Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I should get a share of his overtime pay

292 replies

Homealone01 · 10/02/2022 10:28

Ordinarily my partner and I take home a comparable wage and contribute 50:50 towards all bills, costs and expenses, including those related to our 1yr old child. Anything left over we keep individually for ourselves; we do not hate joint savings. We also split cooking, house maintenance and cleaning etc. All of this we are both happy with and seems ‘fair’ to us.

We both work full time, him 8-4 in the office and I work from home. In reality, although full time, my work takes up about 3-5hrs a day and so I tend to do little bits during our child’s naps in the daytime, spending the rest of the time taking care of her, then my partner looks after her once he’s home, so I can continue working/cook dinner and then I finish off once she goes to bed.

Partner has the opportunity to go away with work in a couple of months and would be gone for 8-10 weeks (gone the whole time, including weekends). This work will attract a big increase in overtime pay/bonus, c. £10k, but it will also be very long hours for him. We really need the money, so I’m happy for him to do this, but it is obviously going to make my job a lot harder too, as for those 8-10 weeks what was 50:50 in terms of childcare, cooking, cleaning etc will fall entirely on me, whilst still trying to fit in my job.

So, my question is, given that him going away will make my job a lot harder too, would it be fair to split his overtime/bonus pay? Or am I being unreasonable, he’s earned that, it’s his money?

OP posts:
RB68 · 10/02/2022 13:57

in th family pot I reckon - you are both making sacrifices for it

EarringsandLipstick · 10/02/2022 13:53

Money is needed to renovate a house we own together. We planned to split purchase and renovation costs 50:50 and this 10k will go towards that. So really it’s whether this 10k is his contribution towards it, or whether we treat it as 5k each

I just can't understand this.

If the €10k is going into the savings, to me they are joint. No need to worry about who is putting in what, you just work out what portion of each of your salary you can save, then do so for the joint benefit of you both & your DC

EarthSight · 10/02/2022 13:49

@Notanewusertool

His wage will increase in future because he's putting the hours in. Yours won't because you're doing childcare when you're supposed to be working (and if your work realise this they will massively disapprove, even if they don't formally discipline you - I know I would). So you're going to have to get used to managing inequality.
And this.

@Notanewusertool

You should not be there as away for him to increase his salary and pocket all of the overtime whilst you get nothing. This is how women often leave some relationships in a very poor financial state. This is how they are left in situations where they need to leave their husbands but don't have a lot of savings of their own to do so.

Blankscreen · 10/02/2022 13:46

Surely this £10k that is really needed for you house renovation is a bit of a windfall for you both.

He has to work harder you have to pick up the burden .

In this Instance it shouldn't be yours or his it's joint and get put towards the house.

Tbh i think your set up is odd and stressful way to live t but each to their own

ivykaty44 · 10/02/2022 13:44

surely if your a couple with a baby you share?
if you're going to do all the childcare, he couldn't up and leave this child if you weren't there to take care of them?

FelicityBob · 10/02/2022 13:43

In our house our pay goes into our joint (and only) account so this wouldn’t be an issue.
I’ll never understand all this angst over splitting finances in a marriage

EarthSight · 10/02/2022 13:42

Would he be able to do this overtime if it weren't for your free labour?

If not, the overtime money needs to be shared somehow. Not sure how much in terms of percentage, but there's a good argument to be made for getting a good chunk of it. It's not fair if he keeps all that 10k - that would be really taking the piss. The reason why he's able to do it is because of you're enabling him to work that overtime. You're the mother too, not just a childminder he can hire, and that needs to be recognised.

ElftonWednesday · 10/02/2022 13:42

Yeah because childcare is always the women's fucking choice isn't it.

Jesus wept.

bonetiredwithtwins · 10/02/2022 13:40

Presumably it's the OPs own choice to Work whilst her child is at home and not use childcare - I can't imagine her DH forces her so any negative impact on her career is own doing

ElftonWednesday · 10/02/2022 13:38

@MistOverTheDowns

I can hardly believe posters suggesting she gets a nanny and charge it to him and the OP takes this on board as a possible idea.

If the money is going to house renovations OP then why are you even thinking this way, as you say you both own the house. It's not as if it is is going to be spent on wine, women and song. Are you trying to make some sort of point?

He's earning extra money. It's going to be used to renovate the home you both own. If you need extra help, surely it should be along the lines of, 'do you think we should use some of that money to pay for a nanny' rather than thinking you are entitled to 'a share'.

How transactional and cold you sound. I hope he spends the bloody lot on renting a castle for a week.

And he's able to do that extra work only because the OP is there and she is able (though not without cost to her own work) to pick up the extra childcare. It wouldn't bloody happen in our house as I wouldn't be there to do the extra childcare, it just wouldn't be possible so we'd have to have a nanny or DH wouldn't go, he wouldn't even suggest it. And if he suggested keeping all the money himself for doing extra work I'd suggest he fucks off to his mother's, as clearly he doesn't want to be part of this family. It's a perfectly fucking reasonable suggestion and not "transactional" unless you dwell under a fucking bridge.
Bunnycat101 · 10/02/2022 13:36

My sister does something similar to you and it’s always struck me as odd. I remember one year her husband had paid for a car so couldn’t pay his share of the family holiday and she refused to sub him despite having the money meaning none of them went away. The whole thing was utterly bizarre to me as the car benefited them all as the holiday would have done.

In your case, the money should just go on renovations and that would be the sensible use but if you stick rigidly to 50:50 for everything he may argue the toss.

DrSbaitso · 10/02/2022 13:34

If we paid each other for childcare during work trips, would we also pay when DH was away looking after MIL?

It's strange to me that you see a joint pot, for additional earnings that couldn't be made without extra work from both partners, as "paying the other for childcare".

It's equally strange to me that you see a moneyless family caring duty as equivalent to this.

OursonGuimauve · 10/02/2022 13:33

We don't split money either but put expenses + fun money into our joint account every month (currently 50:50 as we earn the same but in a ratio that means that everyone a fair amount of personal money when we earn differently) and in our house we'd put the full 10k into the renovations pot and then split the difference. But we might not split if 50:50 as the priority would be getting the project done rather than waiting on the lower earner to catch up on the higher earner.

Notanewusertool · 10/02/2022 13:33

His wage will increase in future because he's putting the hours in. Yours won't because you're doing childcare when you're supposed to be working (and if your work realise this they will massively disapprove, even if they don't formally discipline you - I know I would). So you're going to have to get used to managing inequality.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 10/02/2022 13:31

Well if you werent together, he would not be able to go (or pay a mass of childcare). Doesnt seem very even to me, this splitting of your earnings. Why dont you work from home properly and split childcare costs?

MistOverTheDowns · 10/02/2022 13:31

I can hardly believe posters suggesting she gets a nanny and charge it to him and the OP takes this on board as a possible idea.

If the money is going to house renovations OP then why are you even thinking this way, as you say you both own the house. It's not as if it is is going to be spent on wine, women and song. Are you trying to make some sort of point?

He's earning extra money. It's going to be used to renovate the home you both own. If you need extra help, surely it should be along the lines of, 'do you think we should use some of that money to pay for a nanny' rather than thinking you are entitled to 'a share'.

How transactional and cold you sound. I hope he spends the bloody lot on renting a castle for a week.

PrettyVacancy · 10/02/2022 13:29

So much angst is caused by the so-called ‘50-50’ split 🙄 You claim you’re both very happy with your chosen arrangement OP, so why do you even need to discuss it with a bunch of strangers online? The arrangement’s either working great for you both, or it isn’t. Sort it out between yourselves and carry on living happily.

I think it’s an appalling situation to volunteer to be in, personally. My partner is exactly that, a partner, an equal one. We never argue over money and would hate to have to calculate every last penny so that we could allocate it to one or other’s bank account.

