Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I should get a share of his overtime pay

292 replies

Homealone01 · 10/02/2022 10:28

Ordinarily my partner and I take home a comparable wage and contribute 50:50 towards all bills, costs and expenses, including those related to our 1yr old child. Anything left over we keep individually for ourselves; we do not hate joint savings. We also split cooking, house maintenance and cleaning etc. All of this we are both happy with and seems ‘fair’ to us.

We both work full time, him 8-4 in the office and I work from home. In reality, although full time, my work takes up about 3-5hrs a day and so I tend to do little bits during our child’s naps in the daytime, spending the rest of the time taking care of her, then my partner looks after her once he’s home, so I can continue working/cook dinner and then I finish off once she goes to bed.

Partner has the opportunity to go away with work in a couple of months and would be gone for 8-10 weeks (gone the whole time, including weekends). This work will attract a big increase in overtime pay/bonus, c. £10k, but it will also be very long hours for him. We really need the money, so I’m happy for him to do this, but it is obviously going to make my job a lot harder too, as for those 8-10 weeks what was 50:50 in terms of childcare, cooking, cleaning etc will fall entirely on me, whilst still trying to fit in my job.

So, my question is, given that him going away will make my job a lot harder too, would it be fair to split his overtime/bonus pay? Or am I being unreasonable, he’s earned that, it’s his money?

OP posts:
ThreeLocusts · 10/02/2022 15:08

OP I hear you as I have a similar problem. We both earn well and contribute identical amounts to a shared account for family expenses, but every so often my DH gets lucrative extra gigs that take him away from home. In our case, typically only a few days at a time.

Nevertheless, I've begun to resent how much more quickly his savings are growing than mine, thanks to those extra earnings that invariably involve me doing extra childcare and putting my own professional CV on the back burner.

He couldn't take this job without you doing the extra work at home. You should have a say in how the money is used. If that means rethinking your overall arrangement, so be it.

DrSbaitso · 10/02/2022 15:07

@OneTC

8 weeks worth of doing someone else's chores is worth £5k?
No, half the work involved in making an extra £10k is worth £5k... and all for the joint pot.

This is as strange a way of seeing it as the person who said that to split it would be "paying for childcare" and no different to going away to care for an ailing parent.

Sheesh, people, do you run a life and family together or are you just both in it to get what you can for your individual life?

SleepingStandingUp · 10/02/2022 15:07

@user1493494961

If it's going towards house renovations, what difference does it make whether he puts the 10k in or if it's £5k each. (Unless you're thinking you might split up and want to take out what you've put in).
I think it's that his 10k needs to be matched by her future 10k or its 5k each and then extra is split between them. So if it's 20k total she has to find 10 or 5. If
Rotherweird · 10/02/2022 15:04

I haven't read the whole thread, but my worry is that you'll be able to keep up with your own job while your husband is working away.

You've got a sweet deal getting FT pay for 3-5 hours work per day done entirely flexibly and without having to pay for any childcare - don't mess it up!

ChoiceMummy · 10/02/2022 15:01

@Homealone01

I’m not going to be drawn into the comments that we should just split everything, family money, don’t understand our thinking etc. I’m well aware of that mumsnet minefield! There are many ways people work things that seem ‘fair’ to them and we’ve talked a lot about finances and how we want to split everything. We are both happy with the arrangement we’ve come to in general, it’s just that this is a special one-off, so I can’t decide whether it’s fair in this instance, hence my post.

Money is needed to renovate a house we own together. We planned to split purchase and renovation costs 50:50 and this 10k will go towards that. So really it’s whether this 10k is his contribution towards it, or whether we treat it as 5k each.

I also like the idea about him funding the childcare necessary, so my workload won’t change though, that might be another idea.

Then given your choice to keep finances separate, if he chooses to, that would be his 10k contribution, not yours.

You cannot benefit from his finances when it suits and not reciprocate when it doesn't suit!

OneTC · 10/02/2022 14:55

8 weeks worth of doing someone else's chores is worth £5k?

user1493494961 · 10/02/2022 14:50

If it's going towards house renovations, what difference does it make whether he puts the 10k in or if it's £5k each. (Unless you're thinking you might split up and want to take out what you've put in).

BobMortimersPetOwl · 10/02/2022 14:47

I've said YABU because you said "we need the money" which implies it shouldn't be spent. As the renovation costs are split between you both then of course it makes perfect sense to put the £10k to that.

So I'd say to put it into joint savings until such a time as you're in a position to move forward with the renovations.

I don't think you should just be given a lump sum though.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/02/2022 14:44

@IDidntKnowItWasAParty

I think your set-up of individual finances, when you're supposed to be a partnership, team, parents, FAMILY, is absurd. How are you going to get your work done, while looking after a baby and house full-time?
There's nothing absurd about seperate money. It just isn't what everyone does. At the end of the month, I total up the bills, and food and divide fit by half. I add some money for the kids and what DHs payrise have cos me in tax credits and that's what he pays me. No arguments, a large chunk is actually SO and he just pays the excess above that. If we go out for meals etc he pays generally, I offer occasionally (because he works) but then I tend to buy stuff for the kids out of my money and their CB that I don't ask him for half of. If anything ever happened and either one of us needed it, the other would just transfer money over

What's absurd with that?

deydododatdodontdeydo · 10/02/2022 14:43

I remember one year her husband had paid for a car so couldn’t pay his share of the family holiday and she refused to sub him despite having the money meaning none of them went away.

My ex boss earned more than her husband. One year she went on holiday by herself and I asked why her DH wasn't going. She said because he didn't have enough money to pay Confused
They seemed happy, and are still together and seem happy so it wasn't like he'd blown his money irresponsibly or anything and she didn't want to miss out.

TheTeenageYears · 10/02/2022 14:41

He will be doing more paid work, you will be doing more unpaid work as a result. It's a pretty equal situation so the 10k should be used jointly towards a common goal. If when you discuss DP doesn't see things the same way then you have a problem which may never have presented itself previously. How was maternity leave funded?

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 10/02/2022 14:32

I think your set-up of individual finances, when you're supposed to be a partnership, team, parents, FAMILY, is absurd.
How are you going to get your work done, while looking after a baby and house full-time?

tara66 · 10/02/2022 14:26

Not read many PPs nor fully understand your logic but you do realise that while he's away you won't have to do any shopping, cooking cleaning etc for him though you will have full child care of course. So you'll spend less time and money for that.

PrettyVacancy · 10/02/2022 14:24

@EarthSight Sorry, I totally agree with you, but I can see how my comment may have appeared flippant. Unless one is in an abusive relationship, I think money is best shared in one pot, because so many relationships, as evidenced on this board, seem to founder on the rocks of who earns what, pays for what and so on, until the sums involved must be minuscule. I have actually known a couple, unmarried but in a LTR, who drew lines on the milk carton, had separate packs of cheese etc. Sounds vile to me and they did separate in the end.

Obviously, if one of you is stingy or, conversely, a spendthrift, it wouldn’t work and, yes, women are normally the losers when it comes to earning ability, for several unfair reasons.

ForestDad · 10/02/2022 14:19

I out earn DW by a factor of over 10. If I am asked to do overtime (which is lucrative), I always ask before accepting because I am aware that me working more means that more domestic things fall to her. Most of the time I end up saying no and being around more. If I unilaterally worked more, left her holding the kids and then said well it's my money I've worked for it that wouldn't be too fair. As I am only able to do my work because she is there for the domestic stuff.
All wages go into our joint account.
We discuss any big purchases.
So yes OP I would agree that for a 10 week stint of 100% of domestic duties that you've earned a share of the money, assuming it's not going to a higher purpose e.g family holiday/pay off debt/house etc.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/02/2022 14:15

I think the 10k or whatever is left after assoc costs are deduced is the family contribution. It just goes into a pot that's for renovations and when it's gone you go back to splitting costs from your bank

SleepingStandingUp · 10/02/2022 14:13

You say the money is needed, what is it needed for?

If he's arguing he should work it cos you need the money but is then proposing he stashes it all for him to spend freely, how does that work?

I'd say money is directed to the aforementioned need, some consideration is given to either extras costs and then it's split (so if he's going to be eating out lots or you're going to be hiring childcare)

thisplaceisweird · 10/02/2022 14:13

Agree with PPs that the only safe, sustainable and anguish free way to have bank accounts in a marriage is:

Partner 1 current and savings accounts
Partner 2 current and savings accounts
'Family' current account (for monthly outgoings)
'Family' savings account (to save up for new house/car/furniture/holidays etc)

Then each month both partners put in an agreed amount (to cover bills/outgoings plus a bit of savings) into both the family current and savings accounts. In our household we put in our proportion of earnings, say we have a total of 100k per annum, one partner earns 40k so puts in 40%, the other 60k so puts in 60% of that amount.

EarringsandLipstick · 10/02/2022 14:11

@Blankscreen

Genuinely interested as to how this set up works in practice if you go out for a family meal, who pays? Does the other then transfer the money over? Or if your DC needs new shoes do you go half each?
While my parents didn't have a rigid attitude overall to money - basically they spent everything they had on us children & our education & had v modest spending on themselves, they did have some funny arrangements. For example, my mum bought the groceries. My dad gave her money each month specifically to contribute to this. (They both worked). If he happened to buy a litre of milk, she would insist on paying him back, immediately & to the penny.

Similarly he paid bills, so if she happened to pay one, he'd pay money to her.

I used to find it mad growing up.

I think it was mainly as they had limited money - good jobs but high taxes in 80s & 90s Ireland - and they needed to budget carefully & accurately.

thisplaceisweird · 10/02/2022 14:09

If this were me and my husband it would go directly into our shared savings account, but I wouldn't expect him to hand me 5k, no.

Mountaingoat12 · 10/02/2022 14:03

We throw all money earned into one account. To do otherwise seems crazy.

RenegadeMrs · 10/02/2022 14:00

We have kids. My DP has just given me a third of his bonus. A third is for him and a third has gone into savings. So yes, I would expect it to be split.

Blankscreen · 10/02/2022 13:59

Genuinely interested as to how this set up works in practice if you go out for a family meal, who pays?
Does the other then transfer the money over?
Or if your DC needs new shoes do you go half each?

EarringsandLipstick · 10/02/2022 13:59

@FelicityBob

In our house our pay goes into our joint (and only) account so this wouldn’t be an issue. I’ll never understand all this angst over splitting finances in a marriage
I will say, that if I had my time over again, I would have a shared joint account but retain personal accounts & have my 'own' money. I know it's a paper exercise as in most marriages, most of the money goes to support the family as an entity, rather than individuals.

But in my marriage my H was financially abusive & spent every penny he got his hands on. I kept plugging all the gaps, so by the end of the marriage all my savings were gone, and our joint account was perpetually empty as he flogged it on his own lifestyle.

I wish to God I'd held on to my modest savings & also kept some money in my account (now it's over).

I continued to get Children's Allowance (I'm in Ireland) paid into my own account & was very grateful as many times it was my only source of money for food & essentials.

EarthSight · 10/02/2022 13:58

@PrettyVacancy

So much angst is caused by the so-called ‘50-50’ split 🙄 You claim you’re both very happy with your chosen arrangement OP, so why do you even need to discuss it with a bunch of strangers online? The arrangement’s either working great for you both, or it isn’t. Sort it out between yourselves and carry on living happily.

I think it’s an appalling situation to volunteer to be in, personally. My partner is exactly that, a partner, an equal one. We never argue over money and would hate to have to calculate every last penny so that we could allocate it to one or other’s bank account.

I can only think that some people are keen on doing maths or drawing lines on the milk carton to make sure neither partner has had one more cup of milky tea than the other 🤣

@prettyvacancy

I get the sentiment of your post, but 10k is not just a bit of milky tea, unless you are truly affluent in which case 10k is nothing.

So, so many women on here spend years enabling their husband's careers in one way or another by providing the childcare. Some of it is just a by-product of some women wanting to work part time or not at all. However, it's still a contribution, and often am unrecognised one. One that leaves those husbands in a very strong financial position with plenty of freedom to switch jobs, whilst the woman misses out on years of employment and experience which might set her back in the job market if she ever had to work full time.