Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I should get a share of his overtime pay

292 replies

Homealone01 · 10/02/2022 10:28

Ordinarily my partner and I take home a comparable wage and contribute 50:50 towards all bills, costs and expenses, including those related to our 1yr old child. Anything left over we keep individually for ourselves; we do not hate joint savings. We also split cooking, house maintenance and cleaning etc. All of this we are both happy with and seems ‘fair’ to us.

We both work full time, him 8-4 in the office and I work from home. In reality, although full time, my work takes up about 3-5hrs a day and so I tend to do little bits during our child’s naps in the daytime, spending the rest of the time taking care of her, then my partner looks after her once he’s home, so I can continue working/cook dinner and then I finish off once she goes to bed.

Partner has the opportunity to go away with work in a couple of months and would be gone for 8-10 weeks (gone the whole time, including weekends). This work will attract a big increase in overtime pay/bonus, c. £10k, but it will also be very long hours for him. We really need the money, so I’m happy for him to do this, but it is obviously going to make my job a lot harder too, as for those 8-10 weeks what was 50:50 in terms of childcare, cooking, cleaning etc will fall entirely on me, whilst still trying to fit in my job.

So, my question is, given that him going away will make my job a lot harder too, would it be fair to split his overtime/bonus pay? Or am I being unreasonable, he’s earned that, it’s his money?

OP posts:
Iwonder08 · 10/02/2022 13:16

OP, given you already know how this money is going to be spent then it is a very simple conversation. You tell him that you understand that this money so to go towards the house renovation and you hope he doesn't expect you to match 10k contribution towards the cost given you take care of the entire childcare arrangements during his long absence

TonksInPurple · 10/02/2022 13:13

@Homealone01

I’m not going to be drawn into the comments that we should just split everything, family money, don’t understand our thinking etc. I’m well aware of that mumsnet minefield! There are many ways people work things that seem ‘fair’ to them and we’ve talked a lot about finances and how we want to split everything. We are both happy with the arrangement we’ve come to in general, it’s just that this is a special one-off, so I can’t decide whether it’s fair in this instance, hence my post.

Money is needed to renovate a house we own together. We planned to split purchase and renovation costs 50:50 and this 10k will go towards that. So really it’s whether this 10k is his contribution towards it, or whether we treat it as 5k each.

I also like the idea about him funding the childcare necessary, so my workload won’t change though, that might be another idea.

It should be both your contribution to the pot I’d say as you are contributing in a different way.
MRS54321 · 10/02/2022 13:12

I do a lot of well paid overtime, but I’m only able to as DH watches DC.
So I usually pay the family holiday with it.

If you can’t do that, then he can “ pay “ you an amount for childcare

Maybe going forward yous need to discuss how to split your finances and if he’s going to keep doing o/t, if there’s a better way

Snoozer11 · 10/02/2022 13:12

In normal circumstances the money would be seen as family money, as it clearly should be.

But you've already discussed your finances and agreed to keep your finances are separate, so that's what they are. I'm not sure you can change the terms of the arrangement the moment you're able to benefit.

Blossom64265 · 10/02/2022 13:11

You aren’t really partners with your current setup. He gets to go earn and you have to juggle earning and a child. It’s ridiculous.

This is why couples pool money. If you don’t want to do that, perhaps he could pay you for providing care for his child. Even just your daily setup is unfair as you career is the one facing potential damage by working without proper child care. He needs to pay a hefty premium if he wants to travel for work.

Ponoka7 · 10/02/2022 13:11

You are both putting the effort in and making sacrifices to earn that £10k, so when it goes into the house, it should be counted as £5k each.

@MorningStarling
"You've decided this way is fairest and cannot back out for special occurrences like this"

Of course you can, because it is a special occurrence. This is why women with children suffer greater poverty and get fucked over after couples split.

Totallyanonymousplease · 10/02/2022 13:10

Well if you think you should have a share of his money you are literally talking about shared finances.

If you have separate finances then he should keep the £10k. Maybe you review the 50/50 split for this calendar year since he will earn more than you this year.

DrSbaitso · 10/02/2022 13:10

We don't pay the other person extra for running the home and looking after the DCs when we're away.

What about when it's a significant amount of money over and above your normal salary like this is?

BABAHOTEL · 10/02/2022 13:09

So he hadn't said, he be hot the opportunity to work away, I'll get £10k which would be great help towards the renovation.

I don't get it at all!

It's a shared goal. Why did it have to be 50/50 if one has substantially more than the other?

Odd

trackerby · 10/02/2022 13:09

We don't know what the person working away thinks at the moment, neither does the OP. He might do the right thing and put it into the renovation fund. If he expects the OP to match it, he'll need to explain how he thinks she could do that.

Sunshineandflipflops · 10/02/2022 13:09

@AChocolateOrangeaday

DH and I don't have joint accounts, never have.

I am the full time carer for our severely disabled Son enabling DH to work lots of overtime, not to mention the promotions he has had over the years.

He pays all bills then what is remaining is split between us for "fun money" 50/50 including overtime and bonuses.

Also if he goes away on a trip with his mates he also gives me extra to enable me to pay for additional care should I need it whilst he is away.

It's worked for us for 30 years and because of this I now have substantial savings.

We are a family despite not having joint accounts although this is apparently not the case on MN.

I haven't RTFT yet but this!

I was married for 13 years and although we did have a joint account for mortgage, bills, etc, we also had our own accounts that our salaries were paid into and then we had standing orders to the joint account which was proportionate to what we both earned.

People are quick to criticise women who don't pool every penny they have with their other halves, yet on the other hand are also as quick to insist they have financial independence in case of divorce! It's a bit of a contradiction. Thankfully, me having my own account was very useful when my ex had an affair.
A friend of mine just had one account with her husband and she has to ask him before she buys anything over and above household spends. She can't lend her children money if she wants to (even though she works and actually is the main earner) and there are never any surprises with presents. I'd never just have a joint account with someone and not my own money too.

But back to the question in hand, I think the money should absolutely be shared. Any 'left over' earnings were ours to spend but one off sums of money were always spent on something like a family holiday and this time away will affect you massively.

Severntrent · 10/02/2022 13:08

I'd suggest he puts some it towards childcare.

ElftonWednesday · 10/02/2022 13:03

I am the higher earner and can't imagine the attitude of someone married keeping a substantial amount of additional pay like this to themselves. I'm not saying I wouldn't treat myself but would spend a substantial amount on something that benefits all of us.

LorelaiDeservedBetter · 10/02/2022 13:01

We have separate finances so I don't have the MN horror over that. I am surprised that you haven't discussed it with your DH though. Either he thinks he's taking on this extra work so he can put the entire 10k into the 'project' or he thinks he's doing this because he'll have some extra income. They're different motivators and until you know, there's no point tossing ideas back and forwards here.

Fwiw if I was working away which always necessitates longer hours, etc, then I'd put some of my bonus into the joint project but also have some for my own savings. DH would do the same - the bulk of the extra income into the joint project but some for himself since he's the one who has been away.

The other consideration is do you ever have the opportunity to work away? Because both myself and DH have worked away. We don't pay the other person extra for running the home and looking after the DCs when we're away.

Monopolyiscrap · 10/02/2022 13:00

Say he can keep it. And ask how he will cover his share of housework and childcare. He doesn't get to pretend this is free.

SunshineCake1 · 10/02/2022 12:58

If this was us it would go into joint savings and dh would give me some of it as he would want to acknowledge he could only go away and earn this as I was home with our children. He'd also fill the fridge and freezer before he went and make sure the children had everything they needed.

Whybirdwhy · 10/02/2022 12:57

Well he wouldn't be able to go if you weren't providing childcare would he?
Where would he find a random and reliable childminder for just this particular 8-10 weeks?

DrSbaitso · 10/02/2022 12:56

Given he can't earn that money without you doing work and childcare alone for weeks, getting less free time than he will in that period, I'd call it a joint earning. So even under this system of yours, which I'm dubious about anyway, it's one for the joint pot. House renovation sounds like an ideal place to put it.

DarkCorner · 10/02/2022 12:56

I think allocate some of the extra towards childcare then what is leftover should be a family contribution to the renovations and not then require you to put your "own" £8K in to match. You're both pulling together to enable the money to be earned. Even with a bit of childcare, you still have a lot of extra effort/responsibility while he's away.

Masterchief507 · 10/02/2022 12:55

Big money like this is family money in our house. The majority goes to something that benefits everyone. We're usually always in need of something (clothes for DC, new furniture or appliances, our car is getting old etc) so I'd expect the majority to go towards shared expenses. We usually spend something on ourselves, but no more than a few hundred quid.

Onlyforcake · 10/02/2022 12:54

In our house the 'extra' my husband gets from frequently working away over bank holidays goes in our holiday budget, including my short break once a year. The TOIL he also gets for these long, away stints he uses to go off to his voluntary work once a year. Would that seem a good use of the money? Our finances are essentially pooled but that's how we work out our holiday budget. If he were to want to stay home at Christmas we'd all be ok with it, as that's very rare but we'd have him at home.

Snoozer11 · 10/02/2022 12:52

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Well firstly he will need to use some of that to pay childcare. You can't work ft with a little one from home for 10 weeks. It's insanity
To ba fair, WFH with a child is more than possible if you're only putting in 3-5 hours a day like the OP is.
ancientgran · 10/02/2022 12:47

@WilsonMilson

I’ve never understood relationships like this. What a weird transactional way of operating. You share a life, a house and a child so why don’t you you share the money?

Individual previous savings and personal accounts for some things are fair enough, but me and DH have always worked under the assumption that whatever comes in is family money and shared between us and for the common good, no matter who earns what.

It can be historic. My DH had a brief marriage, less than a year, where she almost bankrupted him. She was drawing money out of joint account, mortgage payments bounced as did gas electric council tax. He worked long hours and she hid the letters so she got away with it for several months until he got a phone call from the bank. He wouldn't believe them so they invited him in and showed him the cheques she'd signed and the money transferred. She moved out that night but it took him time to get back on his feet, well to be honest it wasn't all paid off when we got married so I paid some of it off as well.

It was hardly a shock that he felt uncomfortable with a joint account and by the time our marriage was well established we couldn't see the need to change It's worked for us for nearly 40 years, we've never had a row about money, plenty about other things but not money.

OfstedOffred · 10/02/2022 12:45

You need childcare. The extra money he is earning can pay towards it.

TheMeditativeRose · 10/02/2022 12:45

Sounds to me like it should count as a joint contribution to the renovations. He does extra work, you cover his duties at home.

As an aside though, it might also be an idea to use a small part of the money for something to reconnect as a family when he gets back, so you both take some time off and do some family outings for a week, or go away for a weekend.