Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think weekends off isn't worth 3 nights away every week?

114 replies

maminthesticks · 10/02/2022 19:20

At loggerheads with partner over whether he takes a new job offer or not, I'm wanting to stay put, he's wanting to go for it on the basis that weekends off is worth the sacrifices

This new role would be every weekend off (he currently works every weekend) but he'd be away for 3 nights a week every week.

Will have 2 (very) young kids and would be moving away completely from my support network I have where we are currently and I just can't imagine being happy with the arrangement

AIBU to think weekends off just isn't good enough to compensate for so much time away every week?

(If seems familiar I had a separate thread last week about general logistics of moving from rural Wales to South England but wanted opinions more specifically on the working arrangement rather than the locations)

OP posts:
lemondrop21 · 10/02/2022 21:02

God absolutely not!
With such young children he wants to stay away 3 nights a week?
Why does he want weekends off so bad if you get time off together during the week anyway?
Everything is quieter during the week if you want to go out etc.

LadyPropane · 10/02/2022 20:49

My husband and I have a similar set up and I find it works ok, BUT in his line of work there isn't really a more family friendly option, and if there was we would probably take it.

Also we moved to our current home whilst I was pregnant with our first, so we had some time to get out and about making friends and putting down roots. So now my children are here, although I technically have no support network from family and old friends, I do know enough people here that I can call someone in a childcare emergency and, perhaps more importantly, I can meet up with my other friends who have similar aged DC which makes the whole thing much more pleasant. Bad days when you're alone with the kids never seem quite so bad when you have a friend to vent to.

Twattergy · 10/02/2022 20:48

This is a completely terrible suggestion. It'd actually be better for you all if he got a worse paid job that didn't include weekend working. So why not just focus on getting any job (even if not better paid) that doesn't include weekends? I'd point blank refuse to this proposed set up, it makes no sense at all.

Crunchymum · 10/02/2022 20:48

Can he not negotiate that he does the Monday and Friday from your current home and the rest he travels as planned. Without anyone moving?

Idolovetrees · 10/02/2022 20:45

OP I agee with you. That support network is really important.

TotheletterofthelawTHELETTER · 10/02/2022 20:44

I don’t understand why you can’t stay where you are and he get digs in the south east?
Monday wfh then drive to SE
Tues/weds/thurs away in hotel
Drive back to Wales Thursday night or Friday am, wfh Friday

That way you get your support network

Fuckityfucksake · 10/02/2022 20:44

An absolute no from me.
Don't uproot yourself from your support and your own job for what honestly sounds like a risky crazy idea from your DH
In your shoes I'd still try to appear like I was 'thinking' while making pro v con and expenditure lists so he can see in black and white - in the hope that it will dawn on him that he's batshit!
If not then I'm afraid I'd be telling him that I was staying put.
If it was a role where you didn't uproot and stayed where you were but he went away a few days a week then yeah as a compromise I'd try that out.

RenegadeMrs · 10/02/2022 20:43

Sorry if I've missed this but if's he's going to be away for 3 nights a week would it not be possible to stay where you are (so you keep your job/ support network etc) and he works away for 3/4 nights a week?

Why do you have to move so he can still not be there most of the time?

CinstonWhurchill · 10/02/2022 20:42

"There are lots of issues in my opinion - the thought of having to leave our lovely big detached house and huge garden for a shoebox makes me want to cry (we paid just under £250k for it - rightmove for the south was a shock!), having to quit my job and lose my maternity pay, pull toddler out of nursery and move him hours away the same month a newborn due, too much for him to go through at once etc".

With kindness Op i think the obstacles here are yours. Largely centred around your own fears. Do you have someone impartial to talk to?

Boombastic22 · 10/02/2022 20:42

Don’t move he’s unreasonable he needs to wait for a better more local job.

Equally can you get a better paid job to greater share the load?

maminthesticks · 10/02/2022 20:38

I don't rely lots on others just have grandparents that live locally and are very involved, they don't provide childcare but my mum will come on days out with us a lots and they are very close. Same for I have lots of great friends some with similar age kids and some who are also pregnant. Got neighbours who are lovely and pop over with kids for a cuppa. It's just nice, I have lots of people around me which is what I mean by support system. No one provides childcare (bar a random day or night here and there) over than my partner, me or nursery. Maybe I'm using the term support system wrong.

But yes my partner is the higher earner by a long shot admittedly.

OP posts:
TellOrNot1981 · 10/02/2022 20:38

It does sound like a shite deal for you, and the kids.

Notanewusertool · 10/02/2022 20:37

Absolutely do not move for this man. I did that once in similar circumstances to you. Bitterly regret it. Being happy where you live is so important for quality of life.

CinstonWhurchill · 10/02/2022 20:33

"Have a lot to lose for not much to gain in my opinion but he feels differently"

With kindness herein lies yr problem Op. I suspect the one earning the money to support the family, all things considered, wants to move for work and personal betterment. If you want to stay put and retain your betterment, you need to be able to fund that largely yourself. You cannot preclude him no more than he can preclude you.

You refer to a support network. A support network should not impede on the decisions on your own whole family life. Your family life decisions seem based solely on your own personal circs. With kindness it looks like you rely heavily on others in your family.

Less reliance on others, will free you to consider your partners work choices, your own work opportunities and possible new independent future with your DP and children as a family somewhere new.

Cakeandcardio · 10/02/2022 20:30

I wouldn't give up a really strong support network to be alone. No. You sound really sad in your posts. I don't have a strong support network and it's lonely. I miss what I've never had and I have a husband wfh every day who helps with bathtime etc. You would miss what you already have even more. Don't be pushed into sacrificing yourself for this. Have you had the conversation around you not wanting to go? Our weekends off together are pretty boring anyway as DS is so young. How does he imagine weekends will be better than midweek days off? I actually prefer when my DH has a midweek day off and we go out as a family. Everything is quieter and more enjoyable! Your feelings are valid too. Plus it's good for children to have family nearby.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/02/2022 20:30

I can imagine him being away all week and then needing weekends “to relax” because he’s been so busy being away, leaving you with the lions share of work at the weekend too. Such a big change you need to be confident it’ll improve your quality of life, and be comfortable with the impact of the changes on you and the kids. You don’t sound comfortable with it at all and on that basis I’d be saying no.

Hexuba · 10/02/2022 20:30

@maminthesticks

Thing is as well I have a very family friendly job where we are which pays well for what it is, I've worked my way up as I don't have any qualifications to fall back on apart from GCSES - pretty worried with their being so much competition for jobs in the South and nothing special on my CV that after taking a few months for unpaid maternity that I could really struggle to actually find anything. Which would be more financial strain. I really don't want to go back to worrying about money all the time!
Something you've left out from your original post, what is the split between your income? That'll help us understand if you are BUR or not!
saraclara · 10/02/2022 20:30

Why does he want to do it when the salary increase isn't much?

Having to work every Saturday and ever Sunday is crap. From a social point of view you miss out on loads. Extended family events are almost impossible to arrange to include everyone. Lots of events are on weekends and you miss them all.

Having watched my son in law (and by extension often, my DD) miss out on these things it's something I'd never want to do. And like OP's DH I'd be grabbing opportunities to do something else. I just think he needs to wait a couple of years.

Michellexxx · 10/02/2022 20:30

I wouldn't agree to this. Can he just go and stay in the region for 3 nights and you stay where you are, near family?
Do not give up your job/life for his weekends off...

RandomMess · 10/02/2022 20:24

Geez please don't move your DS needs to stay where he is!

maminthesticks · 10/02/2022 20:23

Toddler goes to paid nursery on the days where my partner and I are both at work, we're all home together then on my partners mid week days off as they are the same as mine (except I get weekends too as I'm part time) he absolutely loves his nursery, it took us 3 different settings before finding one where he was happy, as a covid baby he really struggled but he's come on so well there and is so happy and talks about his friends all the time and I'd absolutely hate to pull him out when he gets so excited to go and has so much fun. He really struggled when we moved in to our current house last year, really really struggled with the adjustment and that was moving half hour down the road to a much nicer house and nothing else changing. The thought of moving him again so soon, and him losing his nursery and little friends, no longer regularly seeing grandparents and then having a newborn arrive and his dad disappear a lot - I think it would just about break him! People keep telling me they are so adaptable when they are young but I think they still have limits of what they can cope with

OP posts:
Shoutingintothewind · 10/02/2022 20:23

@maminthesticks

Condition of job was needs to be based in the region he's covering, needs to get to most of the locations within 2 hours in case of emergencies, would be a lot longer from where we live here so not sustainable long term
But then he's still away overnight, within the region?? This just doesn't make any sense.

Or is the point that on his Monday/Friday WFH days he needs to be able to get to a specific location in his patch in an emergency?

It all sounds bizarre. It's nuts that he's basically suggesting you move hundreds of miles so you can actually see him less....

Glamping1234 · 10/02/2022 20:20

This does not sound good for you at all! You seem to have massive reasons for not going. You say once your oldest is in school he can have Sundays off too? Surely that will be a major plus.

Do not underestimate how important a support network is. Even if he was getting a bigger salary up rooting from everything you know (and love) is hard and it sounds like you would resent the move. My husband has always worked away offshore and I have needed my mam etc when he has been away.

GettingThemFromHereToThere · 10/02/2022 20:19

YANBU. It's not the right job in my view.

  1. the most important factor - you don't want to move. You shouldn't have to. If ever there's options for a family, that effect more than just one person, then it's a joint decision which means either party can ultimately say no.

  2. giving up your job?! Wouldn't that make you worse off? Now and in the future?

  3. I have three young children. I absolutely wouldn't be happy with my partner leaving me alone to do everything half the week. It would be lonely and bloody hard work.

I think he's crazy to consider it. I would keep looking personally.

parrotonthesofa · 10/02/2022 20:17

Sounds like a terrible idea.

If he really had to take the job why couldn't you stay where you are and he come home at weekends?
At least you'd have your support network / nice house that you like / nursery for dc 1 etc.

But it sounds like the best option would be just for him not to change jobs. Is he desperate to do this job? Is it a great opportunity for him?

Swipe left for the next trending thread