Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is being a woman better or worse now?

78 replies

Cheekypeach · 10/02/2022 18:52

Than in, say, 1960 or 1970.

Inspired by the ‘support’ thread, my initial reaction is to say better, women working more financial independence etc.

But when I stop to think about it, is it really better this way? So many women I know are stressed juggling work & motherhood, there seems to be more pressure to look highly groomed, fast fashion, dating apps where women get treated like rubbish.

I know the answer isn’t a simple one as there are pros and cons to both, but what do you think?

OP posts:
SirVixofVixHall · 11/02/2022 08:39

@ouch321

I'd like to have been born in the 60s. I don't think people are very nice as a whole now. People seem to be disposable esp. women. Morals have changed and not for the better.

When I see threads about gender disapppoontment when OP finds out they're having a boy and are sad, I'm always flummoxed because I wouldn't wish being born female on anyone.

That's here in the UK let alone elsewhere. Just today, El Salvador I think, a woman has just been freed from a 10 yr prison sentence when she miscarried as she was charged with homicide...

I was born in the sixties. I have teenage daughters and I can’t believe it but I think being a teenage girl in the late seventies /early eighties, as I was, was so much easier than being a teenager girl now. My eldest dd (17) thinks everything was better for me, the music, the freedom, the older people around who gave my life structure. I think she is right. The world feels more frightening, global warming is terrifying, there is so much more pressure on girls and young women now. The whole gender issue is something that has made things measurably worse for women and girls. Imagine even ten years ago losing friends or being hounded out of a job for saying that girls need single sex changing rooms !
HoodieHoodie · 11/02/2022 08:31

I think it’s mixed.
On the one hand women of the 60s needed a man’s permission to open a bank account, but at the same time there weren’t the pressures to be a perfect mother, super woman type like there is today.

ExH was a 60s child, his mother worked and ran the home, from a fairly young age H was out and about with friends for much of the day. There was no talk of various parenting strategies (so mil says), very little pressure on children in school.

I read on another thread a quote that went something like “we were told we could have it all, we didn’t realise that to do that we’d have to do it all”, which I believe applies to the question.

Women who work still do the majority of housework and childcare. Men are set a very low bar of decency and are congratulated if so much as a little toe passes that bar. Women are held to increasingly high standards and bear the brunt of rising pressures from schools/work/even pet keeping.

Women also currently face a rollback of rights in the form of gender ideology -they’re not women’s rights if they include some men. I think it’ll take time, but if this goes ahead it’ll take a little while before women (those who don’t yet see the issue with it) realise the danger to single sex rights, to safeguarding, and the risks inherent in embracing queer theory. This is currently one of the biggest battles women face.

Soundwave · 11/02/2022 08:28

*sacked for wearing trousers

Swonderful · 11/02/2022 08:27

When my Mum was at school in the 1960s even the brightest girls at the grammar school all went off to train to be secretaries (not that there's anything wrong with that just that they couldn't go higher). Hardly any women went to uni and a female boss in business was almost unheard of.

A generation before that, her mum was given her notice when she got married.

Soundwave · 11/02/2022 08:27

I'd say better. Based purely on the fact that it's actually illegal now for a husband to rape his wife or beat her. Things that were legal when my parents got married.

My mum got asked from a job for wearing trousers. She was not allowed to study certain subjects at school. When she got married, she got asked to leave her job (she didn't BTW and her life was made difficult until she left to have a baby).

There is a long way to go. It has only been in my working life (last 20 years) that our local authority did away with 'bonus payments' for men doing jobs at the same scales as females. I realised the other day I'm the only female on my team who is full time. But there has been progress at least. I'm 42 with two kids and working. My mum wouldn't have been able to do that.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/02/2022 08:22

@Onionpatch

My mum was a working single mum in the 70s and I think being a single working mum is better now. Not easier, but better. more options for quality childcare, more options for well paid work,, less stigma. I wouldnt like to be a teenager now.
Is being a single mother better now?- ok the stigma has gone (kind of), but less chance of a council house, unaffordable childcare, people now move away and people have to work longer so no family to watch your children whilst you work, most flexible jobs ie. Shop work has been automated.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 11/02/2022 08:19

@blyn72

Speaking as a woman of 72, I would say it is a much better world in which to be a woman now than when I was young.
My mum is 82 and has said the same.

Not sure the rest of us are able to comment, though I think it's better now than it was when I started out as a student and a husband could still rape his wife.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 11/02/2022 08:15

Well if you are talking about women worldwide, whilst there is still FGM, forced marriage, females not allowed education, its still as bad as it ever was.

If you are specifically talking about this country, I think women are going through a period where as a sex class, we are hated.

Maybe job opportunities are better, but in terms of our health and wellbeing, nah. It's shite.

I'm not talking about me personally either. But womanhood.

HousePlantNeglect · 11/02/2022 08:13

@OneTC

It's much much better, but it's still not good enough
Yeah this.

Heaps better but along way to go.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 11/02/2022 08:08

@Spookytooth

Part of the problem is the loss of 9-5 jobs in your local town. People could leave school and be a cashier in the bank, be a secretary in a local office. Work in a factory. And then could work their way up.

These jobs have gone - people mostly have to commute which adds so much to the day.

Yes. Until quite recently, you could leave school with no qualifications at all and still find a job fairly easily. It wouldn't be a very interesting or responsible job and it would be low paid, but it was work and you could just about be self-supporting, and once in a job you had a good chance of staying in employment until you retired.

Along the way, you had an excellent chance of getting a council house at an affordable rent, and if you did climb the ladder and get a better paid job you could buy a small house or flat with a mortgage that was also affordable if you budgeted carefully.

Also, the gap between rich and poor was less than it is now because taxes were very high and city and top management salaries weren't as obscenely out of kilter as they are now.

Social mobility is much worse now than it was in the first 30 years or so after the end of WW2. Your chances in life depend far more on your family background than they did back then. I never thought in my lifetime we'd move so rapidly from a position where most of the population could afford to buy their own home to the reverse, and so many people in thrall to private landlords and uncontrolled rents. We've gone backwards in these areas.

(Admittedly, a lot of the above applies more to men than women, whose chances were always a lot more limited.)

FrecklesMalone · 11/02/2022 06:52

If you think it is worse you definitely weren't there.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 11/02/2022 06:45

I think it's better.

Santaslittlemelter · 11/02/2022 06:40

@Cheekypeach

Not to mention the new belief system of ‘gender identity’…
Oh give it a rest!
Spookytooth · 11/02/2022 06:39

Part of the problem is the loss of 9-5 jobs in your local town. People could leave school and be a cashier in the bank, be a secretary in a local office. Work in a factory. And then could work their way up.

These jobs have gone - people mostly have to commute which adds so much to the day.

Kennykenkencat · 10/02/2022 23:36

I'd like to have been born in the 60s. I don't think people are very nice as a whole now

They were f**king awful in the 60s
Especially if you were one of the immigrant families.

Our front door used to get kicked in regularly
by the police because if someone had been broken into then it had to be an immigrant family responsible

I was shouted at regularly because I was obviously up to no good as I had parents who were “foreign”
Actually my mother wasn’t but why let the facts get in the way of a bit of racism

mummykel16 · 10/02/2022 20:52

@Cheekypeach

I guess what I’m getting at is whether the issues around in the 1970s are still here, just with a side portion of extra stress dressed up as ‘opportunity’. I don’t know many women who wouldn’t want to cut down their hours or give up work altogether, at least while their kids are little. But it seems we’ve gone from not having any career prospects to being worked incredibly hard with little say in the matter, plus our domestic ‘duties’.
Sahm are now looked down on the way single mothers used to be, and not just by men
mummykel16 · 10/02/2022 20:41

@Cheekypeach

Than in, say, 1960 or 1970.

Inspired by the ‘support’ thread, my initial reaction is to say better, women working more financial independence etc.

But when I stop to think about it, is it really better this way? So many women I know are stressed juggling work & motherhood, there seems to be more pressure to look highly groomed, fast fashion, dating apps where women get treated like rubbish.

I know the answer isn’t a simple one as there are pros and cons to both, but what do you think?

Some things are better, much has been lost.
Onionpatch · 10/02/2022 20:38

My mum was a working single mum in the 70s and I think being a single working mum is better now. Not easier, but better. more options for quality childcare, more options for well paid work,, less stigma.
I wouldnt like to be a teenager now.

ComtesseDeSpair · 10/02/2022 20:32

Plenty of women are SAHMs or work part time, and couples plan their household finances to enable it. If it’s unaffordable or they don’t want to compromise, they work full time. Just as women from poorer backgrounds have always done.

And as a woman who doesn’t want children (and we are estimated to be over 25% of women by 2040) I’m very glad that I get to benefit from those “opportunities” and am no longer bound by the 1960s expectation that I’ll get married and have babies.

Cheekypeach · 10/02/2022 20:27

I guess what I’m getting at is whether the issues around in the 1970s are still here, just with a side portion of extra stress dressed up as ‘opportunity’. I don’t know many women who wouldn’t want to cut down their hours or give up work altogether, at least while their kids are little. But it seems we’ve gone from not having any career prospects to being worked incredibly hard with little say in the matter, plus our domestic ‘duties’.

OP posts:
Brainwave89 · 10/02/2022 20:24

Overall it is much better to be a woman now than when I was growing up in the 1970s and 1980s. There is less sexism, women can have satisfying careers at a good level and there is less sexism in public life. Marital rape was legal up until 1992, the tax system up until 1990 effectively judged a woman’s income to be part of her husband’s and many professional bodies had a category of “lady member” for the wives of the men who did the proper work. Some challenges have however increased. Access to very viscous pornography has led to more misogyny than I thought possible and somehow the new normal for many women is work and childcare combined. Most surveys show women still do most of the domestic duties with men doing proportionately a lot less. There is still much to do and sometimes I do feel progress is slower than it should be. I could not walk home safely as a teenager and now in my 50s this is still the same….

Spookytooth · 10/02/2022 20:23

Opportunities were less workwise - not in the actual sense - I suppose you could become an engineer or whatever male dominant career but no one told you that, in fact every girl in my class became a teacher (two super brainy became doctors), I didn't want to teach so joined the nhs - but these jobs weren't particularly well paid then. Only ones who went to uni were the doctors as the rest of us went to teacher training college or nursing college.
I wan't my time over again - uni and a well paid interesting career. And a husband that does lift the occasional finger.

OneTC · 10/02/2022 20:19

It's much much better, but it's still not good enough

Nowayoutonlydown · 10/02/2022 20:15

I think its somewhat harder now, but I think that it's harder to be an adult in today's age.

In the 60s/70s when a woman's place was considered to be at home, and a man's was in work, and a house could be bought on a modest salary.
Now, it seems like women and men are both expected to work full time, full time hours seem to be longer than they were in the 60s and 70s.
And not only are women expected to earn as much as the men, were still the ones judged on the state and temperament of our kids, state of the home and are expected to have a meal on the table each night.

Womens jobs seem to have doubled in the past 40 or 50 years.

Yes we have additional rights, yes we have certain things that have become better, but our lives have become harder.

Comedycook · 10/02/2022 20:15

Personally, I don't think we do children any favours by filling up their every waking minute with organised activities. It's important to develop self-reliance and your own interests, and to learn to cope with occaisonal boredom, how to organise yourself, how to get on with all sorts of other people, and how to fight your own battles (within reason)

I actually agree @Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g
However, our whole society operates in a way which doesn't allow this. If I didn't coordinate my dcs life and activities they'd cure their boredom by staring at screens. No one let's their children play out by themselves so you can't send your DC out. If you leave your dc in a car to pop into a shop, or let them walk home from school at a certain age, you'll have people queuing up to vilify you or even report you!

Swipe left for the next trending thread