Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have concerns about men working with non verbal female patients in care homes ? ( Content warning, sexual abuse).

63 replies

strawberrymilkshake123 · 10/02/2022 13:04

My mum recently sent me a link to a horrific story about a male care worker who has been jailed for raping a 99 year old dementia patient in the care home he worked at, ( my mum is hyper alert/ worried about any chances of abuse in care homes atm as my Grandma has recently been moved into one).
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lancashire-60299916

However, googling has shown this isn't a one off.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-51550011

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-stoke-staffordshire-58188294

www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/care-home-worker-who-sexually-23290876

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-57771411

AIBU to say that whilst 99% of men working in care would not behave like this, to protect the dignity and safeguarding of vulnerable/ non-verbal residents, there should be same sex care provided for vulnerable residents ?

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 10/02/2022 14:07

@strawberrymilkshake123
Oh You are not at all unreasonable.
A place i worked in for Cerebral Palsy had a very “ Handsome” young male resident.
There was a worker who used to take the boy into his room.
The boy could not communicate AT ALL.

We voiced concerns to manager several times and were blown off.

He wouldn’t listen.
He said theolder male worker was “ Very reliable” and said we should stop making unfounded allegations.

Why would a seedy 40 yr old male be taking an attractive, utterly non verbal young man into his room for hours..

Makes me feel so bad even now.

Wartywart · 10/02/2022 13:52

Yes I agree with you @MaChienEstUnDick. There are nasty people across all pay scales, absolutely. But higher pay does attract more respect, which in turn attracts better conditions. I'm talking about the workers here, of course. People earning more are likely to consider themselves more important and therefore less likely to put up with the abuse that they get from the residents and even the care home owners who treat their staff like commodities too.

I do agree that there should always be two staff to attend to all residents, to protect both the resident and the staff. Residents often make accusations and if you've attended them alone, it is very difficult to disprove without video evidence, which of course, as a worker, you're not allowed to set up. Sometimes a resident has a history of making allegations and still the staff are not allowed to ask for cctv in the room because it invades the resident's privacy. And the managers/care home owners won't cut their profit margins in order to pay for two staff to be in attendance at all times.

MorningStarling · 10/02/2022 13:47

[quote sadpapercourtesan]@Ponoka7 in which countries is rape legal? Confused

If you're talking about countries in which rape is tolerated, a blind eye turned and convictions vanishingly rare...you're in one.[/quote]
I'm wondering if they meant countries where the definition of rape is different to ours.

Having sex with a 13 year old here would be a form of rape. In Japan it's the age of consent.

In Bahrain rape is illegal but if the man agrees to marry his victim afterwards it is no longer consider rape.

In India a husband cannot rape his wife unless she's under 13. Over that age, forced sex isn't rape.

A person could have committed something that would be an offence in this country whilst living in one of the above example countries. If they had, it wouldn't be a crime, so wouldn't show up on any records.

On the OP's point I don't think it's right to say men can only care for men and women for women. Women commit sexual offences too, unfortunately. What's needed is a thorough investigation into applicants to highlight those who may go on to commit offences, even if they don't have a criminal record yet.

It would be difficult but firstly I would raise pay for care workers in the hope of attracting a better quality of applicant. Second, I'd make it a criminal offence for a care worker not to report suspicions or concerns regarding the treatment of anyone in their care home. Third, I'd make the owners of the organisation criminally liable for offences that their staff carry out.

MaChienEstUnDick · 10/02/2022 13:43

This is a massive problem but I'm cautious about linking it to pay as if 'better' people - which is a phrase used more than once on this thread - are not abusers.

Yes, carers deserve better pay. That's not because 'better' people are rich.
If you want to use pay to attract better qualified people into the sector then say so, but that doesn't mean that the same % of better qualified people won't also be abusers. Abuse cuts across all pay scales.

drspouse · 10/02/2022 13:42

I was browsing Twitter and spotted a case like this - young woman, nonverbal, had been raped. The mum had realised that only male staff (or only one male?) had been on overnight - this seems an easy thing to put right - there should always be a female carer in any setting with female clients.

Wartywart · 10/02/2022 13:40

These kind of threads dismay me because they are so very biased towards the opinion that careworkers are all abusive. @Ponoka7, your post above borders on racist.

I have a very good friend, male actually, who works in a care home. Both he, and the female staff, are often abused physically by the residents. Those from other countries are often racially abused too. And all for minimum wage. 99.9% of careworkers are lovely people, all doing their best to care for the relatives of other people who don't want to do it. There are nasty, abusive people in every place of work, but care work is possibly the job where the workers get the most abuse. Think elderly and strong men grabbing female care workers' boobs, elderly ladies stripping off and shaking their boobs at male care workers, residents calling care workers 'bitches' and 'bastards', shouting 'go back to your own country' to them as they're trying to help them get dressed, scratching their faces, spitting at them. All of that.

It's a difficult job, and emotionally draining - imagine spending all night holding the hand of someone who is about to die and afraid - and the job is paid far too little.

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 13:39

This. You need better pay to attract a better type of person. Currently it's the desperate that take it, not the ones who want to help those in need.

I do agree we should up the pay and status but I don't agree that it is only desperate people who take the job. I have an elderly relative with severe dementia and she has some excellent carers. I will be eternally grateful to two in particular who go way beyond what is expected to make her as comfortable as she can be. They will quote what she likes in food and drink as they remember from when she first went into care and was able to express her views and they make sure she gets offered these things. Another example is me visiting her and she was so distressed the visit was going badly, carer came in with some hand lotion, she sat by the bed and massaged my relatives hands and arms as she talked quietly to her. When she was calm the carer left us to get on with the visit.

We need more like them.

BobbyeinArkansas · 10/02/2022 13:37

I would agree with this. If I couldn't express myself I would not want a biological man in charge of my personal care.

FelicityBeedle · 10/02/2022 13:32

Ok even if your point stands, surely they could be attended by 2 carers one of whom is a woman? Most non verbal service users are going to be doubles anyway.

I think you’re being ignorant of the fact that placing so little trust in the men who do the job will likely make them leave, and we already have too few carers

sadpapercourtesan · 10/02/2022 13:29

@Ponoka7 in which countries is rape legal? Confused

If you're talking about countries in which rape is tolerated, a blind eye turned and convictions vanishingly rare...you're in one.

AllOfUsAreDead · 10/02/2022 13:29

[quote Ponoka7]@entropynow, I know there was. But we need to up the status of the jobs, so a better level of staff can be recruited. A good wage/holiday/pension/sick leave structure would help. My DD is within catering in hospitals, if an NHS contract is on the cards, people work better.[/quote]
This. You need better pay to attract a better type of person. Currently it's the desperate that take it, not the ones who want to help those in need.

Until that actually happens, nothing will change sadly. And the headlines you see are really just the beginnings of what goes on in these places unfortunately.

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 13:28

[quote Ponoka7]@entropynow, I know there was. But we need to up the status of the jobs, so a better level of staff can be recruited. A good wage/holiday/pension/sick leave structure would help. My DD is within catering in hospitals, if an NHS contract is on the cards, people work better.[/quote]
Staffing levels as well, although you sometimes get two evil people working together I think it is generally safer if you have a chaperone.

Ponoka7 · 10/02/2022 13:28

Also look at the prison sentences, or rather lack of them. Other than child sexual abuse, it's one of the lowest crimes, yet they walk free from court.

CorrBlimeyGG · 10/02/2022 13:26

if I was in care but had mental capacity I could request same sex healthcare.

If you're in acute care and the wards are as overwhelmed as they are now, then you'll find you get little choice.

That's the issue in social care too, staffing levels are not nearly high enough to allow for true patient choice. How do you suggest this would work in practice?

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 13:26

@Ponoka7

"If I can't, I'm just assumed to consent to men washing/ dressing/ toileting me, one-on-one, in private. Despite the fact this puts me at risk of abuse."

You won't get a concenus that women are at risk from men. Even on here posters tie themselves up in knots giving scenarios that show they fear nothing about men.

I don't think women (and men) aren't sometimes at risk from men but equally they are sometimes at risk from women. I think the danger is people making an assumption that it is only men who are a risk.
Ponoka7 · 10/02/2022 13:24

@entropynow, I know there was. But we need to up the status of the jobs, so a better level of staff can be recruited. A good wage/holiday/pension/sick leave structure would help. My DD is within catering in hospitals, if an NHS contract is on the cards, people work better.

AllOfUsAreDead · 10/02/2022 13:24

It's not a one off on female care workers and nurses abusing patients too. Want to ban them as well?

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 13:24

Whilst I understand the desirability of same sex caters for men for reasons of dignity, at least female carers aren't going to rape the men in their care.

If you look at my links above one is a young woman who effectively raping elderly women with a vibrator. I know the charge won't be rape but essentially it is what she did.

endofmytether4 · 10/02/2022 13:24

In my place of work there are vulnerable adults and a serious lack of male carers. Some of the service users can be aggressive/inappropriate with female carers so men are requested and are not always available.

entropynow · 10/02/2022 13:23

@Ponoka7

Also, but this isn't going to be popular, if you come from certain countries, a DBS doesn't mean anything because rape is legal in their countries. It might not be legal as such, but it's ignored.
Unpopular? You mean racist as fuck. Men get away with rape in the UK on an epic scale, and you want to point the finger at brown people? Sure.
HoodieHoodie · 10/02/2022 13:22

YANBU
Iirc there was a high profile case of a woman in a vegetative state who was repeatedly raped and ended up having a baby.

The depravity and entitlement to sex of some men is horrendous, and all women should by default be cared for by women unless they are able to consent otherwise.

Ponoka7 · 10/02/2022 13:22

"If I can't, I'm just assumed to consent to men washing/ dressing/ toileting me, one-on-one, in private. Despite the fact this puts me at risk of abuse."

You won't get a concenus that women are at risk from men. Even on here posters tie themselves up in knots giving scenarios that show they fear nothing about men.

ancientgran · 10/02/2022 13:21

If you think it is important for elderly women's privacy and dignity the same has to apply to men.

Cases of abuse where it isn't necessarily sexual and women are the abusers
www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/carer-sentenced-threatening-and-taunting-dementia-sufferer
www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/depraved-carer-who-filmed-herself-6247866
metro.co.uk/2021/01/24/carer-jailed-after-cctv-caught-her-abusing-pensioner-with-dementia-13958133/
www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/callous-care-workers-mocked-threw-17335571

Horrific isn't it but I think we have to be careful if we just assume female = safe.

entropynow · 10/02/2022 13:21

@Ponoka7

At one tim it was supposed to be 2-1 care. There is a shortage of male carers, so the problem didn't arise because they would have enough to do within the care home that they wasn't left with non verbal women. We have a shortage of staff and one the concerns of other staff members aren't listened to. We had one male carer who liked to leave women naked on the bed, as though they were waiting for him. There was a load of other issues but all they did was put him on days, because he would be able to be watched. The answer is council controlled care, with decent allocated budgets. Greater inspection and whistle blowing procedures, to an outside agency, for private homes.
If you think there is no abuse in council-controlled care, or that it's all about how much carers are paid, have I got news for you...
Ponoka7 · 10/02/2022 13:20

"If women who are mentally competent can ask for - and get - same sex health care".
The man who I mentioned used to wait until he knew we'd have those women undressed and come in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread