Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel that I'm being treated unfairly at work?

166 replies

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 08:40

I'll try to keep a long story short and just the facts - trying to be as objective as possible.

Recently returned to work from 10 months maternity leave - been back 6 weeks now. I have struggled with my mental health whilst on maternity leave quite significantly - I spent some time admitted to a mother and baby unit when my baby was born, and have struggled on and off with anxiety and low mood throughout my maternity leave. I have been seen regularly for therapy by a perinatal mental health team, who are fabulous and have helped me lots.

Part of my struggles relate to separation from my baby, which sends my anxiety into overdrive. Hence the return to work has been extremely hard indeed, to put it mildly. But I've put a brave face on and tried to just get on with it thus far.

I submitted a request for flexible working / reduced hours to my manager. I wanted to go from FT (37 hours a week) to PT (33 hours a week). So in effect I'm asking for a reduction of just 4 hours per week. It's been declined. On the basis that it cannot be justified in the current for climate of severe staff shortages and the service being at crisis point as a result of Covid (I am in a large public sector organisation).

However, I know for a fact that some other colleagues work flexibly and have reduced hours, for their own reasons. So in effect I am being treated differently because of the work climate at the moment.

I honestly feel as though I will end up on long term sick if I have to continue to work FT hours. I am asking for a small bit of flexibility to enable me to keep working and to meet my health needs.

Am I being unreasonable? Any advice on how to proceed with this? I'm really lost. Thanks.

OP posts:
careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:25

@Belfastbird

Compressed hours are a nightmare for managers - the staff never seem to be quite as productive on a longer day as having them in 5 days. Creates multiple headaches with cover etc as someone missing a whole day every week. I've been burnt! I've also done it & it's exhausting! Also agree re the budgets situation.

I would understand this argument if no one was permitted to work compressed hours, but loads of my colleagues do, and some have done for years. My manager even asked me if there was any way I could compress my FT hours across 4 days, but I can't because of the timings for picking up my baby from childcare. So he isn't opposed to compressed hours. He's opposed to losing 4 hours of my time a week.

OP posts:
Belfastbird · 10/02/2022 09:23

Compressed hours are a nightmare for managers - the staff never seem to be quite as productive on a longer day as having them in 5 days. Creates multiple headaches with cover etc as someone missing a whole day every week. I've been burnt! I've also done it & it's exhausting!
Also agree re the budgets situation.

ElftonWednesday · 10/02/2022 09:22

I'd do what @MajorCarolDanvers said and look for a manageable part time job.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:21

I can't afford to drop more than those hours, hence why I haven't asked for 3 days a week etc, as pps are suggesting.

OP posts:
careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:19

@itrytomakemyway

Would you have to pay back any maternity benefits if you left now? Worth checking before you decide to leave for another job.
Only if I left before 3 months after returning from mat leave. My notice period is that length anyway.
OP posts:
2022sucksalready · 10/02/2022 09:19

Speak to occupational health.

itrytomakemyway · 10/02/2022 09:17

Would you have to pay back any maternity benefits if you left now? Worth checking before you decide to leave for another job.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:17

@sluj

Having a day off a week will cause more staffing issues than working 5 x shorter days, especially if that day is a Friday. Are you in a role that deals with the public so has to be fully staffed every day to deal with that? In the public sector, if you accept less hours from a team member your budget is permanently reduced to reflect that and you can't ever get your full team budget back. That will give the manager issues if you ever leave and he can only recruit someone for 33 hours which might not be attractive to applicants. Granting less hours flexible working requests to several team members will see the staffing budget severely reduced for ever. Best start looking around for a new job or ask for a 50/50 job share.

Our flexible working policy states that applicants can choose to have the hours they are losing protected against their role for 12 months in case they then want to go back FT, or a decision is made to make it permanent. I made it clear on my application I was looking for a temporary arrangement in the first instance as a trial for 12 months.

OP posts:
Qwill · 10/02/2022 09:15

Unfortunately it’s down to business need. I had the same thing, completely denied any flexibility when there are others (exactly the same job as me in different offices) who were granted it. Is it down to compressed hours? That was a problem with mine, I don’t think they like it in principle. Could you suggest more part time hours? I also wasn’t offered any alternative and was given a different job as the man covering my mat leave has been given the role now!! I think all you can do is look for a new job that suits, that’s what I’m going to have to do unfortunately.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:14

@MajorCarolDanvers

I am asking for a small bit of flexibility to enable me to keep working and to meet my health needs

You need to change your approach.

I don't think you will be successful appealing your flexible working request as they've declined with a justifiable business reason.

What you need to do is approach this on mental health grounds and they need for a reasonable adjustment to be made to enable you to continue to work. Get a doctors appointment and get a fit to wok note from them supporting your need for flexibility's and ask work to get you an occupational health appointment.

I think you will be far more likely to succeed this way and you will be protected legally.

Thank you for this advice, very helpful.
OP posts:
Blimmingdull · 10/02/2022 09:14

I think you need to get some more info on why it was turned down and what you could do to get your request accepted.

One possibility is that it’s because your compressed hours mean that you are not working for a whole day every week, and it is this that is making it hard to cover/accept.

The FTE equivalent of what you have asked for is just over 0.9, but you’ll only be available to work 0.8 actual weekdays (admittedly for longer hours). How about you offer 0.8 instead?

I can’t comment on the fairness of this vs other people’s agreements in your wider team but can imagine how you feel.

I have found it emotionally stressful getting the right balance over the years (my kids are at school now) so I wish you good luck.

Slothydog · 10/02/2022 09:14

Going straight to full time is clearly too much for you and the reduction of 4 hours probably won’t help that much. Perhaps you could go down to 2-3 days and that would allow you to do a job share rather than struggling

AssignedBlobbyAtBirth · 10/02/2022 09:13

Because another employee has got reduced hours isn't relevant because it is what the service can manage at the time. The problem with dropping a few hours is that, unless you have a part timer wanting more hours, they can't be recruited to. We've had that in our team and had lost hours as a result. It's had a negative impact on service
If you go to half time then they can recruit

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/02/2022 09:11

[quote careerchangemaybe]@DoubleChinWoes2

Is postnatal anxiety / depression covered under the equality act at all? [/quote]
Yes it is. You have mental ill health and are protected.

sluj · 10/02/2022 09:11

Having a day off a week will cause more staffing issues than working 5 x shorter days, especially if that day is a Friday. Are you in a role that deals with the public so has to be fully staffed every day to deal with that?

In the public sector, if you accept less hours from a team member your budget is permanently reduced to reflect that and you can't ever get your full team budget back. That will give the manager issues if you ever leave and he can only recruit someone for 33 hours which might not be attractive to applicants. Granting less hours flexible working requests to several team members will see the staffing budget severely reduced for ever.
Best start looking around for a new job or ask for a 50/50 job share.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/02/2022 09:09

I am asking for a small bit of flexibility to enable me to keep working and to meet my health needs

You need to change your approach.

I don't think you will be successful appealing your flexible working request as they've declined with a justifiable business reason.

What you need to do is approach this on mental health grounds and they need for a reasonable adjustment to be made to enable you to continue to work. Get a doctors appointment and get a fit to wok note from them supporting your need for flexibility's and ask work to get you an occupational health appointment.

I think you will be far more likely to succeed this way and you will be protected legally.

careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:08

@DoubleChinWoes2

Is postnatal anxiety / depression covered under the equality act at all?

OP posts:
careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:05

@BobbinHood

Other people’s flexible working requests are irrelevant if they were approved before yours. Sounds like you work in an in-demand role, perhaps seeking a new PT position elsewhere might work better.
I do. There are umpteen vacancies at the moment for my role.
OP posts:
careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:05

@LlamaLucy

Or, could you ask to compress your 37 hours a week into four days? E.g. 9 and a quarter hours a day:

8am - 1pm
20 min statutory lunch
1:20 - 5:35

This doesn't fit with my childcare provider's hours unfortunately, they close at 5.30
OP posts:
careerchangemaybe · 10/02/2022 09:04

@BeeDavis

You want to go on long term sick when you’re not actually sick? Great idea, OP. That will really sit well with your employer.
Did you read the OP at all?! I am sick. I have severe postnatal anxiety and depression for which I am medicated and undergoing regular therapy.
OP posts:
DoubleChinWoes2 · 10/02/2022 09:03

You're*

DoubleChinWoes2 · 10/02/2022 09:02

HR professional here! It doesn't appear your being discriminated against from the info you've posted, echoing what others have said. However, it's generally encouraged that your workplace should suggest an alternative that could work for them. It may be what they suggest doesn't work for you but hey, it might, or at least meet in the middle i.e. finish an hour early three days and start an hour early the other days so it's still full time? Might be worth putting the ball in their court and asking what could work alongside the business need.

ChessieFL · 10/02/2022 09:01

Agree with others - unfortunately they don’t have to agree flexible working just on the basis that others have been allowed to have it. If that was the rule imagine the chaos of everyone suddenly decided to request it! You’re not being treated unfairly if they have reached their limit of what can be permitted.

And while they may lose a good member of staff - from their POV it may still be easier to find a new person who will work FT than try and cope being short staffed one day a week.

BobbinHood · 10/02/2022 09:01

Other people’s flexible working requests are irrelevant if they were approved before yours. Sounds like you work in an in-demand role, perhaps seeking a new PT position elsewhere might work better.

LlamaLucy · 10/02/2022 08:59

Or, could you ask to compress your 37 hours a week into four days? E.g. 9 and a quarter hours a day:

8am - 1pm
20 min statutory lunch
1:20 - 5:35