Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so negatively towards men?

85 replies

MerryMarigold · 10/02/2022 10:12

I've not been abused. I have great relationship with my Dad, but...
... More and more frequently I find myself feeling so angry with men and thinking that in most of the marriages I know the women bring much more to the table and are frankly, nicer people. Out of so many marriages I think the men's faults (all different but all equally bad) outweigh the women's. I can count on one hand the number of marriages I would consider 'equal' where they both equally do good things and bad things (I would include my parents in this). For example: My Dad growing up was not very hands on, but he is extremely kind, warm, patient and generous. He loves underdogs and is very positive and encouraging about others. He can lose his temper at times and went through a nervous breakdown. My mum was a great parent who spent a lot of time with us doing all sorts of interesting things. She takes care of my Dad well and has stuck by him in some hard times. She can be critical but she's very loyal and hard working. She's emotional but tends to hold her emotions in.

I'd say my own marriage is fairly equal but I get upset at my sister or friends where I see it as very unequal. AIBU to feel this way or do others feel like this?

OP posts:
MerryMarigold · 10/02/2022 11:38

I want to be fair to men, but the older I get, the more I see… yes, I have to actively remember NAMALT as my negativity towards their gender grows.

Perhaps it's an age thing. I'm 48.

OP posts:
MerryMarigold · 10/02/2022 11:38

NAMALT?

Not All Men Are ? ? I don't know this expression

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 10/02/2022 11:29

MAMALT. I could give lots of examples of wonderful men.
But I look around at the people I know…

  • the friend pulled across the floor by their hair, in front of their screaming 5yo (they left)
  • the other friend, back black and blue from a beating (they left)
  • yet another friend dealing with confused and upset children because one parent during divorce is constantly bad mouthing the other
  • me, beaten black and blue by a sibling
  • me as a pre-teen, sexually abused by a grown cousin

I have so many examples. Serious ones. Probably the very worst one was a woman against my male friend. Every other single one? Man against woman.

That’s the stories I know closely. That’s before we get onto the news stories where women only want to go for a jog.

I want to be fair to men, but the older I get, the more I see… yes, I have to actively remember NAMALT as my negativity towards their gender grows.

PeeAche · 10/02/2022 11:28

My DSS is 8 yo and talks to me like I'm a piece of litter. It's a fairly new thing.

I've known him since he was a baby and he's always been my special little boy. I'm at my wit's end with his new behaviours.

At his mum's house is a new boyfriend and his own kid. Since he moved in, mum has to ask his permission for everything. She even asked his permission about whether she could change sandwich fillings for her own children's packed lunches. (Denied)
He signs off on whether the cat can go to the vet, whether she can put petrol in the car, even whether the kids are allowed to call my DH "dad". (They are not allowed to. They must call new boyfriend "dad" instead.)

Do I think all men are terrible? No. But I do think that the ones that are are contagious. It's insidious. Bleurgh.

ChocolateMassacre · 10/02/2022 11:23

@rifling

I think that when the point comes where somebody's got to do it, women, more often than men, decide that that somebody has got to be them. I think this is very true. I know a lot of men who have just walked away from their responsibilities. If their ex-wives had behaved in the same way then the children would have had to go into care. Women rarely do this. It is a lot more socially-acceptable for men not to make an effort socially too. I read some shocking statistic the other day that women are far more likely to have their husbands leave them if they become seriously ill than vice versa. I don't think men are inherently worse than women - far from it. But I do think that society expects a lot more from women.
I agree with this.

Also with this: I don't think most men even realise themselves how little they contribute to family life.

A fair number of men have never met their child's key worker at nursery/teacher at school, wouldn't know how to pack a school bag, don't know what days their child has PE, have no idea what homework needs to be done when, couldn't tell you when World Book Day is (or understand that this usually requires a costume), aren't on the class Whatsapp, don't know who their child's friends are and don't know who their child's doctor or dentist is. If you asked them to organise a child's birthday party, well two things - one, they have to be ASKED in the first place rather than understanding that it is required, and two, they would just look blankly at you.

Women don't enjoy knowing all this shit, they just do as a rule.

I'm sure there are some men who could and do deal with everything on this list, but I know plenty who don't (and who will try to push it onto someone else, usually a woman if they get the chance).

Stompythedinosaur · 10/02/2022 11:21

@RedCandyApple

If this is the case then why are women almost always the ones pushing for marriage? If men get so much more out of it, most men are not fussed whether they get married or not.
Because, is a patriarchal society, women's success and worth is connected to their ability to attract and keep a male partner.

Woman have more to gain from marriage socially (bachelor does not have the same negative connotation as spinster). Also, as the oppressed gender, they require the legal protection more.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 10/02/2022 11:17

YANBU.

I’m (mostly) happy in my marriage. I only have sons and while I worry, say, about the impact port might have on them as they get older, I am bringing them up well to be respectful of everyone.

However, when I think generally - and you have to, because when you think individually then of course you feel ok with men in the same bathroom as you (for example) - I see men taking advantage of women at every step and for every single little thing.

This is a huge part of why I stay away from the news, it’s depressing to hear about. Of course NAMALT but as I say, almost at the species level, they are.

Snoken · 10/02/2022 10:59

@RedCandyApple

If this is the case then why are women almost always the ones pushing for marriage? If men get so much more out of it, most men are not fussed whether they get married or not.
Women are also instigating divorce more than men, which I would say indicates that this really is the case. The women often realise too late (once there are kids involved), that they have really got the short end of the stick, whereas the men are perplexed why their wives wants to leave when on the surface they have "everything". I don't think most men even realise themselves how little they contribute to family life. Need to say though, this is all very generalised, as there are women who don't pull their weight too, and there are some amazing husbands and fathers out there.
rifling · 10/02/2022 10:58

I think that when the point comes where somebody's got to do it, women, more often than men, decide that that somebody has got to be them.
I think this is very true. I know a lot of men who have just walked away from their responsibilities. If their ex-wives had behaved in the same way then the children would have had to go into care. Women rarely do this. It is a lot more socially-acceptable for men not to make an effort socially too. I read some shocking statistic the other day that women are far more likely to have their husbands leave them if they become seriously ill than vice versa. I don't think men are inherently worse than women - far from it. But I do think that society expects a lot more from women.

hannahh82x · 10/02/2022 10:57

I generally don't think any of my friend's partners (both male and female) are good enough for them but to be honest it might be because I mostly hear about the negative incidents!

Hawaii33 · 10/02/2022 10:56

Relationships can be at fault due to alot of reasons from males and females. But one thing that's hugely changed in the last 10 years is social media. I have had to block men I thought were my long term friends or linked to my family because they got inappropriate 😐 these men were in relationships with children. I don't know if women do this as I'm obviously not going to have women interested in me romantically.

As for other things. I have friends who's boyfriends are always on the xbox and won't help with fhe kids. I have friends who's partners take the kids fishing and help with the house and take their girlfriends out. It really does depend.

110APiccadilly · 10/02/2022 10:53

I think it's telling that for the two relationships where you'd be reasonably expected to know best whether it was balanced (your own and your parents'), you think it is.

I think you may just be looking in from the outside so not seeing as clearly. Although of course there are unbalanced relationships. Also, there's an element of subjectivity - different faults wine different people up more or less. Ideally you'd end up with a partner who, while not free of faults, is relatively free of the ones that annoy you the most. So when you're looking at others' relationships, you can't really make an even-handed assessment of which faults are worse, because it partly depends on what you care more about. (Excepting abuse, cheating, etc, but I don't think that's what you're talking about - it's on a different level.)

CuntAmongstThePigeons · 10/02/2022 10:52

Definitely agree OP. The way that women and men are socialised so differently definitely contributes to this.

Also the fact that until very, very, recently women did not have the same power as men do in society. And even thats debatable as to how much power we have now. We may no longer be legally raped in marriage, we can now open our own bank account (both of these things are very recent) but we still have less power socially. This dynamic means many women accept bad relationships and marriages as for many thousands of years they've been the only means of protection and social mobility for women.

Were fighting thousands of years of socialisation and culture, women have only just begun to have an (almost) or at least on paper equal role in the society men have built.

MerryMarigold · 10/02/2022 10:45

First of all why do you know so much about other people's relationship.

I have close friends and family. We confide in each other, spend a lot of time together and I know them very well, most of them for many years.

OP posts:
x2boys · 10/02/2022 10:44

@MerryMarigold

True Natty. Maybe MN has ruined men for me after what I see on here, and then see similar stuff (albeit slightly less extreme) in RL relationships. Basically selfish, arrogant men getting their own way and leaving their wives to do twice the amount of work they do.
You can't base your opinion of men on what you read on Mumsnet ,Mumsnet is not representative of real life .
CornishGem1975 · 10/02/2022 10:44

Men can be horrible selfish people. Women can be horrible selfish people. It's not exclusive.

I'd actually say my DH is a nicer, better, more generous and giving person than I am!

x2boys · 10/02/2022 10:40

First of all why do you know so much about other people's relationship,
And secondly people only complain when they are having problems,those of us that are plodding along with things quite happily won't complain

Stompythedinosaur · 10/02/2022 10:39

Usually women get the partners they deserve. If a woman puts up with an uneven relationship that's her fault and also her right.

I think this isn't really true. Women are raised in a sexist society with uneven relationships being modelled, so they are often socialised to accept this.

It is like how women who grow up in families where there is domestic violence are more likely to accept relationships which include domestic violence. Blaming women for their oppression is unfair.

Alcoh · 10/02/2022 10:37

@MerryMarigold I think that is true. Some people just bring the best out in each other. My ex H and I were bad together. He is now with a woman he loves who doesn’t mind the fact he does x and y. I would be a nightmare for some men. But others love that in me.

MerryMarigold · 10/02/2022 10:35

That's true, MorningStarling. Thanks, that is a helpful way to think about it. No one I know if it's being coerced, just kids to think about.

OP posts:
Blessex · 10/02/2022 10:34

Agree. Men can be amazing. Even the one I divorced is a great dad.

MorningStarling · 10/02/2022 10:34

I think YABU because you seem to think that you're doing it right, your parents are doing it right, but everyone else is doing it wrong.

You say your marriage is equal because you have a lot of flaws. Perhaps in other marriages that you think are unbalanced there are flaws you are not aware of? In any case, what right do you have to decide that the women in those relationships don't have the capacity to see that they're being taken advantage of and walk away? Perhaps they are happy in their relationships, perhaps they think they have faults, perhaps they think their partners have positives you're not aware of.

Usually women get the partners they deserve. If a woman puts up with an uneven relationship that's her fault and also her right.

Anyone is free to walk away from a relationship and form a better one. (I'm assuming the people you refer to are not being physically coerced into staying with their partners, otherwise hopefully you'd be telling your story to the police rather than Mumsnet.)

MerryMarigold · 10/02/2022 10:33

@Alcoh

I was married before. And am married again. My now DH is amazing. My ex DH was just not right for me and now is engaged again. Men can be good for you. Women can be good for you. I was probably a shit woman for my ex.
Maybe. I just don't look at those men and think they'd be good for anyone! Perhaps someone else would bring the best out of them 🤷‍♀️.
OP posts:
Lamujere · 10/02/2022 10:32

I don't relate to this at all. My late father was a kind and lovely man and my three adult sons have grown up to be decent good men. Only one is a parent so far but, from my observation, he is a kind and patient father, much as my dad was. I get quite upset when I read these generalisations. I should add that my partner of 20 years (also a man) is a good humoured, hard working man. He is far from perfect but, then, neither am I.

Stompythedinosaur · 10/02/2022 10:31

The older I get, the more I feel like this. I love my dp very much, but I feel so tired of dealing with the masculine bullshit that covers everyday life. Mansplaining, sexist news headlines, shitty "boys will be boys" parenting, pay divide, sexual assaults, incel culture etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread