, whatever that may be Confused
C8H10N4O2 · 11/02/2022 08:02

Stratton, and her husband James Forsyth were both a key and active part of the Boris/Carrie machine with cosy weekends at Chequers. She was literally laughing on camera about the parties in Downing St held when people could not visit dying family. Its not the first time she has been tone deaf on the media. Frankly her tears were for herself, most of us were shedding tears for friends and family at that time.

Maxwell was guilty of trafficking young girls and demonstrated a sense of entitlement the size of Everest despite the billionaire class legal team. The only reason Epstein isn't in jail is because he is dead. Maxwell belongs in jail.

Cressida Dick has presided over a racist, misogynistic police force which if anything seems to have worsened rather than improved. She was still in complete denial of this and pulling the "one bad apple" routine.

Carrie Johnson is not some poor little woman who accidentally overspent on fancy wallpaper. She was and is a politically active person in her own right and deserves to e held accountable just as much as any man.

Janice Turner wrote a good piece on this - compare her to her male predecessors. If Philip May had stuffed No 10 with his own political cronies or Dennis Thatcher had demanded the No 10 Jag be upgraded to a gold plated Rolls there would also have been outrage - quite correctly.

The problem is not these women being held to account, the problem is the paucity of men being held to account with them.

AuntyJanet · 11/02/2022 08:00

@ThinWomansBrain

women have more integrity?

I wish Johnson would follow Cressida Dick's example

You might have a point if she hadn’t been on the ropes for ages and only then resigned when the Mayor of London pulled his support. Not exactly an honourable “falling on her sword”.
x2boys · 11/02/2022 07:59

Sadiq*

x2boys · 11/02/2022 07:56

@ThinWomansBrain

women have more integrity?

I wish Johnson would follow Cressida Dick's example

I'm not sure integrity comes into it she was effectively forced to resign yesterday Siddique Khan .
Bosephine · 11/02/2022 07:26

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/feb/11/cressida-dick-could-not-solve-the-mets-problems-she-could-barely-admit-they-existed

I thought this was an interesting article. Pretty shocked at the number of people who are effectively absolving her of any blame. The head of an organisation is absolutely responsible for its culture and the article above gives an example of a previous commissioner who too this seriously. Dick’s approach has been to cover up at all costs and protect the reputation of the Met at the expense of the public. Excusing this because she’s a woman is pretty sickening.

LunaTheCat · 11/02/2022 07:06

@cocktailclub

Cressida Dick has resigned because she has not been able to address the poor behaviour of MALE police officers. Of course they can't control their own behaviour. Their senior male officers can't control them or perhaps don't see anything wrong with it. Naturally the woman should go because the men can't behave.
Absolutely this.
Porcupineintherough · 11/02/2022 06:59

I dont see it as her resigning because of male behaviour @cocktailclub, more due to the inability unwillingness of the organisation she heads to deal with that behaviour satisfactorily. Look at that officer who was kept on recently despite bring found guilty of 8 counts of gross misconduct! Any place I've worked 1 count would see you instantly dismissed.

cocktailclub · 11/02/2022 06:51

Maxwell is a guilty paedophile. She's not taking the fall for Epstein. Without her and could not have got access to the girls he abused quite as easily. I see her as equally guilty.

Cressida Dick may well be incompetent but so are lots of other senior leaders. The thing here is that it's hard to get to a senior position like this for a woman and she's leaving because of the ingrained poor behaviour of men, and a culture of sexism she inherited. If she was leaving because of making the wrong decision about the shooting, fair enough. That's what I would expect. But leaving because of male behaviour. That's the bit that doesn't feel right to me.

NumberTheory · 11/02/2022 05:45

I don't think this thread makes the case well.

Maxwell was horrendous but they only went after her once Epstein committed suicide in what was, pretty much, the clearest possible confession. I don't think death (despite the way it circumvents the criminal justice system) is actually "getting away with it".

Cressida Dick has stepped down, but plenty of male Met officers have also been convicted of crimes or had their careers cut short. Of the previous 3 Met commissioners, 2 also left post early because of Met scandals.

