Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think weekends off isn't worth 3 nights away every week?

114 replies

maminthesticks · 10/02/2022 19:20

At loggerheads with partner over whether he takes a new job offer or not, I'm wanting to stay put, he's wanting to go for it on the basis that weekends off is worth the sacrifices

This new role would be every weekend off (he currently works every weekend) but he'd be away for 3 nights a week every week.

Will have 2 (very) young kids and would be moving away completely from my support network I have where we are currently and I just can't imagine being happy with the arrangement

AIBU to think weekends off just isn't good enough to compensate for so much time away every week?

(If seems familiar I had a separate thread last week about general logistics of moving from rural Wales to South England but wanted opinions more specifically on the working arrangement rather than the locations)

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 10/02/2022 20:15

I'd refuse to go op.

Dream job, huge pay rise, increase in standard of living etc maybe. MAYBE.

worse house, no support, brand new baby, toddler in top and barely any difference in income. Not a chance.

Surely two days off in the week if great for childcare when they're younger and you'll have all your mat leave not noticing what those two days are (can you cut nursery in those two days?). Meanwhile he's got months to find something SUITABLE

Thewoolmill · 10/02/2022 20:12

It would be a no from me. I can see why weekends off would appeal but you’d be doing the lion share of childcare, no support network, an expensive area and you’d have to give up your job. It wouldn’t be as simple as getting another one if for most of the week your husband was away. I’d stay put, tell him to work away in the week and come back to Wales. Why do you need to move if he would be away most of the week?

CastleCrasher · 10/02/2022 20:11

Also, is your childcare currently provided by family? Even if not, make sure to look at the difference in cost for that- it's likely to be considerably more expensive than what you pay now!

maminthesticks · 10/02/2022 20:10

Thing is as well I have a very family friendly job where we are which pays well for what it is, I've worked my way up as I don't have any qualifications to fall back on apart from GCSES - pretty worried with their being so much competition for jobs in the South and nothing special on my CV that after taking a few months for unpaid maternity that I could really struggle to actually find anything. Which would be more financial strain. I really don't want to go back to worrying about money all the time!

OP posts:
DrWhoNowww · 10/02/2022 20:09

I wouldn’t agree to it, he’s basically opting out of family life in the week in return for mythical family weekends.

If he absolutely must take this job, tell him to get a Monday-Friday let local to the office and he wfh in wales Monday and Friday and commute to local to the office on the Monday night.

Or what is it that he thinks he’s missing out on during the weekends when he’s at work? Do you take DC out on lovely days out that he always misses? Or does he spend the two days a week he has off midweek doing housework/life admin/general shit that means he feels he doesn’t get a “proper” weekend?

CastleCrasher · 10/02/2022 20:09

In itself the set up is one thing, but combined with moving to a new area (with less space, smaller house etc) and zero support network, that would be a deal-breaker for me.

In your DHs shoes I'd be looking closer to home for a change in job that provides better work life balance of the current job isn't doing that, even if that means taking a bit of a hit financially.

RealBecca · 10/02/2022 20:08

To clarify...he gets weekends off and you get 3 full days of childcare? With no back up if you are ill because him and the family arent around? Sounds great...for him!

maminthesticks · 10/02/2022 20:06

His big reasons are more opportunities in the South for kids growing up and being around more when they are in school, both valid in a way but the first is counteracted by the fact it's so bloody expensive to live there and the second by the fact he's away so much in the week! We're not rich by any means but for where we live we are comfortable and have a combined salary of £85k which for this part of the world means we are very comfortable and can afford nice house, abroad holidays, nice car, little luxuries etc and don't have constant worry over money. The loss of my salary even temporarily and the extra cost of living would mean we'd be quite significantly worse off. I think we'd be poor in the south, he thinks I'm being overly dramatic but have said he will get quite the shock at how much our standard of living would change. I grew up with parents who were declared bankrupt multiple times, the difference in childhoods my kids can have to that is enough for me to not want to risk doing anything to change it

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 10/02/2022 20:06

The being away 3 days a week wouldn't bother me. DH worked out of the area and was gone from wee hours Sunday morning 'til Wednesday early evening and the DC and I managed just fine day to day. And I was working full time so had to manage with nursery and school runs on my own.

BUT being in a new area and having to get used to 'the way things are' there AND not having a support system would bother me! I was in a familiar area where I knew where everything was and how things 'ran' and I had my parents and PiLs if I needed help although I very rarely had to use them for anything.

I guess a big question for me would be exactly what does he plan to do on these weekends off?

converseandjeans · 10/02/2022 20:03

Do you think he's trying to get time to himself as if he's away Tues-Thurs he's guaranteed a good night sleep & a lie in. It's quite common for men that are able to work away to up their nights away once a baby arrives.

I think that it's pointless if increased salary has to cover staying away costs.

Do you mean that if you move to new area you can all be together all week? I don't think I would uproot a toddler the same time a newborn was due. You don't know for sure new job will work out. Also you would lose your job & support network. I think I would trade the nights alone for staying put.

Concestor · 10/02/2022 19:58

It sounds awful! Why does he want to do it when the salary increase isn't much?

My DH before lockdown had to work away 2 days a week and I hated it. I can't see this being any good for you or the children at all.

OwlNoises101 · 10/02/2022 19:56

Nope. Don't do it. You loose your home, job, support network and the presence of your DP.
Absolutely not. Hard and flat no.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 10/02/2022 19:54

Nothing in it for you, at all. DS is 3 and currently waking up at 4am so DH and I are splitting the shit sleep, but there is no opportunity to do this for you. You'd be covering absolutely everything when it came to illness and the difficult behaviour stages.

Put it this way - one of my friends has a 4 and 2 year old with a DH who works away and they are quite close to splitting over it.

WutheringHeights66 · 10/02/2022 19:54

Well I wouldn’t give up my job, my house and my support network for any job weekends or otherwise. DH has always known that. He works away three days a week, but pretty much has always worked away since we were early twenties. It’s fine. He’s not away in the for three months a time.

Moving your life and him working away from home is a joke. What’s 8n it for you? A weekend? Woo hoo

Skiptheheartsandflowers · 10/02/2022 19:54

You'd be better not moving and him working away five days instead of three. At least then he'd have weekends off with you, and you'd still have your local support network during the week. I would be saying that and insisting that even if he took the job, the family home stays put.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/02/2022 19:53

You have a couple of years before the kids are in school, an opportunity may present itself in that time which doesn’t mean you losing your job, and mat pay, leaving your support system and downsizing your house - there’s no plus side to this for you at all. I’d be saying no.

Figrollface · 10/02/2022 19:52

So he wants you all to move away from your home, family, friends, nursery and job, while he would work away from the new home 3 full days and nights just so he can have weekends off?
So basically turn your life upside down completly so he can have two different days off in the week?

What exactly does he think he'll be able to do on those days off that he can't do now? It's not like he'll have family and friends around to see?
This sounds very suspicious. Does he do child care on his days off, is he hoping that having the same days off as you will free him up to do his own thing?

maminthesticks · 10/02/2022 19:52

Don't mean to make him sound bad, not the sort of dad to deliberately try and get away or not be around on weekends, if he's not at work he's at home constantly, gets up with toddler every morning, spends all time off or leave with them, he's very hands on and everything has always been very 50/50 which is partly why I'm so scared I can't imagine coping with a newborn alone. I'm crap when I'm tired so he did more than his fair share of night feeds and gets up every morning, I wouldn't get the luxury this time around! He's just always worried about working weekends, of course there are lots of jobs where you don't work weekends but he has experience in this one area and where we live in rural Wales there aren't loads of jobs around, especially ones that pay over £60k, he's been interested in leaving his industry for years but it would always be such a big pay cut that we power through, and then got told can have Sundays once kids school age so figured that was good enough. I think he's just latched on to the thought of weekends suddenly being an option when they normally aren't.

OP posts:
DamnUserName21 · 10/02/2022 19:51

No way!
You'll lose your support network and cost of living is ridiculous in the south.

Sausagis · 10/02/2022 19:51

Hard no from me. I'd divorce before agreeing to that. My husband works Saturdays, we both have Sunday off. It's perfectly do-able and I don't think anyone feels hard done by (kids 10 and 14, husbands always worked Saturdays).

PartyPlan · 10/02/2022 19:50

This isn’t a fair deal at all. Can you cost out everything, including new house, nursery fees, commuting costs, accommodation costs etc. to compare? Maybe seeing it side by side will show it doesn’t make any sense.

saraclara · 10/02/2022 19:50

If your kids were older I'd say it's worth it. My son in law has to work every weekend day and has two days off midweek, and I do wonder what family life will be like once my DGD starts school. And yes, it's more well paid than anything else he could get with his limited qualifications.

But with a toddler and a new baby in a new location, the timing all seems wrong. Is this a promotion within his present company? Is it something that might still be available if he delays for a couple of years?

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 10/02/2022 19:50

@maminthesticks

He'd work from home Monday, leave Monday night, be away Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and drive back for Thursday night then work from home Friday and have weekend off. He wouldn't be here for bedtime at all midweek as he'd leave before bedtime on Monday and get back after bedtime on Thursday. So only Fri, Sat, Sun. The rest of the week toddler and newborn would be fully down to me. I get that single parents do it and manage, but I'm not a single parent and don't really want to put myself through it by choice!
I absolutely would NOT do it, based on what's in this post. Even if it was in the same area, all midweek on your own with a toddler and a newborn would be a big ask to justify.

Can you not simply explain your reasons and say no? My DH and I have moved around a lot including overseas, and our rule was that each of us had a veto on any job moves we weren't happy with. We would discuss it at length but at the end of the day both partners need to be happy with a big change like that.

tabletopgreen · 10/02/2022 19:50

Fuck that for a game of soliders!

Tell him that he can take the job and be divorced. And look up jobs where you can be ‘away’ four nights a week.

Cheeky fucker

TracyMosby · 10/02/2022 19:49

He acknowledges all the other issues but keeps saying weekends will be so important when kids in school
Schooling is important for children. Children need support through school. He just wants fun down time. Tell him he is their father, not their uncle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread