Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask him to borrow some money?

158 replies

dogaibu · 10/02/2022 19:01

Feel like I might BU but I want to check.

My dad died in Feb 21 and I received an inheritance of around 20k. Since then, it appears I've been footing yhr bill for everything. I have Ds11 and he has dss9 and dss12 and it seems that every time they need anything- clothes, bedding, computer games, anything at all- I've been paying for it. We have a dog and a cat and the cat had cancer recently- I footed the entire £1,000 bill.

The house desperately needs painting, the carpet needs shampooing, the deck outside needs power washing, the boys need some new bedroom furniture. It's looking like I'm to foot the entire bill again.

Dh has very little spare money as he pays nearly £450 a month for his Dc, child maintenance, our rent is also pretty high. I obviously have more money than him due to my inheritance but AIBU to ask him to either get a bank loan or use his credit card to pay half of all these household expenses?

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 11/02/2022 11:19

He's on 29k but our rent is a thousand pounds a month

How much do you earn?
How much do you contribute to rent and household expenses?

The above comment sounds like he pays all of the rent - in which case he’s spent a lot more than £20K.

TulaOfDarkWater · 11/02/2022 11:17

In a previous thread, OP said she currently has 35% residency of her DS and is in the middle of a court battle with her ex to raise it to 50/50 so I’m assuming a good bit of the original 45k inheritance has gone on legal fees.

OP also made an offer on a new build that was due to complete in March but I’m assuming she’s backed out of that as she wants to make improvements on her current rental now.

Jvg33 · 11/02/2022 11:17

@NoSquirrels

There’s a lot going on in your post.

You shouldn’t be using your savings (inheritance) to pay for day your day things for DSC.

Your landlord should be responsible for repairs and maintenance (including decorating) to the house.

Most of all, your household budget should cover everyday spending without needing to go into debt. I can’t believe you think that’s a good idea!

If you want to save for your DS, lock some money away in a bank account for him.

Then have a sensible discussion about day to day spending.

Do you work?

A lot of posters saying don't pay for things for step children. If I ever divorced, I would never remarry anyone who didn't treat my children as if they were their own. I'm starting to realise there are a lot of terrible step mothers in the world.
TakeYourFinalPosition · 11/02/2022 11:13

So if you amalgamate the information from your threads; you had a £45k inheritance. You earn £21k, and he earns £29k. Your rent is £1,000 a month; and he pays £450 a month in maintenance.

So he's taking home around £1,900 a month; and you take home around £1,500; so £2,400 all together. Rent takes that down to £1,400; his maintenance to £950.

What other costs do you have that are using that?

Has the missing £25k gone on a house deposit; or has that already been spent on other things, and you're trying to protect the remaining £20k?

If it has gone on a house deposit, is the painting/carpet cleaning for the new house, or to make the current one look better before you move out? To be honest, either of you could easily clean the carpets, and I'm not sure you'll need to paint the house unless you've caused a lot of damage to the paintwork - in which case it might be possible to touch it up?

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 11/02/2022 11:12

If you don't want to spend your inheritance, put it aside and don't spend it.
But if you don't want to spend it, and DH has no spare money, then you as a couple just can't afford the things you mentioned such as new furniture. No, I definitely don't think he should go into debt to pay for things he can't afford.

Jvg33 · 11/02/2022 11:12

Another day and another thread about partners keeping money for themselves. This is not a partnership. Oh well op, if you keep renting and not investing together as a partnership my family will keep becoming more wealthy and my children will have more opportunities. Can you imagine if it was the other way around and it was DH had inherited and asked you to borrow money and get into debt? You don't even seem to care about your step children either. I would tell your DH to move on from this relationship.

FrangipaniBlue · 11/02/2022 11:11

I have Ds11 and he has dss9 and dss12 and it seems that every time they need anything- clothes, bedding, computer games, anything at all- I've been paying for it.

Nope. He needs to pay for his DC and you pay for yours.

We have a dog and a cat and the cat had cancer recently* - I footed the entire £1,000 bill.*

The house desperately needs painting, the carpet needs shampooing, the deck outside needs power washing

I think one off things like this are not unreasonable to pay out of savings (that came from your inheritance). In fact that's what I would expect to use a windfall for ie stuff that you haven't got round to doing because previously you didn't have the funds.

But honestly, if you are having to dip into savings to pay for every day things like clothes for children then you both need to rethink your finances and look at your income and expenditure!

Jonnywishbone · 11/02/2022 11:06

If you have got 20k to use as a deposit for a house why are you renting?

Jvg33 · 11/02/2022 11:04

@Heidi451

Also OP - The house needs painting, the deck needs power washing and the carpets need shampooing? I do all that myself and I am an old woman - so your husband can do it! It costs hardly any money - just labour.
Why are you doing all of this if it's a rental OP?!
fucknuckle · 11/02/2022 11:04

my charmer of an ex-husband forced me into £22k debt as he refused to consider our joint income as family money. he earned 5 x my salary. are you not a family? extra expenses such as video games etc need to be discussed and budgeted for or they don’t happen. you don’t have to piss £20k away on frivolous spending, but you really need to think about whether you see this money as ‘yours’ and are genuinely expecting your husband to go into debt while you have money in the bank.

having been on the other side of this, i can say definitively that it contributed to breakdown of our marriage and subsequent divorce. in the end i had to get legal action taken to force him to buy me out of our house and i managed to pay my debts off. not a pleasant experience.

Jvg33 · 11/02/2022 11:03

@dogaibu

He's on 29k but our rent is a thousand pounds a month
Obvious isn't - use 20k for a house deposit! You two will never be wealthy if you keep paying for a rental.
JudgeJ · 11/02/2022 10:58

@Chilledchablis1

£20,000 won’t last long if you pay for everything.
Isn't the MN mantra that within a marriage it's family money or is that just when the man inherits money? Her's can be ring-fenced as 'ruinniong away' money presumably.
yoyo1234 · 11/02/2022 10:58

I don't think you should be spending a lot on a property that is not yours (will there be a risk of the landlord wanting higher rent/new tenants?).
Try to keep the remaining inheritance as a back up and not spend it for something unless it has a very tangible benefit (eg getting you on the property ladder as you pay a lot in rent). Try to live within your earnings.
I do not think your DH should take out a loan for everyday living if not necessary (it could risk your chance of a decent mortgage if badly managed etc).

Heidi451 · 11/02/2022 10:50

Please don't put it in your children's name! That is money from your Dad left to YOU. It's your insurance money - your fall back.

Cantleave · 11/02/2022 10:48

@WabbitsAndWeasels

In one of your previous threads you said you inherited approximately £45000, did you decide to go forward with the new build with £25000 deposit or has that money been spent on the little stuff you talk about here?

If you still haven't purchased a house I'd definitely be plugging for that. It would be a better inheritance for you DS and the SS (of course protecting your invested but joint investment goes to all) in the long term. As others have said debt is a terrible idea if there's already money in the bank and money is tight otherwise.

You did also say in a previous thread that jointly you earned approximately £50000 joint, why are you struggling so much? Are you actually living within your means or at the limits of your means if you can't afford to hire a carpet cleaner or pressure washer?

£45k is a lot more than the £20k the OP now says she inherited! I don’t feel so sorry for her after reading this. I think the OP has to clarify where the other £25k gone. That’s if she comes back to the thread! Hopefully it hasn’t been frittered away on the little things she is talking about!

Plus, £50k is definitely a decent income, much more than most families have to live on. If they are dipping into her inheritance, with those wages, they are definitely living beyond their means! However, I don’t think the OP should have to subside her dss’, it is up to their parents to pay for them! I doubt their dm would cut the amount of CM she gets if she came into some money.

thenewduchessoflapland · 11/02/2022 10:47

Painting,carpet cleaning and jet washing the deck can be jobs for your DH to do.

Borrow or hire a carpet cleaner;borrow a pressure washer or alternatively you can pick up second hand ones off eBay etc but absolutely don't pay for labour when your DH has hands to do it the lazy sod.

gingerhills · 11/02/2022 10:43

Do you work?

I agree with PPs that the money is shared and the things you are spending it on are reasonable. Reframe your thinking. When I received a similar inheritance. I got a lot of pleasure seeing how far it could go to redecorate the house, renovate the garden, buiy some new things for DC, and give us a few family treats - a holiday and a couple of nights out as a family.

I totally appreciate you want to set some aside for your DC - why not set up an ISA for each of them with a grand in. And I think you should spend a grand on yourself too. Something that will have a big impact on your life or happiness. I spent a grand of my inheritance on a personal trainer and it transformed my life. I now work out regularly,. before I was very overweight.

So deduct the ISAs and a grand for you from what's left and I would definitely also give your DH a treat too, then spend the rest as it is needed and thank you dad for giving you that financial break so you don;t feel ill with worry when the vet bill comes in etc.

Takeitonthechin · 11/02/2022 10:42

So he's bringing home around £1950.00, what I suggest you do, is put some of that money away in a savings account for your son and decide what needs doing first. Ask the carpet company if they have 'off cuts', they will have reels of cheaper carpet that's been left over from other bigger jobs, this will be cheaper.
Can you not paint the house yourselves.
And STOP paying for DSS's, it's his and his ex partners job to pay for them, your dad left the money to you not them.

pinkyredrose · 11/02/2022 10:41

YANBU. Your dad didn't leave you money so you could buy clothes and computer games for your stepkids!

Put the money away in an Isa or something where you can't touch it.

Glitterygreen · 11/02/2022 10:40

I wouldn't expect him to use credit cards or get a loan but I would expect him to contribute from his normal wages.

Surely he must have been contributing before you inherited?

starfishmummy · 11/02/2022 10:34

Can't be doing with all this his and hers money. If you want some of the inheritance for ds put it in a trust and then the rest in the family pot.

girlmom21 · 11/02/2022 10:34

@TyrannosaurusRegina

Your husband pays £450 a month, that's for maintenance, so why is he paying for all this extra stuff?
Because he still has to clothe and entertain his children when it's his contact time ffs. What kind of question is this?!
TyrannosaurusRegina · 11/02/2022 10:33

Your husband pays £450 a month, that's for maintenance, so why is he paying for all this extra stuff?

ilovemybeachhut · 11/02/2022 10:30

@RedskyThisNight

So who paid for things before you had your inheritance?
I'm interested, like several others on here to know this. Op seems coy to help us out with any answers. As for the dss I take they have a mother to facilitate their requiremnets at home, so why have you paid for the non essential computer stuff ?
Heidi451 · 11/02/2022 10:28

Also OP - The house needs painting, the deck needs power washing and the carpets need shampooing? I do all that myself and I am an old woman - so your husband can do it! It costs hardly any money - just labour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread