Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DS10 wants to walk to school by himself

107 replies

Ihearticecream · 10/02/2022 10:22

My DS10 is very good at getting himself ready in the morning and the school have been encouraging independence and a fair few from the year walk to and from school by themselves. I am sure the physical walk is not a problem as he’s done it for years with me or his Dad but the world is not what it used to be and I am feeling like an overprotective mother.
I’m not sure I feel ready to let him go by himself yet.
Fellow mumsnetters any advice?
And do I need to give my head a wobble?
Thanks

OP posts:
stepmad · 10/02/2022 12:00

If he wants the let him . Our primary school they like you let them know if the child is walking by themselves So the register can be checked straight away

ThatPosterIsSoRight · 10/02/2022 12:00

@Christmaswindows

Please let him do this. My eldest two never walked to primary school as I had a younger children in the school. Child 1 walked for the first time to secondary school and I had absolutely no idea that they were unable to cross a road safely without a crossing or a friend telling them when! Child 2 was fine. Child 3 in Year 5 walks half way as too far too walk the full way and I drive past the school to go to work.
Yes definitely. I got caught out by lockdowns in year 5, then we moved and got given a school not in walking distance. So I spent the last few weeks before secondary school trying to get an 11-year-old to learn to cross the road safely (he is particularly bad at being aware of what’s going on around him). Much better to have done it gradually.
Silverswirl · 10/02/2022 11:58

OP no you don’t have to let him walk. Use your mum instincts. Do you think he will be able to cross the road safely. What is your area like? Are there other kids walking and if so what are they like and will your son be influenced if they suggest something daft.
I have a boy about to turn 10 and almost all his friends are walking to school but until I feel he is able to automatically look each way at the side of a road I won’t let him go alone.
At the moment I look back and observe him and he still just runs out without looking.
Don’t bow to peer pressure or other mums saying ‘they need to get independence’ yes that’s true but there are many years ahead to do that.

Notwithittoday · 10/02/2022 11:54

Nope. I’ll be holding out until secondary school and beyond if my my DD lets me. Too many weirdos about

Christmaswindows · 10/02/2022 11:53

Please let him do this. My eldest two never walked to primary school as I had a younger children in the school. Child 1 walked for the first time to secondary school and I had absolutely no idea that they were unable to cross a road safely without a crossing or a friend telling them when! Child 2 was fine. Child 3 in Year 5 walks half way as too far too walk the full way and I drive past the school to go to work.

thesugarbumfairy · 10/02/2022 11:46

There are lots of factors, but I'd say overall, 10 is not too young. He needs to learn independence. Especially if he's in Y6. As stated, build it up gradually. Maybe walk him half way to start with. Nag him to death about road safety and stranger danger.

For your peace of mind, you could get him a phone and use a tracking app. The phone would need to stay in his pocket/in his bag. You can then see in real time where he is. I use find my kids for DS2 who is in Y7 (he gets a train to school which is 30 miles away) I use 'find my kids' on my phone, and then on DS2's phone its called 'pingu' - the apps are connected - but of course the child has to have their phone turned on. Mine has his on silent all day. I can then check that he has managed to get the train home so I can pick him up from the station.
He knows the app is on there.

JustLyra · 10/02/2022 11:44

@Aroundtheworldin80moves

Without knowing the journey its impossible to know really. My 8yo could do her journey without me, I only take and pick her up as its expected by the school. She did go by herself the day her sister had a minor emergency 5 mins before we left. The important detail here is I can see the school from my house.

Other children have to be driven to the school because they might only live a mile away as the crow flies... but the crow can fly other the airport and the children can't walk across the runway!

A 10yo with additional needs should be able to walk 10-15mins in a quiet residential area. Its major road crossings that can be difficult.

You do realise that the school don’t actually have the right to enforce that?

So many times on threads I see when the school “allow” kids to walk to or from school alone. That’s a parental decision - not a school one.

The only thing the school can do is speak to social services if they strongly disagree that it’s safe and within the child’s abilities.

In 20 years working in schools only once did the school not back down and contacted SS (because it was another example of neglect in that case). They just rely on parents not realising that it’s your choice

Theoldcuriosityshop · 10/02/2022 11:42

Guacamoleontoast.
Exactly the same as me. I walked to school from the age of 6 and by 9 I was taking my 5 year old brother.

It was a good mile walk as well, not just around the corner. We were incredibly confident children and knew exactly what to do if anyone stopped in a car and asked us if we'd like a lift etc. Obviously there was no where near the amount of traffic and we had a lollipop lady to see us over the main road.

Ihearticecream · 10/02/2022 11:30

@SnowFlo Me neither

OP posts:
Bramshott · 10/02/2022 11:26

Is he in Y5 or Y6? If the latter then yes definitely, now's the time to start this in preparation for secondary. If the former then it depends...

NickyOy · 10/02/2022 11:17

My son is 11 in first year of high school. He has ASD and ADHD and we have gradually been building up to him walking home from school since the beginning of September. Started with me waiting at end of car park, then round the corner, bit by bit he has learned to do the pedestrian crossing and now meets me near home. He is emotionally less mature than many 11 year olds and needs lots of repetition and practice to help him to be more independent and learn new things. I'm really proud of the progress he's making and will soon be able to walk all the way home on his own, but every child is different with different abilities.

Sally872 · 10/02/2022 11:16

Yes let him, it is scary the first few times but then it becomes normal. You could allow him to walk home himself first as you only have 10-15 mins worrying if managed OK. Then once comfortable with that allow him to wall to school.

RandomMess · 10/02/2022 11:13

Really does depend on the roads.

The ones by our Primary School were treacherous and the average age for accurately being able to judge speed of cars and assess risk is more like 12 and then the craziness of teenage brain kicks in and executive function drops again.

rainbowandglitter · 10/02/2022 11:10

My ds was walking to school and back on his own from year 5. It's about 10-15 minute walk.
Giving them independence does wonders for them, keeping them wrapped in an overprotective bubble does not.
He's now year 7 and gets the school bus every day, goes down the city with friends etc.

bluetongue · 10/02/2022 11:05

@Guacamoleontoast

Times have changed indeed. When I was a child (1950s) my mum took me to school on the first day and after that I walked with a friend. No major roads to cross though, or it might have been different. All the other children did the same. No-one ever mentioned (or possibly never thought about) child abduction. I suppose it happened in the fifties and sixties but wasn't publicized as it would be today.
Exactly. I’m pretty sure the only thing that is more dangerous these days is the increases traffic. Hopefully your child has built up some road sense.

My mum was an overprotective helicopter mum before helicopter parents were even really a thing. It can be really damaging to their development no matter how well meaning you are.

TheOrigRights · 10/02/2022 11:03

The other thing is what to do if he’s approached by a stranger. There have been reports in the area about this so it’s a worry.

There is no way I would let a 10 yo walk alone in an area where this has been reported.
Of course it could happen anywhere, but if it's a known risk then it's not safe, is it.

What I was concerned about when my DS's started walking to school alone was 1) I wouldn't know immediately if they didn't get there and 2) that they were doing the same route at the same time every day, which makes things easier for predators.

It didn't stop me letting them go because they were tiny risks, it was just something I thought of.

MiniatureHotdog · 10/02/2022 11:00

Personally I wouldn't let him. With the best will in the world, he's too young

Why? My 10 year old walks to school. It's ten minutes through residential areas. From September they'll be at secondary school. Stopping DC from becoming independent does them no favours.

OP unless you live in an area where gang warfare is rife he'll be fine Grin

pointythings · 10/02/2022 10:57

Mine walked to school from age 9, Yr 5 - school encouraged this. At that age they should be sensible enough to cross roads and understand about potential strangers. There's also the fact that lots of people walked to school that time of day, either alone, in groups or with parents, so they were never really alone. 10 is absolutely not too young. I walked to school by myself from age 6.

SnowFlo · 10/02/2022 10:56

I didn't walk alone to school until I was in Year 7.

Guacamoleontoast · 10/02/2022 10:56

Times have changed indeed. When I was a child (1950s) my mum took me to school on the first day and after that I walked with a friend. No major roads to cross though, or it might have been different. All the other children did the same. No-one ever mentioned (or possibly never thought about) child abduction. I suppose it happened in the fifties and sixties but wasn't publicized as it would be today.

blyn72 · 10/02/2022 10:55

@Ihearticecream

Hi, there’s not really anyone he could walk with. He could meet some friends about 3/4 of the way in. I like the idea of building up to it. Maybe start with one day a week or as a PP suggested half way. The trickier crossing is near the beginning.
I just saw this, it appears he won't meet other kids until he is nearly at school.

Does he cycle? That might be better.

RedToothBrush · 10/02/2022 10:54

He's ten. Are you going to insist on walking him to school or to the shops when he's in high school?

When do you propose he start, if not now?

Allthegoodusernamesareused · 10/02/2022 10:54

Both of my kids have walked to school with friends since year 5.. aged 9. They start middle school at that age and it's the norm here (semi rural village school, about a mile).
I worried at first, but they were both happy to do it.

blyn72 · 10/02/2022 10:53

It depends how far away the school is and if he will see other children walking to the same place along the way.

Beamur · 10/02/2022 10:53

I was going to let my DD walk to school at this age but then there was a number of attempted abductions and girls being approached by men in cars (primary age) that I decided against it. It probably would have been ok but it just didn't seem worth the risk. She's at high school now and getting herself around just fine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread