Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bin wars - who's in the wrong?

87 replies

Recyclingbinbo · 10/02/2022 09:34

Lighthearted

DH had a box delivered containing some items for a household repair. The delivery arrived over a week ago and he opened it, then left the box with all the contents and packaging inside by the front door.
We've had a lot of deliveries lately and I was taking all the boxes downstairs, after they had accumulated by the front door for a few days. (We live in flats with no lift so going down to the recycling bins tends to get put off even though it makes the job harder).
Anyway, as you've probably guessed, I appear to have mistakenly picked up DH's delivery and taken that down to the recycling as well.
Who is in the wrong?
YANBU - DH should not have left his item by the front door in its packaging for over a week. The cost of replacing the contents should be split (about £40 each).
YABU - You should have checked the box first before disposing of it and should pay to replace the contents yourself.

OP posts:
BooksAndHooks · 10/02/2022 09:48

YABU as boxes should be flattened and double checked for stray inside packaging that isn’t cardboard etc.

Inspectorslack · 10/02/2022 09:46

Both.

Ilovenutellaaaaa · 10/02/2022 09:45

Both of you are in the wrong...him for leaving it lying there for a week among the recycle stuff...and you for not noticing you was throwing a full package out...

Also why are you letting it build up by the door for a week, wouldnt it be easier to each grab a bit of recycle as you head out the door each day and drop it in the bins...that way it's not building up by your front door and if you are passing the bins on your way out it's easier to get rid of some

I think you should both split the cost and consider it a lesson learned....him for keeping his package in what was essentially a rubbish pile...and you for lifting and throwing without double checking nothing important had got into the pile

thewhatsit · 10/02/2022 09:45

I also think it’s a ridiculous argument.

You probably should have noticed but if I made an equally human mistake I would expect my DH to laugh about it and say it wasn’t a problem rather than appropriating blame.

Money is shared money so it would be the same either way.

Sausagedogsarethebest · 10/02/2022 09:44

I agree with PP, cardboard should be flattened before being disposed of. It will leave more room in the recycling bin for other people to get their stuff in, and it's easier to transport. If you'd flattened it you'd have seen it wasn't empty.

That being said, leaving it in the box by the front door was a bit lazy and messy of your DH. If he didn't intend to do the repair straight away he should have put it away somewhere.

Warmduscher · 10/02/2022 09:43

@ohhooh

How did you not notice it was a full box not an empty box? 😂

YABU in my eyes as if it's cardboard it should be deconstructed and flattened before being put in the recycling bins, especially shared bins! My old pet peeves when I lived in a flat was giant boxes taking all of the room! 😂

This is what I was thinking.

I’m a bit obsessed when it comes to recycling so I always check inside for receipts or anything with the name and address together (they get shredded) and then flatten the box.

I can’t understand how you missed that the box contained £80 worth of stuff, unless it was a very small shallow box and the contents were tiny.

SheWoreYellow · 10/02/2022 09:42

It all hangs on whether he left the box in the place recycling sits before it goes out.

nordica · 10/02/2022 09:42

I don't know, I live alone and still double check most boxes before taking them out into the recycling bin just in case I've forgotten a small item in or something. I would notice anyway as I always flatten boxes to fit more in the bin though. How did you not notice a full box, was it not heavier too?

ohhooh · 10/02/2022 09:39

How did you not notice it was a full box not an empty box? 😂

YABU in my eyes as if it's cardboard it should be deconstructed and flattened before being put in the recycling bins, especially shared bins! My old pet peeves when I lived in a flat was giant boxes taking all of the room! 😂

Soubriquet · 10/02/2022 09:37

Are boxes normally left by the front door to go downstairs for disposal?

If so, he’s very much in the wrong

If not, you’re both in the wrong.

Either way, he’s to blame mostly

polkadotcatears · 10/02/2022 09:37

I would assume any box left by the front door (when that sounds like your 'place' for recycling) is rubbish.

Aprilx · 10/02/2022 09:37

I refuse to answer on who should pay for it as I find this ridiculous between a married couple. But in terms of who is at fault here, definitely DH for leaving it lying around where recycling is normally kept for a week.