Of the ones mentioned, Allegra Stratton is the only one who seems to me to have been a fall'guy'.

Simonjt · 11/02/2022 05:33

@MarchCrocus

Cressida Dick has done plenty of appalling things in her own right. De Menezes, anyone? She had no business staying in post as long as she did.
Exactly, she should have been fired when her force decided to murder De Menezes.
Simonjt · 11/02/2022 05:31

@MrsTerryPratchett

Ghislaine Maxwell is a really interesting example. The harm could not have happened without the men. She could not have harmed the young women without the men, the weapon is literally a penis. But the only person prosecuted is the only one incapable of causing the actual harm.

It is shocking. And quite obviously wrong.

So you think trafficking isn’t harmful? How about touching someones genitals without consent?
Monty27 · 11/02/2022 05:18

Or perhaps the women are set up. I'd definitely say that for Theresa May.
Set up to cover up and take the flak. There's a long list of examples when you think about it.

Monty27 · 11/02/2022 05:02

Yes agreed. Used to be a saying fall guy. What's happened there? Women get promoted on merit and men fuck up.

RussiasGreatestLoveMachine · 11/02/2022 04:47

@UnbelievableAlien

I am far from being a supporter of any of these women! Maxwell is hellish and she really sickens me, Dick is incompetent and Stratton is about as far from my politics as is possible to be! Nor did I suggest they should not be held accountable for their various evil crimes/ wrongdoing/ incompetences. However why are non of the myriad of clearly guilty men being held accountable for THEIR crimes and wrongdoings in these cases?!
Totally get you.

Even DH says the same thing about Maxwell. She deserves everything coming to her.

But what about the men?

Mediocrates · 11/02/2022 03:53

I agree with a PP who essentially said that women are rightly are being held accountable in a way that men are largely not (understand that Epstein was and then died).

Interesting to note that these women mentioned hold a lot of privilege, and I wonder if their lack of integrity is indicative of... I don't know - it's 3.45am and I'm awake because I have Covid and am feeling miserable so bear with me while I try to make my brain work. Something about the women who've succeeded in these typically male dominated environments showing a real lack of integrity. It's less usual for women to hold some of these positions and part of me wonders whether they'd have got there if they'd conducted themselves in a more honest manner. Probably not. Doesn't excuse it, but I think theres something in that about how women who progress to these positions and how they're expected to look the other way at best, and be complicit in shitty behaviour at worst.

TomPinch · 11/02/2022 00:42

@ThinWomansBrain

women have more integrity?

I wish Johnson would follow Cressida Dick's example

Johnson is hardly typical in his sense of entitlement. But I hope the ratbag goes too.
TomPinch · 11/02/2022 00:39

@Thewindwhispers

Yanbu. The Allegra one really bugs me. Her career is ruined for laughing about something that her BOSS did. Boss is fine. Not ok.
It was no laughing matter.
TomPinch · 11/02/2022 00:38

@CouldIhaveaword

I would add Carrie Johnson for taking the fall for her husband's incompetence. Don't like the woman, but that's not the point.
Carrie Johnson has no formal role in the UK government yet seems to be bending Johnson's ear behind the scenes, for example Nowzad. If this is true, as seems likely, she deserves criticism for contributing to the government's chaos. She shouldn't be let off just because Johnson isn't telling her to mind her own business.
TomPinch · 11/02/2022 00:34

@MrsTerryPratchett

Ghislaine Maxwell is a really interesting example. The harm could not have happened without the men. She could not have harmed the young women without the men, the weapon is literally a penis. But the only person prosecuted is the only one incapable of causing the actual harm.

It is shocking. And quite obviously wrong.

She's not taking the fall for men. She is taking the fall for what she did (assuming that the allegations against her are true, which seems likely.

This thread is overlooking the fact that a man - Epstein - was charged. He killed himself. You can't prosecute a corpse.

ThinWomansBrain · 11/02/2022 00:26

women have more integrity?

I wish Johnson would follow Cressida Dick's example

Swipe left for the next trending thread