I can only think that some people are keen on doing maths or drawing lines on the milk carton to make sure neither partner has had one more cup of milky tea than the other 🤣

bonetiredwithtwins · 10/02/2022 13:29

YABU

I'd be annoyed if my DH suggested it to me and would think it was a little grabby if they had a cushy job which involved 3-5 hours actual work a day and was paid full time wage . Not like I'd be going out splashing it all on myself and I'd likely pay for some family related things but no way would I "pay" him for doing a bit of extra cooking cleaning and childcare

Inertia · 10/02/2022 13:28

2 options:

  1. It becomes a joint contribution to the renovation fund- he is contributing money, you are contributing childcare which allows him to do this.
  1. You charge him for covering his share of the childcare and household responsibilities while he is away, then you can decide whether to use it to pay for childcare / cleaning help.

He doesn’t get to keep all the money AND freely jettison all his household and childcare duties.

whenwilliwillibefamous · 10/02/2022 13:26

If you were going away, would he let you keep the overtime and happily do the extra work all by himself?
Or would he either a) neglect house and child or b) get in help?

Look. You've got a kid together. Get married, put all income into a joint pot, set up a standing order of "pocket money" to your individual accounts, and make sure that both of you are pulling your own weight when all non-fun activities are totted up. That means neither of you get to bury your head in the sand when it comes to housekeeping, childrearing, or insuring long-term financial stability (which ideally means both of you have viable careers, in case something happens to one or the other).

Remember children are not a "female hobby" - they are the pride and responsibility of both parents.

timeisnotaline · 10/02/2022 13:24

Money is needed to renovate a house we own together. We planned to split purchase and renovation costs 50:50 and this 10k will go towards that. So really it’s whether this 10k is his contribution towards it, or whether we treat it as 5k each.

I also like the idea about him funding the childcare necessary, so my workload won’t change though, that might be another idea.
If he doesn’t like the paying childcare and housekeeping plan, or the sharing the extra income plan, then I’d find some short term work, say 8-10 weeks, that necessitated full evenings and nights/weekends, say to be less disruptive I can move to a friends for 2 months, and he is left to it. Obviously it’s irrelevant that he’d also have to parent full time for those two months as well as his usual work as he’s already decided that doesn’t count as a contribution to the family, so you are free to do this anytime. (Funnily enough I suspect he would see this as quite different, but I would absolutely at a minimum go and stay somewhere for a week to highlight how the parenting contribution is not negligible and cannot be left out of the equation nor taken for granted.)

Another poster made the good point that what if someone were offered a better paying job with longer hours? Do they get to take it, keep the extra, and have the other partner simply have to step and cover at home, sacrificing their own ability to take a higher paying job that requires longer hours? I just don’t see how this works for a couple with children.

LorelaiDeservedBetter · 10/02/2022 13:21

@DrSbaitso

We don't pay the other person extra for running the home and looking after the DCs when we're away.

What about when it's a significant amount of money over and above your normal salary like this is?

We still don't because we don't breakdown hours spent watching the DC. It's fine if other couples do but we decided that was too finicky for us because we both rely on each other to watch the DC at different times. If we paid each other for childcare during work trips, would we also pay when DH was away looking after MIL? Or when I was staying with my DF? It just never made sense to us to pay each other for childcare.
Snoozer11 · 10/02/2022 13:21

I think if he's putting it towards the renovations then it counts as family money.

PrivateHall · 10/02/2022 13:17

I find it a bit odd you are spending all this time and energy thinking about it instead of just discussing it with him. Surely he likely already assumes the money will go towards the renovations?

AryaStarkWolf · 10/02/2022 13:16

@Minionbums

Does your boss know you only work for 3-5 hours a day and spend the rest of your time looking after your child?? I know that’s not the point of your message but if you had a different job you’d have to start paying for childcare.
I got the impression that the OP works 3-5 hours until her DH comes home and finishes her working day later - but I might have misunderstood that